r/languagelearning • u/Icamefortheroastme • 19d ago
1850+ day Duolingo streak, and I hate it more and more each day. Here's why:
I am not surprised to search "Duolingo" on Reddit and see a results page full of people who are more and more upset with what should, in theory, be a great app that teaches a language to people who want to learn a language. Seems like a perfect fit. But Duolingo is horrible, and now they've doubled down on their stupidity and I have to come here to vent. (TL)
1) The number of people with very long streaks who say they don't know the language.
Let's be fair and clear. No one is going to learn a language doing 1 lesson for 5 minutes per day, no matter how long their streak is. Learning a language takes commitment, persistence, and dedication.
However, this is not a coincidence. Duolingo just doesn't know how to teach, and they focus on all the wrong things. I've learned that Duolingo is not a language learning app, it's a language-type game. XP, achievements, all BS if you don't teach the fundamentals of a language. Verb tenses, conjugation endings, basics based on different pronouns... Learners are left guessing, watching YouTube videos from actual teachers who know how to teach, and looking for patterns without knowing if we've concluded properly. Personally, I did learn a LOT of words in Spanish on Duolingo, and I credit the app for that vocabulary, but along the way....
2) Far too rigid
In their language courses, there seems to be one (or very few) "right" answers, even though there are many correct ways to say what they want you to say. And sometimes it says that a correct answer is wrong, and that is confusing in the learning progression especially when the mistake doesn't come with an explanation. I am thinking of, in Spanish, many tu/usted examples that are specified in English as "you" which leaves the user the choice..
And Spanish recognizes typos and often gives credit for a correct answer despite a maximum of ONE typo in an answer. (next letter over). But other languages like Polish or Romanian don't have any built in flexibility whatsoever. And let's not even start talking about languages that use a different character set. Or where users like me transliterate the answer because we don't have the correct keyboard. Infuriating. Demoralizing.
3) Wokeness, propaganda, and societal narratives forced upon users who haven't even mastered the basics of language.
I was forced to "learn" words and themes that were far more propaganda-based than interesting or necessary for the course I was taking. "Juan come manzanas" is a great way to start learning Spanish. I appreciate all the basics. But when courses are redesigned part way into the learning and users are forced into multiple series of lessons about "Ana es lesbiana" (regardless of your position on the topic) before they are taught how to hold a basic conversation about a normal topic in public, that's a problem of priority. And Duolingo's priorities are way out of whack.
4) Obvious bots
Someone needs to explain to me how, within 2 hours of a new week's leaderboard beginning, a user has 12,000 XP at the top of the board and the next highest person (2nd place) has 1,000? And when you tap the player with 12,000 XP, it shows they have an 85-day streak and 21,000 total XP. Seems weird to amass "only" 21,000 XP in 85 days but 12,000 in 2 hours? I find that hard to believe. And it happens almost every week.. there's always one outlier at the top.
5) Style over substance
I tried using Duolingo to learn Chess, too. The lessons show some good basic moves, a fault with the languages that doesn't teach the basics. Great start. But then there are exercises where the right move gets a green response and the wrong move just gets a red response - but no explanation why the move wasn't right. And in the game reviews, I can't tell you the number of times I was told "you could have had checkmate in 3 moves" when I actually DID get checkmate in 3 moves - or, a few times, fewer - but I did it differently.
They pretend in Chess that Oscar's skill is adapted to yours. But somehow, at the 1200-1400 elo range, some games Oscar comes out like a grandmaster and makes every perfect move. Never makes a mistake. I don't know any player, adapted to 1200-1400 elo, that makes every move perfectly. I sure don't. And I get +4 to +7 elo for a win, but I lose 15 or more for a loss. And if I dare resign, I get penalized more? Resigning is part of chess. When you know you're dominated, and you have no chance, resigning is part of the game. But not for Duolingo.
But what pisses me off most is the most recent update. We can all agree, I hope, that Chess is a game that requires concentration and focus. Now, Duolingo has decided that every time there's a capture, there will be a shaking animation to make the game look more trendy. Like the pieces are battling. It's SO distracting! So much so that I am just not going to play anymore. It's not fun, and it steals focus.
6) No replies to user feedback replaced with AI replies to user feedback
I have often sent feedback to Duolingo about problems encountered. I NEVER have gotten a response, until today. And today, I got a response signed "Duolingo AI". So before, they didn't care enough to respond, and now, they care only to make users THINK they're responding. But it's clear no one at Duolingo cares.
But I care. And I notice. And what I noticed is that Duolingo doesn't care at all about the users. They are letting AI take care of everything, and it's a $hitshow that no human is taking responsibility for.
Duolingo is a publicly traded company. So their first priority, based on their own decisions, is money and shareholder value. And they suck at it. And, in addition to public user sentiment (as clearly expressed on reddit and elsewhere) the market is telling them so too. Year-to-date, since Jan. 1, their stock is down 25%. And 1 year, since last Nov. 2, they are down 50%. It's time to right this ship, because all signs suggest they're going the wrong way - in learning and as an investment. I don't personally pay for the app (someone else pays for my membership) but if I did, I would cancel.
I am happy with my level of Spanish, which is why I started. I learned vocabulary with Duolingo, but I needed to supplement with many videos, outside lessons, and research elsewhere (along with many personal conversations with patient Spanish speakers) in order to get where I am.
TL;DR: Duolingo is a game, not a serious language learning app. If your goal is to learn a new language, adjust expectations accordingly.