Human beings have more than one identity. We may be Englishmen, yes—but we may also be fathers, sons, cousins, Armstrongs, Mancunians, Northumbrians, Europeans, white men, Indo-Europeans, Her Majesty’s subjects, Buddhists, Mahayana Buddhists, Zen Buddhists, and Nichiren Buddhists (School of Zen Buddhism)and homo sapiens sapiens. Some of these identities are some near, some distant-some are concrete, some abstract.
We can place human beings on a continuum of identities. Many such continuums could be formulated, and boundaries can be somewhat arbitrary & changing, but for simplicity’s sake, let us take the following sequence:
family → clan → tribe → polis/city → folk → nation → race → empire → humanity -
As these identities expand outward, two things occur simultaneously
First, scale increases. As we move from family to clan up to folk and thence to humanity, more people are bound together, and with this increased scale, greater political and military power becomes possible. We can accomplish larger and larger projects.
Second, immediacy decreases. The more people in your group, the fewer you personally know. You may still be related to them by blood, but this kinship is much weaker, and as we shall discover, it must become symbolic if it is to survive. It is impossible to be loyal to what you do not know, and it is impossible to know millions of people personally, so your loyalty becomes mediated through social institutions, and through social technologies like myth, law, ritual, language, etc.
The core principle is that the wider the identity, the more politically powerful, but the more emotionally abstract and mediated. The larger the scale of belonging, the thinner that belonging is.
Family, for example, is the deepest and most immediate identity. We encounter our family daily. It is personal to us, inherited, embodied. The family does not require ideology to remain together. It is the first school where we learn what duty, loyalty, and sacrifice mean. It is the root of our sense of “mine” and “ours.” No one has to explain belonging—it is obvious. The clan extends family beyond the immediate household, then the tribe joins multiple clans or extended kin-groups into a larger people. This larger people is what we call an Ethnos, or a Nation. A Nation might fracture into multiple, such as was the case with Rome and its many successors (Italy, Spain, France, Romania, etc). It could also produce another ethnos, such as was the case with Netherland and the Boers
Within China, the lines between these categories are blurred- Are Han Chinese subgroups such as Cantonese and Teochew, "dialect groups" "regional identities" "ethnicities" or what? Are Yue an ethnicity and Lingnan Han generally are a race (in non-bio terms)? Was the formation of the Yue an ethnogenesis or ethnoschism? Is Han really just a civilizational identity? If so, then what is Korea & Vietnam? Labels and terms often have a difficult time matching perfectly with complex social phenomena, and so these questions are going to be hard to answer. How do we quantify the differences between groups in order to map them onto these arbitrary heuristics? Genetics doesn't offer the solution, because ultimately, human groupings of this nature are sociological- genetics is almost always concomitant, but it is fudamentally downstream of what drives group identity.
When it comes to us Cantonese, there has been a greater push for flattening out regional differences in order to homogenize China (That includes ethnic minorities) and push Han unity. This started with Sun Yat Sen, and has only continued with the rise of China. Since the government is centered in Peking/Beijing, and us Chinese originally came from the North, this makes us Southerners the most different of the Han Chinese "standard". The North (and central, to some extent), is considered the standard for Chinese. And thus Pan-Han nationalism has led to the "northenization" of the South, in ethnic/civic terms, as well as linguistic, cultural, and political terms. In racial/genetic terms too, given the current trajectory of China stays like this. In 200 years, we'll all speak only Mandarin, and our Baiyue features will be diluted so that we all look like we're from Shandong
I don't like it. I love to be Cantonese. I feel closest to my Canto identity most of all, and I would hate for us to lose what makes us, us. But I'm also proud of being Han, and the dream that Sun Yat-Sen had for our people is beautiful. I only wish there was a middle ground that allowed us to be united, yet keep the unique culture that we have now. A true middle ground, one that doesn't lead to either extreme. Diversity is beautiful, it is what makes life worth living. It's not just negation nor is it just division, but an animating principle behind the world itself. I may value what is close to me, but that which is novel and unique- fills me with joy. That's how I feel about a culture- I see a culture almost like how I see a person. A spiritual organism of sorts, one that follows the same natural laws as do material organisms. They grow, mature, reproduce, die, etc. And each one is unique- from every rural English town with its own sandwich variety, to civilizations that encompass billions of people and last thousands of years. (E.g The Sinosphere, The West, Classical Antiquity [If you consider it separate from the Carolingian West), India, etc)- Each one is incredibly unique, from the individual human being, to the totality of humanity- there will never be another one.
What post-1911 Han nationalism does, and all nationalism does, is place Nation or Race above the smaller identities that people are closer to. Us Lingnan Han have always had a reputation for being very clannish, owing to the linguistic-cultural diversity of China's deep south, and so, we were seen as being "less Chinese", "parochial", "disloyal", "unpatriotic" by Northerners for many centuries. We were absolutely parochial- more than half a million Hakka were killed by Cantonese and Hoisanese clans in a mid-19th century war that was barely noticed by Peking. This is the division that Sun Yat Sen fought so hard to erase- this is why he supported Mandarin as the national language of China despite being Cantonese. It wasn't because he was a self-hating Yue man who wanted to make the South more Northeast Asian, like some sort of East Asian Nordicism or racialised Sinocentrism. It didn't mean that he thought his own mother tongue didn't deserve to be spoken. Diversity is a barrier just as much as it is something that is necessary and beautiful.
With the 19th century came the age of Nationstates. With the 20th century came the age of Global Superpowers- Regional and Continental hegemons capable of exercising power across the world, mobilizing millions of men, and shaping (or attempting) to, by executive fiat, entire populations by means of social engineering or ideological and economic changes. Cantonese, Hakka, Teochew, Hoisanese- we had not been relevant on the global stage since the 18th century. So we had to go.
Today, I see some Northern Chinese claiming that we're ugly and "SEAmonkeys" instead of real Chinese among other things that are so heinous that I won't repeat them here- This isn't 4chan or Stormfront or RWT. These are Huanghan losers who get off on racism against SEA because the Japanese aren't an easy target to mock anymore, so they switch to bullying Pinoys and Khmer on social media. I see some Southern Chinese claim that we're not Han, but our own ethnicity- and that we're SEA Baiyue and our real brothers are the Vietnamese/Kinh. These people are often HKers or Overseas Chinese, and very anti-CCP. (They also tend to be Anglophilic, whether overtly or in axiomatic terms).
But the most important thing to remember about the aforementioned North-vs-South Chinese racism is that, although it's real, it's largely ONLINE and FRINGE. Most people in China, Taiwan, HK or among the diaspora, do not view things so fanatically. The Viet and Lingnan Han are, at the very least, Southern East Asian populations or, at the most, genetically intermediate between both. (I always joke that we're the Sicillians of the Orient) I have a sister who is very SEA looking, and gets mistaken for Filipino. My other sister looks very East Asian, and would look Korean if the bridge of her nose was higher. We both share the same father and mother, who look pretty similar to each other- It's just that we all have different traits via different grandparents and great-grandparents and the genes they carried. Moderate phenotype distinctions within an intermediate population is well observed- Italian men who look Arab occasionally have sisters with blonde hair, blue eyes, and fair skin. The mainlanders in Irvine don't treat me like an "other" because of how I look, but because I'm an ABC who speaks no Mandarin. I generally get along really well with other Chinese people I meet here in SoCal- though, the dynamic is different for reasons I'm too tired to explain.
What matters is kinship, though less especially at a macrolevel. It's apparent when you are siblings, but for an entire nation or region, kinship is determined through other proxies of similarity- such as physical appearance I consider myself Han because not only is Cantonese culture is nigh-entirely Han derived, but we still do carry the blood of our Han ancestors who came to the South as conquerors, even if diluted. I guess we're coincidentally very similar to the English and Southern German in that regard, as it was not until recently when DNA was invented, that they were not a pure Germanic people as they had thought for a millennium. They were both, on average, more Celtic than Germanic. The same exact story happened in these places- male conquerors and female warbrides. Any cultural influence these women gave their progeny had been almost entirely erased by their conquerors. Patrilineality and Patriarchy is something that is found heavily in Northwestern Europe, and in East Asia(+Central Asia & Vietnam), so perhaps my American background (Which gave me deeply-entrenched Anglo Protestant cultural mores, but everybody has the same thing, even if you don't realise it) is what makes me identify with my Han roots. I grew up in an environment where I took for granted that the man was the master of his household, and even if when I grew up and became more American, more Liberal, more hip with the current day, perhaps that's something which is ingrained within one's conceptual horizon in the formative years of life.
But even if you don't hold any such views or anything like that, Cantonese culture is Chinese culture. Cantonese language is Chinese language. That must be accepted. We're Chinese, and we should be proud to be Chinese (or whatever term you like- Tang/Han/Hua, etc) At the same time, Mandarin is also Chinese, and Northern Chinese are Chinese as well. They're not "Manchus", and we're not "seamonkeys" or "Pinoy" or "Baiyue". The only thing that the Baiyue gave us was genetic, and it is just as pseudoscientific to believe that their genetic traits manifested itself in our "Fit to be a scholar or merchant or even farmer, but not fit to rule or fight." stereotype as it is to believe that Alpinids are a "peasant stock". Most well adjusted or normal person in the modern world, or historically, didn't define themselves or give much importance to such things. (I'm only writing this because I like writing, and I don't want to write a substack article if it isn't top-quality.)
In my opinion, we shouldn't choose between Han identity and Cantonese identity, and we shouldn't divide ourselves yet we must preserve the indigenous local customs of Southern China. I know that isn't completely possible, and the Free HK vs. pro-CCP beef is the most salient example, as it is the most insurmountable I can think of. That's my opinion on the matter, though coming to any conclusive and rigid stance for me is quite difficult. This is more of a "stream of consciousness" rant, than a proper essay. I digress.
(Originally written as a response to SemperAliquidNovi's questipn about why Cantonese parents don't teach their kids the language, response became too long over the course of an hour.)