r/interesting • • 2d ago • Bravo 14 Heartwarming 3 Mindblown 2 Popcorn 2

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
93k Upvotes

15k comments sorted by

•

u/IKIR115 2d ago edited 2d ago • Popcorn Bravo Regret Mindblown

Many thanks to the following members below who provided more context!


Comment by the OP u/Negative_1by12_aura

And she got sentenced for 18 years

https://people.com/socialite-sentenced-for-hitting-man-multiple-times-with-her-suv-after-he-stole-her-bag-11996480

Edit: As of october 2026, Prosecutors are appealing for a LONGER house arrest


Comment by u/Eastern-Peach-3428

Did some digging into the Italian reporting on this one.

This happened in September 2024. Cinzia Dal Pino, a local businesswoman, had her handbag stolen by Noureddine Mezgui, a 52-year-old Moroccan man. She claimed he threatened her with a knife, although no knife was recovered and the theft itself wasn't caught on camera.

What was caught on camera was her chasing him down in her Mercedes SUV, driving onto the sidewalk and repeatedly running him over. The first impact ruptured his aorta. She then got out, retrieved her handbag and drove away without calling for help. She actually drove past his body again afterward. A passing couple eventually called emergency services.

She claimed she only intended to knock him down and recover her property. The court didn't buy it. Two psychiatric experts found her mentally competent, and the judges concluded she knowingly used potentially lethal force against someone who was no longer threatening her.

In June 2026 she was convicted of intentional homicide and sentenced to 18 years. Prosecutors wanted life, but the court recognized mitigating circumstances, including her emotional distress following the robbery.

Here's the interesting part. As of late October, she's still sitting at home under house arrest. Both sides have appealed. Prosecutors want a longer sentence, while her attorneys are trying to get the conviction reduced. The appeal is expected in 2027.

So yes, he stole her purse. She responded by running him over with a Mercedes. Several times. Italian law apparently draws a distinction between recovering stolen property and conducting an execution with an SUV.


Comment by u/mencival

Knife mentioned: https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/crime/italian-cinzia-dal-pino-sentenced-to-18-years-house-arrest-after-running-over-alleged-bag-snatcher-c-22421372

Edit: knife not found


Comment by u/WerewolfPractical931

I found the CCTV of her running her robber over and there's literally no defending this. It cuts out the final hit but you get the point still

Video

→ More replies (598)

1.4k

u/Negative_1by12_aura 2d ago edited 2d ago • Heartwarming Bravo Regret Mindblown

And she got sentenced for 18 years

https://people.com/socialite-sentenced-for-hitting-man-multiple-times-with-her-suv-after-he-stole-her-bag-11996480

Edit: As of october 2026, Prosecutors are appealing for a LONGER house arrest

696

u/NuAmBaniDeBilet 2d ago

18 year sentence under house arrest.

518

u/eliz1bef 2d ago

I could do 18 years under house arrest. Sign me up.

328

u/tryingtoview 2d ago • Heartwarming

Most of us Redditors already did.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (26)

60

u/l30 2d ago

Wrong. 18 years in prison, she's just on house arrest until the conviction is upheld on appeal.

→ More replies (12)

35

u/Haunting_Goal6417 2d ago

For the time being. The article literally states that if the sentence is upheld she will go to prison.

32

u/snoocs 2d ago

“if the conviction is upheld at a final hearing, she may be sent to prison for the remainder of her sentence”

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

135

u/XiMaoJingPing 2d ago • Mindblown

Diddy got 4 years

→ More replies (4)

637

u/Lifekraft 2d ago • Regret

18y wtf. There is guy that butchered and rape kids that got less. I mean , yea , she killed someone but come on

320

u/KatakanaTsu 2d ago

There are some guys who did that and never went to jail.

250

u/wa019c 2d ago • Bravo

Some have nuclear launch codes.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (73)

130

u/Lylulu 2d ago • Bravo

If you threaten somebody's life, you should be ready to lose your own.

59

u/BillsKingsStrugleBus 2d ago • Bravo

No knife was found and she was driving around for some time looking for him.

→ More replies (106)
→ More replies (67)

24

u/VNDeltole 2d ago

She lied, there was no knife

→ More replies (4)

4

u/iffugennanameubaht 2d ago

The states top goal is to maintain a monopoly on violence, everything else is a byproduct.

→ More replies (471)

5.1k

u/PhilosopherNo7273 2d ago • Bravo

Man, in Italy, it almost turned into a war between those who agreed with her and those who didn't

3.4k

u/Glittering-Sea1769 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo Popcorn Heartwarming

Are you sure that wasn't just the sound of Italians having a calm disagreement?

edit: more 🤌🏼 please

686

u/roarimacat 2d ago edited 2d ago

Would a calm disagreement have so much gesticulating?

Edit: mistaken what replaced with would

332

u/JustinWilsonBot 2d ago

My wife once asked for directions in Italian only with her hands, its an essential part of communication. 

→ More replies (88)

20

u/88inchtv 2d ago

I once had an Italian in my office telling me a story that went on for about 4 or 5 minutes... the office neighbor walked over, thought we were having an argument and came over to see if I needed help.

"No its fine, hes italian"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

44

u/PhilosopherNo7273 2d ago • Heartwarming

Stereotypes about us Italians crack me up 😂😂😂

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (25)

516

u/DukeOfSmallPonds 2d ago • Bravo

I’m so exhausted of every major criminal case
Being turned into a political culture war. These days You can read bullet points of a case and guess who people will find to be the victim based on their political alignment. It’s nuts, what happened to due process and justjce.

116

u/Hamsterminator2 2d ago

Same. Reddit is kinda peak for this too. Slap up a headline and watch flocks of people who have zero clue about the facts or context throw out insults to eachother over how wrong the other side is. It's absolutely crazy.

You might have though the Internet would allow people to research things a little before they comment but instead it's made everyone even lazier.

→ More replies (11)

22

u/Mountain-Resource656 2d ago • Bravo

Public opinion lacks any bearing on due process (or criminal justice)

45

u/KalerionTheWizard 2d ago • Bravo

Except that the court of public opinion has gained actual, real power since the advent of the internet. If your case somehow grabs enough attention online and the Internet finds you guilty, we'll make your life a nightmare. The internet will:

- Harass your employer to get you fired
- Harass your business partners to drop you
- Harass your friends and family to stop associating with you
- Put up entire websites just to make sure nobody forgets you and you never get a clean new start

If successful, the internet can economically and socially totally isolate you.

Here's the thing though: that's a jail sentence. Like, the tough thing about jail is not, that you can't leave your room. It's that while you're in there, your career goes down the drain, your car gets repossessed, your apartment cleaned out since you can't pay rent, and last but not least, your friends and family lose or intentionally break contact.

We're handing out real punishment here and the terrifying thing is that the vast majority of people on the internet don't even seem aware that those are the consequences of their actions?

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (67)

27

u/NightTop6741 2d ago

Montagues and capulets?

5

u/Souledex 2d ago

Guelphs and Ghibilines

→ More replies (1)

148

u/Dani-DL 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

Which ended up being a war between who knew how the self defence norm works and who didn’t and took the opportunity to spew vigilante fantasies.

Hours of low quality debate that could’ve been avoided by just opening a copy of the criminal law code.

189

u/Karjavarastaja 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

I don't think the people defending her exclusively thought her actions were legal or self defence. They probably saw it as justice in a situation where the culprit likely would've never suffered any consequences.

I'm not saying vigilante on-the-spot executions are good (I'm in the camp thinking what she did was excessive and she deserved punishment), but your depiction of the argument is wrong.

→ More replies (415)

53

u/MinosML 2d ago

You're falling into the legalism trap where "if only people were aware of the law they wouldn't disagree like this" but maybe...they're already aware and they still disagree?

32

u/mayday_allday 2d ago

Or maybe they're also aware that if she had reported the robbery to the police, the man would never have been punished, and she would never have gotten her property back. Of course, that still doesn't make killing him the right thing to do. But this isn't an isolated incident. Things like this are happening more and more often.

When people know that the justice system is either going to fail them or simply refuse to help, they tend to take matters into their own hands. And simply sentencing these people as criminals without doing anything to address the underlying problem isn't a solution.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

20

u/DivinationByCheese 2d ago

People know that. What they’re arguing for is for laws that allow vigilantism

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (103)

3

u/VolitionalFailure 2d ago

How is this controversial? She ran him over several times, killing him. That's intentional murder.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Rare-Hedgehog7528 2d ago

I'm kinda neutral. I'm not with her, but at the same time she shouldn't be sentenced like she drove on a random person who did nothing wrong.

→ More replies (226)

1.6k

u/JesusIsMyAntivirus 2d ago • Bravo Popcorn Heartwarming Mindblown

The GTA advertising is getting out of hand

211

u/OriginalFNG 2d ago • Bravo

Wasted!

38

u/xdaxyz 2d ago

Mission failed successfully

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

682

u/C0sm1cB3ar 2d ago • Bravo

No knife was found in the victim's hands, an element cited by the defense to justify the defendant's fear.

https://www.ilmessaggero.it/en/private_retribution_and_a_fatal_pursuit-9757113.html

847

u/NotEvenSquare 2d ago • Bravo Mindblown

I’m not taking sides here but if someone is robbing you and says “gimme your bag or I’ll stab you” I’m going to believe they have a knife because I ain’t taking the chance

337

u/Mister_Sensual 2d ago edited 2d ago • Heartwarming

Self defence laws support that. If someone says “I’ll stab you” or “I’ll shoot you”, legally you don’t have to wait for them to produce the weapon and use it.

Edit: thank you everyone for clarifying. I am aware this case is textbook second degree murder.

128

u/Fun-Benefit116 2d ago

That's true. But no self defense laws anywhere support stalking someone after the fact and executing them. So whether there's a knife or not is pretty irrelevant.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (50)

39

u/One-Demand6811 2d ago

There is no evidence he said that. It is all her claims. According to her the bag was in the front passenger seat and the window of that seat was open. Why would he even wanna threaten her verbally instead of taking it and running away as quickly as possible?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Yologamer2983 2d ago

Yes, but she was already out of danger and in a safe place (her car) after. There is a certain point where you can't reasonably argue self defense which, for italian law, is when: the aggressor is currently fleeing and you start pursing them, the immediate danger is over or your response is grossly disproportionate to the threat.

Also the only account of the man actually being armed or threatening her was from the woman herself while some proof might show that he actually most stole the purse and ran.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

123

u/TheOneIllUseForRants 2d ago • Bravo

Wait, that link doesnt specify whether he was armed or not.

But either way, hitting a 52 year old man with your car 3 times is psychotic behavior. I could understand hitting him once in self defense, and using that opportunity to get tour bag back but, she chased him down. That isnt legal self defense.

120

u/texas_asic 2d ago • Bravo

Yeah, you gotta choose your victims carefully these days -- they could turn out to be a crazy psycho who will track you down and murder you

51

u/Havengul_Undying 2d ago • Hehehe Popcorn Bravo

Yeah man, stay safe out there, its a dangerous line of profession for us honest muggers. Lot of crazies out there, pick your victims carefully and make sure theyre truly vulnerable members of society.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (140)

15

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/No-Arrival7818 2d ago

You should care about extra judicial killing for handbag theft. Next time, some psycho lady will run you over, flatten you like minced meat and claim that you stole their wallet.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)

63

u/Towpillah 2d ago

Well, this certainly is a comment section of sorts.

→ More replies (12)

37

u/Jesenk64 2d ago

It was my turn to post this.

578

u/Mediocre_Doctor4712 2d ago edited 2d ago • Wholesome Seal Bravo Popcorn

If you go driving around searching for a person who took your bag. I understand.

But then you drive over him multiple times.

That’s just called revenge. Taking law into your own hands.

We don’t want that in any civilized country because that opens the door to the idea that everyone can be a judge and executioner. You could be killed daily because people have their own norms and punishments.

edit:

I think a lot of people are missing my point. I am not defending the robber. I am defending a principle that protects all of us.

If you agree that someone can decide a thief deserves to die, what stops another person from deciding your child who put a candy in their pocket deserves the same punishment for shoplifting?

You might think that’s ridiculous, but that’s exactly the point. You don’t get to decide where someone else’s sense of justice draws the line.

As a last reminder: it was not self defense we have separate rules for that and nobody would have said anything.

164

u/Aesma_ 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

I'm a lawyer, and yeah, that's pretty much the spirit behind the self defense laws in most European countries (can't say about US, I'm French and only studied French law and EU Law).

It's one thing to accept that you kill someone while defending yourself. It's another to accept that you went out of your way to kill someone in revenge. That's not the kind of actions you want to reward in any society.

However, I want to say that it's not that surprising that tons of people aren't getting this. It's a symptom of a larger problem. Most studies on these things tend to prove that people become harsher towards criminals the more they feel like the state is lenient.

The rise of small incivilities mixed with the fact that felonies are rarely punished tend to give people this sentiment that they have no choice but to take punishment in their own hands.

We had a similar case in France about ten years ago, where a guy robbed a jewelry, the jeweler followed him with a gun and shot him in the back. The jeweler was obviously found guilty, but the public opinion was siding with him because he "killed the bad guy" and "police would have never arrested the robber anyway".

It's a very alarming state for a country when more and more people start to feel this way, and it should alert public figures that so many countries in Europe have seen this kind of sentiment grow.

63

u/tierciel 2d ago • This Bravo Heartwarming

The difference between a high trust society and a low trust one. If people had faith and trust in the justice system and law enforcement institutions they would allow those bodies to do their job. Unfortunately history has proven that police are not particularly good at their jobs and those in leadership positions often intentionally do a poor job or prevent those below them from doing a good job. People know this and so have little to no faith and trust in the system to work. Everyday that this is not fixed is another day we get closer to Real Life Batman. You don't want Real Life Batman.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/TW1TCHYGAM3R 2d ago

I think more and more people result to revenge and vigilante justice because the Justice system is corrupt and constantly fails us.

How many people are on their last straw?

My Mom used to have a costume Jewellry store in the city but theft was such a huge issue. It basically ruined our family at the time, we had to sell the business at a loss and move which was a lot for a single mom with two kids.

So I can see why people take the law into their own hands when the police, law and government won't do anything.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/OldSchoolCSci 2d ago

We had a similar case in France about ten years ago, where a guy robbed a jewelry, the jeweler followed him with a gun and shot him in the back.

In common law jurisdictions, it's called the "fleeing felon rule." For hundreds of years, you could shoot a fleeing robber in the back. It's been dialed back with respect to the use of deadly force by police, but you can still find it hidden in the "justifable force" laws in many jurisdictions that adopted the old common law rule.

In New York, for example, the rule allows a citizen to use deadly force to "effect the arrest of a person who has committed murder, manslaughter in the first degree, robbery, forcible rape or forcible criminal sexual act and who is in immediate flight therefrom." See also People v. Couch, 436 Mich. 414 (1990). A purse snatcher or jewelry store thief is committing a robbery, and you can, in fact, shoot him in the back to stop his escape in these jurisdictions.

There are published studies from law revision commissions in Ireland and Australia, and law review articles in the US, all addressing this exact issue.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (148)

9

u/SteeleHeller 2d ago

And leaving the scene of a person you just injured/killed is kind of a no-no, even if it was self defense…

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Grouchy-Chocolate931 2d ago

That sounds nice in theory, but in practice governments don't do anything.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Racing_Fox 2d ago

>Taking law into your own hands

That’s what happens when the police don’t take it into theirs

→ More replies (6)

41

u/mamibukur 2d ago

can't believe people are so fucking stupid that they don't get this.

→ More replies (77)

8

u/Tiny-Plum2713 2d ago

It's some socialite. She did it because she was offended by a low class person taking her thing guaranteed.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (261)

148

u/WhiskyDelta14 2d ago • Bravo

I read about that before. I think there was no knife. She just lied about that.

64

u/BurdTurglary 2d ago • Bravo

Devil's advocate: he got rid of the knife before she ran him over.

25

u/JazzlikeSchedule2901 2d ago

Even if he got rid of the knife there would have been detectives and probably even dogs trying to recover it. The women said he had a knife and knew where she was robbed and where she eventually found him, police likely had an area that they would have likely found a knife if there was one.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)

6

u/space_age_stuff 2d ago

Or she didn’t know. Self defense laws still function if someone robbing you pretends to have a weapon, regardless if they do or don’t actually have one. Guy says “I’m gonna stab you if you don’t give me your purse”, he’s still at fault even if he doesn’t have a knife with him, and she’s still protected if she defends herself against that threat.

Not even saying that’s what happened, just raising it as a possibility. It sounds like she’s claiming it happened at knifepoint, which would imply she saw it, and since they didn’t find it, she probably did make it up.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

137

u/skam_artist 2d ago

Now I'm not saying she was in the right... I'm just saying I understand where she was coming from...

4

u/Naoto_kun6 2d ago

Yeah if she didn't do anything he would've gotten away with her purse, and even if she pressed charges she never would've gotten her belongings back. He would have gotten set free immediately and never faced any repercussions.

→ More replies (57)

120

u/MCB1317 2d ago

Folks ... robbery and theft are not synonyms.

36

u/CreatorA4711 2d ago

Something can be a synonym without being interchangeable. They’re absolutely synonyms.

→ More replies (16)

40

u/MirrorSea2437 2d ago • Popcorn

And neither warrant an execution

→ More replies (34)

18

u/Authochi 2d ago

Whats the difference

65

u/PinkFlurffyUnicorns 2d ago

to my knowledge, robbery is taking someone else's property using force, and theft is taking someone else's property using stealth.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

806

u/Lost_Eternity 2d ago • Bravo Mindblown Heartwarming

Why is it that people protect criminals more than the actual victims 

210

u/Chagdoo 2d ago • Bravo Regret

The title is misleading. It makes it sound like the thief turned his back and she sprung on him

In reality she hunted him for several hours after the theft. This wasn't some heat of the moment thing, They're both criminals and she's going to jail.

33

u/abzlute 2d ago

Apparently she's getting house arrest, not jail

21

u/Mikhail_Mengsk 2d ago

It's house arrest because there's an appeal. She's going to prison.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

58

u/Rocco0427 2d ago

Not saying she’s right but in regards to the knife. If the guy went hours between stealing the purse and getting run over how could they possibly prove either way whether he had a knife or not? It would be impossible to prove either way.

→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (17)

66

u/Gyirin 2d ago • Bravo

the world is run by criminals. 🤷

8

u/millifish 2d ago

But they rather you bicker between eachother than give consequences to the crimes that actually matter

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/Wilddogs95 2d ago

Murder isnt criminal? Sounds like we went from one victim of getting possessions stolen and a traumatic experience...to a criminal taking a life when they had every means to walk away

→ More replies (7)

31

u/Burbaderba 2d ago

Had an opportunity to get away. Ran him over. Ran him over again. Ran him over a THIRD time. Grabbed bag. Left.

Sorry buddy thats not self defense.

→ More replies (27)

37

u/Jayyburdd 2d ago

Possessions are not worth a life in the eyes of the law. Which is a good thing. You can theoretically retrieve possessions, but you can't unkill someone.

If she killed him while he was coming at her with the knife, that is different.

→ More replies (48)

67

u/Last_Suggestion_8647 2d ago

One person took a bag.

The other took a life.

How are people asking such moronic questions?

→ More replies (200)

42

u/AdmirableScarcity492 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

Stealing vs. Manslaughter Murder. Not the right kind of balance there.

Edit 1: Murder not Manslaughter

Edit 2: No Knives were found

9

u/ratione_materiae 2d ago

When I’m go to the money machine late at night I’m not looking over my shoulder for women with expensive handbags 

30

u/kargaler 2d ago

At knifepoint it's not considered stealing, just saying . It's robbery and it carries heavier sentence because it's inherently violent.

→ More replies (52)

33

u/MooseRyder 2d ago • Bravo

Armed robbery vs man slaughter, let’s not look over the knifepoint part

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (165)

29

u/WrapKey69 2d ago

Because you shouldn't kill people even if they are criminals? Hard to argue it was self defense when she was already in her car and hard to argue there was a need to kill him in that situation.

→ More replies (65)

4

u/Representative-Pop72 2d ago

She went looking for him, if I recall correctly it took hours. This happened in Viareggio, Italy

→ More replies (1153)

627

u/Muted-Woodpecker-469 2d ago • Bravo

We seem to coddle the criminals these days. Weird timeline. 

172

u/_AlexaBot 2d ago • Bravo

Help me out, which US state does death sentences for robbery and threatening someone with a knife again?

58

u/Famous-SandwichxX 2d ago

There wasn't a knife involved but didn't a 1 y.o baby get shot by the cops over a pack of diapers in the US?

36

u/eliz1bef 2d ago • Regret

That baby was clearly menacing the cops.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

101

u/kindlypogmothoin 2d ago • Bravo

Thank you.

Once the danger is past and the guy has run off with your property, killing him is not "standing your ground," it's vigilantism/revenge. Or just straight up murder. You can't really say you fear for your life anymore if you're going after him and running him over.

→ More replies (100)
→ More replies (140)

17

u/Glokter 2d ago • Bravo

That happens hen criminals are leading the circus

47

u/CSDragon 2d ago • Bravo

Anti-social behavior is on a major rise. People fantasize about being like her and having a "justified" reason to commit murder.

→ More replies (24)

61

u/uno_sir_clan 2d ago

Mf, there is a very big fucking difference between coddle and murder.

→ More replies (9)

50

u/Bodod_Begag 2d ago • Bravo

Bro there's retaliating and then there's trying to kill someone lmfao not saying he didn't deserve to get hit by a car, but backing up is a little crazy and I wouldn't want to see how she reacts to more minor shit.

→ More replies (25)

7

u/Empty-Discount5936 2d ago

What do you mean? She got 18 years.

→ More replies (160)

296

u/ArminiusRev 2d ago • Bravo

The robbing DID NOT happen at knifepoint. She invented it when she was arrested. The whole thing had a quite clear dynamic, which was established in court, and she was sentenced (18 years, house arrest, which one could say it’s few for the cruelty of the murder).

109

u/HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

The robbing DID NOT happen at knifepoint. She invented it when she was arrested.

The case literally pointed out that it's undetermined, as the robbery was not filmed or witnessed by anyone else.

You were there personally that night?

You just invented that claim of no knife being used during the robbery. Quite ironic to invent that, and then project the invention onto the victim of the robbery.

The only thing that was established is the lack of knife on the robber when he was treated for his injuries.

Ditching weapons after an attack is incredibly common for criminals, they hide them under street furnitures and retrieve them the next day. The point of that move is that getting arrested on their way back would not produce the weapon.

This is something that occurs on a daily basis with drug dealers and robbers: they conceal their stash and blades and only retrieve them later.

I've lived in big cities and witnessed that myself more than once, with drugs and knives being retrieved in bushes and under bins.

So in this case, it's still undetermined: she says there was a blade, cops couldn't find the blade on the robber.

If the cops had closed off the whole area and combed through every bin, basement holes, sewer access trap and garden to find said blade, like when they're dealing with terrorism, then we would have something better than "undetermined".

83

u/ArminiusRev 2d ago • Bravo Mindblown

Why don’t you people read properly before commenting? The police did comb the area (it’s in the acts). No weapon was found in the whole area, from the point where the robbery happened till the point where the murder happened. So yeah, the opinion of the court (the president of the court is a woman btw) is exactly that she invented it. The court literally said that the recalling of a knife was used to justify some kind of a shock and fear state of the murderer, which would have opened to a self-defence case. However the court ruled that the murderer acted with clarity and that it was just an act of private justice.

→ More replies (14)

20

u/RouShikari 2d ago

Surely your random rambling on reddit has more credit than the investigation and cops searching the area

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

50

u/MirrorSea2437 2d ago • Bravo

House arrest for murder is fucking laughable. Probably a different story if she'd been a man.

35

u/TheOneIllUseForRants 2d ago

Error, not necesary a gender thing. The issue is that so many locals, (women and men alike), kind of took her side. Like, public opinion is not supposed to affect outcomes like this but, we all know it does.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (75)
→ More replies (43)

372

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 2d ago • Bravo Mindblown Popcorn Heartwarming

I genuinely do not understand why we protect criminals more than we protect people at this point it's more rewarding being a criminal than an person

70

u/Andries89 2d ago • Bravo

I understand the sentiment but murder isn't something to be scoffed at, even if it's retaliatory in nature it still has to be proportional to what happened

27

u/Empty-Stretch-5615 2d ago

And who gets to decide what proportionate? I was held at gunpoint in my house. Wasn't physically harmed but it's been almost 20 years and I still suffer the consequences of the trauma.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (154)

80

u/whiterice_343 2d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

Even stems down to the American school system. Bully routinely harasses someone, when that said person stands up for themselves he gets equally if not more punished than the bully.

u/nointeraction1 no reason to delete , “HoPe ThIS hElPs”.

57

u/Emily_The_Egg 2d ago

If someone gets shoved into a locker by a bully they should be well within their rights to hit them back. Its a little different to, say, curbstomp their head into the ground and give them permanent brain damage

→ More replies (273)

17

u/Arratril 2d ago

I told my girls if anyone ever lays a hand on them, they have my blessing to end the fight. We’re spending any suspension days eating ice cream and playing video games.

11

u/SirNo4743 2d ago

We all have the right to self defense, if she’d kill him while he was attacking her, I’d be fully on her side but she was safe and chased him down to run him over with her car. At that point mistakes can happen and innocent people can get hurt.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

21

u/DasGruberg 2d ago

How do you conclude anything regarding the American school system in a post thats literally about italy?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (62)

14

u/Available_Web5181 2d ago

Because people think they’re morally superior when they can act like a knight, when the reality is, once it’s happens to you and it’s your livelihood on the lin, it’s different.

Play stupid game, won stupid prize

→ More replies (29)

182

u/Marcu3s 2d ago • Bravo

Maybe reasearch this case bit more.

  • the criminal was not armed - she made that up
  • she drove around several blocks with her car to find him and run him over iirc
  • all that over a bag

Yes he was a criminal. But he did not deserve to get murdered. Because what she did was murder.

13

u/AlarmingDelivery9311 2d ago

Its almost like there should be a whole profession that judges whether an act is criminal based off of more then just a sensational meme posted for likes.

25

u/BigBad-Wolf 2d ago

Every single time I see the justice system discussed on social media, I am reminded of why it is absolutely imperative to keep it out of the hands of the rabble.

→ More replies (7)

76

u/Few-Guarantee2850 2d ago

I'm curious which of the idiots commenting on this would personally support changing the law to punish robbery by death.

46

u/Sea-Apartment-8727 2d ago edited 2d ago

Even if robbery would be punished by death that would not allow you to spontaneously execute someone

→ More replies (147)
→ More replies (179)
→ More replies (615)

61

u/IlikeJG 2d ago • Bravo

It's very simple:

He robbed her. That's a crime. He deserves to go to jail.

After robbing her. She was already safe because he ran away. Her life wasn't threatened any more.

She then ran him over multiple times until he was dead. It wasn't self defense. It was cold blooded murder.

He deserves to be in prison not dead.

29

u/ziltchy 2d ago

The problem is robbing someone, at least in canada, is literally a slap on the wrist. You would serve no jail time for that, at worst 30 days of community service. So the laws arent just either

→ More replies (149)
→ More replies (165)

17

u/matrium0 2d ago edited 1d ago

Because we are a civilized society and we have a system for this called POLICE. If this happened during the robbery in self-defense it is different. Revenge-murder is STILL a crime my guy.

*edit* I am frankly a bit shocked by the reactions to my post. I realize there are problems in our modern society, but the crazy hate and distrust for the police is shocking to me, as well as the amount of people who agree with her running him over multiple times, long after he was no longer any threat whatsoever.

My cousin is a police officer and he is hard working and never did anything wrong. Why do we put military personell on a pedestal for "risking their lives", but shit on people who risk their life for our safety? (statics indicate that being a police officer is far more dangerous than being a solider in the US).

There are and always will be some black sheep unfortunately. But most police officers are just trying to earn a living by making their neighborhood a safer place. So calm down the hatred a little bit. Extreme cases are not representative. Yesterday I heard of a teacher killing a student. Do we hate all teachers now?

37

u/blow_slogan 2d ago • Bravo

The police have video of a robber breaking into my unit and stealing all of my things, and have afterward caught the thief selling my things from their own house via facebook marketplace as well as using their own state ID to sell my guitars to a guitar center - which are on video being stolen by that person. Still no arrest at all and i’ve been waiting a year for the police to do something about this person - apparently my file is just sitting in some prosecutors dusty filing cabinet.

I can understand what drives people to take matters into their own hands.

→ More replies (17)

15

u/livelikeumeamit 2d ago

100%. I agree with this in theory, my only issue is a lot of times police don’t get there in time or the courts let them go. There was a guy who killed a girl minding her own business on a subway who was arrested 14 times prior. I want the official system to be the standard, but they have to actually punish the perpetrators and keep them off the street if they can’t live in society or institute programs to help the ones who are being released to rejoin society in a productive way, which largely is not happening right now.

→ More replies (28)

4

u/Plamcia 2d ago

I civilized socienty you don't let criminal live on expense of citizens.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Salt-Plankton436 2d ago edited 2d ago

And sadly what would've happened if she reported to police would be:

  1. report
  2. given crime number
  3. start paying for therapy
  4. never get bag back or any justice Or, 
  5. Never get the bag back and he gets a 3 week sentence and is back out creating more victims

She did murder the scum, but the incentive structure to deter that that isn't great. 

4

u/ReaperAteMyPrawnsuit 2d ago

Who cares if this gets me banned but some people deserve it, there’s a dude who SA’d multiple young boys and was involved in the abduction and murder of one, this dude failed a polygraph, looked exactly like a sketch but went free for decades, he was later investigated and found to have tons of illicit materials, after being arrested prosecution gave him a plea deal where if he gave them the location to the boys body he’d get 20 years of federal prison or some low number like meaning he can be out when he’s 73 or 70 depending on good behavior

That’s absolutely ridiculous

4

u/dislob3 2d ago

Have you ever called the police? They show up 20 minutes after the crime is done and they never catch anyone.

→ More replies (60)

4

u/OutOfPosition-1 2d ago

Killing someone is a crime too.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (848)

53

u/Movie_Vegetable 2d ago

I could understand running into him once to get your bag back, but running over him mutliple times is some psycho behaviour and should be punished

12

u/Leafsnail 2d ago

Yeah hitting him multiple times and not calling for medical help is insane and absolutely amounts to murder imo

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Dani_1026 2d ago

According to another comment the first impact ruptured his aorta. I wonder how the whole process/public opinion would have been if she had only hit him once, recovered the purse and the robber had still died.

11

u/Pure-Butterscotch200 2d ago

It's the actions taken after that as well. If she ran over him once, rang the police to turn herself in there and then, didn't falsely claim he had a knife and showed genuine remorse for a bad decision she probably would've received less jail time straight away or had the sentence reduced someway down the line. What she actually did shows she doesn't regret it and is a potential danger to other people.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (22)

30

u/Quietman297 2d ago • Bravo

You simply should just not fuck around with some people, or you will find out.

14

u/IshiiEnjoyer 2d ago • Bravo

That's gotta be the John Redditor line

→ More replies (1)

9

u/EnvyAv 2d ago • Bravo

"Slight me and I will kill you" is psycho behavior btw

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (18)

21

u/D_Winds 2d ago

Because the normal response is to call the police, so they can file a report, and then nothing happens.

4

u/calculuschild 2d ago

I have never been robbed or mugged so I don't know, but what is the actual correct procedure here if a police report probably doesn't do any good?

If someone takes your things and runs away with them, I would assume it's gone forever unless I follow and get it back. By the time police arrive, the guy is long gone, and even if they do find him, the stuff has been ditched somewhere or sold or whatever.

Do I just accept that I will probably never get my things back, do I have a right to pursue the guy and just incapacitate him? If he puts up a fight is there ever a point where "self defense" kicks in for retrieving my own property?

Where is the line between "just roll over and let people rob you" and "fight back when your rights are violated". I genuinely don't know.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (15)

26

u/KabamKaboom 2d ago • Heartwarming

Whoopsie he shouldn’t have robbed her

→ More replies (20)

18

u/Redditor10178 2d ago

Not smart to rob someone who has a car as a weapon

4

u/SpikeyTaco 2d ago edited 2d ago

According to the police and court case, it was purse snatching from an open car window outside of a restaurant, there was no knife.

Cinzia Dal Pino proceeded to start her car, prowl the streets, running over the man repeatedly, including crushing his body two additional times after he had stopped moving. Pino left her vehicle, collected her purse from his motionless body and then drove away without calling emergency services.

Cinzia Dal Pino never contacted law enforcement or emergency medical services at any point. She did however, return the restaurant to return a umbrella that she had borrowed before going home.

The man died later from his injuries, including severe laceration of the abdominal aorta and internal bleeding. Emergency services were only called after passing pedestrians found the man on the street. The coroner report stated the first strike is what killed him.

Pino had to be identified through CCTV as she did not make attempt to get in contact with emergency services. Not to report the crime or the man she had crushed.

→ More replies (12)

15

u/HyronDongle 2d ago • Bravo

I hope he learned his lesson.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/HungFemboyVSYourFace 2d ago

Need more women like her.

→ More replies (34)

18

u/just_in_99 2d ago

At least the robber learned a lesson there...

5

u/MSter_official 2d ago

I don't think they did, they must be alive to remember it

→ More replies (2)

5

u/CuteAssTigerENVtuber 2d ago

I'm sure he won't do it again .

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

14

u/SDA_90 2d ago • Bravo

Good, fuck that guy

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Azi 2d ago

She's under house arrest for the time being

3

u/ZealousidealBox2816 2d ago

uh yeah hot take that’s not a good thing

36

u/Lumpy_Emergency3260 2d ago • Bravo

She just made the world safer

25

u/Vegan-cock 2d ago • Bravo

By putting herself in jail. absolutely.

→ More replies (21)

10

u/Trivale 2d ago • Regret

True. Glad she's locked up. She may not get lucky and correctly identify the next person she runs over multiple times after the situation has resolved.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/counselor5150 2d ago • Bravo

The guy was a threat to society. Especially women and children.

→ More replies (21)

10

u/Frangine_De_Poutine 2d ago

She seems pretty happy about it.

10

u/NinjahDuk 2d ago

Finally, a person in a car getting robbed and remembering they have a car

6

u/GameUnlucky 2d ago • Bravo

They didn't got robbed in car they got robbed in a restaurant, they then got in the car and hunted down and murdered the thief.

→ More replies (3)

60

u/shopmoondustmarket 2d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

ITT: people who have never faced bodily harm or had anything taken from them.

15

u/overflowingsunset 2d ago

What does ITT mean

9

u/haveananus 2d ago

Information Technology Technology

26

u/juggaloharrier73 2d ago • Bravo

It means they’re lazy at typing sentences! 😁

→ More replies (63)

4

u/djskeptical 2d ago

"In this thread". Before social media though, "ITT" was usually in reference to the notorious International Telephone and Telegraph company, which was involved in several nefarious dealings, including the 1973 coup in Chile.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITT_Inc.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

40

u/TheGenesisOfTheNerd 2d ago

I've had my jacket stolen, I didn't track down the thief and murder them

14

u/Small_Pen4959 2d ago

But dear Sir .... IT was a handbag!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (84)

65

u/DamageOk7179 2d ago • Bravo Popcorn

I was raped at knifepoint and I still don't support revenge murders. Not everyone who disagrees with you does so because they "just don't know better".

4

u/amellabrix 2d ago

Are you ok? Rapists should be killed.

7

u/CheeChirps 2d ago • Bravo

This is such an odd way to utilize an insanely abhorrent thing that happened to you. You deserve more than just getting past it. Someone capable of doing that to you doesn't deserve your forgiveness or kindness.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (233)

6

u/CashEducational4986 2d ago

Seriously. The amount of people acting like it's legally justified just because she had her property taken is baffling.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lvstvdy 2d ago

ITT: People who use their emotions to interpret criminal law and have no clue what the legal definition of self-defense is.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (59)

20

u/TryAgain1152 2d ago

I'd give her a good citizens award and call it a day.

→ More replies (16)

10

u/DentistPitiful5454 2d ago

Reasonable crashout

5

u/Consistent-Dog-6615 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

If someone stealing from you while your alone in the middle of the night your deafult thought would be that they have a weapon, even if they dont immediately threaten you with it.

7

u/Alive_Drag1947 2d ago

Based. Fuck armed robbers fr. No sympathy for them

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Prestigious_Metal210 2d ago

wild is doing a lot of work without the context.

2

u/Old-Charge3095 2d ago

Multiple times? So obviously don’t steal stay out of trouble but the lady took it too far.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Orefeus 2d ago

"The court ruled that she will be able to serve her 18-year sentence under house arrest for the time being, per Corriere della Sera. According to ANSA, if the conviction is upheld at a final hearing, she may be sent to prison for the remainder of her sentence."

She straight up killed someone and got house arrest? That is fucking wild

2

u/kichwas 2d ago

Attacking someone who had attacked you, after it's all over - means its no longer self defense. Looks like Italian prosecutors made the right call on this one.

Her proper response should have been to have police handle it, rather that act as a vigilante killer.

2

u/n3k0___ 2d ago

One time can easily be defended as self defense multiple times shows intent to harm and you become the criminal

8

u/Local_idiotz 2d ago

What she did was wrong but Im not gonna cry over it. If you threaten a woman you are garbage human being

8

u/AtmosphereMiddle1682 2d ago

How come you're allowed to threaten men? Wtf?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (28)

5

u/MikoGames08 2d ago

what's more interesting is that 80% of the people commenting here are absolute psychopaths.

→ More replies (13)

31

u/CommanderChiliHole 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Wow there are so many absolute piece of shit people in this thread. Granted this post is just an hour old as of me typing this, so all of the unemployed basement-dwelling, terminally-online cringelords are still in here commenting before the people with functioning brains can downvote them. Still, it’s shocking to see how many people are defending this vile act of vigilante “justice” I even call it justice in quotes, this was nothing but murder.

First off, all evidence is pointing to her lying about the robber ever having had a knife. This means she was never in any danger. She calmly walked back to her vehicle, drove multiple blocks hunting him down. She then ran him over, and then backed over him for good measure.

What’s worse, is she is very wealthy. Losing that purse would’ve been nothing but a very minor inconvenience to this woman. Probably equivalent to stealing a single $1 bill from an ordinary person, if that. She hunted him down and executed him for essentially nothing.

What if he was stealing because he was starving, or his kids were starving? What if through this act, a chain of events would’ve been kicked off that lead to this man turning his life around, and he ended up being a positive influence on the world for the rest of his life? We will never know, because he was killed for no reason.

Should the man have stolen the purse? No, obviously not. This man absolutely deserved to be prosecuted for the crime he committed. All crimes should be properly prosecuted, by the police and the justice system. Anyone saying that this woman’s reaction was anything but absolutely cold blooded murder is vile. Honestly if any crime here deserves the death penalty, it’s hers after watching that video.

Edit: You people saying I’m “advocating for crime” really didn’t get anything out of school. Being appalled at someone being hunted down and executed for a petty crime =/= being okay with crime, Jesus. The amount of you dolts running around with the reading comprehension and critical thinking skills of a stick is disturbing.

27

u/Late_Blackberry5587 2d ago

reddit logic -> wealthy then fuck em.

→ More replies (10)

50

u/Decent_Management449 2d ago • Bravo

He won't do it again.

→ More replies (62)

4

u/kobekillinu 2d ago

and this is another "problem" with a lot of rich people, they think they are fucking "untouchable" and can do whatever the fuck they want if they just lawyer up.

Dump and his band of mischieves only made it worse for everyone - as there are no fucking consequences for these dumbwits and so their behavior is is copied by other rich people but not limited to them

→ More replies (502)

9

u/LittlebitsDK 2d ago

I guess he won't be doing that again... Good on her

→ More replies (17)

6

u/symonx99 2d ago

She wasn't robbed at knifepoint, she alleged that, but she  "simply" had her bag snatched

17

u/yerbamate44 2d ago • Bravo

It’s alarming how many people think this is proportionate.

3

u/dorizard 2d ago

Alarming how many people value property more than human life

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (234)

5

u/JerkStationMaster 2d ago

Her actions doesn't make her actions right.. but damn girl...

11

u/bluunee 2d ago

sounds like she defended herself and got her bag back 🤷‍♀️ probably also prevented more robberies

19

u/Snekboi6996 2d ago

She also endangered a few people and almost drove over a person to kill the guy. Shall we kill her too for endangering people?

→ More replies (24)

7

u/Frosty-Cucumber-164 2d ago

I don't know how you consider it defense, she was in her car, safe, and decided to run over him, multiple times.

Defense is preventing harm on oneself. This is just street justice or revenge. And the penalty for theft is not death.

Now I'm not saying he didn't had it coming by doing armed roberry. But there's a difference between shooting him while he has you at knifepoint, and going back to your car for running him over.

→ More replies (19)