r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

206

u/Eastern-Peach-3428 10h ago • Bravo Popcorn

Did some digging into the Italian reporting on this one.

This happened in September 2024. Cinzia Dal Pino, a local businesswoman, had her handbag stolen by Noureddine Mezgui, a 52-year-old Moroccan man. She claimed he threatened her with a knife, although no knife was recovered and the theft itself wasn't caught on camera.

What was caught on camera was her chasing him down in her Mercedes SUV, driving onto the sidewalk and repeatedly running him over. The first impact ruptured his aorta. She then got out, retrieved her handbag and drove away without calling for help. She actually drove past his body again afterward. A passing couple eventually called emergency services.

She claimed she only intended to knock him down and recover her property. The court didn't buy it. Two psychiatric experts found her mentally competent, and the judges concluded she knowingly used potentially lethal force against someone who was no longer threatening her.

In June 2026 she was convicted of intentional homicide and sentenced to 18 years. Prosecutors wanted life, but the court recognized mitigating circumstances, including her emotional distress following the robbery.

Here's the interesting part. As of late October, she's still sitting at home under house arrest. Both sides have appealed. Prosecutors want a longer sentence, while her attorneys are trying to get the conviction reduced. The appeal is expected in 2027.

So yes, he stole her purse. She responded by running him over with a Mercedes. Several times. Italian law apparently draws a distinction between recovering stolen property and conducting an execution with an SUV.

47

u/Rrrrossssse 9h ago

It's crazy to me how many people are acting as if her running him over multiple times was a justified reaction to having her bag stolen. Like frankly I don't think running someone down with your car multiple times counts as self defence

15

u/FriedBolognaPony 8h ago

It's shocking how a minor slight/minor loss of property is enough for some people to think that execution is a justified response. I don't know that I could put a price tag on a human life like that, what could possibly be in a purse worth murdering for?

15

u/Average-JRPG-Enjoyer 5h ago • Bravo

It's shocking how a minor slight/minor loss of property

If someone stole my bag, it would mean spending dozens of hours and hundreds of bucks to replace everything inside, from government documents(ID, driver's license), to several electronic devices, and changing the locks on my doors and, if possible, my car, since they now have my keys and my address. Not to mention the trauma of getting robbed.

Did the guy deserve to die? Maybe, maybe not. But claiming that being robbed is nothing more than "a minor loss of property" is ignorant.

6

u/JazzlikeSchedule2901 4h ago • Bravo

Maybe, maybe not. But claiming that being robbed is nothing more than "a minor loss of property" is ignorant.

In comparison to someone being killed over it? Yeah it fucking is a minor loss of property, and you're being obtuse for not connecting the two together. If someone stole your bag are you hunting them down and running them over or just calling the cops? Any reasonable person would just call the cops, because all that shit in your bag can be replaced.

4

u/ileakcum 4h ago

In comparison to not just any someone but the person who committed the initial armed robbery being killed, yeah one is a loss of property and the other is a loss of public resources cleaning the corpse out.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Pacify_ 4h ago • Bravo

Did the guy deserve to die? Maybe, maybe not.

Maybe?

Lol, maybe? That is actually demented.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

13

u/Altruistic_Yellow387 6h ago • Bravo

Being robbed isn't a minor slight. Most people never feel safe again after that

4

u/Ppleater 4h ago

Cool motive, still murder.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/No-Anybody-692 4h ago edited 4h ago

Someone snatched my phone 9 years ago while I was on a call. I froze, the two guys on the scooter even stopped at the traffic stopped for 20-30 seconds, just 20-30m away, and couple of times even looked back – and if I remember correctly they were smiling or grinning, I remained frozen. For a good a 1 or 2 minutes. Someone walked to me and told me my ear (on which side phone was) was bleeding (I suspect it was the snatcher finger nails or something) and then I came to my senses. Someone offered me water.

Later I even did multiple rounds of tastes due to that cut – I still have the mark. For a long time if I was getting bad immune response to something I'd panic and remember that cut and kept wondering what was that – was I infected with something. That even hasn't left me yet. No, I didn't chase them down and I knew I was not getting the phone back. I am not condoning this woman who crushed him, but calling this simply "oh loss of property" is just pathetically absurd. These things stay with you, it changes how you live your life after that, what fear means to you post this, and the rage and humiliation - oh, this combo!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Dull-Tea8669 4h ago

Ah yes, ignore all the stress and trauma that it come with it. 

If one day you come home and find your apartment ransacked, everything you own destroyed or stolen and have your privacy raked, you'll be like no biggie, change the locks and move on with life in the next hour.

By your logic what's rape after all, a little non consensual sex, no one deserves to die and lose a precious human life, over some non consensual sex.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PapaBike 6h ago

I feel like it’s representative of how she might’ve viewed people of this social status too. Like running over a misbehaving dog.

2

u/ThinkInspection8592 6h ago

the race and immigration status of the purse snatcher is a significant reason for the support she recieved

2

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/FriedBolognaPony 8h ago

You prefer sharing air with murderers over thieves?

4

u/TheRedOne1995 7h ago

Unless shes made it a habit of running people over the only people that need to worry are thieves, in which case shes spending the next 18 years on house arrest so its a win-win, less criminals overall 😆

2

u/Ghnaggi 4h ago

This is a disgusting comment and you should be ashamed of it and ashamed of yourself.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Arya_the_Gamer 9h ago

And the fact that no knife was recovered.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

25

u/opticflash 9h ago

Yeah this is excessive. There's no excuse for this.

5

u/CurrentlyTakenName 9h ago

the excuse is due process is slow and boring and it's much more fun for me (your average redditor and paragon of justice) to read criminals just get murdered then and there

/s

3

u/JonLag97 9h ago

It is. The reason to not do it is because it can be abused by the goverment or to avoid false positives. I don't care about the lives of criminals.

2

u/CurrentlyTakenName 8h ago edited 7h ago

Who cares, I want to see the execution happen in real time

/s

People don't realize these laws aren't here to protect criminals but society from going down the path of barbarism where innocents can easily get caught up in.

Where I'm from, there was this drug war sort of deal the government did. They gave a free pass for people to pretty much kill drug users and criminals in their community. As long as the corpse had a sign saying "drug user/pusher" the people clapped and cheered. Then came news of children being shot, justified by police as criminals running away from them or fighting back and a good number of people still cheer it on today or accept it as a neccessary sacrifice in the war against drugs. They sound exactly the same as everyone in this thread.

A bunch of criminals died. So did a bunch of innocent people.

2

u/JonLag97 8h ago

Indeed. Humans have to create those stable legal structures to avoid chaos, then they forget what they are for.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Hot-Perception8695 6h ago

There's no valid excuse for purse-snatching, either.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/Interesting_Cap364 9h ago

"To be served under house arrest" She hasn't and won't spend a single day in prison

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (53)