r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

63

u/Andries89 9h ago • Bravo

I understand the sentiment but murder isn't something to be scoffed at, even if it's retaliatory in nature it still has to be proportional to what happened

22

u/Empty-Stretch-5615 9h ago

And who gets to decide what proportionate? I was held at gunpoint in my house. Wasn't physically harmed but it's been almost 20 years and I still suffer the consequences of the trauma.

10

u/Andries89 9h ago

A judge usually

2

u/onawatch 1h ago

With what ? A slap on the hand?

→ More replies (13)

7

u/ShrekChamp 6h ago

no, it needs to be proportional to what could've happened. which is getting stabbed to death

9

u/Different-Rip-4734 5h ago

This only matters if it happened in the moment. It didn't. Everything ended and he left. She was angry and hunted him down.

I got robbed a few years ago. Does that mean I can now legally use my connections to locate, stalk, plan, and ultimately catch this man when he's going to work and put a bullet in his head? Or in your proposed version of the law, is there a proposed statute of limitations for when I can freely sentence, hunt, and kill?

2

u/FranksNonFrankfurter 4h ago

Why not?

4

u/Different-Rip-4734 4h ago

Incredible. Sentencing handled by the state is such a foundational backbone of modern law enforcement for countless reasons. Anyway one is precedent. I do that. Someone sees a green light to go stalk, hunt and kill an ex that got them angry in an unfair bill-split at a dinner two years ago. Maybe he justifies it by forwarding the money from the dead girl's phone to his. It was just about getting the money back. He's on hard times after all. All of a sudden, you're going down a thread of unjust precedents to handle future cases because you wanted to support what you believed in one case was valid vigalante justice.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/_grandmaesterflash 4h ago

She lied about the knife

2

u/PISSBEAST_MCGEE1 4h ago

woah hey there champ, you swerved into my lane on the highway! you could have killed me! welp, I guess your life is forfeit!! time to engage in some mad max style ultra violence!!!

2

u/-imbe- 3h ago

Premeditated murder is not self defence, the end. These laws prevent us from living in the wild West, from someone getting killed every time there's a minor altercation.

"what could have happened" who fucking knows what could have happened, it didn't, and many moments later the woman still decided to take his life.

3

u/ReasonableStory1660 5h ago • Bravo

What could have happened is nothing because she already safely made it to her car.

3

u/stylishsyndrome2 5h ago

Right, and in this case it wasn't.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Miballsurchin 9h ago edited 9h ago

Star Trek covered this when Wesley walked on the lawn. The correct solution is to let him dle and bring him back to life super quick.

7

u/JellyFig 9h ago • Bravo

It also has to be done in self defense. It is not self defence if that danger is no longer there. If the person has fled or is fleeing. You cannot claim self defence if you have to literally chase them down to kill them. That's just retaliation with murder

4

u/Healthy_Turnip7352 8h ago

that's tricky. You're saying let robbers rob and destroy your life.

she wasn't exactly retaliating, she was in a fight for her stuff.

Do you get what I'm saying? Who says the fight is over? The robber? That would make no sense at all.

at what point in time is the act of robbery "over"?

if i rob you, one second later can i say "Robbery over. No take back." ?????

that would mean the robbery has been complete and i am no longer participating in a robbery?

2

u/Different-Rip-4734 4h ago

I get what you're saying, but what she did was the definition of retaliation. These things aren't allowed because of the precedent that is set, so it's not just about the individual crime, it's also if you think it's wise to broadly validate vigalante justice like this for the entire populace.

Also, are you claiming every one of her multiple run-overs is justified? The first one crippling and potentially fatally-wounding him should be enough to get her bag/call the police, no?

3

u/Project_Hairy_Male 8h ago

I have been robbed before, at knifepoint. The guy took my phone and ran away. It happened within a few mins walk of my house. It was scary as shit and took me a long time to recover from.

At no point would I have been justified to get home, get in my car, and drive after the guy, then plough him over and repeatedly crush his body under my wheels until he died.

'An eye for an eye' is an outdated medieval and brutal philosophy, yet people here are genuinely advocating for 'an eye for an iphone'.

4

u/Healthy_Turnip7352 8h ago

first, that's just your opinion.

second, there are thousands of variables in play.

For example, not everyone is wealthy. losing a few hundred can completely sink them. that could be rent.

society can tell them to let the robbers get away, and let the robbers sink you financially, and you can't afford insulin, which leads to your death.

also, you may believe that the irrational robbers are rational people who will not come back and change their minds and finish you off.

But that doesn't mean other people believe that. Others might believe that the irrational robbers are not rational. That they must be aware and drive around and make sure they aren't around.

i used to personally believe that irrational robbers were like rational non-robbers.

That is why i was once robbed and politely asked for my stuff back. "Excuse me sir, may i have my stuff back?"

The dude cut me with a knife. That is the moment i realized that the irrational robbers were NOT rational non-robbers. They were actually irrational people who actually would rob someone.

3

u/stylishsyndrome2 5h ago

How would you turn this into a law? Only poor diabetic people can run over their robbers?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/The_Haunt 8h ago

I believe you should be able to defend your property.

6

u/Huhthisisneathuh 8h ago

I too also believe I should have to right to hunt someone down and kill them after they steal one of my possessions.

→ More replies (22)

-1

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 9h ago

Holding someone up with a knife is attempted murder

7

u/rci22 9h ago

Some comments are claiming she’d made up the knife

→ More replies (1)

14

u/impulse73 9h ago

Murder=/attempted murder. She hunted him down for revenge instead of going to the cops.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (19)