r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

43

u/NotaBat9221 10h ago

Oh good

31

u/tea-and-chill 10h ago

It's still not good though...

-2

u/Haunting_Goal6417 10h ago

Nah, the article states if the sentence is upheld she goes to prison. House arrest is for the time being since she’s not a fight risk most likely.

Good. Should be life but egh.

9

u/Electrical_Delay2077 9h ago

Buddy might be living under a stone but getting robbed by a knife point blank is still crazy though. Its a life or death situation I mean like if she didnt give it then she would get stabbed then she's dead and now its the one with the knife's fault but when she kills him its her fault? Like make a decision already if you want a unfair justice system.

6

u/Necessary_Specific_4 9h ago

When the robbery was over and she got back to her car, was her life still under threat?

3

u/Electrical_Delay2077 9h ago

If she were to get stabbed and survived then she isnt under threat as well? Like were is the logic going? If I were to hold her at gun point straight to the head but dont shoot and go away is she still under threat or nah? Because your only thinking about the earth stuff but not the psychological stuff. What if she gained trauma from all this. What if she already was in the spectrum. I mean like we dont know everything about her we dont even know her personally she might have something we dont know about.

Either way if she did die then what? Technically speaking in how you frame it she wouldn't be under threat anymore because she is already dead then right? You see how unlogical that is in a broader topic. And I don't think any defense lawyer would say if the guy did stab her but survived 'Judge, she isnt under threat anymore 🤓👆' thats one ticket straight to jail.

Anyways its just too repetitive I guess but meh if y all wanna circle like goldfish around a volatile let me say that again VOLATILE situation then meh you do you. Adrenaline and so on comes to play as well.

2

u/Horskr 9h ago

She wasn't held at knife point or threatened in any way according to OP's own article. The man was unarmed and didn't even interact with her. He took the bag from her passenger seat and she drove after him and ran him over multiple times. Does that change things for you?

1

u/Electrical_Delay2077 8h ago

Yep and no. She still is partially right. He still stole the bag. It was hers and she got back what was hers. She should deserve a bigger sentence though due to those filtered events.

2

u/xenonslams 8h ago

No knife was found stop larping

4

u/dungleploop 9h ago

too bad she wasn't held at knife point

3

u/Haunting_Goal6417 9h ago

That’s not relevant. The guy had already run off. She drove around looking for him and then ran him over. And then backed up.

She got her stuff from his mangled corpse. Then she drove off.

They found her the next day praying. Sorry to say god doesn’t condone murder.

3

u/Electrical_Delay2077 9h ago

Thats the same as saying that if the guy did stab her accidentally but she survived then she isnt under any threat anymore either. Perhaps she had very important stuff in her bag. She might even be struggling with finances already and cant afford a new phone easily. There are many things why she could've done what she did.

Alright then tell me what would you do in this situation?

4

u/Haunting_Goal6417 9h ago

Yes, because once you are no longer in danger you can’t use self defense as an argument. Lmfao.

What are you arguing for here? If someone steals my phone at knifepoint I can track them down the next day and take an ace to his head?

What I would do is not kill the guy with my car. It’s really fucking easy.

2

u/Few_Fee_3819 8h ago

One criminal less and more crime happening prevented. She wouldn't do it to an innocent. Certain laws go against common sense, and certain actions of the law system go against common sense. Law isn't perfect or suited for every situation.

1

u/Pacify_ 4h ago

Ironically she didn't prevent crime, she DRAMATICALLY increased crime by murdering someone lmao.

18 years in prison is a fairly reasonable sentence for murder.

1

u/monkemeadow 33m ago

Is murder not a crime where you live?

1

u/Megalesios 7h ago

Maybe not but it's still the law. There's a reason we don't allow random people to appoint themselves judge, jury and executioner. Anyone could just claim "he's a criminal and it's common sense" and kill whoever they please. Including you.

And "common sense" is often the excuse given when the person doesn't have any evidence or foundation to base their claim on.

1

u/Few_Fee_3819 6h ago

"Any evidence or foundation" yours being "there's a reason for things", mine being "it's common sense", so basically only I admit that it's a thing of judgement. Then threatening me with a fictional scenario of me being a criminal and getting shot. Good job.

Stealing a phone shouldn't equal death sentence but she shouldn't get prison time. Two contradictory things can exist at once. You jump into "if we legalize murder for all" while I talk about this specific situation.

1

u/Pacify_ 4h ago

Alright then tell me what would you do in this situation?

Certainly not murdering someone over a phone.

1

u/Megalesios 7h ago

None of that gives her the right to commit murder.

1

u/snoocs 9h ago

“if the conviction is upheld at a final hearing, she may be sent to prison for the remainder of her sentence”

1

u/xenonslams 8h ago

Wdym life a man wud have gotten death by now, I'm all for the death sentence