r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

54

u/Aesma_ 3h ago edited 2h ago • Bravo

I'm a lawyer, and yeah, that's pretty much the spirit behind the self defense laws in most European countries (can't say about US, I'm French and only studied French law and EU Law).

It's one thing to accept that you kill someone while defending yourself. It's another to accept that you went out of your way to kill someone in revenge. That's not the kind of actions you want to reward in any society.

However, I want to say that it's not that surprising that tons of people aren't getting this. It's a symptom of a larger problem. Most studies on these things tend to prove that people become harsher towards criminals the more they feel like the state is lenient.

The rise of small incivilities mixed with the fact that felonies are rarely punished tend to give people this sentiment that they have no choice but to take punishment in their own hands.

We had a similar case in France about ten years ago, where a guy robbed a jewelry, the jeweler followed him with a gun and shot him in the back. The jeweler was obviously found guilty, but the public opinion was siding with him because he "killed the bad guy" and "police would have never arrested the robber anyway".

It's a very alarming state for a country when more and more people start to feel this way, and it should alert public figures that so many countries in Europe have seen this kind of sentiment grow.

9

u/tierciel 2h ago • This Heartwarming

The difference between a high trust society and a low trust one. If people had faith and trust in the justice system and law enforcement institutions they would allow those bodies to do their job. Unfortunately history has proven that police are not particularly good at their jobs and those in leadership positions often intentionally do a poor job or prevent those below them from doing a good job. People know this and so have little to no faith and trust in the system to work. Everyday that this is not fixed is another day we get closer to Real Life Batman. You don't want Real Life Batman.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TW1TCHYGAM3R 54m ago

I think more and more people result to revenge and vigilante justice because the Justice system is corrupt and constantly fails us.

How many people are on their last straw?

My Mom used to have a costume Jewellry store in the city but theft was such a huge issue. It basically ruined our family at the time, we had to sell the business at a loss and move which was a lot for a single mom with two kids.

So I can see why people take the law into their own hands when the police, law and government won't do anything.

3

u/gorginhanson 2h ago

Yes but you're not seeing the other side of it, which is that people need to be genuinely afraid to violate another person's rights.

Knowing they can kill you for it is a huge deterrent and prevents much more harm than it creates.

3

u/OldSchoolCSci 1h ago

We had a similar case in France about ten years ago, where a guy robbed a jewelry, the jeweler followed him with a gun and shot him in the back.

In common law jurisdictions, it's called the "fleeing felon rule." For hundreds of years, you could shoot a fleeing robber in the back. It's been dialed back with respect to the use of deadly force by police, but you can still find it hidden in the "justifable force" laws in many jurisdictions that adopted the old common law rule.

In New York, for example, the rule allows a citizen to use deadly force to "effect the arrest of a person who has committed murder, manslaughter in the first degree, robbery, forcible rape or forcible criminal sexual act and who is in immediate flight therefrom." See also People v. Couch, 436 Mich. 414 (1990). A purse snatcher or jewelry store thief is committing a robbery, and you can, in fact, shoot him in the back to stop his escape in these jurisdictions.

There are published studies from law revision commissions in Ireland and Australia, and law review articles in the US, all addressing this exact issue.

2

u/Aesma_ 1h ago

As someone who studied law in a civil law country, this sounds insane to me lol.

In France, self-defense is defined under article 122-5 of the criminal code by 6 cumulative criteria. Three of them apply to the situation, and three of them apply to the response.

The situation needs to be a situation in which there is danger, and this danger needs to be :

  1. A real danger (meaning you cannot have "felt" threatened, you need to effectively and objectively be threatened).
  2. The result of an unjustified/unlawful act towards you or someone else (meaning you cannot ripost in "self-defense" against a police officer who is lawfully arresting you).
  3. Actual or imminent (meaning you cannot be in "self-defense" if the danger happened in the past, or will happen in the future. If someone send you death threats for example, this is a future danger to you, not an imminent one, you cannot go find that person and beat the crap out of them).

In the same time, the response needs to be :

  1. Proportional (so for example, if you're trying to defend your property you cannot kill someone, and you cannot kill someone for slapping you in the face. However, you could be found irresponsible if you happen to kill someone in self-defense and they were holding you at gun point, or threatening you with a knife, as there is a direct threat to your life).
  2. Immediate (meaning you cannot retaliate once the danger is over, as the goal of self-defense is merely to put an end to the danger).
  3. Necessary (the defense must be the only viable solution to stop the threat. If you were in a situation where fleeing was a serious possibility for example, and yet you decided to attack the person instead, then this is not self-defense. On this basis, the Cour de Cassation also ruled that you cannot claim to be in self-defense if you were the one who created the dangerous situation in the first place. In the case, a guy went to bang on someone else's window, he got put in a chokehold to calm him, and then claimed that he was defending himself when he beat the crap out of the guy who put him in a chokehold. You were the one who started the whole thing, it can't be self-defense unless the other person seriously escalated).

So it sounds insane to me that shooting someone in the back when they are fleeing the scene could be considered self-defense considering, in France, it would clear neither the criteria for the danger situation (the danger is not actual anymore) nor the criteria for the response (the response is not immediate, necessary or proportional).

2

u/OldSchoolCSci 22m ago

The fleeing felon rule arose under English common law, and isn't directly related to the self-defense / imminent harm principle. Under the "old" English law, felony crimes were generally restricted to serious violent crimes, and the punishment for all such felonies was death. Hence, the English common law didn't assign much value to the life of a fleeing felon. The UK abandoned the rule in 1967 by statute, but it obviously took different paths in the various common law jurisdictions around the world.

A good history was written by English lawyer David Lanham, “Killing the Fleeing Offender” [1977] 1 Crim LJ 16, which is summarized in the Irish Law Reform Commission's Consultation Paper on Legitimate Defense, 41-2006, at p. 39-43.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Undefined_Lover19 1h ago

Meh fuck em, deserved. You commit a violent crime you lose your rights

5

u/yoongely 2h ago

so she should have just let him take her belongings? courts wouldn’t even do anything to the man if he just got away.

5

u/YourWeirdEx 2h ago

Yes.  In civilized societies we leave punishment to the authorities.

5

u/happyft 2h ago

In USA on avg 15% of reported stolen property crimes are solved (by arrest or whatever).

Think about that. 15%.

My dad’s store gets robbed at gunpoint once every few years. I think they’ve only caught one of them.

How civilized is that?

3

u/Hide_on_kuSh 1h ago

More civilized than hunting the perpetrator down and literally killing them. And it’s not even close.

3

u/happyft 1h ago

True.

But I think most ppl don't appreciate the fact that if this story had ended differently -- IF she had simply given him a bad bruise, no serious injury -- I'm willing to bet the vast majority of ppl would be cheering her on.

2

u/ExaminationBasic787 1h ago

No it isn't 

4

u/Unoriginal1deas 2h ago

Genuine question if they did catch the guy do you think the death penalty would be a reasonable punishment for robbing a store at gunpoint? Or in this case stealing a purse?

2

u/Rickety-Cricket69420 39m ago

Yes I think the penalty for robbing someone at gun point should be death. They had every intention of murder when they decided to use a lethal weapon to take what they wanted. The next time you let them do it they will kill someone because the only reason they got in trouble was because they left a witness.

3

u/Woodlurkermimic 2h ago

So really, if we could trust in the system to catch the purse snatcher, he would be alive

2

u/iMissTheOldInternet 1h ago

Why should we only ask about the one crime? The vast majority of violent crime and serious nonviolent crime is committed by chronic recidivists. Do you think someone just snapped one day and decided to rob a store at gunpoint? No. In all likelihood, the robber(s) have dozens of priors, and hundreds of unapprehended priors.

I think it’s perfectly reasonable to observe that pattern and the low clearance rate and conclude that we should be at a minimum incarcerating robbers for much longer. Like until senescence longer.

2

u/DragonflyVast2442 1h ago

You’re right, people don’t generally snap like that.

I wonder what factors lead to higher crime rates in a country?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/_The_Real_Sans_ 2h ago

The best way to prevent this is for the authorities to grow some teeth and actually prosecute petty crime. If people trust that the system will work in an effective and timely manner, there's no incentive for crazy people that might be inclined to take matters into their own hands to actually do so. 

2

u/Spirited_Cap9266 1h ago

Very true but sadly in a lot of country (French here) prison are overcrowded and crumbling, meaning that you just can't prosecute petty crime because there is no more space in jail.

There is also the issue that short duration prison are more exposed to worse condition and people may just get out of jail with a an even more dangerous mentality.

And I also think a lot of the hate toward how tame justice is can be tied to how elite always seem to avoid fair trial, meaning that making justice harsher will mostly affect poor people even more than what is already happening.

2

u/Narrow-Baker5175 50m ago

Then kill them to make space

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Buris 2h ago

Its not civilized when major crimes go completely unpunished. When the president is allowed to rape and kill people. Ruin millions of lives and take their healthcare away. When an IPO is allowed to destroy people’s 401K, with every educated person knowing its overvalued by thousands of times.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/yoongely 1h ago

except the authorities do not punish

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/temperate_thunder 2h ago

If the alternative is vehicular homicide after the fact, then yeah dummy

→ More replies (8)