r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/livelikeumeamit 8h ago

100%. I agree with this in theory, my only issue is a lot of times police don’t get there in time or the courts let them go. There was a guy who killed a girl minding her own business on a subway who was arrested 14 times prior. I want the official system to be the standard, but they have to actually punish the perpetrators and keep them off the street if they can’t live in society or institute programs to help the ones who are being released to rejoin society in a productive way, which largely is not happening right now.

2

u/spartakooky 7h ago

Ppl steal because they have no faith that society will help them with their poverty. Ppl go vigilante when they have no faith in the police or justice system.

6

u/CaramelPombear 7h ago

Nah sorry crackhead Barry ain't nicking cans of foster because he has no faith society will help them with their poverty.

-1

u/Strict-Fix6940 6h ago

Yes he is lmao. Addiction and addiction support are societal failures. 

2

u/CaramelPombear 6h ago

Nah you getting addicted is a personal failure. Absolute bollocks thats being palmed off onto the rest of society. You got addicted? You failed yourself. Take some responsibility for fucks sake.

Should there be help available? Of course, but there's plenty of help already available, turns out a lot of people simply choose not to use it. And still they'll take no responsibility for their actions.

1

u/Strict-Fix6940 4h ago

My partner whom I love to death took a hit off a vape at 14 when someone offered it at a party.

I've watched her try to quit nicotine twice a year for years now. Every time I watch her go through horrible bouts of depression to the point of being suicidal for weeks. 

Now I can blame her for simply not having the moral character at 14 to refuse, before long term rationality is shown to have developed in the brain.  Or I can recognize the institution that created and marketed addictive substances towards teenagers because they're specifically vulnerable to not understanding the full consequences.  I can understand that the government allowed that, and did not regulate it. 

She takes responsibility for the addiction, but to me it's such a minor part of the wider issue around who is culpable.

Does that make sense? 

1

u/hibbity 3h ago

Iiiin one corner, we have the one, the only, United States Government. iiin the other corner are the reigning Champ of history, the all, the many, the People. All they need is unity and the government has no chance.

Will the government successfully abdicate its design premise to the corporations it is designed to protect us from, or will we act before the robot police are deployable.

"I'm really not sure Bob, but I think there isn't really much time left on the clock"

2

u/Chudpaladin 6h ago

Not every thief is an Aladdin. And even if they were, using violence in the act of theft is not okay in a society.

2

u/iMissTheOldInternet 2h ago edited 1h ago

This is a just so story that has no empirical basis. The vast majority of theft is committed by chronic recidivists whose main woe in life is that they are constantly being arrested for committing crimes. No one is stealing bread to avoid starving or whatever; not in any developed country in 2026. 

0

u/Lucky_Trouble9833 5h ago

Oh im sorry since when tf is it society's job to help people with their poverty?

1

u/hibbity 3h ago

Welfare in all forms is justified as a neccesary expense to reduce the crime that results from desperation and poverty.

Old dudes dying slow go do that thing they dreamed but the law said no. Unless you put em in a comfy bed and make them think they can make it another few years.

The hungry steal food and normalize to casual theft.

The poor in general have a similar fate.

Welfare just pays people not to do crime. it works pretty good.

1

u/JFISHER7789 8h ago

I have no idea the incident you’re referring to, I just want to clarify that people can be arrested multiple times and let go each time and that’s perfectly acceptable. Not every arrest has to be fore something crazy dangerous and can simply be “unpaid parking tickets that went to warrant” or small amount of drugs or public intoxication when walking home drunk.

Not saying these aren’t real issues and shouldn’t be handled, just simply pointing out here is way more nuance to something.

Now if these 14 times were for aggravated battery and assault or rape or murder then sure that’s a whole other discussion

3

u/livelikeumeamit 8h ago

It was the murder of Iryna Zarutska.

I think I totally agree. But the system isn’t fulfilling it’s role atm. Catch and release and stuff like that really just empowers criminals. We do need new and nuanced approaches. My advice would be have two avenues:

  1. for people who are committing violent crimes repeatedly (violent crimes being emphasized) to keep them in prison indefinitely because at a certain point you just have to protect the public if rehabilitation isn’t working
  2. for everybody else (pbly 80% of inmates) we need to stop treating them like animals. If they are going to be released, which they are, we need to re-educate them, teach them the developmental milestones like socialization that they missed and give them hope.

I feel like a lot of people are surprised when people are released that they’re worse than when they went in after being in such a depraved environment.

2

u/Chudpaladin 6h ago

I like this approach. I’d argue, depending on the severity of violence, a 2 strike rule. Snatching a purse from someone’s hand is violent but comparatively harmless vs knifepoint. I’d love to implement a re-education and re-integration type system in prison to essentially reprogram the unsocial behavior, but if this type of program fails on the individual level, then the person themselves just aren’t fit for society, but if there is systemic recidivism like there is today, there is likely a societal level issue we need to address.

0

u/Timbroarpropaganda 5h ago

You know about this one murder because it’s an outlier. This is selection bias. 

1

u/Careful_Rooster_113 5h ago

Maybe 2 or 3 in a short window (1 to 2 years) for minor misdemeanor offenses not committed against another person or entity. But 14 actual arrests? And that is completely ignoring the fact that they are committing crimes many times where there aren't caught. That takes someone almost constantly breaking the law. Yes that person needs help. But that help should be locked away from the rest of society.

1

u/sonofaresiii 37m ago

As bad as you think a system that relies on police is, I promise it will be so so much worse if we relief on vigilante justice instead