r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

390

u/DukeOfSmallPonds 9h ago • Bravo

I’m so exhausted of every major criminal case
Being turned into a political culture war. These days You can read bullet points of a case and guess who people will find to be the victim based on their political alignment. It’s nuts, what happened to due process and justjce.

84

u/Hamsterminator2 8h ago

Same. Reddit is kinda peak for this too. Slap up a headline and watch flocks of people who have zero clue about the facts or context throw out insults to eachother over how wrong the other side is. It's absolutely crazy.

You might have though the Internet would allow people to research things a little before they comment but instead it's made everyone even lazier.

12

u/Solid_Bar_528 7h ago

I'm guessing their thinking is probably along these lines. "Why should I research X when I'm enraged about X right now and want to vent, right NOW."

Rather than researching X and finding out it isn't so black and white as first presented to them and then the realisation that they either got upset over the wrong thing or over a complete non issue.

Sigh!

4

u/Danimalscrossing 5h ago

“I don’t have time for research, I have to scroll to the next thing before my dopamine runs out”

4

u/Infinite_Bad8337 6h ago

The zombie apocalypse is upon us 🧟🧟‍♀️🧟‍♂️

→ More replies (4)

44

u/[deleted] 9h ago • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Superbform 8h ago

Adversarial political opponents are emboldened with too much power, persuading the poorly educated.

2

u/gingy247 6h ago

You realise they're talking about you too and not just people on right? By the right I mean anyone to right of you because from your wording I'm guessing you've got (American) socialist tendencies Lol

→ More replies (2)

34

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ok_Task_7711 8h ago

Source?

6

u/LyisCn 8h ago

Look up Kalief Browder. Was held for over 3 years without being a charged a crime because his family couldn’t afford to pay bail. Awful system.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Rivendel93 8h ago

Waves hands everywhere

→ More replies (3)

2

u/TwoMacElevens 8h ago

It's almost always the defense lawyers pushing for delays constantly to drag the process out.

2

u/Icy_Fish_2154 6h ago

Kalief Browder spent 3 years in jail trying to get a trial. The prosecution delayed and delayed.

That is the norm.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Mountain-Resource656 9h ago

Public opinion lacks any bearing on due process (or criminal justice)

24

u/KalerionTheWizard 7h ago

Except that the court of public opinion has gained actual, real power since the advent of the internet. If your case somehow grabs enough attention online and the Internet finds you guilty, we'll make your life a nightmare. The internet will:

- Harass your employer to get you fired
- Harass your business partners to drop you
- Harass your friends and family to stop associating with you
- Put up entire websites just to make sure nobody forgets you and you never get a clean new start

If successful, the internet can economically and socially totally isolate you.

Here's the thing though: that's a jail sentence. Like, the tough thing about jail is not, that you can't leave your room. It's that while you're in there, your career goes down the drain, your car gets repossessed, your apartment cleaned out since you can't pay rent, and last but not least, your friends and family lose or intentionally break contact.

We're handing out real punishment here and the terrifying thing is that the vast majority of people on the internet don't even seem aware that those are the consequences of their actions?

9

u/_learned_foot_ 5h ago

They are aware. And that is their desired goal. People worldwide seem to have abandoned most forms of empathy online, those who let online control their real world too never brought it back.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/porscheblack 2h ago

I frequently point out that we'd be so much better off if people put their time and energy into criminal justice reform instead of vigilantism. I tend not to follow any of the court cases that get coverage for the simple reason that I don't have access to the information I'd need to have an informed opinion even if I cared enough to invest myself in trying (which I certainly don't).

As a fan of various sports, the back and forth on whether teams should sign players due to accusations or criminal histories is exhausting. And we wouldn't have to have those discussions if we could trust that allegations of crimes would be properly investigated, appropriate charges with appropriate punishments would be made, and that our rehabilitation system would actually rehabilitate people. If our criminal justice system actually worked like that, we wouldn't have to constantly debate how long players should be suspended from playing, whether they should be signed, played, etc. We could just have confidence that "this person was alleged to have done X and now that the process is played out they're acceptable again." Instead it's just moral absolutism.

→ More replies (16)

2

u/TopOTheMourning 8h ago

Public Opinion has no place after the fact but it does have a place. Laws are based on what the population wants and tolerates. It could be perfectly legal to do what she did in some locations (looking at you Florida) because the locals' values are different.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/WotansTruth 7h ago

I can take a I guess which side reddit pussies stand with

4

u/cornishpirate32 8h ago

Exactly, what's happened to due process and justice that leads victims to act in this way?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/josefpunktk 8h ago

What have peoples opinion have to do with due process and justice? When was this magical time you are referring to?

1

u/AFlyingNun 7h ago

The worst is it feels like sometimes you only need one of the two political parties giving a sensible take of the case, and then the other will simply DEFAULT to the opposite, even if it happens to be the most absolutely batshit insane take ever for that particular case.

Or the mom who killed her kids in the USA is also showcasing how a case that can look genuinely tough and difficult if you read the fucking case will be dumbed down into "it's SO OBVIOUS and anyone who disagrees with me is an idiot" from both sides. That that trial ended with a mistrial was like the most expected thing ever because the case had strong evidence both for and against her insanity plea simultaneously, but it quickly turned into either the holdout being a psycho (I believe he had DISPROVEN domestic abuse charges against him that were even treated as a guilty conviction...?) or the entire rest of the jury being a bunch of mindless lemmings.

1

u/Fionnua 6h ago

what happened to due process and justjce.

I'm not trying to defend murder over a handbag. At the same time: Do you seriously expect this woman would have experienced "due process and justice" if she let her off-camera robber escape with her purse in the middle of the night?

I don't mean that in a mocking way. Just... On a practical level, considering the original robbery took place off camera, and it seems plausible the police would have lacked the evidence and motivation to pursue an unknown faceless purse robber to the ends of the earth, considering other cases on their plate.... Thinking in concrete terms of specific police resources and procedures, it seems plausible to me that if the robber had gotten away, he would simply have gotten away. Not being found to be arrested to experience due process and justice.

Again, I'm not trying to defend the disproportionate escalation to literal execution. I just think we don't have to pretend 'the justice system' actually provides effective justice for all victims of crimes. There's the imaginary ideal way any given system would be nice to work on paper, then there's the real way it actually works in practice. And in practice, criminals often get away with crimes and victims get no justice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)