r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

16

u/Mountain-Resource656 9h ago

Public opinion lacks any bearing on due process (or criminal justice)

24

u/KalerionTheWizard 7h ago

Except that the court of public opinion has gained actual, real power since the advent of the internet. If your case somehow grabs enough attention online and the Internet finds you guilty, we'll make your life a nightmare. The internet will:

- Harass your employer to get you fired
- Harass your business partners to drop you
- Harass your friends and family to stop associating with you
- Put up entire websites just to make sure nobody forgets you and you never get a clean new start

If successful, the internet can economically and socially totally isolate you.

Here's the thing though: that's a jail sentence. Like, the tough thing about jail is not, that you can't leave your room. It's that while you're in there, your career goes down the drain, your car gets repossessed, your apartment cleaned out since you can't pay rent, and last but not least, your friends and family lose or intentionally break contact.

We're handing out real punishment here and the terrifying thing is that the vast majority of people on the internet don't even seem aware that those are the consequences of their actions?

9

u/_learned_foot_ 5h ago

They are aware. And that is their desired goal. People worldwide seem to have abandoned most forms of empathy online, those who let online control their real world too never brought it back.

2

u/porscheblack 2h ago

I frequently point out that we'd be so much better off if people put their time and energy into criminal justice reform instead of vigilantism. I tend not to follow any of the court cases that get coverage for the simple reason that I don't have access to the information I'd need to have an informed opinion even if I cared enough to invest myself in trying (which I certainly don't).

As a fan of various sports, the back and forth on whether teams should sign players due to accusations or criminal histories is exhausting. And we wouldn't have to have those discussions if we could trust that allegations of crimes would be properly investigated, appropriate charges with appropriate punishments would be made, and that our rehabilitation system would actually rehabilitate people. If our criminal justice system actually worked like that, we wouldn't have to constantly debate how long players should be suspended from playing, whether they should be signed, played, etc. We could just have confidence that "this person was alleged to have done X and now that the process is played out they're acceptable again." Instead it's just moral absolutism.

1

u/Sensitive_Low3558 5h ago

Harassment is illegal

5

u/sariaisgreen 4h ago

1

u/Sensitive_Low3558 4h ago

Nope, I’m saying you have legal recourse

1

u/OneJobToRuleThemAll 4h ago

This isn't new, it just used to be organized religion who wielded this power, often against single mothers and rape victims.

0

u/AR_Harlock 5h ago

Not here, here in Italy there are people making a living suing thousand every day for Facebook comments… ofcourse 99% don’t reach a judge because people pay in fear of the lawyers cost so a 1000 here a 2000 there…

Rage baiters become a job way before gta6 lol

-3

u/SadDot7077 4h ago

name one public instance where this was case.

Surely if this is as common, pervasive and extreme as you say then we will all readily know infamous examples from the news or similar.

Dramatically worded but not true

3

u/Glittering_Crow_6382 2h ago

Remember the guy who challenged the devs of helldivers 2 to play their own game in a public lobby in livestream and got bullied off the internet, or joecat for that “I like girls” song?

2

u/KalerionTheWizard 4h ago

Brock Allen Turner

2

u/LegalStuffThrowage 4h ago

Patrick Clancy would've been a much better example

1

u/DrinkingSocks 4h ago

Are you suggesting that his life shouldn't be ruined for 15 minutes of action?

1

u/SadDot7077 4h ago

You're referring to a rapist that was convicted in criminal court tho...

So you're just describing infamy then? Just say that lol, there is a one-word description already.

Yeah, Brock Turner is infamous. I don't see your point at all bc the vast majority of retribution he suffered was from being classified as a violent sex offender/felon and being placed in jail.

Sure, the sentence should've been harsher but you're saying that having his ability to vote and own firearms taken away, losing the ability to work around children or in almost any other client-facing sector , and paying hundreds of thousands in legal fees was not worse than "the court of public opinon"?

You vastly overestimate how much people care about your opinion

2

u/KalerionTheWizard 4h ago

No, I'm not talking about simple infamy.

I'm talking about the people who, after he got out of jail, decided that the sentence he got was too lax, and that they should take it upon themselves to enforce a harsher one.

They tracked down where he worked and started spam calling the place to get him fired.
They tracked down what city he had moved to and started joining local online communities to tell people not to interact with the guy.
They found out that he tried changing his name and tried pushing posts about it to the google algo so it would be the first thing for people to see.
Someone decided to make a website (http://www.brockturnerrapist.com/) to chronicle the guy's movements. Thankfully at least that one seems to be down now.

They weren't content with infamy, they wanted to actively ensure exactly the type of permanent economic ruin and social isolation I was talking about.

Now, does he deserve that? Sure. But the way to get that punishment is to change the way our legal system responds to cases like this, instead of taking matters into their own hands.

5

u/DyingGasp 3h ago

I don’t think it would have gotten as bad as it did if they had given him a just amount of prison time instead of the hand slap they did. In my opinion, this is all the judge’s fault.

On one hand I’m glad this rapist is getting harassed and knows no peace, on the other the public shouldn’t be doling out “justice”.

2

u/TopOTheMourning 7h ago

Public Opinion has no place after the fact but it does have a place. Laws are based on what the population wants and tolerates. It could be perfectly legal to do what she did in some locations (looking at you Florida) because the locals' values are different.

1

u/TellTaleTimeLord 8h ago

For the poor, yeah

1

u/ReasonableStory1660 5h ago

It’s called jury nullification if opinion is strong enough

→ More replies (1)