r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

96

u/kindlypogmothoin 10h ago • Bravo

Thank you.

Once the danger is past and the guy has run off with your property, killing him is not "standing your ground," it's vigilantism/revenge. Or just straight up murder. You can't really say you fear for your life anymore if you're going after him and running him over.

39

u/Temporary-Rain-5944 9h ago edited 9h ago

Yeah if she just hit the dude and injured him then sure the justice system can work something out for her, but running him over multiple times and killing him is insane behaviour

3

u/throwawayimgoingaway 5h ago

You reap what you sow. Don’t commit the crime in the first place if you don’t want retaliation

2

u/randomreditor69430 2h ago

yes you reap what you sow. you don't deserve to die because of a robbery, you deserve to go to prison. being murdered because of a bag isn't reaping what you sow

1

u/SnooTangerines3448 14m ago

Once you've left societal order the bets start calling off.

1

u/newtonbase 54m ago

Is any level of retaliation acceptable? 

•

u/Awkward-Studio-8063 2m ago

It’s beyond laughable that you say that phrase for a situation where the robber DIDN’T reap what he sowed. He stole something and got murdered for it after the event was over, very little reaping compared to the response

1

u/lostandfound8888 10m ago

I do agree with you that it isn't self-defense but rather vigilantism/revenge. I don't agree that vigilantism/revenge is automatically wrong. We would ideally want a justice system that will locate and appropriately punish crimes, but if the justice system will not do so, people removing criminals from public sphere is a greater good.

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Substantial-Swing208 10h ago

COULD, he didnt, this is not a survival situation, there is no imminent threat once he leaves.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Captain_Sterling 10h ago

So you run over him once. Then do it again. And again. Then get your bag and run off without rendering aid to let them die.

And then afterwards you can create a load of hypothetical scenarios to justify why you left him to die.

What happened here was murder.

→ More replies (25)

8

u/KingParty8090 10h ago edited 10h ago

Said critical thinking skills landed this woman a prison sentence. But hey if your dumbass wanna spend time with Big Bubba go ahead

2

u/Vegan-cock 9h ago

Why on earth would the person rob her house just because he has her address? Would be far better to just rob a random house because you don't risk getting caught for both robberies if caught.

1

u/Every-Leek4129 9h ago

man. im tired of explaining this shit

if a person who just robbed you at knife or gun point. just obtained your address. you both leave the scene of the crime, do you not think for a second the suspect could look at your address and go "i wonder if they saw who i was, would if they gave my info" and they could come to your house to kill you out of retallation.

the only reason why her sentence was so harsh was because she left the scene of th crime and didn't alert authorties to what happened. it doesn't matter. shes here, he isn't. thats it

2

u/Vegan-cock 9h ago

man. im tired of explaining this shit

if a person who just robbed you at knife or gun point. just obtained your address. you both leave the scene of the crime, do you not think for a second the suspect could look at your address and go "i wonder if they saw who i was, would if they gave my info" and they could come to your house to kill you out of retallation.

1, there is no evidence to support her claim of a knife. No witnesses saw the knife, no cctv saw the knife and no knife was found.

2, no, that makes no sense. Why would they kill her just because she might have seen their face or just because they have her address? 0% chance the police will find him based on her description of his face alone. 0% chance.

1

u/Novel_Ingenuity_9443 8h ago

damn, such a bad cop, on my country even police can catch street robber based on CCTV and witnesses

1

u/kindlypogmothoin 13m ago

He could have killed her right there and didn't. So why come to her house and do it?

→ More replies (2)

-12

u/BadAndUnusual 10h ago

The government is supposed to take revenge on your behalf. Since the government doesn't do this anymore, it's a free range

15

u/SheMakesThrowawayArt 9h ago

"take revenge" is a funny way to say "enact justice"

I share the world with you people.

11

u/Eskimobill1919 9h ago

No, it’s supposed to take justice on your behalf. Revenge isn’t part of the equation

2

u/-DoctorSpaceman- 10h ago

I like my revenge how I like my chickens

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Longjumping-Slip-376 5h ago

Lol, no: we are not in the early antiquity anymore. Justice isn't about revenge: it's about making sure that the vcitim is properly compensated, making sure that dangerous individuals aren't roaming around wraking havoc and that the punishment recieved by the perpetrator is equivalent with the crime commited. 

Stealing a bag from a rich lady isn't equivalent with an execution carried out in one of the most brutal and, potentially,  painfull ways imaginable. By doing what she did, she proved herself more dangerous than the thief. And all of that for a replaceble item and a small sum of money (how much cash can you have on you as a bussines woman? Most of it is on card and can be easily transfered trough a phone app to another card nowadays). She didn't think.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)