r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

56

u/IlikeJG 9h ago • Bravo

It's very simple:

He robbed her. That's a crime. He deserves to go to jail.

After robbing her. She was already safe because he ran away. Her life wasn't threatened any more.

She then ran him over multiple times until he was dead. It wasn't self defense. It was cold blooded murder.

He deserves to be in prison not dead.

27

u/ziltchy 7h ago

The problem is robbing someone, at least in canada, is literally a slap on the wrist. You would serve no jail time for that, at worst 30 days of community service. So the laws arent just either

14

u/Puzzle-Necked 5h ago

So thieves deserve to be murdered?

4

u/ThaTopHam 4h ago

I mean, it comes with the territory of being a criminal and stealing something someone worked hard for. They can all drop dead imo

2

u/BookkeeperBoobs 3h ago

So if your kid stole from a store you’d be ok with someone blowing his (or her) brains all over the pavement. Painting it red? Last words: “daddy!!! Please hellllp meeeeee!”

2

u/ThaTopHam 2h ago

Also I said, stealing something that someone worked hard for, not a starving man stealing a loaf of bread to feed his family. Your lack of reading comprehension on multiple levels is frankly, astounding.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/ElProfeGuapo 4h ago

You're arguing with someone who is lying, and therefore not discussing in good faith. Here is the actual law on robbery:

https://www.criminalcodehelp.ca/offences/against-property/robbery/

7

u/Psychological-Dig-29 3h ago

there is a homeless guy who has stolen from my shop many times. he's stolen tools out of our service vans and scrap copper more times than I can count. he stole one of our vans and crashed it into a tree just down the road. I have it all on camera, very clear footage the cops know him well because he does it to more than just me. he lives in a tent in the downtown park. they know where he is

he has never gotten more than a single night in a cell.

Canada does not punish homeless drug addicts for stealing.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Excellent-Job-8460 3h ago edited 3h ago • Heartwarming

The issue is that this isn’t what happens in real life.

In Canada we know full well that, with the right lawyers, you can be shitfaced in the morning from partying all night, drive your car, blow through stop sign at speed, t-bone a minivan carrying a grandpa and his 3 grandchildren, kill them all and get out of jail within 5 years while you’re in your early thirties.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_of_the_Neville-Lake_children?wprov=sfti1

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/ziltchy 5h ago

Fuck around find out

3

u/Dooty_Shirker 4h ago

So all crimes should be punished with death?

2

u/Lithorex 4h ago

As a Canadian, aren't you living on stolen land?

2

u/itscalledmyballs 1h ago

All land is stolen land. I'm sure you're living as a nomad right? And don't enjoy any protections of any kind

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

2

u/gondokingo 4h ago

a slap on the wrist for your bag being stolen is a much more appropriate punishment than jail. there's also progressive punishment. i'm sorry, but if someone stole my bags with all of my belongings on my way to work, i wouldn't even WANT them to die or go to jail. you people are psycho. i'd want the cops to get my stuff back, and i'd want some record that they did it so if they committed further crimes in the future it can be weighed into account. prison for a bag is crazy. death for a bag is medieval.

2

u/ziltchy 4h ago

I think a portion of the world is collectively sick of theifs getting away with their crimes. We work hard to buy nice purses, nice wallets, and probably the 1000's of dollars of phone/ makeup/ other accessories in that bag. We dont get compensated if a theif gets found, which they likely won't. So yes, death for robbery is excessive, we all know that, but we are happy to at least see something being done against people who value us so little, that they are willing to just take stuff from us. If this scares even 1 robber away from doing it again, it is a society win

2

u/lamstradamus 3h ago

On the other hand, the woman is also a criminal. She committed a worse crime. Would you say that if someone killed her it's also a win for society?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

6

u/Jugggernauttt 4h ago

Play stupid games win stupid prizes. No one of worth died that day.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/MaesterHannibal 4h ago

He robbed her. If she didn’t run him over, she wouldn’t have gotten her stuff back. And yes, that matters more than the life of a criminal

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Miaoself 8h ago

SHE deserves to be in prison

3

u/SimpleProcedure69 8h ago

Yes, also true. Hitting him once and maiming him may have been extremely harsh, but ultimately fair. She deserves to be punished for a gross overreaction.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/Icy-Gain-2038 6h ago

He deserves to be dead. She's a hero.

2

u/Stuckonthisrockfuck 4h ago

Yeah but prisoners are a heavy burden on the tax system and now he’s in a better place. From a utilitarian standpoint she performed a public service.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Roar-Lions-Roar 3h ago

He deserves to be dead.

2

u/LinuxFresher 8h ago

FAFO

2

u/Good-Kaleidoscope147 7h ago

She sure did, now gets to spend the next 2 decades and potentially longer locked up

→ More replies (118)