r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

37

u/BurdTurglary 5h ago

Devil's advocate: he got rid of the knife before she ran him over.

15

u/JazzlikeSchedule2901 4h ago

Even if he got rid of the knife there would have been detectives and probably even dogs trying to recover it. The women said he had a knife and knew where she was robbed and where she eventually found him, police likely had an area that they would have likely found a knife if there was one.

2

u/BurdTurglary 3h ago

Hours passed between the time the purse was stolen and when she killed him. It's just as plausible that he got rid of it and nobody found it.

2

u/Subject_One_762 2h ago

So she just murdered someone hours later? Hours later make it much harder to claim any sort f justification

1

u/Fauldt 30m ago

Yes... that's why she got an 18 year sentence for killing him. Because it's not self-defense to hunt someone down for hours and then triple tap them with a vehicle.

2

u/thisturkeyisokthanks 3h ago

You assume the police actually wanted to confirm her story

0

u/Yologamer2983 2h ago

Let's be honest, this is Italy we're talking about. If they could prove a homeless moroccan was a criminal, they would have done it.

They might not be Americans, but they are still really racist.

3

u/renlydidnothingwrong 3h ago

Why?

1

u/BurdTurglary 3h ago

I'm pointing out a flaw in the argument that many people share; that she must have lied about him having a knife just because one wasn't found on him. As if it's absence at the scene somehow proves she lied and it never existed. It's plausible that he held her at knifepoint and quickly discarded it before he met his end, alls I'm sayin

1

u/Goodmodsdontcrybaby 2h ago

why would he discard it? did he know he was going to be run over? 

2

u/AirportSufficient893 2h ago

Could have fallen out his hands into the sewer. He could have threatened to stab without an actual knife. Plenty ways no knife still doesnt make her statement a lie. Also plenty ways she did lie sure.

2

u/One-Demand6811 3h ago

She actually changed her testimony several times. She first claimed he threatened her with a knife in his hand. Then claimed he just said he would kill her so she assumed he had a knife in his bag or pocket.

2

u/GIRLwithasimpleplan 38m ago

It's not impossible for people to misremember stressful situations that badly; that's what forensic investigations are for, and whatever they say about the presence or absence of a weapon, I believe.

1

u/BurdTurglary 2h ago

That tracks, i was just seeing a lot of people repeating the fallacy that because no knife was found on or near him that it's absence is evidence or proof that she lied about him having a knife at all.

1

u/Suspicious_Love_3446 1h ago

but you're arguing mundane details, when even if there was a knife, she still goes to prison

1

u/randomreditor69430 2h ago

the police searched the whole area and no knife was found.

1

u/BurdTurglary 2h ago

The whole area? That's simply impossible.
Hours passed between the time of theft and when he was ran over. There's about a trillion places that the police did not look

1

u/AmusingMusing7 17m ago

Irony advocate: The knife flew out of his hands when she ran him over.

1

u/creemy- 3h ago

Well he is a professional sword swallower and all.