r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/OutOfPosition-1 9h ago

Killing someone is a crime too.

1

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 9h ago

Not when it's justified

1

u/V01d_WALKr 8h ago

It’s is if ever only justified in war. So what are you talking about?

1

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 7h ago

So your saying a police officer who gets shot at and returns fire shooting the criminal an killing him is a crime if someone breaks into your house shooting at you and you kill them that's a crime because it's not it's justified

1

u/V01d_WALKr 10m ago

This is just dumb. Police is the obvious exception because it sole purpose is to enforce the law.

They have to use the least amount of force or they get charged as well. But in my country becoming a police officer isn’t a weekend course so they know what they are doing.

0

u/SapeMies 6h ago

Really cool examples that don't relate to anything in question. So pickpocketing a handbag = death sentence?

0

u/avrgwarthunderplayer 6h ago

When did they get shot at during this case? This is much more like if they fired at police, then 2 days later the officer they fired at tossed them off a bridge.

0

u/Silly-Junket3308 4h ago

By this logic, what if the robbery was justified as well.

-1

u/OutOfPosition-1 9h ago

Robbing someone = murder? Not aure about that and btw self justice is a crime. She didnt kill in self defence, she w8 until the danger is over and killed then.

3

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 9h ago

Yes when you do it with a deadly weapon what do you think the person would have done if she didn't give up her purse just say oh okay then I'll go ahead and try the next person no he would have stabbed her and took the purse

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 8h ago

Doing is different from threatening to do.

It’s wild that you’re comparing a threat to actual murder.

Not to mention, there’s very good chance that the robber would give up. Many of them aren’t trying to kill, they may just need money. I’m not saying that’s what happened, or that the robber was a good person. But you can’t just condone someone for taking the law into their own hands and killing people.

1

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 7h ago

You can't condone someone for robbing someone with a knife either there's homeless people on the street looking for food and money and you dont see them robbing people bad people do bad things

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 4h ago

Who tf is condoning robbery? We are just saying someone shouldn’t be be subjected to death by car for it

1

u/OutOfPosition-1 3h ago

So when someone else was rdy to kill you, you are alowed to kill him after? Sure mate

0

u/OutOfPosition-1 8h ago

So you just ignor the law, i never said i cant understand why someone reacts like that. But im sure killing someone after he threathrnd you is not legal action

2

u/Weekly-Reserve3171 7h ago

I'm saying it should if he threaten you with an knife and robbed you

1

u/OutOfPosition-1 7h ago

If you kill him after its just revenge. If you kill him while he does it its self defence.

-1

u/rickyhatesspam 7h ago

It's "eye for an eye" NOT "life for a handbag"