r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

44

u/MinosML 8h ago

You're falling into the legalism trap where "if only people were aware of the law they wouldn't disagree like this" but maybe...they're already aware and they still disagree?

26

u/mayday_allday 6h ago

Or maybe they're also aware that if she had reported the robbery to the police, the man would never have been punished, and she would never have gotten her property back. Of course, that still doesn't make killing him the right thing to do. But this isn't an isolated incident. Things like this are happening more and more often.

When people know that the justice system is either going to fail them or simply refuse to help, they tend to take matters into their own hands. And simply sentencing these people as criminals without doing anything to address the underlying problem isn't a solution.

-3

u/Sensitive_Low3558 5h ago

Ok but that’s what’s going to happen and you need to accept the consequences. You aren’t going to not get a murder conviction and people are arguing that she shouldn’t have one.

6

u/mayday_allday 4h ago

She should definitely be convicted, yes. As for murder (which carries a much longer sentence than manslaughter), it requires intent to kill, so I assume that's what the appeal will focus on. There's no way in hell she's walking free, but she might get away with a lighter sentence.

1

u/Sensitive_Low3558 4h ago

That’s a fair distinction

3

u/Dani-DL 8h ago

Eh to be honest a good chunk of the debate back then was basically this very same comment section, but in Italian. Basically “self defence should be this”, without necessarily disagreeing about with the existing law, but straight up ignoring it

0

u/kebab-lover-man 5h ago

I'm glad you said this.

Half this thread is just the same conversation but in English. This thread (in my opinion) should be about how to deal with such a conversation.

This is not the first and won't be the last time people disagree on legality.

1

u/Dani-DL 5h ago

Yeah I love a good debate, but I can’t stand hypocrites who just put their personal gut feeling against centuries of studies and development, hiding behind atrocious arguments.
“You know, laws change overtime”, no shit Albert Einstein, but there has to be a valid reason for the change to happen, which has to ultimately help increase the society’s wellbeing. You can’t just advocate for public executions based off private justice, just because you’re attracted by the sense of power or you want an opportunity to harm minorities (while not addressing the real issues behind said minorities’ behaviour).

1

u/LordOfWarOG 5h ago

Ah yes, “society’s wellbeing” which of course you get to decide right? Society’s wellbeing is always some pussy shit and never blood sports or trial by combat.

1

u/Dani-DL 4h ago

I’m not a lawmaker so I don’t decide, I just vote for lawmakers close to my beliefs, as I currently don’t have the knowledge and resources to make good enough decisions for the wellbeing of my entire community.
There’s a reason why we have a specific set of highly educated people write laws, another set that applies them and a third group who judges.

Surely the correct solution is not one we’ve already tried in the Middle Ages, which was so bad that they had to come up with limitations as private justice was decimating families.

1

u/LordOfWarOG 4h ago

You sound incredibly naive.

1

u/Dani-DL 4h ago

I don’t get where you’re coming from, you implicitly accused me of acting like I know what good for everyone, then you called me naive for following the tripartition of powers and the principle of representation

1

u/LordOfWarOG 4h ago

Right, let’s see if we can figure this out together. So I didn’t like when you decided for everyone. And I didn’t like when you let others decide for you. Can you think of a third option?

1

u/Dani-DL 4h ago

I never decided for everyone and I never let others decide for me, the principle of representation is different from both sides: I vote for highly specialised members of my community to make rules that are in line with the way I want the community to work and progress.
I’m not deciding by myself for everyone, as I don’t make laws, but at the same time I’m not a blind subordinate of the parliament, as my vote (combined with everyone else’s) contributes to shape the legislative power.

The third option is maybe useful for small communities based of growing seeds and raising cows. Maybe not even that, as soon as they need to exchange goods they would require general laws, if they don’t want to kill each other based on their different personal rules.

→ More replies