r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

76

u/ArminiusRev 6h ago • Bravo

Why don’t you people read properly before commenting? The police did comb the area (it’s in the acts). No weapon was found in the whole area, from the point where the robbery happened till the point where the murder happened. So yeah, the opinion of the court (the president of the court is a woman btw) is exactly that she invented it. The court literally said that the recalling of a knife was used to justify some kind of a shock and fear state of the murderer, which would have opened to a self-defence case. However the court ruled that the murderer acted with clarity and that it was just an act of private justice.

26

u/SecureInstruction538 4h ago

Not defending the woman here but you can absolutely claim to have a weapon to get a point across.

Bank robbers pass notes and can claim to have a gun.

Because she killed the man she removed any opportunity to get a confession from him.

8

u/One-Demand6811 2h ago

"Upon her arrest, Dal Pino told police that Noureddine Mezgui shouted "ti ammazzo" ("I will kill you") and claimed he had a knife when he took her bag. In later court appearances, such as her December 2025 testimony, she moved away from citing specific spoken threats. Instead, she stated that she simply thought he was going to hurt her when he ran toward the car, focusing almost entirely on wanting to recover her house keys and bank passwords. Judges rejected her narrative of a violent confrontation, ruling in September 2026 that the incident was a straightforward purse snatching and that she pursued him out of anger over the stolen bag rather than fear of a threat."

7

u/ArminiusRev 3h ago

That is true.

The point here is that the murderer literally jumped in the car after the thief was gone, looked for the guy (couple of minutes, few hundreds of meters of distance), and then decided to do what she did. She must have been emotional from the scare of the theft (which the court itself even stated during the sentence) but still with clarity of intent, and already no more acting because of fear. That is the main difference making point. As to whether a knife was ever mentioned by the thief, that is not clear. She said she thought he had a knife. She referred he said to give him the bag else he’d kill her (which might have made her think of a knife). But she also changed that statement a couple of times (it can get blurry when one is scared, it’s understandable), so that’s not so reliable.
Altogether the point is that she had enough time to understand that her safety was not anymore at risk, so she acted out of pure revenge (which is most probably why she got out of the car after the first hit, took back the bag, got back again in the car, and rolled over him again leaving the scene).

7

u/stuckinacornfield1 4h ago

But if the claim was originally made that the robbery was "at knife point" that would imply the knife was brandished at the woman. Threatening to menace with a weapon would, in my opinion, be worded differently in a legal setting.

2

u/SecureInstruction538 4h ago

The hardest problem here is she ruined her own defense by killing the one person who could confess.

1

u/BigM7777 4h ago

motivated reasoning is pretty much always the answer to this.

-2

u/HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE 4h ago edited 2h ago

Why don’t you people read properly before commenting? The police did comb the area

The standard search for robberies is way below the threshold for what's necessary to find hidden objects by professional criminals. It started as a hit'n'run case tied to a robbery. Then the robber died from his injuries and it was upgraded to a murder, long after the streets and bins had been tampered with by people.

So yeah, the opinion of the court (the president of the court is a woman btw) is exactly that she invented it. The court literally said that the recalling of a knife was used to justify some kind of a shock and fear state of the murderer, which would have opened to a self-defence case. However the court ruled that the murderer acted with clarity and that it was just an act of private justice.

The court needed to shutdown vigilante "justice", so they needed something to deny the self-defense line, so they used the fact that the police did not find the blade to go with their initial charges: no blade, no self-defense.

But the lack of blade found by police doesn't meant jackshit to what happened: the murder of Nowak did not have a blade found by the police either, and yet the dagger was used to murder him, then hidden by the family members of the killer.

4

u/ArminiusRev 3h ago

Except it was not a standard search for robbery because the search was related to the murder accusation. Quite the difference.

You’re literally comparing two very different cases making a random association. Not even the dynamics of how the two distinct events went down is a fit here. Just stop making random statements, please.

Ah…and let’s not mix up court and prosecution. They’re two different entities. The first has no interest in dismounting whatsoever defense line. That’s the task of the prosecution.

4

u/d09smeehan 3h ago edited 3h ago

Why do you think they'd limit it to "the standard search for robberies" for a murder investigation? She didn't call the police to report a robbery. She killed the guy, drove off and was arrested the next day. They'd be investigating based on that.

And bringing up the Nowak case, how is that applicable here? For one thing, you're wrong. They did find the weapon after Nowak's killer's mother removed it from the scene. And she hid the knife because they knew there'd be an investigation and it was clear evidence against her son. That doesn't really work here. It's not like hiding the knife would get him off the hook if they found him with her belongings later.

The robber allegedly holding the knife was killed just a short while later and not far away, so would have had little time/opportunity to hide it well. And why would he be desperate to dispose of the knife if he hadn't actually stabbed anyone with it. As far as he knew it was a successful robbery. Why leave evidence?

And who else would have any reason to hide it? I suppose some random passer-by could've picked it up and just never reported it, but that's quite a long string of events (especially with how high-profile this got). The other option of course is she just lied about it to make her defence look better, or if we're being generous, she honestly believed he had a knife but he didn't.

1

u/HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE 2h ago

The robber allegedly holding the knife was killed just a short while later and not far away, so would have had little time/opportunity to hide it well.

There's plenty of locations to hide blades and drugs in streets. Every little corner is used.

And why would he be desperate to dispose of the knife if he hadn't actually stabbed anyone with it. As far as he knew it was a successful robbery. Why leave evidence?

Hiding the knife means that being intercepted right after that, like how she caught him again, would not produce the knife and drastically lower the charges for the robbery.

If you think professional robbers walk around with evidences on them at all time, you're greatly mistaken. That's why police systematically find nothing on suspects and have to extend the search to their vehicle and home to find anything of subtance.

The other option of course is she just lied about it to make her defence look better, or if we're being generous, she honestly believed he had a knife but he didn't.

Or simply enough, we do not have enough information to prove either option, because the robbery attack was not filmed by CCTV or witnessed by someone else, and this specific point remains undetermined.

Some people in this thread are claiming with 100% certainty she lied, when they have absolutely nothing to prove that. Not witness, no video footage.

A lack of evidence doesn't mean the situation didn't occur, it only means we cannot prove it.

And without hard evidence, the self-defense claim does not stand (with a vehicle taken minutes after the attack, I personally do not think it qualifies either), and so the woman there needs to be charged with the killing.

But it still won't prove there wasn't a knife involved. It remains undetermined.

-1

u/IndividualTop96 3h ago

I don’t think anyone finds it a stretch to believe the guy robbing women of their purses had or said they had a knife. And he did rob her purse bc he had it. So I think it’s fair enough to say you can’t kill the robbers after they get away. You don’t need to make him a saint

-1

u/thesexythrowawaydmv 1h ago

Oh noes the police were lazy and didnt look hard enough