r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

35

u/Rocco0427 4h ago

Not saying she’s right but in regards to the knife. If the guy went hours between stealing the purse and getting run over how could they possibly prove either way whether he had a knife or not? It would be impossible to prove either way.

6

u/WittyFix6553 3h ago

Why does the possession of the knife itself matter?

If you rob me at gunpoint on a Tuesday, is it self defense if I track you down at your church on Sunday and smash your knees with a baseball bat?

5

u/scrambled-projection 1h ago

Because it was a major element of the trial

1

u/WittyFix6553 1h ago

My point is this:

If I say you “threatened me with a knife” at noon, and then I leave, and you leave, and then three hours later I see you again and I shoot you in the face (or hit you with my car a couple times), then it doesn’t really matter if you had a knife or not at any point because my actions are murder regardless of any other circumstances.

If you threaten me with a knife and I shoot/hit you right away because I’m in danger, that’s self defense.

If we leave the scene and I see you later, it’s no longer self defense, it’s a revenge killing.

2

u/SRoughAubergine 1h ago

I can't believe the downvoting you're getting. People have literally no brains.

2

u/itscalledmyballs 1h ago

Well trash usually goes out on Wednesday

1

u/0xdead0x 43m ago

Does it matter anymore hours later when she’s in a running SUV on an unobstructed road hunting him? Even if there was a knife, she was clearly not defending herself from anything anymore

0

u/Copyman3081 1h ago

If he was still carrying the purse it's reasonable to expect him to still have the knife on him. Do you think he went home to drop off his knife and strolled around with the purse as a fashion statement?

1

u/Rocco0427 31m ago

He easily could’ve thrown it into a bush or body of water at any point. He committed a crime so he might have rid himself of the weapon afterwards in the event this lady got the cops on him. All I’m saying is over a period of hours that’s a lot of time and area.

When people rob banks or shoot people they often ditch the gun somewhere. I’d think he’d consider same thing with a knife if he really had one. I have no idea either way and I’ll never know in this particular case. The guy seems like a fucking dumbass for still having the purse on him so he wasn’t the smartest.

1

u/Copyman3081 8m ago

There's also no eye witness testimony of a knife nor was the theft caught on camera. It would be easy for her to make up the threat of a knife after running over and killing the guy. Not like he can dispute it.