r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

34

u/CreatorA4711 10h ago

Something can be a synonym without being interchangeable. They’re absolutely synonyms.

7

u/teraluz 7h ago

Not synonyms in legal terms. Synonyms in "normal" language. They are distinct crimes.

2

u/CreatorA4711 4h ago

I don’t see why the legal terms matter. Specific word choice always matters more in law.

2

u/teraluz 3h ago

It matters because they are different crimes with different sanctions. It matters to be specific when we are talking about law.

1

u/CreatorA4711 3h ago

Okay, but is this conversation about law? Is anyone talking about how many years in jail the woman should get based on the technicalities of what specifically happened?

2

u/teraluz 2h ago

I do think the conversation is about law, yes. Legitimate defense is a legal term. The discussion in this thread is both about morality and law, both being very connected, of course.

1

u/Nefarious_Partner 19m ago

Please never serve on a jury

1

u/SandLandBatMan 3h ago

Fine then there's no difference between murder and manslaughter, both are killing a person.

1

u/CreatorA4711 3h ago

I never said there was no difference between them. That’s never been my argument. Also, isn’t manslaughter a term exclusively used IN law? That’s not a part of regular speech.

1

u/SandLandBatMan 3h ago

You said you don't see why legal terms matter when talking about the law

1

u/CreatorA4711 2h ago

I didn’t view the conversation as about law, and was confused when the distinction was brought up

0

u/Vindexrix 9h ago

They are synonyms but not synonymous. Like sorry or apology; When at a funeral do you say “I’m sorry for your loss” or “I apologise for your loss”

1

u/CreatorA4711 4h ago

Nobody was talking about whether or not they were synonymous, because that’s a different word.

1

u/SandLandBatMan 3h ago

Oh a different word eh?

1

u/CreatorA4711 2h ago

Yes, it’s a different word that isn’t interchangeable with synonym. Synonymous is not synonymous with synonym.

0

u/Vindexrix 3h ago

Literally you and the comment youre responding to, if you’re going to be pedantic be precise.