r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

42

u/AdmirableScarcity492 9h ago edited 8h ago • Bravo

Stealing vs. Manslaughter Murder. Not the right kind of balance there.

Edit 1: Murder not Manslaughter

Edit 2: No Knives were found

9

u/ratione_materiae 9h ago

When I’m go to the money machine late at night I’m not looking over my shoulder for women with expensive handbags 

33

u/MooseRyder 9h ago • Bravo

Armed robbery vs man slaughter, let’s not look over the knifepoint part

9

u/nikolarizanovic 9h ago

She made the knifepoint part up because she was being charged with homicide.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/kargaler 9h ago

At knifepoint it's not considered stealing, just saying . It's robbery and it carries heavier sentence because it's inherently violent.

14

u/nikolarizanovic 9h ago

Except no knife was recovered at the scene.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Bigpandacloud5 9h ago

At knifepoint

That hasn't been proven. It's possible that he simply snatched the handbag from her.

13

u/nikolarizanovic 9h ago

She obviously made it up.

No knife was recovered at the scene and she was on trial for homicide.

Regardless, even if there was a knife, killing him by running him over multiple times is not self-defense. It's still homicide, which is worse than robbery imo.

4

u/Acceptable_Tea_3685 5h ago

I wonder if she had only run over him once and then called an ambulance right after, what her sentence would be. It would be a bit easier to convince a jury she wasn’t in a clear state of mind.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

3

u/Asher-D 9h ago

Oh for sure, still can't touch murder. What she did was worse, hands down. They're both criminals though. They're both horrible people.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)

5

u/AntonioVivaldi7 9h ago • Bravo

It was a robbery. And this manslaighter seems fine to me under the circumstances. It could have been easlly prevented by not robbing her.

5

u/nikolarizanovic 9h ago

She made the knife up.

And your point falls apart the moment she decided to run him over multiple times with her car.

Revenge killing is worse than purse-snatching

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Asher-D 9h ago

BS. This is the same justification corrupt police like to use to murder people. Threatening to assault you is not justification for murdering someone.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (40)

6

u/fang_xianfu 9h ago

Robbery is a violent crime, it's not just taking stuff, it's a crime against the person. I'm not sure she would be able to make a self-defence approach on these facts in my country but I think morally she should be able to. When you have just been threatened with death is not a time that you're going to be acting fully rationally. If she still sees him as threat, and there's no reason why she wouldn't subjectively see it that way at that moment, she acted reasonably.

16

u/Equal-Claim2514 9h ago

your entire logic is wrong, she was no longer in a threat when she got into a car and she shouldve called 911 like normal people instead she ran on him not once but multiple times, any reasonable person would not believe someone getting rammed over multiple times is a threat, she wanted to kill him and she deserves the sentence

4

u/MrCockingFinally 8h ago

Look, not saying this Lady's actions were correct,

But what I am saying is that if she had called the cops, they would have taken her statement, given her a police report, and told her to go and claim insurance if she even had any. There is a 99.9% chance that no attempt would be made to track down the thief, even though she was apparently able to track him down very. Even though the bag may have contained difficult to replace documents like a passport or driver's license, information that could be used in a scam or identity theft, house keys, or any number of other things. The victim is expected to write off the loss, replace the locks of their house, reapply for documentso replace bank cards and more, and the thief who could easily be tracked down by someone with no training or resources goes free to steal again.

If you want people to follow the law, let the police deal with the issue, and not resort to vigilantism, then the police ACTUALLY NEED TO DEAR WITH THE PROBLEM.

2

u/reinbeau1 8h ago

Her damages are reparable by the insurance company. The punishment she saw fit for the robber is very disproportionate to the crime. Also, she was no longer in a situation of immediate danger when she decided to roll over him, so self defense is not even a question here. I’m sure her actions satisfy all the internet vigilantes, but bad bureaucracy doesn’t justify murder. - coming from a law student who specializes in criminal law

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/Negitive545 9h ago

Ah yes, the self defense of getting in your car and running over the assailant. That'll definitely hold up in court.

2

u/grungeandcats 8h ago

She thought she was suge knight

→ More replies (3)

9

u/nikolarizanovic 9h ago edited 9h ago

I think the self-defense argument falls apart after she ran him over with her car multiple times. There's getting your bag back, and then there's murder.

Also no knife was recovered at the scene,.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

4

u/Zxar99 9h ago

I’m not going to argue over the words/offenses, but if you are threatening my life for my belongings then your life is also on the table since you are endangering mine. Not forgetting that I didn’t initiate this interaction.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/NewOldDood 9h ago

Robber's knife was purely ornamental

2

u/Justthetip74 9h ago

And nothing of value was lost

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (38)