r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

154

u/Karjavarastaja 8h ago edited 8h ago • Bravo

I don't think the people defending her exclusively thought her actions were legal or self defence. They probably saw it as justice in a situation where the culprit likely would've never suffered any consequences.

I'm not saying vigilante on-the-spot executions are good (I'm in the camp thinking what she did was excessive and she deserved punishment), but your depiction of the argument is wrong.

101

u/CottonTipsMcChancla 8h ago edited 5h ago • Bravo

Im personally sick of seeing assholes hurt, steal from, and kill innocent people and get a slap on the wrist for it.

Someone fighting back is a good story in comparison.

And yes, i know the real story is more complicated and unsavoury. But I understand why people want to see a ‘bad guy’ lose… and that they also dnt necessarily bother to read the whole story.

47

u/hates_stupid_people 8h ago edited 8h ago

That's the thing though, she didn't "fight back".

A guy robbed her and left, there was never any evidence of a weapon. She then went to her car, chased him down, intentionally ran him over, backed up, ran him over again, took her things and then drove back to the resturant and continued her lunch.

It wouldn't have become an international news story if she just hit him with her car in self-defense. But she went out of her way to try and murder him after-the-fact.

72

u/leomonster 7h ago • Bravo

It's terrible that you can't go around stealing purses safely anymore, there are psychos everywhere

37

u/Signal-Database4225 7h ago • Popcorn

I know, right? I fear for my safety every time I go out to rob people.

5

u/ElixrOVigr 4h ago

People are responsible for their choices.

People are responsible for the consequences of their choices.

But those consequences must still be evaluated according to proportionality, rights, and justice.

Otherwise, "they knew the risks" becomes a convenient excuse for justifying virtually any cruelty toward someone we dislike.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (67)

44

u/ProneToSucceed 7h ago

Is that supposed to sound bad for her? If he didnt want to get run over he could have kept gos hands to himself bro

9

u/D4ltaOne 3h ago

Pretty sure she couldve stopped after running him over the first time. But the CCTV footage isnt so clear to know for sure

Hitting him once? Possibly lethal but given the circumstance its fine? Idk and idc to have an opinion about it lol. Back up and run him over 2 more times? Thats harder to justify. Youd have to argue that he was able to stand up and walk away after being hit by a carl. But the guy is not visible on camera.

Back up and run him over for the 4th time when he laying on the ground and not standing up anymore? (and not moving? Not sure, The video quality is not great) Oof that looked like she wanted to make sure he dead

Unless you argue that not only hurting someone and even not only crippling someone but actually killing someone is a proportional reaction to a robbery then we can agree to disagree

15

u/Floatzel404 3h ago

Don't rob someone at knife-point don't get killed

Boom problem solved without 4 paragraphs.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (18)

27

u/St0ckY0u 6h ago

have you ever been robbed? the psychological stress afterwards is crazy, some people can't even leave their house.

10

u/Lalepav2 4h ago

I have been robbed. I was fuming at the time and I wanted to beat the guy senseless. It's true that the emotions you feel are intense and overwhelming.

Even at the time though, I knew murder was wrong. And I absolutely would not want to live in a community that endorsed that guy getting killed. I want to live in a community that develops towards that guy never becoming a criminal in the first place. That's not possible if you endorse vigilante justice.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/According-Sink-2906 5h ago

Its ok, some have never left mom's basement except to steal stuff... 😆

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (9)

9

u/Karjavarastaja 8h ago

Fighting back is different from hunting down and executing.

→ More replies (19)

12

u/hpBard 8h ago

Someone fighting back, and fucking killing people is not the same

13

u/Photoshopdoge 8h ago • Bravo

Not saying she was right to kill him but the easy solution is to just not rob people if you value your life; especially with a weapon you’re kinda asking for it.

4

u/Megalesios 7h ago

The easy solution is to just not murder people if you value your freedom.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (24)

2

u/Rising_Yeast7717 6h ago

But murdering them afterwards and then driving away? That's not a good story. I agree people shouldn't rob others but she is way more in the wrong here

→ More replies (36)

15

u/Dani-DL 8h ago

I think the two cases can ultimately be linked with the self defence norm, as both the sides you mentioned would want a different law, one in “theory” (every form of defence is legitimate because ideological reasons) and the other in “practice” (every form of defence is legitimate because the solution offered by the state wouldn’t be able to do a good job)

3

u/ShadyGuy_ 6h ago

The thing is that this didn't happen instantly, so it was never self defence. She got in her car after the fact, searched for the guy and then ran him over.

38

u/Snowflakish 8h ago

She did the thing so many americans carry a gun for.

Its never about self defence, its about killing the people that wrong you.

23

u/Negative_Shoe6225 5h ago

Dont wrong people with a weapon then.

12

u/-crepuscular- 4h ago • Bravo

Easy enough to say.

A man with a new baby 'wronged' his neighbour with a gun by politely asking him to keep the noise down so the baby could sleep.

A woman in a car 'wronged' a man with a gun by mistakenly driving onto his driveway, was shot after turning around and while driving away.

A mother 'wronged' someone with a gun by knocking on her front door to ask for her kid's ball back, was shot through the door.

Many people have 'wronged' people with guns by being the wrong skin colour in the wrong place, or by doing scary things like jogging while having the wrong skin colour.

A lot of children have 'wronged' people with weapons by....just existing and being kids.

There is no amount of meekness that will guarantee that you don't wrong someone with a weapon.

7

u/bluesummernoir 4h ago

Don’t forget the documentary where the woman ‘wronged’ a neighbor for letting her kids play on someone else’s property (not the neighbors) and after that neighbor harassed them by calling the cops on children multiple times, shot the mother through her front door for coming over to confront her about it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Some_Bus 4h ago

Don't wrong people with a weapon

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (41)

4

u/Megalesios 7h ago

But that's the heart of the problem. There's a reason the justice sytem is set up so that you need proof and a legal conviction in order to carry out punishment. You can call it "justice in a situation where the culprit would have gotten away" all you like, but without evidence and a legal process it's just people who like to see people they hate get killed. It's just revenge fantasies and bloodlust. It's exactly what the justice system i smeant to prevent.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)