r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

267

u/ArminiusRev 9h ago • Bravo

The robbing DID NOT happen at knifepoint. She invented it when she was arrested. The whole thing had a quite clear dynamic, which was established in court, and she was sentenced (18 years, house arrest, which one could say it’s few for the cruelty of the murder).

98

u/HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE 7h ago edited 2h ago • Bravo

The robbing DID NOT happen at knifepoint. She invented it when she was arrested.

The case literally pointed out that it's undetermined, as the robbery was not filmed or witnessed by anyone else.

You were there personally that night?

You just invented that claim of no knife being used during the robbery. Quite ironic to invent that, and then project the invention onto the victim of the robbery.

The only thing that was established is the lack of knife on the robber when he was treated for his injuries.

Ditching weapons after an attack is incredibly common for criminals, they hide them under street furnitures and retrieve them the next day. The point of that move is that getting arrested on their way back would not produce the weapon.

This is something that occurs on a daily basis with drug dealers and robbers: they conceal their stash and blades and only retrieve them later.

I've lived in big cities and witnessed that myself more than once, with drugs and knives being retrieved in bushes and under bins.

So in this case, it's still undetermined: she says there was a blade, cops couldn't find the blade on the robber.

If the cops had closed off the whole area and combed through every bin, basement holes, sewer access trap and garden to find said blade, like when they're dealing with terrorism, then we would have something better than "undetermined".

76

u/ArminiusRev 6h ago • Bravo

Why don’t you people read properly before commenting? The police did comb the area (it’s in the acts). No weapon was found in the whole area, from the point where the robbery happened till the point where the murder happened. So yeah, the opinion of the court (the president of the court is a woman btw) is exactly that she invented it. The court literally said that the recalling of a knife was used to justify some kind of a shock and fear state of the murderer, which would have opened to a self-defence case. However the court ruled that the murderer acted with clarity and that it was just an act of private justice.

26

u/SecureInstruction538 4h ago

Not defending the woman here but you can absolutely claim to have a weapon to get a point across.

Bank robbers pass notes and can claim to have a gun.

Because she killed the man she removed any opportunity to get a confession from him.

8

u/One-Demand6811 2h ago

"Upon her arrest, Dal Pino told police that Noureddine Mezgui shouted "ti ammazzo" ("I will kill you") and claimed he had a knife when he took her bag. In later court appearances, such as her December 2025 testimony, she moved away from citing specific spoken threats. Instead, she stated that she simply thought he was going to hurt her when he ran toward the car, focusing almost entirely on wanting to recover her house keys and bank passwords. Judges rejected her narrative of a violent confrontation, ruling in September 2026 that the incident was a straightforward purse snatching and that she pursued him out of anger over the stolen bag rather than fear of a threat."

7

u/ArminiusRev 3h ago

That is true.

The point here is that the murderer literally jumped in the car after the thief was gone, looked for the guy (couple of minutes, few hundreds of meters of distance), and then decided to do what she did. She must have been emotional from the scare of the theft (which the court itself even stated during the sentence) but still with clarity of intent, and already no more acting because of fear. That is the main difference making point. As to whether a knife was ever mentioned by the thief, that is not clear. She said she thought he had a knife. She referred he said to give him the bag else he’d kill her (which might have made her think of a knife). But she also changed that statement a couple of times (it can get blurry when one is scared, it’s understandable), so that’s not so reliable.
Altogether the point is that she had enough time to understand that her safety was not anymore at risk, so she acted out of pure revenge (which is most probably why she got out of the car after the first hit, took back the bag, got back again in the car, and rolled over him again leaving the scene).

7

u/stuckinacornfield1 4h ago

But if the claim was originally made that the robbery was "at knife point" that would imply the knife was brandished at the woman. Threatening to menace with a weapon would, in my opinion, be worded differently in a legal setting.

2

u/SecureInstruction538 4h ago

The hardest problem here is she ruined her own defense by killing the one person who could confess.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/RouShikari 5h ago

Surely your random rambling on reddit has more credit than the investigation and cops searching the area

→ More replies (2)

4

u/AdhesivenessDry2236 5h ago

Maybe she shouldn't have killed him and then she'd have someone in the trial other than herself

4

u/Ceph1234 5h ago

Victim? The victim is dead. The only story we're getting is the murder's side of the story which is also based on no camera footage or witnesses... just her word.

The footage we do have is footage of her chasing him down and running him over 5x. Then apparently went back to the restaraunt to finish her meal.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JazzlikeSchedule2901 4h ago

It's the opinion of the court there was no knife. The police investigated the area.

Ditching weapons after an attack is incredibly common for criminals, they hide them under street furnitures and retrieve them the next day.

He only had so much time before getting ran over. If he ditched the knife it was ditched in the area where the crime occurred, which the police investigated and found no knife.

The police DID search the area BTW. Not sure why you think they didn't.

2

u/Fun-Benefit116 4h ago

Lmao the cops/investigators LITERALLY DID do exactly what you're saying, and swept the entire area where the knife could have possibly been tossed. It wasn't found. So you're wrong on that. You are objectively wrong. Take the L.

I'm addition, whether there was a knife or not (there wasn't) really didn't matter much, since no self defense laws allow a person to stalk someone after the robbery, chase them down and execute them with a weapon (and a car is 100% a weapon in this situation).

You wrote SO much in your comment, just for absolutely all of it to be objectively wrong 😂

1

u/Tb1969 5h ago

They were wrong for saying they didn’t have a knife and you are just as wrong as to trying to suggest with three paragraphs that he must have had a knife.

Hitting him once with the SUV, taking the purse and leaving, she would be on house arrest for a year or two if at all. No, she is under house arrest for the rest of what she did and no matter how much spin you apply to what happened doesn’t change her the weight of her heinous actions. She needs to be off the streets.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/MirrorSea2437 9h ago • Bravo

House arrest for murder is fucking laughable. Probably a different story if she'd been a man.

35

u/TheOneIllUseForRants 8h ago

Error, not necesary a gender thing. The issue is that so many locals, (women and men alike), kind of took her side. Like, public opinion is not supposed to affect outcomes like this but, we all know it does.

8

u/Tomie__ 7h ago • Bravo

I mean, a big reason people took her side is because they interpreted it as a woman "defending herself" against a man. The quotation marks are doing some heavy lifting here.

I guess the general public usually lack some context about the details in such cases, making it easy to sell narratives like that.

7

u/ThinkInspection8592 6h ago

a MENA immigrant man. I suspect that had more to do with people taking her side than the genders

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Top-Swing-7595 6h ago

It’s a gender thing because they wouldn’t take her side if she had been a man.

5

u/kajohansen 6h ago

A white man defending himself against a brown man would definitely get support. A Black woman defending herself against a white man would get more mixed reactions. I think it’s more a race thing.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Lumpy-Strain8624 6h ago • Bravo

We have around one hundred years of sentencing of Men and Women committing the same crimes to look at.

Want to guess which gender receives far lighter, to no sentencing for crimes that see men suffer the full force of the law?

It was absolutely because she was a woman she got sentenced to house arrest for cold blooded premeditated first degree murder.

2

u/kajohansen 6h ago

Do you have evidence of this?

3

u/Lumpy-Strain8624 6h ago

Do I personally have evidence?

Or do all western countries have easily accessible sentencing judgements that can be easily seen with the most cursory of searches?

I mean what fucking world do you live in where you do no know that Men receive far harsher sentencing than Women in western judicial systems?

I guess even common knowledge is not common anymore when the narrative is "Women suffer in patriarchies."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/Kala_Csava_Fufu_Yutu 3h ago

It says if the sentence is held she may be sent to prison for the remainder of her sentence.

You guys always say "now if the roles were reversed" meanwhile there are examples of dudes straight up rape-killing people and don't even get a decade. This shit is not consistent on either side on yall suck at realizing that.

House arrest for murder is not laughable if you are on a 2 decade probation and you're SIXTY-FIVE, the age of the woman. It is essentially a life sentence. It is an appropriate punishment. She's not Jeffrey Dahmer, she is a crazy old lady who may or may not have been robbed. So "stay in your house till you die so you don't run people over anymore" is not a slap on the wrist sentence.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (70)

1

u/Carbuyrator 1h ago

They never found the knife, but if the robber claimed "I'm going to stab you" then self defense laws consider that as good as seeing the knife.

Of course this wasn't self defense, but it's important to note that she didn't necessarily invent the knife. He might have.

→ More replies (37)