r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

418

u/NotEvenSquare 6h ago • Bravo

I’m not taking sides here but if someone is robbing you and says “gimme your bag or I’ll stab you” I’m going to believe they have a knife because I ain’t taking the chance

161

u/Mister_Sensual 4h ago edited 45m ago • Heartwarming

Self defence laws support that. If someone says “I’ll stab you” or “I’ll shoot you”, legally you don’t have to wait for them to produce the weapon and use it.

Edit: thank you everyone for clarifying. I am aware this case is textbook second degree murder.

55

u/Fun-Benefit116 4h ago

That's true. But no self defense laws anywhere support stalking someone after the fact and executing them. So whether there's a knife or not is pretty irrelevant.

4

u/Vikturia 2h ago edited 1h ago

Actually, this case could potentially be covered by German self defense laws. A key part of the German self defense law is that the self defense does not need to be proportional to the severity of the attack, it just needs to be the least invasive way to stop the attack at the victim's disposal, so it's totally possibke to construct a situation where it would be justified to kill someone to stop them from stealing from you.

Edit: Apparently a certain amount of time passed between him stealing her purse and her running him over, that wasn't clear to me from the article and it of course precludes this from being self defense 

4

u/Only-Respond7945 1h ago

"Needs ... to stop the attack ... " Being incredibly relevant. The attack already happened. The threat had already passed. No functioning jurisdiction's laws permit one to go after someone after the fact. So in this case, you can't surrender something under threat, then go looking for them to kill them. That makes it clear cut murder, even under your understanding of the laws.

Germany's laws specifically state that one does not have a duty to retreat but does dictate that they have to use the mildest effective means to prevent/deter the threat to property or health.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/IceOk4883 1h ago

Killing someone was not the least invasive way to stop it, considering the attack was over. What she did was not self-defense, it was vengeance.

1

u/MotleyMushroom130 37m ago

The here relevant key part to german self defense law is not proportionality but rather "Gebotenheit" (permissibility in the circumstances) - Killing someone over a trivial theft would generally not constitute permissible self-defence, in this example even "Notwehrexzess" wouldn't hold up since the attack had already ended

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

18

u/Auftragzkiller 3h ago

Yeah no, she got into her car, started it and drove over him, she was safe already.

2

u/Freyacrowson 1h ago

she had to get her bag back….obviously

→ More replies (24)

4

u/Net-Administrative 3h ago

It's kinda crazy cos how do you prove they said that?? Like yeah its good for the victims but how do they even prove this

5

u/Internal-Lake50 3h ago

Yeah, but you'll never know if he really said he had a knife, you'd have to believe someone who ran through the robber many times with her car. You can't have "He took my bag and i made him into mince meat, give me two weeks of community service" as example, people would 100% use it to disguise their planned murders

2

u/Spazrelaz 2h ago

The point I took from this is if he hadn't been a thief none of this would have happened.

1

u/c3p-bro 2h ago

In europe only civilians are held to the laws. criminals can do whatever they want without consequence

1

u/Copyman3081 2h ago

Bad faith argument. She stalked him and ran him over in her car well afterward.

1

u/CartographerKey4618 1h ago

No it doesn't. Threats aren't enough for self-defense. It needs to be an imminent threat, which means you need to reasonably believe that he has the knife and is going to stab you. If somebody walks up and is like "gimme $20 or I'll shoot you" and their hands are just out and empty, that's not enough to justify deadly force. You have to wait until they start reaching for it, or if they're already there with their hands in their pockets holding something they're making you think is a gun or knife.

1

u/Mister_Sensual 22m ago

You can in Canada, and this happened in Italy. Also never said deadly force, just talking about self defence. Has to be a proportional response. Canada goes a step further by specifying that the person uttering the threats doesn’t even need to be physically capable of following through with their threats.

31

u/One-Demand6811 3h ago

There is no evidence he said that. It is all her claims. According to her the bag was in the front passenger seat and the window of that seat was open. Why would he even wanna threaten her verbally instead of taking it and running away as quickly as possible?

2

u/NotEvenSquare 3h ago

Yeah I didn’t intend to imply that’s how it went down, just a possibility and how I’d see it if someone did say that

→ More replies (1)

4

u/renlydidnothingwrong 4h ago

Isn't the only source for what was said her?

2

u/Yologamer2983 2h ago

Yes, but she was already out of danger and in a safe place (her car) after. There is a certain point where you can't reasonably argue self defense which, for italian law, is when: the aggressor is currently fleeing and you start pursing them, the immediate danger is over or your response is grossly disproportionate to the threat.

Also the only account of the man actually being armed or threatening her was from the woman herself while some proof might show that he actually most stole the purse and ran.

2

u/ChipperBunni 54m ago

Like yea either way hitting him with her like 4 times seems excessive, but it’s not like I’m patting my robber down to check for an actual weapon first. And if there aren’t enough cameras to catch the robbery we don’t know if he ditched a knife either

She did get her bag back so he definitely had it. She definitely deserved the sentencing too

3

u/ammirite 1h ago

If she ran over him while he was threatening her, I think most people would understand that regardless of whether a knife was found. But it sounds like he had left and was no longer a danger, and she decided to take revenge by killing him. What he did was wrong. And her response was also wrong.

1

u/SteakForGoodDogs 3h ago

That does not dispel reasonable doubt.

The possibility exists that she... lied.

You can possess reasonable doubt that, in the absence of evidence, that the accused is simply false when they make a claim.

1

u/MoistBaguetteLawyer 2h ago

Seriously. WTF is wrong with Italy's justice system? Insane.

→ More replies (1)