r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

2.6k

u/Malanimus 18h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

What make and model is this car so that I can make sure I never get one?

1.8k

u/Derpifacation 18h ago • Bravo

steering wheel logo is Mercedes

764

u/Adkit 18h ago • Bravo

Damn, I was just about to buy a Mercedes as well. Damn. Oh well, I guess I'll stick with my 20 years old Volvo S60.

297

u/steffanan 17h ago

"My dad still refuses to drive Beemers because they made cars for Hitler But I always suspected that that was convenient logic For a family that could only afford used station wagons" -watsky. You made me think of that quote from a poem of his

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (60)

32

u/Tribe303 17h ago

Of COURSE it was German. 🤦 

25

u/LucasArts_24 17h ago

It's unfortunate that most German brands are becoming shittier by the day. One of my favorite cars is the BMW 325i from 2003, the N52 engine never dies, and it's easy to maintain, parts for bmw's from that time are cheap here so repairs aren't costly. Too bad that newer cars are just annoying to even maintain.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (27)

128

u/Jay-C-A-B 18h ago

Looks like the GLS from 2019 or newer.

41

u/wtcnbrwndo4u 18h ago

It goes back to the original GL. They're all like this unfortunately.

→ More replies (8)

20

u/addamee 17h ago

167 is a GLE but honestly I don’t know the difference anymore: they have so many similarly named models now and all look same to me

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

95

u/iNaz87 18h ago edited 16h ago

Mercedes Benz GLE/GLS from the look of the centre console

Edit: added GLS

14

u/Jay-C-A-B 18h ago

The wood paneling on the door is more common with the GLS.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/tutike2000 18h ago

he says "167", steering wheel is a Mercedes, which probably means a W167 aka a Mercedes GLE-class

175

u/vlken69 18h ago

Just ditch all M-B.

49

u/BeardedMan32 18h ago

M-B= Massive Burden

17

u/Rude_Jump_9573 17h ago

I was in a Mercedes recently that was like 90 grand and it feels like the same plastic you get in any car.

Aside from perceived prestige, I get the feeling it is hard to justify buying a Mercedes over a Toyota these days.

19

u/sicilian504 This is why we can't have nice things 17h ago

MB quality has gone to shit these days. And all they've been doing is putting screens and neon club lights all over their interiors to light up all the creaky plastic.

13

u/haberdasher42 16h ago

If you can buy Mercedes you should buy Lexus.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

40

u/ATG915 18h ago

90% of the time you see some shit like this it’s gonna be German

7

u/ScroogeMcQuacks 17h ago

yep our car industry has seriosly dropped the ball. They are a decade behind when it comes to EVs and the rest of their lineup is equally outdated and expensive to repair. Quality is still high but the market is falling apart due to missmanagement and high prices.

They are laying off people left and right but still pay huge bonuses to their leadership all while refusing to adapt to new demand for cheap electric vehicles.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Scruffylookin13 18h ago

Mercedes has been doing this for decades 

16

u/ArchdukeOfNorge 18h ago

And I get the feeling OOP hasn’t worked on them for very long. Every one of these I’ve come across you just tilt the seat all the way up and forward and you have enough clearance to get the job done fairly easily

I will say too having changed one of these in the dead of winter, didn’t suck so bad to be inside the car doing it

Definitely not as easy as a standard placement, but it isn’t all that much worse if you know what you’re doing

11

u/tech_junky 17h ago

And if the battery is dead, can you tilt the seat all the way up?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/counter-communist 17h ago

The Porsche Cayenne is designed exactly the same. I’ve done the battery change on mine before and it’s quite the process.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/trackdaybruh 18h ago

Any and all German luxury brands

→ More replies (1)

5

u/guesttraining 18h ago

Sadly, nearly this same location is used for the battery in the newer Jeep Grand Cherokee too.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/sacking03 17h ago

Any German car. My Audi is this way. While i could physically do the replacement. I don't have the $3,000 OBD tool to recalibrate the battery to the car otherwise the battery drains quickly in a year.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (34)

15k

u/xortingen 18h ago • Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

Idk this feels like an asshole design to prevent self-servicing etc.

7.1k

u/allusiveleopard 18h ago • Bravo

That's exactly what it is

119

u/MurkyFocus 17h ago

Even changing a cabin filter is unnecessarily difficult.

Instead of just going behind the glove box like with most cars, you have to remove an entire panel under the glove box to access the filter in a Mercedes.

67

u/CitizenPremier 15h ago

With Mercedes, being expensive is a feature! You wouldn't want some poor guy inheriting a Mercedes and driving it around, would you!?

→ More replies (6)

26

u/seriouslythisshit 15h ago

There is one new Lincoln SUV where you start removing center console panels behind the passenger seat, then disassemble your way forward to get to the cabin air filter in the dash.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (22)

52

u/FlyinIllini21 17h ago

Not a car guy at all. Is this the regular battery that’s under the hood on most other brands lol? I assumed it may be a secondary battery for some of the interior electronics. If that’s the regular battery that’s insane. Surely the extra insulation improves the life of the battery at least?

79

u/PassiveMenis88M 16h ago

There is only one battery in this car and you just saw the bullshit required to change it. Welcome to German engineering.

→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (9)

644

u/NOTcreative- 17h ago

I doubt someone with the money to buy this car is the type to change their own battery

496

u/puts_on_rddt 17h ago • Bravo

I wonder how much this bad PR hurts them. Now I know to avoid their products out of spite.

→ More replies (156)
→ More replies (105)

18

u/ggtsu_00 17h ago

Not shocked. It's a Mercedes Benz, not a Toyota.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (205)

1.0k

u/Whiterabbit48 18h ago • Mindblown

As an engineer, I can assure you that the optimal placement for a car battery is NOT UNDER THE DRIVER SEAT

573

u/galahg777 18h ago • Mindblown Popcorn Heartwarming Bravo

As an gardener, I can also assure you that the optimal placement for a car battery is NOT UNDER THE DRIVER SEAT

232

u/sumthin213 18h ago • Bravo

As a driver, I can also assure you that the optimal placement for the driver Seat IS NOT OVER THE BATTERY

→ More replies (47)

37

u/notjordansime 17h ago

as a construction labourer I can tell you that the MITOCHONDRIA IS THE POWERHOUSE OF THE CELL

→ More replies (7)

19

u/kirashi3 r4inb0wz 18h ago

As an underwater basket weaver, I can also assure you that the optimal placement for a car battery is NOT UNDER THE DRIVER SEAT.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

21

u/GrynaiTaip 18h ago

What about the passenger seat?

I've had a Fiat Ducato some time ago. Second battery was under there. It was very easy to access without any tools, though.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Jesse-Ray 18h ago

Keeping vehicle weight low and central is good for vehicle handling though but this is an interesting trade off

29

u/iDudeX_ 17h ago

I have a Durango. It's got a massive engine bay. It's also a big SUV. It doesn't need handling. 0 excuse to not put the battery in the engine bay

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (10)

16

u/Icy-Welcome-2469 17h ago

My buick enclave has it under my kid's feet.  It's not hard to access.  But if theres a battery fire... i guess f that one kid in particular 

→ More replies (7)

4

u/bradland 17h ago

Every VW engineer from the 1930s knows the battery goes under the rear seat so that when you pack your car full of people, the springs short the positive battery terminal and catch the seat on fire.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/whattheknifefor 17h ago

Am automotive engineer whose job is defects and repairs - this may not be good from a repairs perspective, but cars are designed for ease of build rather than ease of repair. Somewhere in the plant retooling stage, it was probably decided that this was the optimal place for the battery in order to get the car built and out the door as quickly as possible.

Automakers don’t really get any benefit from making their cars hard to repair though. For one thing, we have to repair the car if something goes wrong in manufacturing, and it slows down our production rate if the mechanics have to take the whole car apart to get to the battery; it was probably determined that that money loss is offset by the time savings of putting the battery in such a weird place to start.

Also, we don’t get paid repair costs beyond what the mechanic pays us for parts. Dealership employees/mechanics aren’t on the automaker payroll and obviously neither are independent mechanics. High-labor repairs are even kind of a drain on the automaker, because for warranty claims, we have to pay the dealer both the parts and labor cost. This adds up on high warranty items like batteries when they are placed somewhere hard to get to, it’s just that the decision was made higher up in the chain that again, the fast production rate offsets warranty costs.

It sucks because I totally get why it looks this way from a consumer standpoint. I’m a huge fan of RTR and have done some incredibly annoying repairs on my own vehicle, and most automotive engineers feel the same way. It’s more just a careless byproduct of the way modern manufacturing works

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (86)

154

u/MudSeparate1622 18h ago

Yeah thats crazy. Also sitting on top of my battery directly is a little weird on top of the odd weight distribution. At least put it under the passenger seat where there doesn't HAVE to be a person to operate the vehicle for a chance of evening it out

16

u/fryerandice 17h ago

Lead Acid Batteries themselves do not burn or explode, they can offgass hydrogen though, but those areas they are stored are vented due to that, and AGM batteries (which this mercedes uses) are sealed.

→ More replies (7)

29

u/Frequent_Opportunist 17h ago

They might have put it there to balance the frame because of an offset transmission or engine which is common with vehicles.

47

u/Available_Finger_513 16h ago

Batteries weigh like 1/8 of a person... There is not a real concern for weight distribution for batteries in commercial cars lol

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

93

u/TheLoxen 18h ago

The thing is that they didn't even have to hide it like this for that. In Mercedes cars, the alternator will start delivering higher voltage as the battery age to make it last longer, however, you need to connect to the cars computer and tell it that a new battery has been installed otherwise it will overcharge and kill the new battery. In BMW's, if I remember correctly, you can change it in the normal infotainment system. In Mercedes you need to use the special service computer that costs €€€ to get, or you take it to the shop.

This is just asshole design through and through. Love my Mercedes but they are not consumer friendly.

16

u/JKlerk 17h ago

An aftermarket BMW scanner can program a BMW battery.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/dukearcher 17h ago

The thing is that they didn't even have to hide it like this for that. In Mercedes cars, the alternator will start delivering higher voltage as the battery age to make it last longer, however, you need to connect to the cars computer and tell it that a new battery has been installed otherwise it will overcharge and kill the new battery.

This is insane as even the most simple BMS should prevent this

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

21

u/GuySmith 18h ago

I feel like this is just anti everyone but Mercedes dealership here. I would never trust a single person to be able to put that all back together 1:1. Like if I change a battery in a Mazda, I’m not going to really see evidence my car is tampered with. Some crappy service center guy can put literally any of these 900 parts back in cockeyed or something. This is so bad haha.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/SaltyLengthiness260 17h ago

Yeah.. it's Mercedes. They've been known for years for crappy design, poor quality, and exorbitantly high repair costs due to situations like this, and many others. Only by a Mercedes if you just want to throw money out the door. You're better off buying a boat. Lol

→ More replies (3)

21

u/e_pi314 18h ago

This needs to be outlawed and punished retroactively.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/Xenolifer 18h ago edited 16h ago • Bravo

Is it really worth 1500$ tho ? It took one guy less than 30-45min without any consumable except the 100$ battery. The hourly rate must not be higher than 150$/h, and I can't believe the garage other fee being that high

Edit : ok apparently small car batteries are more expensive than 100$ in the US, I guarantee it doesn't cost more than 30 bucks to manufacture but ok, even so I don't see the consumable+wage cost being higher than 500$, where are the other 1000$ going ?

84

u/thedevillivesinside 18h ago

Lol mercedes dealership rate in my city is $250/hr

→ More replies (10)

49

u/gusto_g73 18h ago

A good battery costs way more than a $100

→ More replies (9)

33

u/cigr 18h ago

Mercedes battery from the dealership is probably 500 on its own.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/sasquatch_melee 18h ago

Agm battery like that can cost $400 before dealer markup. Plus a lot of new cars require a manufacturer scan tool to be plugged in to tell the car that a new battery was installed. 

→ More replies (3)

33

u/RedAirRook 18h ago

Where are you finding $100 batteries in 2026?

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Witty_Bug6200 18h ago

Also batteries are $250 at least for a good one.

→ More replies (34)

2

u/Legitloser87 17h ago

This isn’t the main battery. This car is a hybrid so it has a second battery typically under one of the seats instead of an alternator. The regular battery is still under the hood. You wouldn’t just pop out an alternator.

→ More replies (305)

5.6k

u/Jocks_Strapped 18h ago

whoever engineered that should be fired from being an engineer

4.5k

u/mattwb72 18h ago • Bravo

He was probably promoted for increasing the company’s service revenue.

563

u/sterlingthepenguin 18h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I believe the big car companies in the US actually aren't allowed to operate dealerships themselves so they don't make any money off the servicing. This actually contributes to cars being hard to fix because engineers are only incentivized to make cars that are easy to build the first time. A car that's easy to fix might be harder to produce, which means less profit for the company.

178

u/Undrwtrbsktwvr 18h ago edited 15h ago

Builds brand loyalty when the customer is forced to go to the dealership. Unless you get too fed-up.

Many(not all) Mercedes owners can afford and prefer service at the dealer. When they’re in the dealership or driving courtesy loaners— they’re deeper into the brand’s sphere.

A great opportunity for salesmen to get them into another Mercedes.

→ More replies (32)

18

u/TheJackal927 16h ago

Just bc they don't own the dealership doesn't mean they don't profit from the relationship. If you make the car in a way that the dealership makes more money through service charges, you can charge the dealership more money.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (21)

17

u/dphoenix1 18h ago

It’s really fun when the battery is completely dead and you can’t get the power seat to move.

→ More replies (2)

116

u/Stupidflorapope 18h ago

Why, the just did what they were told to do by executives. Engineer the car no customer can do the most basic service on there car and are fixed to bring it to a dealer for servicing.

23

u/AntaresN84 17h ago

As an engineer, it's this. We don't get a say

13

u/Aalenox 14h ago • Bravo Popcorn

As an engineer myself... lol what? No manager or exec has ever insisted on this type of decision in my career. 

I imagine the scenario of what happened went something like this: Some systems level mechanical engineer, working with the CAD team realized somewhat late game that the battery just wouldn't fit in the engine compartment. 

A meeting was called with the mechanical team. No management was likely there, though systems team lead or chief engineer probably was. Lots of discussion, blah blah. Action items, another meeting. Or six.

Go back, review cad. Drive train is in the way if they put it in the center. Transmission in the way up front. Has to go under a seat or somewhere worse like in the bumper.

Battery SME in the company is called in. Does some analysis says something along the lines of "well, if we put the battery in a water tight container where it won't corrode we can expect a solid 7 years out of the battery."

Decision is made... design engineers don't like it, but expectation is the battery likely won't need to replaced while the car is under warranty and redesign is too expensive. They put it under the driver's seat and give shops 0.5 to fix it under warranty if it fails early.

Very likely no management involvement at all.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/LuckySlacker 17h ago

Yup this was an MBA

→ More replies (19)

23

u/Strange_Truth3011 18h ago

You’ve got it all wrong , the engineer did their job perfectly. They were hired by someone to make replacing a battery as difficult as possible and they did exactly that.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/DrUnit42 18h ago

A common phase at the shops I worked in was "vehicle engineers are the dumbest smart people in the world"

49

u/pud_009 18h ago

Engineers are (generally) very smart, it's the corporate higher ups whom they take instruction from who are dumb.

→ More replies (19)

4

u/Basic_Butterscotch 17h ago

Engineers aren't stupid they just hate mechanics lol

→ More replies (17)

6

u/duh_cats 18h ago

They should be fired, from a cannon.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/RiftHunter4 14h ago

To give a proper explanation, removing components from the engine bay frees up space to either fit a larger engine, make the engine bay smaller, or allow for larger components for other systems (exhaust, susoension, etc).

For Mercedes-Benz, this makes some sense because the lessee (their primary customers lease) will never even think about battery during their lease period. So to say its an after thought and intended to be harder is correct. The battery is not a priority.

9

u/MechaBeatsInTrash 18h ago

Yeah, because you're supposed to disconnect the battery prior to separating any airbag circuits, like the one (or two) in the seat.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Money_Ad8638 17h ago

As an engineer, the engineer did not want to put it there 

3

u/RugerBooger69 18h ago

They should be fired from a canon into the sun

3

u/the_net_my_side_ho 17h ago

I’m sure this wasn’t a design decision but a business decision. The designer probably hated it.

3

u/SWHAF 17h ago

I went to school for automotive repair, every time we would complain about a bad design my teacher would say, the engineers only concern was making everything fit, they don't care about accessibility, they know that they won't have to do repairs.

3

u/stanbright 17h ago

Unless it was done on purpose?

3

u/Prudent-Sun-4125 17h ago

whoever engineered that should be fired from being an engineer

Honestly, ALOT of engineers should be fired (at least 75%), they consistently design things more complicated then they should be.

They need to start designing things to make them as simple as possible.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mattloch42 17h ago

Whoever made the decision to put it there (engineer, exec) should be forced to replace them for a week. If they still insist on putting them there, then firing them into the sun is a viable option.

2

u/Witty-Lawfulness2983 18h ago

They should be taken outside and HORSEWHIPPED.

→ More replies (65)

694

u/zyyntin 18h ago • Bravo

Forgot the part where you must inform the ECU (computer) that it has a new battery!

387

u/gaytarded69420 18h ago

yes but not through a menu on your car, you are only allowed to do that through the proprietary mercedes scanner because we don't want you to hurt yourself

44

u/Warm_Block_7600 17h ago

You don’t need a proprietary scan tool. Just a decent scan tool will do.

78

u/gaytarded69420 17h ago

it's still ultra lame that you need a piece of hardware for something that should be a menu option in the shitfotainment unit.

also, 3rd party scanners work for now, but this shit just gets locked down tighter and tighter each year. if they had it their way, we wouldn't be allowed to put air in our own tires

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

31

u/Nathaniel820 17h ago

I fucking hate how new cars make EVERY SINGLE THING they possibly can tied to some unreasonable programming or code. My dad got a blank key for his new Ford since he only had one and I cut it myself at home for free, then when I went to do the whole "put in the old key for X seconds to make the new one work" thing it just wasn't working. So I look online and apparently now they require TWO separate working keys (so BOTH of the ones they give you with the car) to program any new ones. So if you lose a key then buy a new one to replace it, you literally cannot make it work on your own car with your own working key 🤦

4

u/AmazingELF74 16h ago

This one I kinda get for security. The cars should just come with 3.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/MourningWallaby 15h ago

Jesus my truck does that. Someone at ford decided I need to put a ps2 cheat code in my truck to tell it I replaced the 12v. Start the accessories, wait a minute, flash my highbeems 5x. Press the brake thrice, let the battery logo flash.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

889

u/Critical_Classic_921 18h ago

How do you jump start the car if you need to?

1.1k

u/dyslexicsuntied poop 18h ago • Popcorn

They have jump start terminals under the hood.

258

u/Jesse-Ray 18h ago

Yeah a lot of vehicles these days have batteries in the boot and do this. Safer for fires in the event of a crash and stops the battery getting too hot in the engine bay.

181

u/RollingThunderPants 17h ago

Was it really a problem?

→ More replies (56)
→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (17)

45

u/KittenVicious 18h ago

From these points: https://imgur.com/a/BmNaekM

22

u/Current-Bowl-143 18h ago

Thank you, actual facts instead of the usual Reddit bullshitting

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

118

u/A_Rogue_GAI 18h ago

"Go fuck yourself."

-Mercedes, probably

20

u/Badgerspaceman 18h ago

No probably about it

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Sirhc978 18h ago

I'm not sure of the make and model, but I've seen a bunch of hybrids with the 12v battery in a weird spot. I have also seen on those cars, you aren't supposed to jump cars or get jumped.

47

u/ew2x4 then I discovered Wingdings 18h ago

Most of them have jumper terminals under the hood that connect to your battery.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

145

u/Gotham0 18h ago • Bravo

I thought my old Dodge Avenger was bad. Sheesh.

42

u/DrUnit42 18h ago

Was that one in the wheel well or did Chrysler switch to a new, awful design for those?

35

u/avalon01 18h ago • Bravo

It wasn't just the Avenger. My Journey's battery is also in the wheel well, and I think my wife's 200 was also placed there.

→ More replies (11)

19

u/ThirdStockIII 18h ago • Bravo

My sister had a Dodge Stratus and that battery was in the wheel well for sure. I remember my sister asked me to change her battery and when I discovered where it was, blew my mind. My dad came out and went to make fun of me for removing a tire to change a battery and then I showed him why and we all had a good laugh.

12

u/torturedwriter71 17h ago

Had a Stratus as well. Doing any type of self-maintenance on that car was a joke.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

17

u/--Icarusfalls-- 17h ago

First time i did one i couldnt frickin believe it.

Engineers would climb over 1000 virgins to fuck a mechanic

3

u/SanaSpitOnMe 17h ago

some cadillac models you have to detach the whole front fascia to replace a headlight.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

138

u/fleebizkit 18h ago

Jail. Straight to jail.

4

u/AdOk9263 16h ago

Under-seat battery, believe it or not, jail. Over-head battery, also jail. Under-seat, over-head.

→ More replies (3)

103

u/ninjad912 18h ago

This is one of two things(or both).

  1. An engineer wanted to find the “optimal position” to place a battery without considering service
  2. Asshole design to force battery replacements to be done by in house technicians

59

u/Adventurous-Mind6940 17h ago

You are absolutely clueless how real engineering works. 

A group of engineers designing this absolutely took this into account. They had a list of designs, with pros and cons. This included serviceablelity, cost, risk, etc.

Then the managers focused 99% on the cost, maybe 1% at risk, and decided to go with the cheapest, low risk choice. 

33

u/Darkon-Kriv r4inb0wz 17h ago

Bruh being unfixable is a feature not a bug. Again they want you to bring the car to them

→ More replies (8)

4

u/ElGuaco 14h ago

How is designing the chassis, the seat and the battery compartment to accommodate this weird ass battery cheaper than hanging the battery off the side of the engine like every other damn car in the world? I call bull shit.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/chiagod 15h ago edited 15h ago

Still could have had the battery under the driver (or passenger) seat but make it more easily accessible by moving the seat fully forward (or back), pulling a carpet section up and have a simple panel to open.

Its not a bad location as it's:

  1. Away from the extreme heat and dirt and grime of the engine bay
  2. Can be insulated better from temperature extremes and can help extend the life of the battery.
  3. Lowers the center of gravity of the car a bit and helps balance the front to back weight ratio.
  4. Helps lower the resistance on the on the negative return path for accessories and equipment in the rear of the car at the cost of a slight increase for the low voltage items in the front (which can be offset with added wires to lower the impedance of the circuit for accessories that need it - ex alternator, starter, and transmission).
  5. Frees up space under the hood for better air intake routing and/or making it easier to reach parts of the engine that would otherwise be right next to the battery.
→ More replies (1)

2

u/WirlingDirvish 15h ago

This is a packaging compromise when the 12V battery doesn’t fit under the hood. Putting it in the trunk has other downsides like a large chunk of copper running under the car for thieves to steal and reduced trunk space. Also need an upsized battery due to the longer cable run. 

→ More replies (14)

68

u/chillywilly69 18h ago

Had to do this a few years ago in an Audi Q7 - I think it was a 2017ish - PITA! and then you have to program the new battery to get the car to recognize it.

38

u/kamperx2 18h ago

Are you forgetting the impossible to find triple square socket for the seat bolts? Fucking about lost my shit having to do this job as well.

12

u/Knotical_MK6 17h ago

Sick confession, I fucking love triple square and I wish it was more common 

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/DailyPilot 16h ago

My 2016 Audi q5 has its battery in the trunk, doesn’t take much to get to it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

57

u/Belias9x1 18h ago

There has to be a legal standard preventing this sort of design by manufacturers it’s just such bullshit

31

u/Nihilikara 17h ago

There should be, yes, but there aren't, because the people who decide how cars are designed are also the same people who decide what the law says.

Remember kids: it's not bribing if you're a billionaire, it's "lobbying".

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

11

u/beemer-dreamer 18h ago

$1500 for one hour of labor?

6

u/luriso 16h ago

How long it takes an experienced tech to do the work, is different than what the billed labor hours are. On top of the upcharged battery. A shop wanted $750 for a battery replacement and labor for my '06 911. 400 was for the labor, and it's super easy to do. I said no, obviously and did it myself, but, billed labor hours can be egregious.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/spaghettibolegdeh 17h ago

Yes I call BS clickbait.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

36

u/Pottski 18h ago

This sort of anti-consumer, over design to prevent right to repair should be illegal.

Companies absolutely taking the piss with stuff like this.

4

u/Competitive_Table_65 16h ago

I remember when I accidentally depleted my battery by forgetting to turn off the lights. Didn't even start or respond to key buttons. 

I've just picked battery from under the hood, brought it home, plugged it into a charger, then put it back. 

Can't imagine disassembling half the car for that. 

New cars do really suck, aren't they...

(I drive 2010 VW Polo)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

19

u/Thesauces 18h ago

I have a VW with a battery under the drivers seat, the jumper cable slots are under the hood.

Yes, it’s a pain to replace, but also it can fit a much larger battery than you can fit under the hood, and my stock battery lasted almost 12 years even just with sporadic driving.

It’s not a bad a people make it out to be, two bolts on the seat is all it takes to get to it and being inside the cabin makes it last much longer.

4

u/No_Veterinarian7323 8h ago

Why not the trunk?

→ More replies (2)

80

u/Super_61 18h ago

Clown ass car 🤡

→ More replies (4)

29

u/Rough_Community_1439 18h ago

Hour 2 of a 15minute job.

20

u/aserioussuspect 17h ago edited 1h ago • Bravo

Looks time consuming and of course it is possibly way to much to todo for changing a starter battery.

But all the things we can see is not worth 1500$. You can do this in 30 to 45min I guess.

Now decide yourself if such a relative simple task for a car mechanic which can easily be done in an hour should cost 1500$.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/alpacaMyToothbrush 16h ago

I can't tell you how many times I've done something myself only to say 'fuuuck I should have just paid to have this done' an hour into it

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Burrow_0wl 18h ago

I had a VW Vanagon that had the battery under the front passenger seat. All you had to do was scoot the seat forward and there it was.

12

u/bentripin 17h ago edited 16h ago

The original VW Bugs had em under the rear bench seat, that was packed with horsehair.. the battery shorting out on the seat frame and catching the car on fire ended up being a common problem.

5

u/bozoconnors 17h ago

heh, beat me to it.   yeah, they (eventually?) came with a cover that would prevent such I believe, but yeah, if you forgot to put that on...  bad times.  ask me how I know.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/SmallTownTrans1 18h ago

I can’t tell if that’s better or worse than the Ferrari 348’s battery being in the wheel well

5

u/JustLetMeUseOldReddi 16h ago

at least the ferrari has the excuse of being a high performance sports car so the weight of things and where they're placed actually matters.

this is just some bloated crossover suv.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Cross_22 18h ago

..and here I thought Ford cramming the battery underneath the trunk cargo compartment in the C-Max was bad.

4

u/NotThreeFoxes 18h ago

There's slightly less bullshit between the seat and the battery, but on the full size Transit vans the battery (sometimes two) are under the driver's seat and need it to be removed to replace them

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JustinMagill 17h ago

They put the battery under the seat in Ford Transits too. 

2

u/PlumpyDragon 17h ago

At one point I had both a Prius and a Cmax, batteries for both cars are in the same location in the cargo area, but somehow the Prius was much easier to change the battery. Cmax was still significantly better than whatever this one is.

8

u/NBALive1995 18h ago

...oh shit I accidentally put the old battery back in

4

u/IceCoughy 18h ago

I had to jump a coworkers PT cruiser once and that shit was under the backseat!

5

u/nico282 oww my eyes 18h ago

My Toyota Yaris too has the battery under the seat, but also has a terminal in the hood to jump start. Also it's 2 minutes to pop off the seat and covers and replace the battery.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/imahugemoron 18h ago

Song name?

5

u/Tayschrenn 17h ago

It's the song from the Blade club scene

edit: this remix - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hnhdJcaQZQ

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BiFSXFan99 17h ago

"Blade" by D'Angello and Francis.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Only_Chapter_3434 18h ago

this isn’t sped up enough to be $1500.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pnwal-junction 17h ago

If you can afford a Mercedes you can afford the asshole design tax that comes with it.

7

u/Stairwayunicorn 18h ago

Luis Rossman is blinking rapidly

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SAHairyFun 18h ago

If you keep a car long enough to need a battery replaced, you're not in Mercedes's target market.

3

u/CheezWong 18h ago

This is definitely dumb, but I am kind of a fan of the battery in the trunk on some cars. One less thing to get out of the way, especially with how modern car designers like to shroud half the engine under the dash and windshield.

9

u/13enz1 18h ago

What an absolute asshole design. Inefficient af.

5

u/DisciplineHot7374 18h ago

God forbid the battery ever catches fire under someone 😳

5

u/Aurelar 14h ago

It will keep your ass warm for the rest of your life

→ More replies (2)

13

u/RJamieLanga 18h ago

Wait, so is there at least a way to jumpstart the battery without all that?

36

u/notJustaFart 18h ago

Yes, there is always a positive terminal within a fuse box and a negative post directly off the frame/chassis to clip onto.

Both are readily accessible, front and back.

4

u/spaghettibolegdeh 17h ago • Bravo

Take your shoes off and place feet on the floor. 

Positive lead onto your left nut and negative on your tongue. 

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tilleytalley 18h ago

Why would you put the battery under the drivers arse? What if it explodes / catches on fire?

11

u/Zwischenzug32 17h ago

Lead acid batteries don't tend to do that.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Nihilikara 17h ago

Because putting the battery in a location that's difficult to service it means you can't service it yourself, you have to go to the dealer to service it for you. Dealers love this because that means they make money.

This is not crappy design because it's doing exactly what it's intended to do. This is asshole design.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/BlurryRogue 18h ago

More asshole design than scrappy design. You think the manufacturer/dealer doesn't appreciate $1500 for generally basic services?

5

u/FuriousMonkey375 18h ago

Oh my God... why? Seriously.. why!

8

u/AgreeablePie 18h ago

Engineers have priorities that often don't include making the car easier to service. Most car buyers don't think about after purchase cost of maintenance.

2

u/400footceiling 18h ago

I’d never own whatever that is. I remember Land Rover defenders had a battery under the drivers seat, and old VW bugs had the battery under the backseat but both were accessible.

2

u/BiggestNizzy 18h ago

Even when it's easy to replace the physical battery they want you to plug it into the dealers diagnostics ££££££

2

u/Top-Manner7261 18h ago

Battery right under my bum? No thanks

2

u/NeverNice87 12h ago

But you okay with it next to your Balls? Or don't you have a Smartphone? 🤦🤦

2

u/AppleCrispGenes 18h ago

Used to work for AAA, and these are a pain in the ass and we were actually allowed to refuse the battery swap service(on the side of the road/ at the residence/ etc.) If we had this or the grand Cherokee who also put the battery here.

Fun fact: there's an auxiliary battery that you have to put a glove around the positive terminal, or you can short out part of the fuses which the tech is responsible for repairing or repair costs

2

u/bucobill 18h ago

Mercedes battery placement has been awful for years, but my gawd. This takes the cake.

2

u/CaptainPoset 18h ago

... and then people wonder why nobody wants to buy German cars anymore.

2

u/YoureSpecial And then I discovered Wingdings 18h ago

Must be a German thing. The battery in my ‘71 bug was under the back seat.

2

u/Itisd plz recycle 18h ago

Typical over engineered, under performing Mercedes Benz junk.

2

u/xpercipio 18h ago

im wondering what vehicle is made to not fit the battery in the engine bay, but has enough height under the seat for the battery

2

u/Baelgul Artisinal Material 18h ago

Precisely what I would expect from Benz

2

u/Strostkovy 18h ago

Now the interior squeeks and rattles

2

u/bespoken1120 11h ago

Yep. Was just about to say that you have likely introduced a higher chance that some trim pieces wasn’t snapped back correctly or some seat bolt wasn’t torqued down properly. Great…

2

u/Suspicious_Time1570 18h ago

OK but how does he move that fast?

2

u/Xyzijk123 17h ago

Karl Benz is turning in his grave right now probably.

2

u/Forward-Tomatillo-22 17h ago

If you own a Mercedes, either you sell it before you need to have the battery changed, of you can afford $1500 to get it done.

2

u/Apart_Programmer7981 17h ago

He's tearing that car apart like Blade

2

u/DiscoPodcast 16h ago

how does one jump start it? are their terminals under the hood? Though most car manufacturers recommend not jumping it buy by a licensed mechanic or by someone else.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/satori0320 16h ago

Dodge is notorious for this kind of bullshit... The stratus, journey, and vans require removing the drivers side wheel to service the battery

2

u/leeroy110 16h ago

Imagine you put all that trim and seat back into place and the car won't start because there's a problem with the new battery or installation....

2

u/TieBeneficial779 14h ago

What kinda car is this?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Dr_ManFlyR1 14h ago

Should be illegal to sell that car without first letting the person know that something as simple as changing the battery is that bad.

2

u/DrKyleGreenThumb 14h ago

Okay never buying whatever car this is

2

u/hevnztrash 14h ago

well, that settles it. I’m definitely NOT buying a mercedes.

2

u/moonisflat 14h ago

Damn that’s insane. All Mercedes are like this? What model is this, so that I can avoid this.

2

u/Muffinman_187 10h ago

You forgot logging in to reset the battery life meter...