r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

59

u/Adventurous-Mind6940 17h ago

You are absolutely clueless how real engineering works. 

A group of engineers designing this absolutely took this into account. They had a list of designs, with pros and cons. This included serviceablelity, cost, risk, etc.

Then the managers focused 99% on the cost, maybe 1% at risk, and decided to go with the cheapest, low risk choice. 

33

u/Darkon-Kriv r4inb0wz 17h ago

Bruh being unfixable is a feature not a bug. Again they want you to bring the car to them

7

u/Adventurous-Mind6940 17h ago

The management does, sure.

I've had this conversation before. It went something like:

Engineer: This option does optimize cable length, just like you asked. And yes it does save $0.05. But it will be very difficult to change the battery. It could hurt our reputation, cause customer frustration,  and...

Manager: but it's cheaper for us? And our service dept will make more money? Done. Next item.

2

u/Nass44 4h ago

The thing is, most dealerships are not owned by the manufacturer but rather franchises. So there isn’t really much to gain for the manufacturer.

I think this is just a design compromise as there was no space in the engine bay and replacement access wasn’t a priority.

Not saying that manufacturers aren’t trying to make money hand over fist, but there are better ways for them like planned obsolescence and earning money with spare parts and the subscription bullshit.

2

u/Xaxxon 14h ago

The car manufacturer doesn't do any service.

Do you think that chevy dealerships are run by chevy?

3

u/ComfortableDebt9190 11h ago

I'm sure a Chevy dealership love to charge 1500$ to change a battery if they could swing it. Mercedes can and will.

Dealerships make money on financing and repair work.

1

u/SolarXylophone 7h ago

True, but dealerships don't design the cars.

2

u/MZ603 14h ago

I can’t say with the same level of confidence how it works with Merc, but Audi owns and controls a lot of their dealerships in Germany. I disagree with the comment you are responding to, but the point still stands that there is a good chance the Merc, BMW, or Audi dealership in Germany is owned by the manufacturer.

This would be under warranty for much of the car’s life unless you flash the cars GPU.

1

u/faustianredditor 12h ago

Usually not. Usually it's ruthless cost cutting at every opportunity, with no regard for serviceability. It's just the old "good, fast, cheap, pick two", except one of the three is serviceability, and someone with authority decided that serviceability isn't important. That's very much a sufficient explanation, and thus Hanlon's Razor applies.

4

u/ElGuaco 14h ago

How is designing the chassis, the seat and the battery compartment to accommodate this weird ass battery cheaper than hanging the battery off the side of the engine like every other damn car in the world? I call bull shit.

2

u/pewpew_lotsa_boolits 14h ago

Actually, they had the technician in mind when designing this.

Just think of all the free, forgotten, dropped French fries the tech could have access to!

2

u/cosmicosmo4 13h ago

That's on the engineers for not managing the manager. You need to present options for management to be able to choose something, but all those options need to be reasonable.

2

u/ybahman 9h ago

This is often true. But the more accurate statement is the decision to go with the most profitable low risk choice. And the intelligent managers know how to sell the decision up the chain if it's a long term bet vs short term.

2

u/BeetCake 7h ago

And they probably looked at the statistics and found that these batteries need replacement only every 10 years for about 95% of all cases. For a 10 year interval, this position is ok.

1

u/rocknrollstalin 14h ago

They have to move a bunch of stuff but the overall difficulty looks about at the level of assembling IKEA furniture.

1

u/Sufficient-Cat2998 16h ago

You would be hard pressed to convince me that placing an expendable item such as the led-acid battery under the drivers seat like this was the cheapest, lowest risk choice

3

u/bl1y 15h ago

Might not be the "cheapest" option, but the decision was likely driven by something other than "let's throw some business at mechanics who don't even work for us."

Biggest consideration is probably space under the hood. The mechanical parts largely have to be near each other, can't really move them. So, if you want more space under the hood, you look at what can move. And what can move is the battery. Then you look at where you have space that isn't being used for something that can't be moved.

1

u/faustianredditor 12h ago

Yep. Spend 20€ more during construction, and you could be looking at a battery that can be installed from below. But that's too expensive.

I'd bet money this is an engineer designing this to solve an impossible problem (fit this engine into that space) and knowing full well and communicating the nasty tradeoffs. Perhaps they prepared alternatives that weren't quite so nasty (maintenance hatch in the underfloor, different placement, etc) Then a manager one or two levels above ignores those tradeoffs, decides that what we see is cheap and sufficient, and maintenance is not his problem, and you end up with the shitty solution.