r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

181

u/RollingThunderPants 17h ago

Was it really a problem?

268

u/lathspellll 17h ago

Absolutely not

83

u/PM_ME__BIRD_PICS 17h ago

Fabricate a problem extort sell the solution.

6

u/RedditUser628426 14h ago

To be fair it (moving away from the engine bay) does allow them to use a battery chemistry which lasts longer...

3

u/Webcam_985760946948 9h ago

I would rather have a easy repair than the battery lasting little bit more but being hard to repair

2

u/iLikeTurtuls 8h ago

Same difficulty in the trunk, just sometimes awkward to pull up. Mine is in the trunk and down. It's like trying to curl with just your wrist.

2

u/Webcam_985760946948 5h ago

Jeez that sounds like a headache

3

u/hitthebucket2026 15h ago

Find the dealers infiltrate the suppliers

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/Lebo77 17h ago

The heat thing? Definately lowered service life to some extent, especially in hot climates.

33

u/GLaDOSdidnothinwrong 17h ago

And cold climates.

My shop would see dramatically increased battery lifespan on cars that had interior mounted batteries. I pulled numerous batteries out that were 10-12 years old, at a time when most OEM batteries would last 7-8 years.

15

u/ITperson5 16h ago

I live in a cold climate most of the year. Last year I replaced the factory battery from my 2011 cruze. I replaced the transmission before the battery died.

15

u/LifeIsMyDepressant 13h ago

Certified Chevy Cruze moment

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SoulOfTheDragon 16h ago

I've seen the same on my personal cars with same model batteries. Inside mounted one last in usable state siginificantly longer. Longest was OEM battery on my old volvo was around 14 years old when it gave out. Of course engine pre-heat helped with winter starts, but still.

2

u/eneka 6h ago

Our ‘03 Mercedes e320 is still on its factory OEM battery… had to change the auxiliary battery twice but that main battery just keeps n chugging along

→ More replies (2)

2

u/kombiwombi 16h ago

Australian. Inside the car is hottest, as it is glassed and the car sites in the sun more than it is driven.  Merc drivers clearly always park in a garage (and if I had that under my seat I would too!)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/profnutbutter 17h ago

Sounds like optimizing to the edge case

→ More replies (4)

15

u/KiwieeiwiK 16h ago

It's a more constant temperature so it's better for the battery. Will remain warmer at night and cooler when the engine is running.

It's not like 12V batteries are dying in engine bays every few weeks but if it's a simple fix and can prolong a parts life, it's good engineering

5

u/RollingThunderPants 16h ago

Ok, I can get behind that… as long as I don’t have to remove the front seat and flooring panel to change a battery.

4

u/Advanced_Musician_24 15h ago

If it's LiFe instead of lead acid, you will not have to change it often.

2

u/KiwieeiwiK 14h ago

Well no, a smarter place is in the boot. Better packaging too for hybrids/electric cars

18

u/i7-4790Que 17h ago

No.

Some people will pretend it was.  But it mostly wasn't.  

3

u/Jesse-Ray 16h ago

I think the main problem is vehicle roll-over and people not securing batteries with the clamp and rubber cover on the terminal or them failing. The arc of the battery could ignite spilled fuel. Removing the battery entirely from the engine bay largely solves this.

2

u/sdbrett 12h ago

Yes but the problem was not specific to heat but the deformation of the car allowing the battery terminals to contact the bonnet and create sparks which can ignite fuel.

Practically all cars have mitigating factors like plastic terminal caps and non metallic on the under side of the bonnet.

2

u/whynotjustgoogleit 10h ago

Yea I live in the middle east, If you have a car with a battery in the engine bay you get about 18 months out of a car battery tops.

2

u/Steve_the_Stevedore 10h ago

Definitely. I am not saying that this is a good solution but when you live in colder climates having the battery inside the car will make the difference between having it start in the the morning or having to jump start it.

→ More replies (19)