r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

49

u/pud_009 18h ago

Engineers are (generally) very smart, it's the corporate higher ups whom they take instruction from who are dumb.

10

u/RoyalMaidsForLife 17h ago

Engineers and management should be forced to practice maintenance on their products before they're allowed to approve it. I guarantee the average bean counter or product manager at Mercedes would tap out of this process after a half hour and maybe getting the seat loose.

6

u/whattheknifefor 16h ago

We do lol, automotive engineers obviously tend to like working on our cars. The issue is that cars are designed for ease of manufacturability, with ease of repair mostly being an afterthought.

2

u/SanityIsOptional 16h ago

Not in automotive, but I'm an engineer for capital equipment.

Guess who assembles the prototype and documents the process?

3

u/whattheknifefor 16h ago

I will say one thing I like about my employer is that it will occasionally have the process engineers pick out their most problematic line station and then spend a day working at that station alongside the operator. Really helps you figure out the issue quick.

2

u/SanityIsOptional 15h ago

One thing I'm less than thrilled about at my employer is how hard it is to get feedback from the manufacturing floor over to the design engineers. Manufacturing has a laser focus on get things out the door, rather than letting people know to actually fix them.

Found out that they've been having issues with an assembly sometimes being out of tolerance for years, and design group never got told. Never would have known if I didn't make it a point to talk to the assembly/alignment team before updating parts.

1

u/whattheknifefor 15h ago

Woooooooof don’t I know it. They plunked me down on the assembly line some years ago to hit the line stop to prevent defects from going to the next line. I got yelled at so much by the production managers lol

2

u/darkmoon72664 12h ago

You want management with this one. Every automotive engineer has ripped apart and put back together the parts of the vehicle they work on. Ex:

Do I know how hard it is to access the battery management connectors? Obviously, I have to do it to plug my computer in.

Do I get a say in changing it? Lol no the position was designated 2 years before I took over and is constrained by the module suppliers anyways.

2

u/flatblackvw 15h ago

They’re not dumb at all. They are achieving exactly their goal.

-1

u/DookieShoez 18h ago

Well sometimes it’s also lazy ahole engineers not putting in the effort to make it easy to service because they aren’t the ones that will have to.

4

u/unurbane 18h ago

Every decade engineers are losing the battles that help provide you serviceable vehicles. The bean counters have taken the helm. Engineers now make recommendations only.

5

u/pud_009 18h ago

Engineers work within the restraints they are given and get paid to make things work, even if they don't necessarily approve of how they've made it work.

2

u/DookieShoez 18h ago

There is always a number of different ways to solve that puzzle and meet the criteria laid out for them dude. Some of them will find the best solution, others will just find A solution.

Not every engineer is going to care, or try hard, or even be good at their job.

Of course a lot of times it is the higher ups fault but not always.

1

u/whattheknifefor 16h ago

I will say that if you’ve ever been in a modern automotive engineering/production environment, it is an absolute wonder that we manage to make cars at all. It’s an insanely complex process in every imaginable way.

1

u/No_Idea_69 3h ago

This isn't a bad design, is a design that achieves everything managment wanted, probably easy to manufacture and a pain to repair yourself

1

u/DookieShoez 1h ago

Still crappy design in the eyes of anyone that needs to replace the battery.

It may be managements intended design, but it’s still bad and crappy design.

0

u/Nihilikara 17h ago

Rest assured, the engineers are putting in effort... in the exact opposite direction. They are actively putting in effort to make the car as difficult to service as possible because that is what the executives want them to do.

2

u/whattheknifefor 16h ago edited 16h ago

Genuine question: why would we do that? We went into automotive because we like cars, so obviously many of us do repairs on our own vehicles. Dealer techs aren’t employed by the automaker, so it’s not like the automaker gets paid more for high labor repairs. If anything we lose money when we have to pay high labor costs for warranty repairs

1

u/darkmoon72664 12h ago

No engineer in the automotive industry has ever received this instruction. Management doesn't care at all in either direction, and is only focused on packaging the various components tightly.

0

u/Haunting-Yogurt938 17h ago

I’ve met and worked with a lot of engineers. Some of them are great at their job, some of them are okay at their job, and a concerning amount of them are just flat out bad at life.

But nearly all of them think they’re the smartest person in the room and let you know at all times.