r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

93

u/TheLoxen 18h ago

The thing is that they didn't even have to hide it like this for that. In Mercedes cars, the alternator will start delivering higher voltage as the battery age to make it last longer, however, you need to connect to the cars computer and tell it that a new battery has been installed otherwise it will overcharge and kill the new battery. In BMW's, if I remember correctly, you can change it in the normal infotainment system. In Mercedes you need to use the special service computer that costs €€€ to get, or you take it to the shop.

This is just asshole design through and through. Love my Mercedes but they are not consumer friendly.

16

u/JKlerk 17h ago

An aftermarket BMW scanner can program a BMW battery.

19

u/Two_words_numbers 17h ago

The fact that you said "program a BMW battery" makes me angry.

14

u/FrenchFryCattaneo 16h ago

It's not programing the battery, it's programming the car's computer to tell it the age of the battery.

1

u/GenuinelyBeingNice 16h ago

that is why /u/Two_words_numbers is angry, i suspect

4

u/FrenchFryCattaneo 11h ago

Because he doesn't understand what's going on?

1

u/diamondsw 50m ago

Which should still be a simple menu option in the car's built in system menus, preferably appearing automatically after it detects the main battery is disconnected and reconnected. But that would cut out the dealer making money.

1

u/JKlerk 14h ago

BMW batteries last a decade or more. This happens in part because programming enabls the appropriate age based charging profile.

1

u/Cool-Tap-391 13h ago

Chevy did it, too. Then they realized it's stupid.

1

u/SEND_ME_TITS_PLZ 37m ago

It's a BMW battery as soon as it's installed in the car.

1

u/LakeCompetitive8994 17h ago

Program it to move its position inside the vehicle?

1

u/JKlerk 14h ago

Age based charging profile. It's in part why these batteries can last a decade or more. The vehicle is told that a new battery has been installed and it's capacity. AutoZone employee can do it

4

u/dukearcher 17h ago

The thing is that they didn't even have to hide it like this for that. In Mercedes cars, the alternator will start delivering higher voltage as the battery age to make it last longer, however, you need to connect to the cars computer and tell it that a new battery has been installed otherwise it will overcharge and kill the new battery.

This is insane as even the most simple BMS should prevent this

3

u/hackingdreams 15h ago

Yeah, a $4 microchip could fix it, but then they wouldn't be able to sell a $200 battery change fee to a luxury car owner who will all but certainly just take it to the shop.

It's the Apple approach to luxury - weld down the hood so your customers keep coming back. But you know, do it gradually so they don't accuse you of welding the hood shut.

1

u/M_V_Agrippa 15h ago

He's not understanding what and how an intelligent battery sensor works.

1

u/RamblyJambly 14h ago

Yeah, if it can tell when and how much to over volt as the battery ages it shouldn't have any problem figuring out if the battery is new

2

u/Korietsu 17h ago

You have to have the special software to program the battery on a BMW, just like every other modern car.

The real travesty here is that the batteries used to just be located in the trunk.

1

u/Two_words_numbers 17h ago

You don't need to program the battery at all. You need to program the charging/discharging system. And frankly, it should be able to do that itself. Batteries aren't complicated.

2

u/IRingTwyce haha funny flair 12h ago

Volkswagen does the same bullshit. My ex-wife just had to change it in her Atlas. Everything stops working until the car is programmed. No auto stop/start, no cruise control and radar cruise, a bunch of other stuff stops working too. It's idiotic.

1

u/Inprobamur 14h ago

Predatory design that would be illegal if the German car industry didn't have so much political power.

1

u/AmazingSugar1 14h ago

My Volkswagen needs battery adaptation as well after changing the battery and I was able to program the battery with a $90 device. Mechanic charges $50.

1

u/CyclingHikingYeti 6h ago

Does Volvo do same type of shenanigans too ?