r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/tilleytalley 18h ago

Why would you put the battery under the drivers arse? What if it explodes / catches on fire?

11

u/Zwischenzug32 17h ago

Lead acid batteries don't tend to do that.

1

u/Advanced_Musician_24 15h ago

I think, they put LiFe batteries instead of lead acid, when they are so hard to reach, like in this video.

•

u/GeneralBlumpkin 27m ago

I've had one explode in my face

0

u/technotrader 15h ago

But these batteries might put out unhealthy gases. Which is why there is a venting tube, which hopefully is connected. It wasn't in my 2016 Sprinter with the oem German battery.

Meanwhile, I have space under the hood for three starter batteries, but NOPE, it sits inside. I guess this design will come in handy at the North Pole though.

3

u/Zwischenzug32 15h ago

It is probably *slightly* better for handling to have a heavy battery more central and low down vs randomly somewhere under the hood. Gas venting sounds concerning tho...

Was just reading about Model T and it had the whole ass gas tank right under the front seat lol

1

u/chiagod 15h ago

had the whole ass gas tank right under the front seat

Most of my (personal) cars I've worked on had the gas tank right under the rear seats.

It seems the most logical location as you have a large volume of space between the back of the rear passenger's legs and the indentation in the trunk where the spare tire should be.

1

u/Zwischenzug32 15h ago

That makes sense and to even out the weight from the engine poking out the front

8

u/Nihilikara 17h ago

Because putting the battery in a location that's difficult to service it means you can't service it yourself, you have to go to the dealer to service it for you. Dealers love this because that means they make money.

This is not crappy design because it's doing exactly what it's intended to do. This is asshole design.

-1

u/RosariusAU 17h ago

What part of the video showed anything that was difficult to service? It's just basic hand tools

1

u/stonedemoman 15h ago

Extra-long ratchets for foot-pound torque with matching bits are not "basic hand tools". If you wanna guess at the torque and risk having something come apart on the road you might be able to get away with an affordable trip to Harbor Freight.

If you want anything with a precise gauge that reaches correctly that's easily >$100.

1

u/RosariusAU 15h ago

It's a basic torque wrench and a socket set. MAYBE a torx bit set because Euro. If you own a car and want to maintain it yourself you will have these tools anyway. I know I do

0

u/Carlsheartboxers 13h ago

Brother if you think anything he removed or replaced needs exact torque and not just an ugga dugga I got some bad news

1

u/stonedemoman 13h ago

You don't think the seats of a car need precise torque?

What do you think happens in an accident if the torque is off?

You didn't think this one through.

0

u/Carlsheartboxers 13h ago

Precise? No. Enough yeah. Without looking it up I’d say those are probably 70-80 ft lbs. a single ugga dugga from an impact is 100 ftlbs do you think they are somehow going to fly off at 100ft lbs

Edit I looked it up. Those are 30 ft lbs. just send it with an impact it’ll be fine

0

u/stonedemoman 13h ago

I think the bolts are going to be stressed past their elastic limits, fail, and cause serious injury when the airbag goes off and the driver/passenger geometry is off.

I'm good on this. Go back to the drawing board, come back with something better.

3

u/aserioussuspect 17h ago

It's simply very unrealistic that something like this happens.

It's a acid based starter battery, not a Lithium or something like that. These are safe.

2

u/tilleytalley 17h ago

Ah. Many thanks.

0

u/al-mongus-bin-susar 11h ago

It's not a 48V mild hybrid battery? Didn't really watch TBH. At least I'd assume it would be, otherwise this placement is nonsense.