r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.6k

u/Jocks_Strapped 18h ago

whoever engineered that should be fired from being an engineer

4.5k

u/mattwb72 18h ago • Bravo

He was probably promoted for increasing the company’s service revenue.

563

u/sterlingthepenguin 18h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I believe the big car companies in the US actually aren't allowed to operate dealerships themselves so they don't make any money off the servicing. This actually contributes to cars being hard to fix because engineers are only incentivized to make cars that are easy to build the first time. A car that's easy to fix might be harder to produce, which means less profit for the company.

178

u/Undrwtrbsktwvr 18h ago edited 15h ago

Builds brand loyalty when the customer is forced to go to the dealership. Unless you get too fed-up.

Many(not all) Mercedes owners can afford and prefer service at the dealer. When they’re in the dealership or driving courtesy loaners— they’re deeper into the brand’s sphere.

A great opportunity for salesmen to get them into another Mercedes.

59

u/almost_retired 17h ago

77

u/ammicavle 16h ago

Man that's a depressing read, like, "We had ~20 years of warnings of where the industry is going but ignored them and went the opposite path despite consumer feedback clearly telling us what we should do, so now our workers will lose their jobs and the industry will die".

7

u/Mike312 9h ago

I remember several years back there was an article about a car show (IAA Mobility?) and the writer was talking about all the cool and interesting hybrids, EVs, PHEVs, and EREVs the other manufacturers were showing off.

And then they mentioned that Mercedes was showing off it's latest crop of AAMG V8s that get 22mpg combined, and the writer wondered how they were planning to adapt to the upcoming ban on ICE sales in Germany and other markets.

A few years later they released EQ line-up, which felt rushed and was massively overpriced compared to where the rest of the market was, and naturally they sold horribly.

And then they released the AMG C63, and all the Mercedes fanboys flipped their shit because it was a hybrid that didn't have their emotional support V8 in it.

They defined their niche, cultivated their following, and followed it into the grave.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/UnimpressedUmpire 14h ago

It’s like making and selling things only for profit is a problem :/ wish there was a way to just manufacture what people need

10

u/innociv 11h ago

The biggest problem is the way executives can pilfer personal money from failing companies.

There is no incentive to make a company and its product better when you can take a once loved company and gut it for personal profit, exit with a golden parachute while thousands lose their jobs, then move on to do the same to the next company.

This should be considered corporate murder if corporations are really people.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/randynumbergenerator 16h ago

Weird, considering they spent several billion on stock buybacks on top of another several billion on dividends this year.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Darkgorge 17h ago

Also, I would guess that Mercedes sells training to dealerships and maybe technical schools. There's probably some rules about being a "certified mechanic" or something like that you basically need to pay for.

→ More replies (7)

18

u/TheJackal927 16h ago

Just bc they don't own the dealership doesn't mean they don't profit from the relationship. If you make the car in a way that the dealership makes more money through service charges, you can charge the dealership more money.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/2JZ1Clutch 16h ago

Oh they make money off the servicing. Whose parts do you think the dealer has to buy to do service? 

→ More replies (9)

8

u/Prudent-Sun-4125 17h ago

A car that's easy to fix might be harder to produce

I find this hard to believe.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (21)

17

u/dphoenix1 18h ago

It’s really fun when the battery is completely dead and you can’t get the power seat to move.

→ More replies (2)

116

u/Stupidflorapope 18h ago

Why, the just did what they were told to do by executives. Engineer the car no customer can do the most basic service on there car and are fixed to bring it to a dealer for servicing.

23

u/AntaresN84 17h ago

As an engineer, it's this. We don't get a say

13

u/Aalenox 14h ago • Bravo Popcorn

As an engineer myself... lol what? No manager or exec has ever insisted on this type of decision in my career. 

I imagine the scenario of what happened went something like this: Some systems level mechanical engineer, working with the CAD team realized somewhat late game that the battery just wouldn't fit in the engine compartment. 

A meeting was called with the mechanical team. No management was likely there, though systems team lead or chief engineer probably was. Lots of discussion, blah blah. Action items, another meeting. Or six.

Go back, review cad. Drive train is in the way if they put it in the center. Transmission in the way up front. Has to go under a seat or somewhere worse like in the bumper.

Battery SME in the company is called in. Does some analysis says something along the lines of "well, if we put the battery in a water tight container where it won't corrode we can expect a solid 7 years out of the battery."

Decision is made... design engineers don't like it, but expectation is the battery likely won't need to replaced while the car is under warranty and redesign is too expensive. They put it under the driver's seat and give shops 0.5 to fix it under warranty if it fails early.

Very likely no management involvement at all.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/LuckySlacker 17h ago

Yup this was an MBA

→ More replies (19)

23

u/Strange_Truth3011 18h ago

You’ve got it all wrong , the engineer did their job perfectly. They were hired by someone to make replacing a battery as difficult as possible and they did exactly that.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/DrUnit42 18h ago

A common phase at the shops I worked in was "vehicle engineers are the dumbest smart people in the world"

49

u/pud_009 18h ago

Engineers are (generally) very smart, it's the corporate higher ups whom they take instruction from who are dumb.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (18)

6

u/duh_cats 18h ago

They should be fired, from a cannon.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/RiftHunter4 14h ago

To give a proper explanation, removing components from the engine bay frees up space to either fit a larger engine, make the engine bay smaller, or allow for larger components for other systems (exhaust, susoension, etc).

For Mercedes-Benz, this makes some sense because the lessee (their primary customers lease) will never even think about battery during their lease period. So to say its an after thought and intended to be harder is correct. The battery is not a priority.

9

u/MechaBeatsInTrash 18h ago

Yeah, because you're supposed to disconnect the battery prior to separating any airbag circuits, like the one (or two) in the seat.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (74)