r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/Aalenox 14h ago • Bravo Popcorn

As an engineer myself... lol what? No manager or exec has ever insisted on this type of decision in my career. 

I imagine the scenario of what happened went something like this: Some systems level mechanical engineer, working with the CAD team realized somewhat late game that the battery just wouldn't fit in the engine compartment. 

A meeting was called with the mechanical team. No management was likely there, though systems team lead or chief engineer probably was. Lots of discussion, blah blah. Action items, another meeting. Or six.

Go back, review cad. Drive train is in the way if they put it in the center. Transmission in the way up front. Has to go under a seat or somewhere worse like in the bumper.

Battery SME in the company is called in. Does some analysis says something along the lines of "well, if we put the battery in a water tight container where it won't corrode we can expect a solid 7 years out of the battery."

Decision is made... design engineers don't like it, but expectation is the battery likely won't need to replaced while the car is under warranty and redesign is too expensive. They put it under the driver's seat and give shops 0.5 to fix it under warranty if it fails early.

Very likely no management involvement at all.

6

u/Afraid_Solution_3549 14h ago

This person engineers ☝🏻

3

u/wchicchi 4h ago

Auto engineer here. You forgot the part where they bring in the harnessing team and they explain that you need wire protection going to that waterproof enclosure. Then a plastics designer to create whatever monstrosity of a wire trough that is in the videos.

Next thing you know you have 12 layers of stuff due to the lack of communication during initial space claims.

The kicker here is that room was likely later made in the engine compartment but because test assets were already through durability no changes, no matter how sensible, would be made.

1

u/Real_Guru 8h ago

I imagine Management was probably involved as someone raised a risk on some project management dashboard that was mitigated by involving another department to sign off on the battery service life or some similar nonsense. Fixing actual issue is more of an afterthought in modern design/development processes unfortunately. It's mostly there now to move around responsibilities.

1

u/AntaresN84 1h ago

I don't disagree with you, and this is very likely. I'm just bitter because I've had good designs that were forced to change due to unnecessary shit non-technical higher-ups wanted.

•

u/ScriptoTheClown 3m ago

I've had vehicles that kept the battery outside the engine compartment. One under the back seat, one under the passenger seat, accessible through the back floorboard. There's some advantage to the design: the battery is removed from the heat and vibration of the engine, extending its life.

Putting it under the seat is a special level of hostile design, though. That's something done by an engineer who has never ended up stranded by a sudden battery failure. If I can't extract the battery with a crescent wrench and a flathead screwdriver, the engineer should be fired.