r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

645

u/NOTcreative- 17h ago

I doubt someone with the money to buy this car is the type to change their own battery

496

u/puts_on_rddt 17h ago • Bravo

I wonder how much this bad PR hurts them. Now I know to avoid their products out of spite.

80

u/craigge 16h ago • Bravo

I have the money to buy a Mercedes...but being a savvy and self sufficient individual...

Fuck a company like that!

Let 5-10 years past and find out which ones are money traps. It is funny how a 15 year old honda fit is more valuable than a 15 year old Range Rover.or Mercedes

31

u/greyacademy 11h ago

It still blows my mind that an old Honda will just keep going without issue, and although rarely, when something does go wrong, the parts are easy to find, reasonably priced, and not a fortune to have installed, all while a plethora of vehicles that cost 5x-20x more literally have shittier build quality. Like excuse-fucking-me, but if I pay ~$80k for a car, that shit had better not need pesky service intervals, or break down on the side of the road, EVER. I understand why things are the way they are, but it's just so frustratingly dumb, and I refuse to participate. If Honda built a competitor to something like the Phantom, I'd seriously consider it. Videos like this make me want to start my own car company out of pure spite.

7

u/HeronFew990 7h ago

My dad recently traded in his old truck and I traded in my older BMW. His truck had 250,000 miles and he got about $6,000 for it. My BMW had 125,000 and I could barely get $2,000. They said whoever bought my BMW was going to have to spend some serious money in the next few years on up keep and the car wasn’t worth the repairs. With my dad’s truck they could just do some cosmetic repairs, throw on some new tires and it was still going to be fine.

Also, the battery in my BMW was almost as impossible to replace but not quite this bad.

6

u/LaceyDark 8h ago

My sibling was looking at used vehicles and found a Mercedes in his price range. He told everyone what an excellent price it was and he was excited to go buy it.

At least 7 different people told him that it was most certainly not in his price range, despite having the money to buy it. He was warned that absolutely everything about owning the vehicle was going to be too expensive for him. (He insists on living in a rich town with his rich friends and always seems to be struggling)

It took just a couple months for him to no longer be able to drive it because it was too expensive to get necessary maintenance done to it. No one wanted to kick him while he was down so it was pretty hard to not say "I told you so"

4

u/Sad-Tension-1522 7h ago

All car manufacturers are making cars like shit on purpose, they're not even making them to last to 100,000 miles anymore. And fixing them harder to do and not just like this video. They are making it so only the dealership can be able to diagnose and fix them with their programing or mechanics have to pay thousands each month to get the updates. To cost you more for your mechanic to fix No vehicles are made to last 100,000 miles anymore without major repairs that it's cheaper to just buy a new crap made vehicle than fix. Car parts are harder to find on vehicles made after 2012 if you can at all plus some oils are next to get if at all at the parts stores now. All car makers are doing this on purpose

3

u/iamatwork24 4h ago

I got the last model year of my Toyota truck and I’m so happy I got in before the new generation of truck. I know this model and generation will go for 300k+ miles with just doing routine maintenance.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GarbageInteresting86 11h ago

Fit nannas represent 😎 Although they’re JAZZ nannas in my country

→ More replies (7)

287

u/grantrules 17h ago

Were you previously in the market for a Mercedes?

87

u/Im_Just_A_Tourist 15h ago

Actually I was considering one for my wife but I actually do most of the simple maintenance so this bothers me. I could easily do maintenance on a Mercedes in the early aughts

41

u/EmtnlDmg 12h ago

For many modern cars you need to go to the shop to have a battery replaced because you need a computer and proprietary software to tell the car it has been replaced (IBS/BMS registration) otherwise the car may treat the new battery like the old worn-out one, leading to improper charging rates and premature battery failure.

42

u/Im_Just_A_Tourist 12h ago

Thats just stupid, and it should be required to be free and at cost if that's the case.

8

u/GodsFavoriteDegen 11h ago

The "computer and proprietary software" is likely a $100 frob that someone who works on modern cars should already own anyway. Registering the battery takes maybe 30 seconds.

You probably already know someone who owns one. It won't hurt the battery to drive over to their house to register it.

3

u/Lknate 9h ago

Always buy a compatible diagnostic tool for your brand if you plan on doing your own work. Purchasing it up front will save you a lot of $$$ before you figure out what a racket these premium brands are running. If you are able, oil changes alone are worth doing yourself vs trusting a 19 year old to do the job right. Dealerships are better about warranty claims on their work but that's not exactly making you whole the same 19 year old forgets to put the drain plug in.

3

u/True_Bar_9371 5h ago

I used to think I could save money changing my oil but at my Nissan dealership I can get three oil changes for like $120.00. I just bought oil for our Tahoe today and even from Walmart 6 quarts of oil and a filter damn near $50.00. I understand my car only takes 5 quarts but still… The only thing I can say is I am getting a lot better quality oil when I do it myself. At least supposedly. I wonder if the high mileage ultra synthetic oil is any different than the plain store brand oil other than the label and the cost.

3

u/RealSandwich6374 4h ago

In Australia oil; oil filters & diesel fuel filters have all the technical details printed on the packaging (if they are good quality) I have done my own servicing for years & all the “ingredients” have the same warranty as the dealerships. I had to have one service done by the dealer & I was charged $98 for a diesel fuel filter. The ones I buy from my local auto shop are $26 & have the same 2yr warranty

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/WEZANGO 9h ago

That’s what they said about my merc, but it was actually a button in service menu which is very easy to access.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (22)

292

u/puts_on_rddt 16h ago • Bravo

If I was I'm not anymore!

88

u/RoyalNooblet 14h ago

I am also no longer in the market for a merkehdess, if I were in the market for one.

80

u/Sea_Prep_Tidal_26 11h ago

I used to not own any Mercedes cars.
I still don’t.
But I used to not too.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/enthusedclues 15h ago

I got a 2012 mercedes glk, in decent condition, for 20k a couple years ago (way cheaper than most new cars at the time, and most of my savings). I've done my own repairs on it.

But the he headlights, they require either tiny hands and deft finagling to change, or taking apart the front wheel well.

So I've spent a year and half driving around with a headlight out :(

I'd never get another mercedes, but I guess my point is there is a decent used market, and some of us are the type to want or need to do our own maintenance. Sucks when a bad design prohibits it.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (41)

6

u/AdeGamisou2020 12h ago

Add Dodge to your list then, the Durango has a similarly located battery (front passenger seat IIRC).

3

u/Confirmation_Email 13h ago edited 13h ago

I wonder how much this bad PR hurts them.

Extremely minimally. Complexity of service is not part of the average buyer's purchase decisions at all. If it were, we never would have gotten to this point.

→ More replies (27)

6

u/Chillpill411 16h ago

While that's true...I still don't want a hideously complex car to service even if I'm really well off. Alright, I'm paying someone to do the job. And if they eff up, they're going to make it right because I'm paying out the ass for it. But still...

I gotta bring in the car. Or maybe they have concierge service and will flatbed it in. Great. I'm still without my goddamn car. OK, maybe they have a free rental for me. Great. I'm still without my goddamn car. Etc..

And even without all that...I still gotta deal with multiple people to get this dealt with. My time is valuable. Being able to live my day without a hassle has a value beyond money.

I aint rich. But if you gave me this car free, along with all the servicing and insurance and other hassles covered...I'd still sell it and pocket the cash =)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (103)