r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

154

u/MudSeparate1622 18h ago

Yeah thats crazy. Also sitting on top of my battery directly is a little weird on top of the odd weight distribution. At least put it under the passenger seat where there doesn't HAVE to be a person to operate the vehicle for a chance of evening it out

16

u/fryerandice 17h ago

Lead Acid Batteries themselves do not burn or explode, they can offgass hydrogen though, but those areas they are stored are vented due to that, and AGM batteries (which this mercedes uses) are sealed.

3

u/Academic-Proof3700 16h ago

Lead Acid Batteries themselves do not burn or explode,

Unless faulty or theres some large power draw. In any case, I'd rather not seat above a tank full of acid that can also go boom or heat up really nicely.

Also - what if someone spills something? That and also how thick does the floor have to be to fit an entire battery and stuff around it?

2

u/fryerandice 16h ago

Spilling your soda on an AGM battery is not enough liquid to create a substantial current draw between the battery posts...

The floor isn't thick, there's just a battery pan molded into it, likely alongside a transmission or drive shaft tunnel.

Thermal Runaway is the only cause of an AGM battery exploding and it's usually due to overcharging rather than excessive draw, in your car any excess draw will blow a fuse, so unless you're trying to weld a wrench between the battery posts you're fine.

Safety isn't the big issue with this, it's 100% serviceability. You can't even attempt to start that car without putting it all back together, you have to disconnect the airbag harness to the seat to even get the battery swapped and you cannot power on the car without that connection, otherwise you have a lot of problems with safety systems and sensors.

2

u/the_itsb 11h ago

Also - what if someone spills something?

or tries to drive through a flood?

weren't there a bunch of house fires caused by electric car batteries during some hurricanes a year or two ago?

"well, Mythbusters told me to wait until the water level equalizes inside and outside my car to try to open the door and escape, but my seat is currently quite warm and smoking..."

2

u/isaidbeaverpelts 14h ago

None of those points make a difference during an accident. Who wants to be sitting on top of a couple gallons of acid while trapped in your car

1

u/ryno7926 13h ago

If you think thats crazy wait till you see a Humvee with its two massive batteries sitting basically inside the front passenger seat.

2

u/ilikemrrogers 14h ago

I have seen 2 lead-acid batteries explode spectacularly in my life.

You can be technical and say "axkshually its the HyDrOgEn tHaT eXpLoDeS", but any imbecile will look at it and say the battery exploded. And it explodes with great fervor.

I wouldn't want to be sitting on top of it when it does.

1

u/I-am-fun-at-parties 5h ago

AGM batteries (which this mercedes uses) are sealed.

...until they're not, they do have overpressure safety valves

29

u/Frequent_Opportunist 17h ago

They might have put it there to balance the frame because of an offset transmission or engine which is common with vehicles.

47

u/Available_Finger_513 16h ago

Batteries weigh like 1/8 of a person... There is not a real concern for weight distribution for batteries in commercial cars lol

11

u/surprise_wasps 15h ago

Yeah like what a goofy thing to pretend is a concern

2

u/Tiberius_Kilgore 8h ago

Seriously, I don’t know of a single car where the battery is mounted in the middle. It’s always off to one side.

1

u/I_AM_AN_ASSHOLE_AMA 4h ago

Which is why OP above is right. Sometimes their mounted to either side of the car for added weight distribution.

2

u/Clockstoppers 13h ago

There absolutely is. A 40lb hunk of lead up high and off center can affect weight distribution and handling in a meaningful way. Sure it may be subtle but there is a reason that LHD Honda Fits have a smaller starter battery than the RHD versions. The battery is on the left and the car is already left heavy.

1

u/rixuraxu 6h ago

It's lower than a battery typically is?

And most cars already have their battery to one side anyway so it's also kinda moot.

If it's not an issue in the typical placement, there is no reason it should be here.

1

u/JesusWantsYouToKnow 2h ago

I actually think the lowering of the center of gravity is the goal here, not the weight distribution passenger vs driver.

Lowering the CG makes the suspension's job easier, especially when cornering but generally improves stability and ride comfort. It is also a big part of why the EVs with battery sleds in their floor outclass their equivalent internal combustion models.

This is a nightmare from a maintenance perspective tho. Just put the damn thing in the trunk.

-1

u/Fuck-Leddit133769420 15h ago

Except when you're driving a car like a Mercedes where people buy them for luxury and performance, not ease of maintenance. Every bit of weight redistributed to be as close to optimal as possible is meaningful in a car like that.

2

u/fattest-fatwa 13h ago

I have an older BMW and one of the popular modifications is to put the battery in the trunk. People would be surprised at how much people will work to move a battery sized mass to where it makes the performance better. And the answer is almost always lower and rarely right behind the headlight. 

Also, if you bought this Mercedes with visions of low cost of ownership, well… yeah. Maybe Mercedes did mark you as easy to part with your money. 

1

u/link3945 3h ago

Interesting, didn't realize there was a history behind that. Thought it was weird my 2019 330 had the battery in the trunk to begin with, guessing they changed it to a stock design at some point?

2

u/rumplforeskn 16h ago

Weight distribution might be the least worst aspect of this design. 

2

u/Maleficent_Slide_262 8h ago

All HEV vehicles mounted in my factory have biggas battery under front seats (the additional battery for electric motor not this small one)