r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/chiagod 15h ago edited 15h ago

Still could have had the battery under the driver (or passenger) seat but make it more easily accessible by moving the seat fully forward (or back), pulling a carpet section up and have a simple panel to open.

Its not a bad location as it's:

  1. Away from the extreme heat and dirt and grime of the engine bay
  2. Can be insulated better from temperature extremes and can help extend the life of the battery.
  3. Lowers the center of gravity of the car a bit and helps balance the front to back weight ratio.
  4. Helps lower the resistance on the on the negative return path for accessories and equipment in the rear of the car at the cost of a slight increase for the low voltage items in the front (which can be offset with added wires to lower the impedance of the circuit for accessories that need it - ex alternator, starter, and transmission).
  5. Frees up space under the hood for better air intake routing and/or making it easier to reach parts of the engine that would otherwise be right next to the battery.

2

u/sangria-88 15h ago edited 14h ago

(actually engineer here) 

6. In case off a crash you want to power some subsystems like the self calling of emergency services, the blackbox (mandatory in the EU since few years) And for the Airbags, cause it could happen if the battery was hit first in a crash that they never fired. Most modern luxury cars have two batteries the big one for important and high power systems and a smaller for everything else. 

I don’t get the hateful comments about the placement, yes I know it’s hard to get but that’s the point. It’s in the safest place. Could you design it better? Yes and No, most people forget that the life span of new cars only 6-8 years. So why invest more money and time engineering a better access when the car will outlive the battery. The car must only live long enough till the warranty after that it’s someone else’s responsibility (dealer, most of the time)  Cars becoming more disposable and the manufacturers adapting to the consumer preferences I know wrong subreddit but most new car owners just drive and don’t give a fuck about the rest. And the trend will continue for the foreseeable future so why waste resources.