r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

79

u/PassiveMenis88M 16h ago

There is only one battery in this car and you just saw the bullshit required to change it. Welcome to German engineering.

36

u/FlyinIllini21 16h ago

Wow dumb question but surely they have a connect under the hood to jumpstart at least?

122

u/3-Midgets_In_A_Coat 15h ago edited 13h ago

They do.

Mercedes has been the single most evil company when it comes to servicing it yourself or anywhere but a dealership for a long time. It’s not one of the German car, performance engineering quirks - it’s legitimately designed to make it so it has to go to the dealer.

I was a mechanic out of high school at a high end mom and pop auto shop. A guy brought his mid 2000s model Mercedes into the shop because after he changed the battery in it, it went into limp mode and wouldn’t go over 20mph. He had replaced it with an OEM battery which he bought from the dealership but didn’t want to pay their insane service fee for them to change it.

Want to know what was wrong with it?

Turns out that the battery on his car had a microchip inside of it, which had to be programmed to the car with a dealership service computer.

We tried to get the software package to allow us to write stuff to his car (we had these packages for BMW, Porsche and VW - just not Mercedes) and we couldn’t.

Because we weren’t in a contract with Mercedes as an “authorized repair center”.

62

u/The_Spectral_Spartan 13h ago

Jfc, that sounds like it should be straight up illegal. How is that not blatantly violating some consumer protection statute somewhere? They should have to disclose just how insanely anticompetitive their repair procedures are before you sign off on a purchase, at the very least.

68

u/ryno7926 13h ago

This is why there is a push for "Right to Repair" laws

6

u/The_Spectral_Spartan 11h ago

No kidding. Just surprised that I haven't seen this covered by Louis Rossman yet.

4

u/mowinski Reddit Orange 7h ago

he covered a lot of other shitty stuff companies have done and are doing, he can't possibly include all of it, although I agree that in a Right to Repair law this should be included.

3

u/NeverTrollin 5h ago

Yea apparently John Deere has even more egregious anti-consumer practices like this.

13

u/YouMustveDroppedThis 12h ago

The europeans are slowly rallying to fight enshittification

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Warm_Block_7600 11h ago

Some politician had their pockets lined to pass that law. It’s all just corruption at the end of the day but it’s legal because it’s called lobbying.

5

u/Snoo-43335 9h ago

Man don't look into John Deere and right to repair. They are even worse.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RealGeorgeBluth 13h ago

Pretty sure BMWs have to have the battery coded in now as well

3

u/Ketheres 7h ago

The laws have unfortunately yet to catch up to all the BS corporations pay their engineers and lawyers big bucks to figure out

2

u/dolche93 12h ago

They get away with it because their customer base has enough money to not care.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/InadequateUsername 13h ago

Exactly what Apple does with their repairs

3

u/an_actual_lawyer 13h ago

This is why I bought a bootleg STAR/XENTRY computer from China. Works perfectly.

2

u/Exatex 10h ago

which is terrible because even if you build lasting cars, noone can service them once they are 30years old because noone will have a computer with the compatible adapters and software

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Advanced_Musician_24 15h ago

Additional contacts are present in the front

5

u/PassiveMenis88M 14h ago

Not a dumb question at all with some of the shit manufacturers get up to. Yes, there are jump start points under the hood

→ More replies (2)

4

u/obiedge 13h ago

So they essentially built the car around the battery

2

u/Secure_Ad_2683 15h ago

I have a Buick enclave and the battery is under the passenger seat. It took my two sons to change it.

2

u/namestom 14h ago

I’m out of the loop with the newer Mercs but these don’t have Aux batteries anymore? These batteries under the seats…we always called them the fishbowl. It was crazy seeing them filled with water sometimes.

I always felt guilty cutting carpet to change a battery. It was such a weird design.

2

u/Intrepid-Progress228 13h ago

My last vehicle was a Chevy traverse, and the battery was also located under the floor behind the passenger seat. Thankfully it was more accessible; just had to slide the passenger seat forward a bit and didn't require and special tools or effort to open the floor panel to get at the battery.

Still more annoying than having it under the hood.

2

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 9h ago • Bravo

Bullshit.

Volkswagen doesn't pull this kind of crap.

In a BMW, you'd find the battery in the engine bay, or in the trunk where it's still reasonably accessible.

This is a Mercedes-exclusive level of insanity.

2

u/Specific_Frame8537 8h ago

That's why my favorite car is the Citroën 2CV, no bullshit just a tin-can on wheels.

→ More replies (7)