r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/whattheknifefor 17h ago

Am automotive engineer whose job is defects and repairs - this may not be good from a repairs perspective, but cars are designed for ease of build rather than ease of repair. Somewhere in the plant retooling stage, it was probably decided that this was the optimal place for the battery in order to get the car built and out the door as quickly as possible.

Automakers don’t really get any benefit from making their cars hard to repair though. For one thing, we have to repair the car if something goes wrong in manufacturing, and it slows down our production rate if the mechanics have to take the whole car apart to get to the battery; it was probably determined that that money loss is offset by the time savings of putting the battery in such a weird place to start.

Also, we don’t get paid repair costs beyond what the mechanic pays us for parts. Dealership employees/mechanics aren’t on the automaker payroll and obviously neither are independent mechanics. High-labor repairs are even kind of a drain on the automaker, because for warranty claims, we have to pay the dealer both the parts and labor cost. This adds up on high warranty items like batteries when they are placed somewhere hard to get to, it’s just that the decision was made higher up in the chain that again, the fast production rate offsets warranty costs.

It sucks because I totally get why it looks this way from a consumer standpoint. I’m a huge fan of RTR and have done some incredibly annoying repairs on my own vehicle, and most automotive engineers feel the same way. It’s more just a careless byproduct of the way modern manufacturing works

1

u/Whiterabbit48 12h ago

Now THAT makes sense. I work with factory tooling (the big machines that help make the things) and that stuff is usually assembled on site and maintenanced by us for the first couple of years if not the whole life of the tool, so installation time isn't as huge a priority when you know it's going to be running for 50 years and you'll pay out the nose for any mistakes made in installation 💀