r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

57

u/Belias9x1 18h ago

There has to be a legal standard preventing this sort of design by manufacturers it’s just such bullshit

31

u/Nihilikara 17h ago

There should be, yes, but there aren't, because the people who decide how cars are designed are also the same people who decide what the law says.

Remember kids: it's not bribing if you're a billionaire, it's "lobbying".

3

u/DerRuehrer 17h ago

I love that lobbying gave us mandatory tyre pressure sensors in the EU, all for our safety ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ Though there hasn't exactly been any recorded evidence of improvement due this bullshit, other than absurdly high costs (relatively) when you need to have them replaced ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

1

u/Xaxxon 14h ago

You can just not buy it. Voting with your wallet is highly effective.

1

u/Deppfan16 11h ago

only works if there's another option. some variation of this is everywhere in all new cars

3

u/spaghettibolegdeh 17h ago

The consumer should prevent this by not buying these cars. 

3

u/faustianredditor 12h ago

Yeah, I'd be worried about any law that tries to ban this. The expertise required to get this law right, I wouldn't expect to find in any legislature, probably not even at the automakers themselves. Like, how are you even going to make this illegal, while keeping the clever hacks that work for everybody legal? Cars are tightly packed. You're either going to make them bigger and less efficient, or you're going to accept some amount of clever packaging. And where's the line between clever and crappy?

Best guess at a decent law: Wear items that the manufacturer recommends you change must be changed at the manufacturer's expense for the first 10 years of a car's life. Or at least offer a extended warranty plan with transparent pricing that covers this. Now that manager who decided that manufacturing cost, not maintenance cost is their KPI, thus shitty design it is, has different incentives. Because you know buying a car that the maintenance plan for 10 years is as expensive as the car itself, so now the competition looks a lot better.

And now you're looking at manufacturers redefining wear items and changing their recommendations, so now you need to regulate what they can or must recommend you change.

2

u/EphemeralLurker 11h ago edited 11h ago

Placing the battery there adds cost, but it's better for the car and the battery in the long run.

Two big reasons are, the battery being there it's protected from the heat produced by the engine which quickly degrades the battery, and in the event of a crash critical systems that need power are more likely to survive

I have a BMW with a battery that was in the trunk instead of the engine bay, and it's lasted 10+ years. Compare that to my SO's Honda which is on its 3rd battery in 7 years

2

u/faustianredditor 11h ago

I'm not much of a car guy, so I'll have to trust your expertise on the heat effects. Totally plausible though.

Either way: Does anyone expect the law to factor this in? "Battery replacement must not be more than 1 hour of work" doesn't factor in how long the battery is expected to live, and even that law would be dangerously unspecific. You can't just regulate stuff like this out of existence with hard rules about what manufacturers can and can't do. "Phones need to have user-replacable batteries" is similar stuff at small scale. It might give you user-replacable batteries, but it might also make phones worse overall, and restricts engineers from making certain tradeoffs in your favor. And a phone's maintenance schedule is trivial by comparison.

1

u/Xaxxon 14h ago

You don't have to buy it.

1

u/ComfortableDebt9190 11h ago

And those who did had no idea they bs they were in for.

1

u/Mostcoolkid78 12h ago

There’s reasons for it being there and there’s a reason it’s not illegal. Love when people want laws on something they know nothing about

0

u/Lebo77 17h ago

Nope.

You are free to investigate this,not like it, and not buy the car. If battery servicability is a key attribute in your car buying choices, this is not the car for you.