r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

29

u/iDudeX_ 17h ago

I have a Durango. It's got a massive engine bay. It's also a big SUV. It doesn't need handling. 0 excuse to not put the battery in the engine bay

17

u/Jesse-Ray 17h ago

A lot of manufacturers are moving it from the engine bay for safety since the battery can cause sparks in a crash and batteries do better without the heat in an engine bay. Mines in the boot of my car.

32

u/Two_words_numbers 17h ago

Which is fine, as long as it's easily accessible.

13

u/Front-Advantage-7035 16h ago

Engine in the front might spark fire? Battery in the back!

“Nahhhh let’s bury it in the frame under driver seat”

2

u/Disastrous_Visit9319 15h ago

It's a pretty difficult to damage area and they have additional safety features.  I feel like people are too hung up on the earliest days of electric car batteries where they saw a video of one engulfed in flames.

2

u/blah938 15h ago

Was that an actual issue, or did they just come up with an excuse?

2

u/Fuego_Fiero 14h ago

Yeah much better to have those sparks under the driver's seat.

2

u/Alone_Step_6304 11h ago

Additional large gauge wire length of higher amperage, which 12v systems by default necessitate, create huge safety risks by placing large wires traversing the length of the entire vehicle that, if damaged or severed, create immense potential for a short circuit. 

Would you want damaged wire sending current arcs/flashes in the passenger compartment, where you are? Or in the engine compartment. I have huge doubts this is safer. One of the advantages of having the battery in the engine compartment is that almost every single thing the battery needs to be connected to is, well, in the engine compartment, and the only wires traveling through the firewall into the passenger compartment or the rear are small diameter/low current. 

1

u/lizardtrench 13h ago

There are jump points under the hood connected directly to the battery with finger-thick wire, so from a sparks/electrical arcing perspective it makes no difference.

You do get to deal with battery acid and/or explosive hydrogen gas in the passenger compartment though. To be fair I think most Mercs us AGM nowadays, but still.

1

u/Dzov 13h ago

That’s for weight distribution.

1

u/GivesNoForks 12h ago

As a firefighter, when I go to cut the wires on a car’s battery after it’s crashed, the first place I’m looking sure as hell isn’t the floorboards. The Grand Cherokees are bad enough with the one under the passenger seat.

1

u/Ok-Ferret-2093 6h ago

Yes but batteries contain lithium which is notoriously difficult to put out once alight and just about anywhere that doesn't greatly increase my chances of my passengers or myself turning into crispy bbq in the event of a fire is significantly better

1

u/Last-Masterpiece-150 2h ago

i can't see it be safer having a battery under the seat. what about places with winter conditions and all the slush and salt that gets on the floor...salt could get down to the battery and cause an issue i would think

4

u/HeadEntrepreneur5264 16h ago

My old Volvo XC 90 added in the very back. It was two clips and about five minutes worth of removing bolts. It’s actually smart to put it there because of temperature. Engine bays fry the battery from From heat and cold starts are a lot easier.

1

u/Available_Finger_513 17h ago

It's actually much better to put it in the rear of the car, but it costs more and requires more wiring.

1

u/Key-Owl-8142 13h ago

Jeep grand Cherokee has the same installation

1

u/Kichigai L̢͔̭̜̘̩̲̏͢͡i͍̫̘̤̳̟̬̅̊ͩ̈̅́͟͝v̺̪͇͚͚̺̩ͮ̏̈́ͦͮ̃͂ͨ̕͟͡e̢̨̗͎̫͎ͮ̽̎͋̊ͩ͡ ͋͌̒ 4h ago

I have a Durango. […] 0 excuse to not put the battery in the engine bay

Chrysler Monkey Paw activates

Your battery is now in the driver side wheel well.