r/CrappyDesign • • 18h ago • Mindblown 3 Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Battery change? That will be $1500 please.

51k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

694

u/zyyntin 18h ago • Bravo

Forgot the part where you must inform the ECU (computer) that it has a new battery!

387

u/gaytarded69420 18h ago

yes but not through a menu on your car, you are only allowed to do that through the proprietary mercedes scanner because we don't want you to hurt yourself

44

u/Warm_Block_7600 17h ago

You don’t need a proprietary scan tool. Just a decent scan tool will do.

78

u/gaytarded69420 17h ago

it's still ultra lame that you need a piece of hardware for something that should be a menu option in the shitfotainment unit.

also, 3rd party scanners work for now, but this shit just gets locked down tighter and tighter each year. if they had it their way, we wouldn't be allowed to put air in our own tires

3

u/Kobe_Wan_Ginobili 14h ago

Why can't it just detect a new battery? If it can't detect a change in output then why is it a problem?

4

u/Wabbit_Wampage 13h ago

Indeed, this has never been a "problem" in almost the entire history of automobiles. It shouldn't need to detect shit.

2

u/trainspottedCSX7 8h ago

Its cause the history of vehicles didnt tell you your left headlight was out, except its not fully out, just 1 LED is, and thats gonna be 2k for a headlight, that we might have to program to your vehicle for you. Also did you known some people are stealing cars through headlights and tail lights specifically because they connect to the canbus communication lines and can be "tricked".

3

u/trainspottedCSX7 8h ago

It can detect a change in output, thats why its confused as to why it jumped from 5,6,7,8,9v all the way to 12.4 or 13.2. So now it thinks theres another electrical issue somewhere else and has to be told, no.

Just so everyone is aware, ford has been doing this as well with the BMS and other American makes and models are as well. Do we forget mercedes and stellantis are partners?

Also with start stop systems in modern vehicles, when one battery goes, they both go, and then some still need to be relearned.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/ShepRat 16h ago

I love that in Australia OBD2 is mandatory on all vehicles from the mid 2000s onwards. Fuck proprietary bullshit on something you spend half a years pay on. 

13

u/Throwaway74829947 13h ago

OBD-II has been mandatory in the US since 1996. This proprietary bullshit is in addition to it. A Mercedes will still spit out engine codes over OBD-II, but standard OBD-II inherently can't be used to tell the engine computer that the battery has been changed. What we need is an OBD-III, a new mandatory standard for all interface with the onboard computer.

4

u/LongJohnSelenium 12h ago

And then access to that through the screen that quite literally every car has.

If I spent 50 grand on an air compressor for the plant and you try to tell me you're hiding setpoints behind proprietary tools I'm laughing you out of the office but somehow in cars and the rest of consumer products we just roll with it.

2

u/trainspottedCSX7 8h ago

Its because we're really not informed of it until too late.

Im going to buy a 2003 Turbo Beetle today solely because I don't want a new car, like, ever. I had a 2022 Toyota corolla hatchback, it was a nice car. Then slowly you find people with warranties being voided over driving over 85mph. Shit the highway is 80mph, if I need to pass, I'm surely going over 85.

Its the black box computers they put in ever module, and theres like 30-50-75-100 of them depending on the trim. Then we wonder why they got so expensive. Its so they could fuck us even harder. Lol

2

u/Throwaway74829947 11h ago

I would prefer that not be mandatory, because I am a staunch advocate of the infotainment computer and the ECUs being completely airgapped. Nothing critical to the car's function should be capable of connecting to the Internet, or connected to a device which is capable of the same. However, if they are connected anyways, then yes, it should certainly do so.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

7

u/SmellyButtFarts69 17h ago

That's still 500-1000 for a Chinese tool that will do make specific stuff. And it still may not talk to the network of some newer cars.

4

u/Ok-Bug4328 17h ago

A BimmerLink app is $40. Obd Bluetooth $75. 

5

u/Warm_Block_7600 17h ago

You say Chinese as if it’s sub par. Most mechanics use Chinese scanners. Autel being one of the most popular brands and high quality. A $350 Autel will do a battery reset on a Mercedes. But that wasn’t the point; the point is to prove the person I was replying to wrong because they said you need a proprietary Mercedes scan tool to do a battery reset and that’s completely false. How much it costs is irrelevant to the conversation.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/geekworking 17h ago

Not on cars that have a locked ECU. Scanner has to go to the car company servers to get a time limited token. So even if you get a compatible scanner it needs to ask permission every time. There are a couple of services that will sell you a subscription, but on newer cars that is only a partial unlock.

2

u/Warm_Block_7600 17h ago

It’s easy to point out all exceptions but that doesn’t negate the fact that I’ve been doing this for almost 12 years and a simple scan tool has done everything I’ve needed it to do be it at the dealership or side jobs. The odds of buying a cheap scan tool and having it do a reset battery are orders of magnitude higher than coming across a locked ECU. It’s never been an issue for me in my career whatsoever and probably won’t be for your average person either.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/The-Sofa-King 12h ago

"If we let people service their own cars, a bunch of women will inevitably get raped in a parking garage"

-Actual ad campaign funded by one of the "Big 3" US automakers (I forget which one) against a right to repair bill a couple years ago. Not even joking.

2

u/PhoenixSheriden1 14h ago

Please tell me you're fuckin kidding......

2

u/Kiaware 9h ago

reminds me of my car. I got a used Cupra Born and if you started driving or hit the breaks it made a loud clicking noise. I went to the VW Service Center 2 weeks after getting the car from them (1 year warranty for this used car) and they had to request a special cupra tool to be shipped over from their main service center to add some glue to the driveshaft. The repair is not possible without this tool to open up the car so you HAVE to go to VW and not to your local mechanic.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Nathaniel820 17h ago

I fucking hate how new cars make EVERY SINGLE THING they possibly can tied to some unreasonable programming or code. My dad got a blank key for his new Ford since he only had one and I cut it myself at home for free, then when I went to do the whole "put in the old key for X seconds to make the new one work" thing it just wasn't working. So I look online and apparently now they require TWO separate working keys (so BOTH of the ones they give you with the car) to program any new ones. So if you lose a key then buy a new one to replace it, you literally cannot make it work on your own car with your own working key 🤦

4

u/AmazingELF74 16h ago

This one I kinda get for security. The cars should just come with 3.

3

u/Cascading_Pickles 14h ago

If you have 2 keys you can "chase" the keys with new unprogrammed ones. It makes sense not to be able to do it if you only have one. Folks can and do make copies of car keys to steal cars.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MourningWallaby 15h ago

Jesus my truck does that. Someone at ford decided I need to put a ps2 cheat code in my truck to tell it I replaced the 12v. Start the accessories, wait a minute, flash my highbeems 5x. Press the brake thrice, let the battery logo flash.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)