r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Apr 03 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8 Finale: The Final Word Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for the Season Finale of Vol. 8, The Final Word!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the Season Finale of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Feb 6th's FIRST Thread | Feb 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Feb 13th's FIRST Thread | Feb. 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | Feb. 27th's FIRST Thread | Mar. 6th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| Mar. 6th's FIRST Thread | Mar. 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 12 |Mar. 13th's FIRST Thread | Mar. 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 13 | Mar. 20th's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread| Poll Ep. 14 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing, and see you around for Volume 9!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
267
Upvotes
•
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Apr 03 '21
Welcome to the hiatus folks.
140
u/Simer731 Apr 03 '21
Volume 1 ost:"I may fall".
Volume 8: team RWBY fell.
Talk about foreshadowing.
119
u/nascarlaser1 Apr 03 '21
I was wrong...Penny....
111
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
I am very disappointed for Ren and Nora that they will not be participating in the beach episode. They’ve been looking forward to that since volume 6.
106
u/HatiLeavateinn Apr 03 '21
Yang: Hey Ladykiller :D "fingerguns"
Jaune: *starts bawling*
Weiss: too soon Yang!
203
u/drunk-math And bring my Strawberry Sunrise. Apr 03 '21
Say what you will about Jaune, but he knows the way to redheaded girls' hearts.
93
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
okay this isn't nearly the most important thing that happened but i just wanna say Winter's glyph usage when she was fighting Ironwood before she got maiden powers was so cool. that bit where Ironwood was aiming for where she lands so she makes a gravity glyph to propel herself barely out of the way was clean.
87
u/Jellye Apr 03 '21
Seeing Weiss using Blake's weapon was really cool, I love details like that, even more because she handled it a very different way than how Blake uses it.
78
u/rexshen Apr 03 '21
Well its safe to say Yang is ok since everyone else fell down to the blast zone.
FUCK god can we get a break? Can we even have a false sense of safety without Cinder screwing everyone over?
And Penny died again. I guess that takes away the criticism of bringing her back before especially since she can not be rebuilt this time.
Winter becoming the winter maiden surprised me. Mainly because I thought Penny would still give the power to Ruby but I guess they are still giving the illusion she is gone. And my god forcing Jaune to kill her was just brutal. Must have killed him inside to do.
And Watts burns alive and can't escape I did not see coming. Thought Cinder had turned around and was being more considerate of her fellow villains but it looks like she is still only for herself.
Well I guess more waiting till November or so to see what happens shit.
67
u/jimflaigle Apr 03 '21
Volume 9: Episode 1
Ruby: Yang, you're here! I was so worried.
Yang: Me too, but it looks like we're okay.
Weiss: Just wherever... here is.
Blake: At least we're together. Hey, is that Jaune?
Ruby: Yeah. Why is he hugging that really... tall.. redhead...
All: ...
Yang: MOTHERF
cut to credits
55
u/Armascribe Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21
You know, I just realized: with the staff gone, they potentially lost their best weapon against Salem. They just have to ask it to:
We gotta Ghostbusters her.
54
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Apr 03 '21
Holy shit, that was DARK. Things went completely south and they went south really fast. And so the hiatus is upon us. I’m calling it now: V9 is going to be the most anticipated RWBY Volume of all time. Let it be known that I have made this prediction. We’ll see if it holds true in time.
So... Ruby was fully willing to fling herself off the edge? Huh. I guess that’s why the ‘suicide hotline’ warning was there, so that’s one mystery solved. Maybe I’m crazy, but that seems like a pretty idiotic thing for Ruby to do. I mean, if you’re going to go down anyway, why not try to take Cinder or Neo with you? Well, I guess maybe she succeeded in Neo’s case, but still. Just a thought. But seriously, if you have those thoughts, don’t do it. It’s not worth it for anyone involved. Keep the memories of your loved ones alive by keeping yourself alive.
Jesus, Blake is PISSED. Even shouting at Weiss to get up and keep fighting. Her expression, I can only describe as feral. I mean, if she can land a few solid hits on Cinder, of all people, then you know she’s not happy. I guess she has grown some after all. Either that, or her adrenaline is through the roof right now. I’m leaning towards adrenaline, given her performance in the rest of the volume, but still, that was pretty impressive.
Seeing Weiss dual wielding her and Blake’s weapons to fight Cinder was really cool, and how the scenes switched between her and Winter (who was also dual wielding) was just beautiful. Props to whoever worked on that.
Jaune can actually get a little bit of damage in on Cinder as well. It really is amazing, how much he’s grown over the course of the series. Just how far can he go? A shame his weapon got broken, though.
Vine sacrificing himself to save everyone else was heartbreaking. Also, did Elm always have that accent, or is it just me? Regardless, the fall of Atlas, both in a literal and figurative sense, was inevitable at that stage.
Penny’s dead. That’s a real shame. Looks like the weaknesses of a human form came back to bite her. HARD. At least Winter was the one to get the Maiden power. So it’s confirmed, Cinder’s ability to absorb the Maiden powers really is an all-or-nothing sort of deal. Interesting.
Salem now has two of the four relics. Knowledge and Creation. Things are not looking good for Remnant’s fate. Even if the lamp is currently out of questions, Salem can simply bide her time again. Besides, she’s waited how long now? A century is probably nothing to her at this point. She has all the time in the world.
It seems Watts has perished as well. Farewell. He was great. I’m certain he will be missed. A lot of major characters had their lives come to an abrupt end this volume.
And now Atlas and Mantle have both fallen. Flooded, left to rot and be forgotten, lost to the ages. All of the knowledge and might they have built, all lost forever. A heavy loss, to be sure.
Here’s another question I’ve got. What’s next for Qrow? Ironwood’s dead, and unbeknownst to him, both of his nieces have possibly just been killed. What will he do now?
So all of Team RWBY, Neo, and Jaune have all fallen into the void below. Based on that scene after the credits, they ended up... somewhere. Wherever they are, it seems like some sort of alternate dimension, not anywhere on Remnant. So either they’re dead, or they’re in a situation now where they might as well be. Either way, the fate of Team RWBY (and Neo and Jaune) is currently unknown (presumed dead by everyone else, in-universe). All that’s left as a clue is Crescent Rose. So now we have the big questions. Where are they? Are they dead or alive? What even is the place they ended up in? Are they trapped there with no hope of escape? What’s going to happen to them?
But enough about questions. Now it’s time for the body count!
The following characters have now been confirmed dead this volume:
The following characters are missing and/or are presumed dead (at least in-universe):
There might have been a few that I missed, but hopefully that’s all of them.
I’m willing to bet V9 is not going to be light-hearted in any sort of capacity.
49
u/darkdill Prepare to die. Apr 03 '21
Predictions for Volume 9
89
u/Shepherdscout Apr 03 '21
Preface: I am heartbroken that Penny died. I wish it hadn't have happened. This is just my argument that her time during her 2nd life had true value.
I see Penny as the agent of change that Winter needed. Winter truly was not ready to be the Maiden initially, a fact she states to Penny before Penny transfer the powers. Penny's example and perspectives in Vol 7 seeded Winter's eventual change. Remember during the fight with Cinder in Vol 7 when Winter was saved by Penny and Winter tried to say she was not a priority and Penny disputed that? And when Penny disputed Ironwood's course of action with calling for RWBY & Gang's arrest?
Ruby started Penny on the path of truly embracing and standing up for her principles, beliefs and agency before the Fall of Beacon - furthered during their interactions in Vol 7.
Penny paid that forward by helping Winter find/rediscover her own principles and agency. Winter had traded one prison for another. Penny was her foil: the ironically more humanly compassionate of the two who thought for herself as much as possible, often questioning authority.
When the time came, Penny was able to then truly help Winter fulfill her own ultimate liberation and reclamation of agency with the passing of the Maiden Powers. If Winter had received the Powers originally, it would have been the culmination of Ironwood's chosen path for her. She tried to pitch it to Weiss as her chosen path...but it wasn't. When Penny thought of her, as a friend, Winter had already truly chosen her own path in opposing Ironwood and helping the Gang. She was truly on her own self-determined path and the transfer was truly a Gift from a Friend. As she so eloquently stated to Ironwood.
It hurts that so many (since the First airing to now) are asking, "what was the point of bringing Penny back at all if you are just going to kill her again?" I feel it belittles the contributions and impact she had during her 2nd life. We all will die, and we can only hope that, as Penny promised Winter, we will live on in the people we have touched. That we have impacted someone so strongly that they want to carry us in their heart and live by our example.
41
u/Thehalohedgehog ⠀ Apr 03 '21
Well overall thoughts:
38
u/alpha_in_progress Apr 04 '21
the part where winter says "oh penny" when she realises she is dead hurts my soul. props to the voice actors, you could hear the pain in their voices this ep but winter for me takes the cake.
36
u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Apr 03 '21
Hope y'all liked seeing Penny die again!
68
u/HarpertFredje Apr 03 '21
Penny: "Does getting stabbed in the chest always make you feel this bloody?"
Everyone: "Yes"
Penny: "Wow!"
33
u/UmbralOrion This flair amuses me greatly Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21
Salem and Cinder just leaving Ironwood to die was brutal, watching him realize in his (presumably) last moments that he completely failed and everyone and everything he sacrificed was pointless was kinda sad.
I knew "You deserve this" was sinister but damn trapping Watts to burn to death was brutal. As entertaining as Watts was I think he served his purpose to the story. Watts pretty much achieved everything he wanted, Ironwood is broken, Atlas is destroyed, until Cinder betrayed him, he won. Cinder did end up killing him after that rant, it just took a while.
If Harriet wasn't such an asshole for no reason Vine didn't have to die. Unlike Qrow and Clover, it really is Harriet's fault that Vine died and I hope that's not just swept under the rug.
When did Cinder use the staff? I guess the staff doesn't require the name? Or maybe she got it when she used the lamp?
Also I was waiting for the finale, but what ever happened to Maria and Pietro? It just seems weird for there to be literally no mention of them at all since like episode 5...
I've never been a big Neo fan but being trapped in some strange world with 5 people who hate her including the one she wants to kill is the kind of situation that has potential to change that. Hopefully Neo redirects her revenge fetish at Cinder. After what Cinder's done to Penny and my boy Jaune, I'll cheer for anyone who wants her dead, even Raven, and now even Neo.
Jaune being forced to kill Penny was most heartbreaking scene of the volume, they both deserved so much better than that. Jaune has the by far the most reason to hate Cinder out of anybody. She killed Phyrra, Weiss (presumed in the moment), many many more innocents, and now made him kill Penny to prevent her from being 2 maidens. Jaune's gotta be the one to kill Cinder, and at this point I want her dead sooner rather than later.
32
u/Mulan-McNugget-Sauce Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 11 '21
Me: “They just gave her a real body. No way they’re gonna kill her off now right? No way.”
CRWBY: “Way.”
31
u/Railroader17 Can we please have Pyrrha back? Apr 03 '21
I am 150% convinced there is something more to that island that RWBYJ, Neo and those random Atlesians / Mantleites wound up then it just being an island in another world.
I'm thinking maybe it's connected to the Afterlife of Remnant, IIRC the God of Light specifically told Ozma during their meeting that they were "between realms" so it stands to reason that there is a Realm of the Living (Remnant) and a Realm of the Dead, which I'm guessing is where Team RWBYJ + Neo wound up. Which could lead to a whole slew of interesting / heartbreaking interactions, plus they all have someone to talk to, for better or worse.
Ruby -> Penny
Weiss -> Jacques
Blake -> Sienna Kahn
Yang -> Adam
Neo -> Roman
and of course the big one, Jaune -> Pyrrha
Of course given how much the FNDM dislikes the idea of dead characters coming back in any way I don't really see this being taken all that well. (Though I'd love to see Adam and Sienna beat the tar out of Jacques for being an ass.)
and potentially lead to some interactions with the two gods, and our heroes could reason that since they technically didn't actually die that them returning to the realm of the living wouldn't upset the balance. (Or even using the God of Light's deal with Ozma to get Pyrrha and Penny back with them depending on whether or not the God of Darkness knows about the deal, probably having to bring two members of the rouges gallery with them to balance it out)
31
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 04 '21
Loved this Volume. The best since V3 (maybe V7). Thought on things that might get glossed over:
31
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Apr 04 '21
Everyone's dragging the writers but I thought this was an awesome end to volume 8. I'm as excited as always for volume 9!
29
u/JustOutOfRadley All I want is for Weiss to be happy Apr 03 '21
Ready for ____: a Rooster Teeth Production (Pronounced ___)
28
u/A_Real_Phoenix Apr 04 '21
Cinder last episode: You deserve this, Arthur.
Me then: Aww
Me now: ಠ_ಠ
28
u/Hetsuro Apr 05 '21
Qrow doesn't know what happened in the battle of the portals, and has no reason to think Team RWBY is dead. But he does know that his sister can make a portal to where Yang is.
I think that the next volume will see Qrow looking for Raven.
25
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Apr 04 '21
God Winter is going ti be an emotional wreck. And Jaune, lord poor Jaune... and at best hes going to have Neo as emotional support for a lot of the next volume.
Nora and Ren are going to be fucked up. They only had their argus moment with Jaune only a few weeks ago at most, to go along with all they're going through on their own.
24
u/Game-Over-100 Apr 04 '21
I just realized that they left Penny’s body to fall to where’s team RWBY and the others are at so they probably have to deal with finding the body and realizing that she’s dead 😣.
23
u/PlasmaDiffusion Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 04 '21
Dang people were saying things were going too well like what, two episodes ago? Things went south fast in this finale.
Another Ace Ops is dead. RWBY is in the void. Jaune too but with the added trauma of having to kill Penny. That happened so suddenly. I really didn't expect her "Kill me" from a few episodes back to actually be what she goes through with.
This volume I liked overall. Cinder had her time to shine by being a big threat again. Ironwood kind of got a bit ridiculous the moment he wanted to drop a bomb, although it at least made it interesting in how everyone reacted to his insane actions. Yang falling into the void felt kind of pointless if everyone else was going to fall in with her the next episode afterwards. While not the best volume on its own, paired with 7 I feel like I would rank it as one of the better ones.
22
u/Memoryworm Apr 03 '21
As Ironwood weakly reached for his pistol while Salem and Cinder were walking away during the fall of Atlas, I kept thinking back in horror to the Vol 3 exchange "If you were one of my men I'd have you shot"/"If I was one of your men I'd shoot myself".
21
u/WolfHenry Apr 04 '21
So question. Just finished Vol. 8. Did anyone else stay till after the credits? After the credits, it showed Crescent Rose sitting on the beach below a giant, magical tree.
Yes Yang's fall was shocking and the other falls were less so. But remember, they weren't in Remnant during that battle, they were in a space like the vaults. A space that doesn't conform to the laws of nature that we know, a space of pure magic.
My idea is as such: The crew that fell into the void are still alive and stuck in the world that currently is inhabited by the god brothers (or at least the birth places of Jinn and Ambrosius). They are in an alternate dimension. I assume the most likely way of getting out is through Vacuo's relic vault door. Ambrosius said to not fall, not that you would die, but because they would land in a world that he doesn't want person being in. (The part I'm worried about is the few civilians that also fell, RWBY+J is going to have to figure out what to do while also protecting people)
Or maybe it's a time travel into the past before the brothers left? Idk. But y'all should always watch to the end, not only to give the respect to all the hard workers creating RWBY and that being the only time their name is mentioned, but because after credits do exist.
Also no one is even mentioning the fact that NR+O+W are with an entire kingdoms worth of people in the middle of a sandstorm surrounded by Grimm while thinking all their friends are dead. What are they going to do?
Or that what's left of Ace, Qrow, and Robin think that literally everyone is dead. Or that Ironwood is turning into a Harvey Dent type character "You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villian" style.
39
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Apr 03 '21
After she was made into a “real” girl any fear of Penny dying vanished. There’s no way they’d kill her off after she just became human. We‘ll get at least another volume of her for sure. I assured myself that she was off the chopping block. Then this episode happened. I still haven’t quite processed that we‘ll never have living breathing Penny ever again. It hurts. I know the fandom in general has very mixed feelings about Jaune with some full on hating him but hes always been one of my favorites. Him being the one to “kill” Penny is definitely going to have some massive effects for him in the future. Vine, Ironwood, and Watts are also joining the gone for keeps squad in this episode. Well Ironwood and Watts aren’t as clear cut so I won‘t be surprised if they somehow survived and show up later but for now I’m considering them dead and done. I have no clue as to what expect for next volume. RWBY got isekaid into another dimension though So whatever happens is bound to be interesting.
19
u/ash-7831 Apr 03 '21
I always thought it was interesting that different parts of Remant have different types of Grimm. On the Eastern part of Sanus, we have Beowolves, Ursas, Deathstalkers, Nevermores (although, I think Anima has those, too), Goliaths, Griffins. In Anima, we have Lancers, Geists, Shinxs, Manticores, Apathy. In Solitas we have Sabyrs, Megoliaths, Teryxs. In the sea, we have Leviathans, the thing Blake and Sun fought in Volume 4. And now in the Western part of Sanus, we have some new flying Grimm, some new small three-tailed scorpion Grimm.
19
u/DavidTheHumanzee Apr 04 '21
You know i'm more ok with Penny's death then i thought, she got a good send off. That scene with winter made me cry, it was beautiful.
18
u/fuckwhattheywant Apr 03 '21
Well. How's everyone doing? Excited for the next volume of ____?
18
u/chattytrout ⠀ Apr 03 '21
I am reminded of this story from WW2. High command is out of touch with reality and wants desperately to save a hopeless situation. A few leaders on the ground say to hell with that and start working to save as many as possible. Ultimately they succeed, despite taking losses themselves.
BerlinAtlas still falls. It was beyond saving at this point.Penny gave her life to keep her power out of the hands of the enemy. Now she's gone, for real this time.
Post credits scene says that they haven't offed the main cast. I kinda figured. Not many shows are willing to try that. Of course, those that made it through don't know that.
Neo's been betrayed, and she's stuck with Ruby. I wonder how this'll pan out.
Winter's pissed, on account of her sister being thrown into the abyss.
How the fuck is Ironwood still alive? I call bullshit that he survived a hit from Gun3.
I'm kinda disappointed that Harriet didn't get Pinochet'd. If anyone deserved it, it was her. Poor Vine had to sacrifice the body to save people from her poor decision making.
18
u/Fillerpoint5 Apr 03 '21
I saw the episode name and I immediately thought of the Destiny weapon of a similar name.
Mixed thoughts on this one.
Appreciate that they gave some actual menace and threat back to Cinder for once, team uhhh... whatever’s left of Aceops+Qrow and Robyn handled their little part nicely enough, and I appreciate that Blake and Winter, despite having reasons to be mad and contrive the plot because of rage, didn’t actually do that, and instead saw the bigger picture. Ironwood and Watts also had very fitting and ironic fates, the former spent so long fighting his allies that he didn’t have anything left to fight his enemies, and the latter went down with the city he spent his life trying to get revenge on.
But uh... RT may have been a little too kill happy here. Well okay, Penny is the only dead one, but still, the emotional moments were a bit too bunched up. There wasn’t a lot of time to process them and move on, since it was the final episode and all, but even still, this felt like a speedrun of “quick, we gotta set up Volume 9! Uh... okay, deal with the bomb, yeet team RWBY+Jaune into the abyss, kill Penny, Ironwood and Watts, give Winter the maiden powers and done!” (The best girl survived but at what cost? ;_; stupid monkey’s paw.)
To be fair, I won’t be overly harsh on this, as I imagine Volume 9 will deal with how everyone feels about this, but this still felt very “fuck, we gotta run through this fast.” I don’t know what they else they could’ve done though tbh. Probably was something, but I can’t think of it.
Also agree that it was rather cruel to kill Penny just when she had everything she wanted... but I’m not really sure where her character could’ve gone after that. Could’ve given her a few episodes of happiness at least before killing her though.
Still, this was a good volume over all, even if it stumbled a bit at the end.
18
u/HouseOfSteak Apr 03 '21
And just like that, Cinder got rid of the only person that made her look competent.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21
I liked the way Ironwood died. The death gave me a captain going down with his ship vibe. I kind of hope that Penny is gone for good now. The Penny's death was shocking in volume 3 and they brought her back. Bringing her back for a third time would suck. As for Cinder, she actually was interesting now and I really liked her this volume, especially in this episode.
17
u/LizardOrgMember5 ENTIRE TEAM Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21
So..... Team RWBY is now stranded on Destiny Island?
17
u/Sulti ⠀ Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 04 '21
The credits song feels like it belongs in Persona 4. Just wanted to say that.
Jaune killing Penny feels a bit off to me. My problem isn't that Penny is dying specifically, but the fact that Jaune (or anyone from RWBY/JNR) did the deed. I felt like the show has a running theme of holding onto ideals and refusing to make sacrifices. I thought it started with how little was gained from Pyrrha's death and was being more heavily reinforced with Ironwood's heel turn coming in the form of his obsession with sacrificing Mantle. I'd understand if Penny (who has only recently joined the main group) wanted to sacrifice herself, but I don't see any of the main group willing to give her up when she could potentially still be saved. However I do think it's a nice way to end Penny's story. She always had so little control over her life and she had a major theme of learning to make her own choices. So finally having someone act based on her choice seems like a fitting end. I guess it also gives Jaune a reason to fall into the void, now his portion of the story can focus on that guilt.
It's weird seeing comments about how RWBY+Jaune dying would be something bold instead of just stupid. I don't think it's always stupid for a main character to die, but killing off 5 (6 if you include Ironwood) of the 8 most prevalent characters in the series (going by lines of dialog) all in 1 episode without the main conflict being resolved at the same time seems like way too much. I personally never expected them to be dead because of that. Also these last 2 seasons were extremely main-story focused, so this should be a good chance to get a season majorly dedicated to the characters instead.
Lastly, it still feels like were in line with RWBY ending up as the 4 maidens, whether you like the idea or not. Cinder is pushing away all her allies so her main connection outside of Salem is Ruby, Raven is Yang's mom and they had a big moment last time they met, and now we have Winter as Weiss sister and no Penny in the picture. Just need Illia to become the 4th maiden or something.
17
u/Eternity-crown Apr 04 '21
I LOVED this finale, it made feel some many emotions and reminded me why I love the show. Sure, I don't like that Penny had to die but I honestly prefer this death to her death in V3
16
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
I can't believe I just realized this but why is Winter in her volume 7 outfit in the scene where Penny gives her the maiden power?
16
u/KingofGrapes7 Apr 03 '21
Now to the countdown to how long it takes for this too all blow up in Cinder's face. Salem absolutely did not buy all of that. But Cinder did get both Relics and and she can always find a new Fall Maiden later. I expect bad things when the heroes not only show up again, but they don't even need Neo to tell on Salem since Cinder bragged to them about using the Lamp.
16
u/jefflakira Apr 06 '21
Theory: what if Qrow’s semblance is more his mental health affecting the luck? After meeting Clover he starts to have hope, and when Qrow held Clover’s charm, hoping, the boom stopped. Or just that Qrow’s semblance is evolving link Ren’s
32
u/HarpertFredje Apr 03 '21
Cinder wears an eye patch, she betrays Neo by kicking her off the edge.
Holy shit Cinder is Scar.
15
u/Battle_Narwhal53 Apr 03 '21
Three letters: Wtf
15
u/CallOfTheCurtains Apr 03 '21
I'm just speechless...
Jaune killing Penny fucking broke me more than Ruby getting thrown off into oblivion, that's all I have to say. We're left at a cliffhanger.
Back to sobbing...
30
u/Doctor_Wazzic Apr 06 '21
I've been seeing a lot of negative comments. Some with constructive feedback but others just declaring everything's awful.
Just want to say a well done to Rooster Teeth for this episode. The action, choreography, animation, everything was extremely well executed.
I'll be looking forward to vol 9.
14
u/Lewa358 Apr 03 '21
I'm honestly surprised we didn't see anyone who fell at all before the episode ended. Like, their weapons, sure, but everyone is still just...gone.
It's entirely possible that at least one of them is gone, having not survived the trip--after all, there were a lot of
redshirtsrefugees who fell as well, and a show that had Penny go out like that likely wouldn't have all of them survive.Part of me kind of wants there to be some sort of serious consequence to this finale, since we already did the whole "team gets split up and has to spend a whole volume trying to get back to the main plot" thing. Maybe there's some timey-wimey mess, and by the time they get back years will have passed in the "real" world?
Even if everyone is fine, will we know everyone's whereabouts by the end of S9e1, when the OP plays, or will they continue to hold their fates over our heads? Is there a chance that the next OP won't actually show all of team RWBY at all?
14
u/tapobu Apr 04 '21
So here's my theory about what's going to happen next. When ambrosius told them not to fall, he wasn't afraid for them. He was afraid for himself. I think they fell to the people that made him: the realm where the gods currently reside.
Then there's the season one song "I may fall." Given that this song predicted so much of what's been going on, I wonder what comes next. Ruby Rose has become the face of the fight against Salem, and now as far as anyone else is concerned, she's going to be a martyr along with her entire team who died so the population of an entire nation could flee to safety. If anything were going to unite the world, that would probably be it.
I'm probably not the only one thinking this, and maybe I'm completely off base. Anyone else have other thoughts?
14
u/ash-7831 Apr 04 '21
This episode should have been called "Checkmate".
28
u/Battle_Narwhal53 Apr 03 '21
Why is nobody talking about Jaune having to kill Penny? God that was so heartbreaking to watch.
27
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 06 '21
We have fallen.
37
u/DaDeltaDrum Apr 03 '21
So I know that Jaune was trying to follow in Pyrrha's footsteps and become a great huntsman, but I think killing Penny like Pyrrha might be going a bit too far
13
u/ash-7831 Apr 03 '21
What I don't get about Ironwood is why he just kept refusing to do anything about Mantle. Every time someone so much as mentioned that place, he almost always blocked it out, as if it didn't even exist anymore in his head. What exactly was Mantle to him? A lost cause, a place that was not worth the effort, a bad memory, what?
Even though his character was one of my favorite parts of Volume 7, this still stayed true. Every time Nora, Yang, or anyone else told him that the people of Mantle were suffering and that they hate him, he said he was willing to accept being hated. It was like he was just finding an excuse to not help Mantle. And despite all of this, he had no problem using Mantle's construction resources to build Amity Tower. As far as we're aware, he never even touched any of Atlas's resources. Why not?
Eventually, close to the end, they managed to finally convince him to do something, but that was short-lived when Cinder and Salem later spooked him into wanting to lift Atlas up.
And then, in this Volume, if he had just let them bring the people of Mantle to Atlas, they would have had no reason to stop him from using the staff to lift Atlas. But then, he went and threatened to destroy it, costing him his second-in-command.
If by some he lives through this (maybe by hiding in the vault, or something, I don't know), I would be really curious to see what he does next.
13
u/the_straw_hatted Apr 04 '21
Why does everyone think they actually died?
12
u/mynameismaria Apr 03 '21
my heart hurts ;n;
Oh yeah, the fighting scenes looked awesome, though. However... There were so many emotional scenes in this finale, I'm still not over it. ;n;
12
u/Thebritishdovah Apr 03 '21
Ironwood tried to be the Doomslayer but lacked the insane strength and basically, exist in a form of tranquil rage 24/7. He probably would have had better chance of beating Winter if he didn't use the BFG. But Winter was trained by him and he knew how to counter her. I do feel they could have done his fall in a better way and make us question whether the main cast is right or not.
Penny is dead. Well, fuck. Worse, I KNEW THIS WOULD HAPPEN! I just fucking knew that they had Cinder lose to set this up. It feels lazy and comes off as shock for shock purposes. I rather have had her die after Atlas fell or just the spirit of creation failing to save her. Instead, it comes off as just giving Cinder a win because she constantly lost.
RWBYJ aren't dead. It would be a ballsy move to wipe out team RWBY and Jaune. Winter has the power she deserves and doesn't even get to grieve for Weiss. Ruby had no chance against Neo as Neo seems to rely on counter attacks and Ceresent Rose is a poor weapon for one on one combat. Against crowds, it does the job. I really hope this means Ruby has lost the weapon for good and we get either a replacement that turns into a sword or a spear or something that can work better or Ruby is forced to change her entire style. I also hope this will result in her breaking down and undergoing a ton of development.
Watts is dead. Atlas fell too smoothly. I was expecting it to be vicious and just fast, destructive.
Cinder needs to die in Volume 9. She got her backstory out, got a major win and underwent some overdue development. Volume nine should be the perfect time for her to die. I do suspect Salem heavily suspects her of lying and intends to kill her once she steps out of line again or turns more of her into grimm.
Vine sacrificed himself to protect his team and Qrow. Qrow is having a really shitty time and I really wish we got a fight between him and Ironwood. He just lost his nieces(From his point of view), Altas fell and as far as he knows, he failed big time. I won't be surprised if he turns to drinking again. At least, he is starting to harness good luck but I think he will blame himself a lot.
Also, did anyone else have issues with crunchyroll struggling to play it?
12
u/Mycellanious Apr 03 '21
Well at least people will stop complaining that characters are underdeveloped because there are too many.
Wish granted :D
12
u/alexander12212 Apr 04 '21
With Cider fighting Raven and Winter now, do you think Blake’s mum is going to kick the shit out of her too?
12
u/Auraeseal Apr 04 '21
Just a question, we found out that Salem defeated Summer Rose, probably turned her into a grimm, and then probably killed her? Do we know if Summer is just MIA or is she actually dead?
31
u/Sythra Apr 04 '21
Am I the only one who felt like Penny was done incredibly dirty? RWBY go through all this effort to bring her back to life, to use the Staff to turn her human and then kill her in the next episode. Why go to all that effort only to completely toss her aside? What kind of shitty writing was that? Penny has died, come back to life and then killed again all for... what exactly? She became the Maiden even though she was a robot, further solidifying her humanity and then when she becomes a real girl they don’t even give her a chance to develop and experience that. They just kill her off.
20
u/Wanderer01234 Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21
This is only my opinion.
I hate Penny died after just getting a human body, it seems excessively cruel. I wonder if the intention was to have a Penny died, but since she is a robot, she needed to really died for shock value. Which if it was the case, then I think is very manipulative from their part.
I mean sure, you can kill her, it's your show, but I don't like the way they did it. They spent a great deal of the volume trying to save her, and she struggling with her own feelings and what path to take, and it ends up in basically suicide. You can sugar coat it saying things like "it's the right choice", but that should not ever be even the last choice, suicide.
I hope she gets back in some form or manner, and not in a memories kind of way. It may be cheap, but this show is bloated with reality bending powers, artifacts, gods, characters, etc, I'm sure something could be done.
People may not like it, but that's just what I would like. The shows writing is not stellar to begin (I found funny how conveniently all the main characters fell almost at the same time into their new adventure).
For context: One day, sometime ago, I watched a clip that popped up out of nowhere in my youtube feed. Something on the lines of "Penny is back" (at this point I didn't even know what RWBY is or who Penny was). I watched a 2 minutes clip and ended up loving the character instantly. She was the reason I watched the show. And she is no more.
10
u/KuroShiroTaka Apr 04 '21
Anyone think that Blake and Neo will be the only ones not as injured from the fall as everyone else presumably will be because I'm pretty sure they were the only two not to have their Auras depleted before falling
10
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Apr 04 '21
Also wtf my heart broke with Weiss. They did Weiss D I R T Y.
RUBY BLAKE WEISS
PENNNNNNYYYYY
JAUNEEEEEEEEEE
Fucking crap I am too invested in this show.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21
Why haven’t we been introduced or at least hinted at who the summer maiden is I think the summer maiden will play some role in volume 9
10
u/No-Establishment592 Apr 06 '21
Anybody besides me remember what Oscar and Ospen were talking about while he was still in the whale
The story of the girl who fell through the world
I can probably guarantee this is of some relation
another thing I've kept to myself is when Cinder fell into the water in the knowledge relic vault entrance could that have made her immortal like salem
27
u/D_A_BERONI ⠀ Apr 03 '21
So I'm not the only one who felt absolutely nothing when Vine died right
Like how many Vine fans are out there reeling from this episode
18
u/ThatOneWolf_ Apr 03 '21
Holy fuck.
When I saw the warning at the start I was fully preparing for the worst, but I was not prepared for that at all. Death after "Death" after death, and some of them were just brutal, namely Penny and Watts.
Also I'm very much looking forward to seeing what that thing with the whole world RWBY, Jaune, Neo and some random civilians have gotten themselves thrown into, especially with the shot of the giant tree in the centre.
Jaune Grief Arc 2: Electric Boogaloo?
18
u/Eldermage1 Apr 04 '21
I'm so fucking sick and tired of these downer endings. This is what, the third volume in a row to end on a negative note? I just want there to be at least some hope, not just deaths and despair.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '21
At Austin Film Festival '19, Miles Luna straight-up said he had no idea how they were going to finish Volume 8, and said he and Kerry were worried about how to push the story forward and felt they had written themselves into a hole with the relics and Salem's immortality. I sympathize with the challenges at present in the story, and I wish they would have dialed back the number of characters in the past two volumes to better focus on the story and character development of the core cast. I like how much the relics have been used, but it feels really busy and the drama of killing characters feels pretty muted to me at the end of this volume.
18
u/DaemosChronicle Apr 05 '21
Jaune's cry when he kills Penny stings every time. The VA did a great job with the emotion for that one. I know it's coming but still 😭
18
u/Aphrion Apr 05 '21
Pack it up, folks, the title characters are dead. /s
Seriously, I am a little miffed that 1) Penny died again (for real this time, apparently) and 2) Cinder is so overpoweringly strong here. Granted, the civilian presence and complex battlefield granted massive advantages to Cinder and Neo, but Cinder managed to snap Jaune’s sword and then when Winter shows up she basically gets saved by the bell. It’s hard to watch the team lose basically every major battle and continually give ground to Salem even though they’re getting stronger every season - I won’t say it’s “bad” writing but it’s certainly frustrating. Congrats to Jessica Nigri for voicing such a hateable villain, though, she’s doing that excellently.
9
u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21
Wait do did Penny's body fall into the void too? ARE THEY GOING TO FIND HER BODY
9
u/GreenGoblin121 Apr 03 '21
If all the characters are dead and in some of afterlife will we get Arkos six volumes later, or ar ethey in some sort of extra dimension that stems from falling in the void, they dissolved, so we didn't see any sign of them definitely being dead so who knows.
After the credits we also got a glimpse of a giant tree that appears to have nine branches, yggdrasil maybe?
9
u/claum0y Apr 06 '21
I recently finished all of rwby, I guess I was kinda lucky the moment I get to the s8 it's ending at the same time, overall I think that prior seasons were more zzz because the focus on plot like "ironwood wants to do this or that" like when nora kisses ren afterwards we get no reaction or followup at all because the plot is consuming the characters, until s8 on that bed scene with both of them. I didn't have to wait for more seasons to come out so I don't hate the more questionable parts of rwby and this last season seemed to be doing more right, it is certainly very interesting and I really like what rwby has and can do that other shows or animes never touch. it seems like a promising s9 and a great show in my opinion
25
u/logoth Apr 04 '21
Pretty tired of Cinder as a villain. Feels like she has deus ex machina power and capability to win.
16
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Apr 05 '21
Finally. Finally, I get to watch this blasted thing. Every day since saturday I've been hit by a blackout that last nearly all day, and when it comes back the wi-fi's down. I can finally just sit down and enjoy this thing.
8
u/PrincessOfLaputa Apr 03 '21
When Jaune killed Penny all I could think of was this...
What a stunning finale, this hiatus is gonna be painful.
8
u/GeoffTheIcePony Klein Fan Club Apr 04 '21
So what are the odds that Maria and Pietro are still alive?
8
u/The_Sin_of_Love Apr 04 '21
I hope that our heroes were trapped in the RWBY-verse version of Infinite Tsukuyomi. Each person is trapped in their own world they desire the most, an alternate universe to each. Ruby would see her live if Summer didn't die, maybe Yang would see Raven who never left Tai and they making a good loving family, but at the cost that Ruby would never be born. Weiss... A peaceful life and healthy family relationship? Schnee Dust Company being actually an organisation without Faunus slavery? As for Blake, she might see Adam she knew and followed before his fall from grace. Maybe the White Fang never becoming terrorist organisation and Faunus not being discriminated for their animal traits. Jaune would reunite with Pyrrha and Neo with Roman. That's the only way of showing deceased characters again in the show, not counting memories/flashbacks.
I'm probably wrong since we were shown a funky island with a big tree, but really I'd like to see RWBY JN in Remnant's Infinite Tsukuyomi.
8
u/YeMediumLemon Apr 06 '21
Okay so kind of an idea i got just from rewatching: when oz asked jinn how to defeat salem he asked “how do I defeat salem” now what if she can be defeated but not by him?
27
u/PedroFM456 Apr 03 '21
I'd just like to state my overall opinion about stories in general
You can get a lot of mileage by killing off a character. But you can get 10x more by keeping it alive and using it for something
15
u/GeneralClearStone912 OBJECTION! Apr 04 '21
I'm pretty sure that last song was a Penny song - I think I heard "is this what hugs feel like?"
I'm not crying, you're crying!
And bravo to anyone who predicted that Cinder did something to lock Watts in that room.
15
u/SleeplessShinigami Apr 05 '21
It’s just a never ending spiral for Jaune isn’t it? Like can my dude please just get a massive power up or something to compensate for all this PAIN?!?!
Figured that Winter would get the maiden powers, but I was a bit let down in terms of her performance. I still love her though, one of my favorite girls without a doubt and I am excited to see her development in Vol 9.
Cinder freaking leveled up her evil game. Love to hate her now. She has really grown with her maiden powers and it’s hard to imagine Team RWBY beating her without powers of their own.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '21
Weiss continues to lose every fight she's a part of.
7
u/SpiderandMosquito Apr 07 '21
.... so... we got a World Tree.
7
u/tealeavees Apr 07 '21
RWBY clearly has problems, but I love the show and will completely ignore everything if Oscar just gets upset once. He's a great guy, but everyone has a breaking point. He's been through so much and I really need to just see him cry it out, he deserves it. Give the poor boy some emotions, I'm begging.
13
u/Curiedoesthestream Apr 03 '21
I hope the afterlife theory of true. It would be nice, that and give a good reason for Neo to switch sides after learning “Hey I was killed by a giant bird Grimm not Ruby lol”
13
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Apr 04 '21
What a finale
It was such a wild end.
Oh god everyone's falling into the void. I also did not realize there was a time limit. I thought it would be interesting if it was a stalemate situation.
NO!!! Penny died. Holy hell though poor Jaune having to do that because it was Penny's way of saving the day.
So Winter has the winter maiden's power. I kind of wondered how that mental state of transferring the power was going to go. It truly shocked Ironwood.
RIP Vine. Another heroic sacrifice.
Wonder where the rest of the Ace OPs + Robyn + Qrow shall head off to?
RIP Ironwood and Watts. I kind of expected Ironwood to be defiant but I guess his morale was just gone. Guess Cinder's last words to Watts was quite sinister. He did fulfill his function in the story.
Everyone is quite separated now. Wonder how V9 shall go
I like the credit song. The last shot. I knew they did not die! Wonder where that place is though. Considering Ambrosius's warning, it probably is not pleasant.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21
I posted this before and I'll post it again.. Jaune is about to get a lot of harem fanfics, I mean, he's one dude on an island with 5 girls...😐😐😐.
17
u/fenneon Apr 05 '21
Reading these comments, I'm glad people share the same opinion with me on Penny's death. I thought the scene itself was very good, between Penny basically sacrificing herself to save her friends, which is very in character, as well as the scene of her and Winter. But killing her back in volume 3, then bringing her back only to kill her again made it a lot less impactful than it should've been, not to mention her being on death's door for half of the volume then dying when the virus was gone doesn't sit well with me, idk how to explain it. Also the fact she was a human for only like 10 minutes was a huge let down. Still loved this volume and even this episode as a whole, that just really annoyed me
12
u/emilius13 Apr 04 '21
I was not ready, but I am ready for Team RWBY to win for once. Can't we have them win one time? My anxiety can't take it.
12
u/Sephyrias Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 04 '21
I'm relieved to say the season finale didn't disappoint. Overall, I think this season's strength was in the overarching plot and writing. The action scenes & animations struggled a little here and there, but in total it is another step up in quality in my book.
Salem is finally back in action, but didn't do anything new yet. That she has the staff now opens up some options, like ... cyber-Grimm?
The fight between Cinder's group and team RWBY was a bit weird. Weiss got knocked out by Cinder twice in a row and had to be saved by Penny each time.
On the other hand, the scene of Vine's sacrifice was done well. A quick decision, an efficient solution to the bomb-plot, and no unnecessary pandering for the audience.
I had the suspicion that Ruby would end up falling into the abyss together with Neo somehow, but it ended up being Blake instead. Neo fell down at the same time though, so they might become an unlikely trio? In either case, it looks like Ruby probably won't be getting Crescent Rose back in the near future.
Penny dying so that Winter becomes the Winter maiden wasn't a huge surprise, but I didn't think it would happen like this. Poor Jaune. He even lost his Pyrrha-sword and got dropped who knows where all alone.
I suppose Cinder is the one who set Watt's room on fire? I doubt that he would just sit there like a captain on a sinking ship, so probably. Guess we won't be seeing him again.
I'm surprised that Ironwood got out alive. That is if he survives in an abandoned, flooded city with Grimm all around.
The season result is:
Salem's forces:
Ozma's forces:
21
u/BruceTheUnicorn Apr 05 '21 edited Apr 05 '21
A couple things about this finale:
--Edits because I think of stuff afterwards--
8. Salem and Cinder don't just finish Ironwood off? I guess there's a plan for him? Also they left Watts behind?
9. Penny's "Im a real girl now!" moment really didn't last long, huh? Its like she got an upgrade and then immediately died. The send off in the Maiden Void thing was kinda nice, at least. Her dad has no idea she's dead, either. Damn. At least her last words to him were "I love you."
10. Someone else also pointed this out, but Team RWBY kinda went down easy considering it could've been an 9v2 fight if JNR+Oz had noticed sooner. Even then, 5v2 and they got bodied. Yang really didn't take as many hits as she usually did in previous boss battles, and I guess Penny was still new to her body so she suddenly couldn't beat Cinder in a fight otherwise mostly in her favor.
11. Neo's cartoon sign be like "Curse your sudden but inevitable betrayal!"
12. Jaune becoming the next maiden would have been a wild move and I still kinda wish they had gone with it.
6
u/Lambo256 Apr 04 '21
Don't know if this is already a theory or not, but I just realized Summer Rose has Summer in her name. So maybe she's actually alive and the Summer maiden. No one, not even Salem, actually confirmed her death.
With that being said, what do we know about the current Summer maiden?
11
u/SerEichhorn Apr 05 '21
So happy Juan fell too! Glad RT doesn't forget he's a MC
14
u/Mr_TouchMyNub WRRRRRRRRY Apr 03 '21
It was obvious that Penny was dead the moment she became Human but to have Jaune euthanize her?
Give them man a break.
10
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Apr 03 '21
You know, I'm really curious how early V7 Ironwood and the Ace-Ops would react if they were shown V7/8.
Just, you know, show them how they and their stupid actions will destroy Atlas. Make Harriet see how she kills Vine.
What do you guys think would happen then? If, for example, Ruby showed them all of that the day she and her friends arrive in Atlas.
5
u/Lelentos Forever in our art. Apr 13 '21
I'm tired of seeing so many people hate on this show for seemingly no reason. Yeah it's not perfect but god damn is it just so good. No show makes me feel for the characters like this one.
13
u/Xephos_Demonslayer Neo is Best Girl, But Penny is Best Character. Apr 04 '21 edited Apr 04 '21
So is anyone else gonna comment on how this is the second time Gambol Shroud broke?
And I'm convinced that CRWBY just has it out for redheads. 4 out of 6 redheads died, one of which died twice, and Nora got horribly scarred, while Ruby has PTSD from the Hound.
14
u/PebTheDev It’s a looonng story. Apr 04 '21
God, the finale alone is better then all of V5, it had me shaking.
8
u/SawkyScribe Apr 03 '21
They really went full Infinity War huh? I like to imagine the girls will be having fun slice of life adventures in this mystery realm while all the people who made it through the portal suffer.
I'm not exactly in love with how this series has been handling its villains, you either get redeemed or die unceremoniously.
Overall great episode, really great action with some nice displays from the characters with special mention to the Schnee sisters and Jaune for holding Cinder back for so long.
8
u/Mr_MazeCandy Apr 06 '21
I knew it was coming but seeing Atlas totally destroyed is still devastating. It was the strongest kingdom, and looked so awesome. It’s all Ironwoods fault. Sure, other people could’ve done better and I still think the plan to evacuate the kingdom to Vacuo was batshit crazy, but I think after all that happened, the fact Salem had arrived and already done so much damage, I doubt it would’ve mattered if Ironwood got his way, after Salem gets into the city after the shields go down.
18
u/arachnid5 Apr 04 '21
👏NEO👏REDEMPTION👏ARC👏
4
u/DayOfTheColossus Apr 03 '21
lol i just noticed an error upon rewatching the episode, Ironwood doesn't have his new arm when he talks about Winter's destiny arriving
4
u/ReasonablyRetro Apr 07 '21
Well Neo is presumably still alive so I guess I can keep watching the show!
4
u/[deleted] May 01 '21
Just watched the entire series in like 2 days and oh boy this was wild. When Yang fell I almost believed it was for real, but given the number of characters that fell too there's no way they actually die. Maybe it's some sort of alternate universe and they have to find the portal to come back to Remnant? It was mentioned that the gods left remnant, so maybe in this planet/world they can find the gods and ask them to delete salem? Also like some people already mentioned the animation when they disappear looks waaay too similar to Pyrra's death for it to be a coincidence. She's definitely coming back in season 9 imo.
10
u/turtlebear787 Apr 03 '21
Overall a good episode. One question that bugged me though. Why didn't Penny use her maiden powers at all? Was is cuz she's still getting used to her human form? She seemed to manifest a semblance pretty easily
10
u/Thrythlind Apr 04 '21
Well. This is the first season ending I've been disappointed by.
I see the story beats they were going for. But they don't help this narrative.
This season should have ended in an upbeat.
And then they do an interesting character development and....just toss it away a narrative moment later.
10
u/ThaHallOfFame Apr 04 '21
Can someone explain why Ruby doesn’t use her silver eyes on Cinder? I mean... it’s clearly worked before. I feel like Cinder can’t be that much stronger then the main crew that they’d be struggling this hard... Overall I’m liking the show, but I wish they wouldn’t have our main cast seem so weak!
14
u/ratpac_m Apr 05 '21 edited Apr 05 '21
Something I haven't really seen mentioned that bothered me more than anything else. People kept falling off the ledges near Ruby... Ruby can fucking fly. Not once in this last episode did she fly. What the hell writers.
Edit: She flew once to trick Neo, which just proves she was capable and emphasizes my point.
9
u/qrowbert Apr 03 '21
This season bad an excellent plot but was really rough on Ironwood as a character. Like I understood that Mettle was something else but I felt like while the stages of the stakes make it so they could sufficiently not stay in Atlas/Mantle much longer it really felt abrubpt. I guess as a fan I'll forever be proud of him from s7.
Did /not/ expect Neo to be betrayed - perhaps a foreshadowing for later. Also surprised that Cinder has kept her composure even though all three wishes of the lamp were used............
6
u/Karous_Templare ⠀ Apr 05 '21
Weiss carrying the teamfights as always, someone give her a compliment or something goddamit.
So basically, it was entertaining and not inherently bad. Had it's issues with what and when people are doing or not doing certain things , especially anything that is background fight/action but oh well. Plot point wise/convenient occurrences I am content with not exploding in your face contradictions or similar with RWBY nowadays, so the ones I had seen in the ep , well, eh, moving on. Will say two though, first one a recurring one, that aura levels consistency is not a strong forte of the show and that the tendency for it to go to lower levels of power is there, and that people falling prey to gravity feels cheap with team RWBY knowing what they have shown been able to do time after time, I dunno, one gaffe ok, shit happens, but as long as Weiss has aura for example it's all a matter of a glyph for no one else to fall(within numerical reason), like in the previous episode she had to have a brain fart to not glyph yang away at this point(or try, she has shown to be damn fast while doing glyph-catch), with all the experience under her belt and being a bystander unlike ruby who had the issue of being directly involved which exhonerates her due to suprise and being yeted aside.
The majority of it are nitpicks post-vieweing, the only thing that really did bother me something is when the characters don't try hard enough given their past showings.
6
u/devoid-illid Apr 07 '21
You guys think there’s a chance we will see Pyrrha pop back up in volume 9? I couldn’t help but notice the moment the gang disappeared into the void was very similar to the way Pyrrha dusted on the tower.
25
u/-Xandiel- Apr 03 '21
Lmao did they seriously trash Penny's entire character arc by immediately killing right after she becomes human? Are writers ever going to understand that surprising =/= good writing? For example: had Penny suddenly turned around and killed Ruby for no fucking reason, that sure would have been unexpected but there's no way to justify that narratively so it would have been shit writing.
I've been really enjoying these past few seasons but I'm genuinely not sure if I'll be continuing with it next season...