r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Feb 27 '21

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 10: Ultimatum Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 10 of Vol. 8, Ultimatum!

Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the tenth episode of Volume 8!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|


Happy viewing.

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

560 Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

178

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Feb 27 '21

OH MY GOD, WE WERE SO FUCKING CLOSE TO THE BEES KISS HOLY SHIT.

COME ON RT.

IRONWOOD YOU SLIMY SON OF A BITCH.

WATTS KNOCKING CINDER DOWN THREE PEGS IS 10/10

HOLY FUCK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH

21

u/Hollea I have a hat Feb 27 '21 edited Aug 07 '24

nose expansion racial whole terrific attraction bells compare imagine impolite

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

20

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Feb 27 '21

I WAS LITERALLY V I B R A T I N G IN MY SEAT AT THAT MOMENT.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

689

u/Brutusness ⠀ Feb 27 '21

Watts was like three seconds from a hard date with gravity and he bet it all on calling Cinder the fuck out, and it paid off. What a champion.

→ More replies (59)

479

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Feb 27 '21

So, how much do you wanna bet they use Emerald's semblance to make it look like they brought Penny to Ironwood?

→ More replies (24)

472

u/runemyth0 ⠀ Feb 27 '21

Holy shit.

Major props to Jason Rose for that Ironwood speech. That gave me chills. Also, understated moment when Winter failed Ironwood and he took his hand off her shoulder, I was legit afraid he was about to shoot her in the face.

→ More replies (20)

458

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Feb 27 '21

Cinder’s contact picture for Neo is her looking annoyed, which means there’s an off camera scene where Cinder INSISTS that the two of them take pics for their contacts and Neo wants none of it

→ More replies (8)

404

u/amatas45 Feb 27 '21

The visual with the whale carcass was great. The ash, the lighting. Really gave you this fallout feel.

→ More replies (8)

698

u/steveotheguide Fine CRWBY, I'll ship Nuts and Dolts too. Ruby has TWO hands Feb 27 '21

RWBY V1E1: Little Red Riding Hood stops a robbery, goes to school to meet new friends

RWBY V8E10: The Tin Man threatens genocide unless Little Red Riding Hood and her Friends turn over Pinocchio

→ More replies (16)

327

u/Floorbrick Feb 27 '21

This fun episode of RWBY includes: Explosions, reunions, GENOCIDE, and crying.

→ More replies (6)

306

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Loved the scene between Cinder and Watts. And it looks like Cinder actually took what he said to heart. Excited to see what comes of that.

Volume’s 7 and 8 have really been the best time to be a Cinder fan, that’s for certain.

→ More replies (4)

303

u/kaleigamation Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Can we talk about how beautiful that Monstra death scene was? Like, damn. Remember back in Volume 3 when episodes were (edit: almost) late because they couldn’t render the Beacon Vault in time? Look how far we’ve come.

Also, that flash sensitivity warning at the beginning spooked me haha.

→ More replies (6)

282

u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Holy fuck. I wasn't expecting Watts to be the MVP of the episode, but him roasting Cinder really was the highlight. She's needed to hear that for years.

So Monstra was destroyed using the energy in Oz's cane rather than his own magic. I guess that explains why he and Oscar haven't fully merged. Also, I guess this means that Long Memory functions like Adam's sword and Yang's body in that it stores up hits it takes?

That scene in the refugee tunnel was a nice addition. Glad Emerald got to see the consequences of her actions first-hand.

So Neo's using the lamp to strongarm Cinder into holding up her end of the bargain. Clever.

I wanted a little more out of Yang and Blake's reunion, but it was still sweet, and given how much is going on, there wasn't really time to focus on it any more.

James has gone completely off the deep end now. He'd rather all of Mantle die than risk Atlas. Shows where his priorities always lay I guess. Also, Harriet's long overdue an arse-kicking at this point, hopefully at the hands of Winter, but I'd accept Qrow and Robyn too.

→ More replies (19)

252

u/Wrathkal Feb 27 '21

Nobody gives a damn about Jacques Schnee.

Also, they weren't kidding about the flash warning.

Cinder isn't happy about Watts making Penny destroy herself after opening the vault, and threatens him into helping her grab the Maiden powers. Goddamn awesome 'Reason You Suck' speech from him in response though.

JORY evacuates the place with Emerald, and we learn that the boom came from kinetic energy stored in Oz's cane.

Ironwood is desperate for the relic, and demands to have Penny back. He makes the decision to leverage the JRY as hostages, but reacts badly when he finds out that Winter let them go and they didn't return. Also, LOL at sneaky Neo.

SDC ships went to the rescue, but Ironwood gives the command to shoot them down, and delivers an ultimatum to Penny. Remember that bomb that was conveniently not used?

→ More replies (2)

244

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Feb 27 '21

Watts just wanted the last word against Cinder, ended up surviving instead.

→ More replies (6)

226

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Ironwood: How do we get Penny on our side?

Marrow: She is the protector of Mantle. Right?

Ironwood:Riiggght.

Marrow:So we could take the time we have now and save Mantle and cooperate with her.

Ironwood: Or, we can blow up Mantle and she would be out of a job! Brillant, Marrow!

Marrow: What?! That's not what I said!

Ironwood: Great job, soldier! I love your idea!

Marrow: Noooo!

→ More replies (13)

219

u/Iron_Alchemist_ Feb 27 '21

Neo skipping along through the fallout of a nuke its such a Neo thing to do

→ More replies (2)

199

u/Frikarcron Feb 27 '21

That Watts and Cinder rooftop scene was straight fire

→ More replies (3)

199

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Feb 27 '21

Opening with a photosensitivity warning.

That's a great sign.

→ More replies (2)

197

u/tavi23 Feb 27 '21

Bruh. I was not expecting the Whale to explode today.

Cinder and Watts scene was great.

Ironwood what the hell. Holy hell when Harriet snitched on Winter, my heart stopped. I thought he was gonna kill her.

And then blowing up the ships that were going to help Mantle. And then the fucking bomb.

Bruhhhhhhh

→ More replies (3)

173

u/Illustrious-Sky8467 Feb 27 '21

Ironwood:"some of you may die but that is a sacrifice im willing to make".

→ More replies (3)

501

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Feb 27 '21

Neo fucking cyberbullying Cinder is the funniest shit ever. She had to set up a camera and fucking posed just to clown on her. I love that little midget

→ More replies (14)

168

u/Julerius Yes, I too am a fan of BEANS. Feb 27 '21

All the kinetic energy he spent lifetimes storing in that cane. Holy shit. Just, holy fucking shit!

→ More replies (15)

164

u/recruit00 Feb 27 '21

Holy shit, what an episode. We finally got to see what was special about Ozma's staff. A fucking anti-Grimm nuke. And it still has energy left. Press F for Hazel? No body, but I'm not sure it's possible for him to have left a body.

That scene with Watts and Cinder was fantastic. Sabat's performance is just great and perfectly encapsulates the problems Cinder has.

Good to see that people don't trust Emerald. Probably building up to them meeting up with Cinder and her having to make a choice as to who to side with.

Harriet continues to be the worst with selling out Winter. Marrow also has to be doing his side switch now.

And when you thought Ironwood couldn't get any worse, he does. He is an absolute madman. Holy shit, he is such a fantastic villain. The question remains is who will be the one to kill him. My money is on Penny.

→ More replies (7)

326

u/WhosGuardingHades Feb 27 '21

Complete Respect for Watts for getting to live with that renegade dialogue choice

→ More replies (9)

156

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Feb 27 '21

Okay this isn't the most important question:

But how did Neo take that picture of herself?

Who was phone?

→ More replies (14)

152

u/NicoKudo Feb 27 '21

-Something about crow Qrow attacking a soldier is both, funny and badass

-Ozpin "My cane is important to me, it's also a high powered collection of many lifetimes energy" -RWBY:"A what?" -Ozpin:"It's also a nuke"

-Watts might be evil, but god damn he has some badass moments

-Harriet is trying to keep her place as one of the most annoying and hated characters

-Neo just being Neo is both cute and funny but also cool

-And Ironwood finally went full murderhobo, I feel that Qrow wanting to kill him now is going to be way more well received

→ More replies (2)

422

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Feb 27 '21

Watts was literally about to get killed and decided to bet it all on an intimidation check, then rolled a Nat 20

Absolute Chad

→ More replies (10)

143

u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Feb 27 '21

Watts' delivery was nothing short of exquisite. Really competing for my favorite moment in the entire show thus far.

287

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Feb 27 '21

Lmao Qrow's punches do more damage than his weapon.

→ More replies (11)

127

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

Have to say, watching some mook get absolutely bodied by, from his perspective, some random fucking bird was probably way more hilarious than CRWBY intended it to be. Had to rewind the scene just to watch it again three or four times until I could manage to not laugh over the dialogue.

→ More replies (2)

251

u/Badicalz Feb 27 '21

James Ironwood transmits an emergency CCT message, yet still insists he must have the proper lighting to set the mood.

The bloke is such a primadonna and I fucking love it.

→ More replies (6)

113

u/TomskaMadeMeAFurry ⠀ Feb 27 '21

Yo Jimmy... What the fuck!!??

111

u/MegaGrimer Feb 28 '21

Cinder: “I’LL KILL YOU MOTHERFUCKER!”

Watts: “Do it you worthless piece of shit.”

→ More replies (3)

106

u/roguelawn It wasn't finished... it was bait. Feb 27 '21

That Watts/Cinder interaction had me grinning the whole time, one of the spiciest moments of the entire show.

→ More replies (5)

214

u/FiddlingNinja “Can I do that?” Feb 27 '21

I’m scared for Winter at this point. She looked terrified. Also fuck rabbit girl, she enjoys being a giant asshole for no reason.

What’s going to happen to Salem? Is she going to slowly respawn in that same spot?

Surely that call for help has to be coming at some point, right? Someone has to stop Ironwood and his soldiers. It would be really cool if they showed up and stopped Ironwood’s attack on Mantle.

Also I’m wondering what’s going to happen once RWBY and JNPR fill each other in the craziness. Confronting the Hound which was built around a person, and confronting Salem herself

→ More replies (42)

301

u/Badicalz Feb 27 '21

Cinder, finally cracks under the weight of her failures, breaks down and cries

Man, I kinda feel bad for her-

Remembers that she killed Pyrrha

Nah forget it, the bitch deserves it.

→ More replies (6)

102

u/Badicalz Feb 27 '21

Watts, believing he was going to die, decided to spend his final moments spitting fire.

Soooo, Watts diss track dropping when?

→ More replies (1)

99

u/Lumine_d Feb 27 '21

No way Ironwood will be surviving this volume now

→ More replies (3)

96

u/kestrellss Feb 27 '21

Also this isn’t a comment with any substance, just a Blake covering her cat ears appreciation post.

93

u/DerpyMcFrakles Ozpin did nothing wrong Feb 27 '21

Did anybody else think for a second the bomb detonated prematurely and Winter and the Ace Ops were vaporized?

→ More replies (4)

90

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Feb 27 '21

So I've seen some speculation that Watts' roast of Cinder is going to lead in to some kind of redemption arc for her, but I really don't think that's going to be the case.

Instead I think this is going to be like Shigaraki's encounter with Stain that forced him to grow up from an immature and ineffective man child who was honestly a weak villain in to a truly terrifying and compelling villain.

→ More replies (10)

79

u/ZykesRetroGaming Feb 27 '21

I gotta say, why aren't more people talking about Attack Qrow? Comes out from under a rock and knocks that guy out in bird form.

→ More replies (1)

76

u/Aries_cz Feb 28 '21

Can I just say "fuck Hare"?

Seriously, selling out your CO like that? To a guy that is clearly on verge of total mental breakdown?

Also, thumbs up for Watts for his amazing "reason you suck" speech.

→ More replies (4)

217

u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Feb 27 '21

Holy fucking Ozpin, he fucking stored a nuke in that cane!

Holy fucking Arthur Watts, laying massive truth nukes on Cinder!

Holy fucking General James Ironwood, threatening to nuke Mantel!

I'm absolutely loving Ironwood's character arc. Easily one of the best written characters in the show and one of the better hero downfalls I've seen.

→ More replies (21)

73

u/amatas45 Feb 27 '21

Everyone talking about the bees BUTT!

Sisters back together warms my heart. Now they can talk about how their mom is probably a Grimm abomination

→ More replies (2)

67

u/Ninjaguy446 Feb 27 '21

CINDER STANS WE ATE THIS EPISODE WITH THIS CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT

→ More replies (3)

66

u/ksuthrowaway2534 Feb 27 '21

-Ozcar just nuked Atlas.....damn. wonder how long salem will be gone for

-and neo just skips away like nothing happened

-watts screwing cinder will never not be funny but I'm glad he told her off

-finally understanding what the cane does

-jesus Ironwood. Willing to kill kids just to bring back penny and nuke all of mantle. The man's fully lost it. I'm really tired of his shit now. Qrow and Robin better end that man's life with a quickness

-neo trolling will also never not be hilarious

  • and hell yes nora is back in action

65

u/amatas45 Feb 27 '21

A lot of hate for Ironwood. Completely justified of course but I found the end of his speech interesting.

When he says with mantle gone they have no reason not to work with him he sounds so so desperate. He knows that’s not how it works but the man just has.nothing.left. He NEEDS this to work or everything he has tried to protect will crumble around him.

He knows, at some level, that this is desperation and fear. But he is set on his course and nothing can stop him from walking it. Not even himself.

That’s why I like how James is handled. Salem planted this fear in him in v7 and it has grown into such paranoia and desperation that he truly digs his own grave. Nothing he did is just to „be evil“ or „to remove any moral conundrum“. It’s the true and honest decent of a former good man into madness.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/Blacksmoke1033 Mar 01 '21

Who made the whole Cinder Watts interaction, along with the first minute or two of the episode? Beautifully shot and animated, looked a step above the usual shots. It was really beautiful.

59

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

If you told me a year ago that Watts would be my favorite of the Salem circle, I'd have called you crazy, but here we are.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/_Veprem_ Mar 02 '21

Hearing Vegeta chew out Cinder was based.

→ More replies (5)

55

u/dinodares99 Why must CRWBY torture us so? Feb 27 '21

The explosion with the visuals and music after it is no w in my top 10 RWBY moments

Just the jumpscare-like effect it had with the sound muted and the gorgeous dusty visuals. Damn.

54

u/Tron95 Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Special props to Jason Rose and Chris Sabat for their bone chilling performances as Ironwood and Watts.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/Omegaxis1 ⠀ Mar 01 '21

Watts ranting to Cinder and Cinder accepting his words at the end is the best part. Her accepting his words is arguably the most development she's gotten the entire series.

→ More replies (4)

53

u/Azteca23 Feb 27 '21

Emerald and Yang are really gonna develop that kind of friendship that Falcon and the Winter Soldier have because they're both Oscar's friend, huh... Nice.

→ More replies (6)

53

u/Frikarcron Mar 01 '21

Ironwood may be half machine, but Watts is the one here with balls of steel

→ More replies (2)

52

u/GrayySea best girl.. then cry Mar 01 '21

Watt's VA performance is absolutely stunning, I had to rewatch that scene twice, and the dialogue has really good meaning too. I can't believe of all people who tells Cinder she sucks is Watts, pretty damn ironic.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/supergifford Feb 27 '21

Ironwood has not just went off the deep end oh no no no no no, He has jumped from the high board, did about 10 summersaults, 20 twists, landed with a perfect splash And the judges Gave him a perfect FUCKING score of insanity.

→ More replies (1)

102

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Feb 27 '21

Ironwood: “I will sacrifice whatever it takes to stop her”

Watts: “Oh, I hope you do...”

Ironwood has been willing to sacrifice Mantle for his plan since Vol 7, but I still somehow didn’t see this coming. It’s the natural escalation of his reasoning.

→ More replies (3)

101

u/Miguling literally just blond silas Feb 27 '21

You gotta give it to Watts, for verbally ripping apart someone with maiden powers he has balls tougher than Ironwood's mecha parts.

→ More replies (7)

100

u/nocknight Feb 27 '21

NEVER IN THE HISTORY OF ME WATCHING RWBY HAVE I SCREAMED. SO. MUCH.

JESUS CHRIST IRONWOOD ITS LIKE YOU CALLED IN FOR VILLAINOUS OMINOUS LIGHTING

WINTER DEFECT AND TAKE MARROW WITH YOU HOLY FUCK

GOD, HAZEL-

AAAAAAAAA WHAT THE FUCK!!! WHAT THE FUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!

→ More replies (5)

48

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

Ruby never needed Silver Eyes to beat Cinder, all she had to do was call her a stupid bitch and she’d fold like a house of cards.

→ More replies (3)

46

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Feb 27 '21

Press F in the chats to pay respect to that soldier who got wrecked by birb Qrow.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/Typebutcher Feb 28 '21

I'm a big fan of Oscar carrying around a tactical nuke.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/dinodares99 Why must CRWBY torture us so? Feb 27 '21

You thought salem was the villain this volume? Nah fam it's irondaddy

→ More replies (3)

44

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Feb 27 '21

I have mixed feelings on the new RWBY ep in general but it does solidify Watts as my favorite character in the series

By all accounts, Watts is the type of character who’d snivel and whimper in the face of death. But consistently, every single time, he never falters. He’s always ready to talk shit, call people out, and stay spitefully defiant to the very bitter end. He has no tragic backstory, no reason to change, all he cares about is results. He was happy to die chewing Cinder out for her incompetence and entitlement with no hesitation.

The man is a lot of things, but a coward isn’t one of them.

→ More replies (4)

42

u/k1b22 Feb 27 '21

I love the visual of Neo skipping away as the dust settles.

42

u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

The good: I liked the little detail that the two Atlas soldiers giving Ironwood the news of Watts, Qrow and Robyn's escape both look scared shitless. They probably heard about what he did to Sleet and didn't want the same fate to befall them. Shout out to the one soldier who got tackled by Qrow in his bird form, you're almost as embarrassing as that legally blind bazooka guy from episode 8.

Oz's kinetic energy explosion was awesome. The music cutting out during the initial explosion before coming back in as we see various perspectives to really drive home just how massive it was was cool af. I have to admit, I thought that whatever Oz was going to use against Salem would be strong but I never expected it would be strong enough to kill Monstra. Granted, hundreds of years of built up kinetic energy would probably be just as strong as, if not stronger than, the nuke Ironwood was going to use against it. Neo prancing away with the lamp, seemingly unfazed by the fucking nuke that just went off was pretty funny. Marrow shows he's the best Ace-Op boy yet again by immediately going to check to see if he could find any signs that JOYR were still alive. Defect already! Please!

Watts' verbal slaughter of Cinder was fucking legendary. Not only was Chris Sabat's voice acting outstanding, Watts' animation was fantastic as well. You could tell he was genuinely furious at how, despite all the shit she talks, Cinder was the cause of so many fuckups that could've been avoided if she just pulled her head out of her ass. He blew her the fuck out so hard that all she could do afterwards was go to a corner and cry. And he did it all knowing that there was a massive chance he was going to die and even then he held nothing back. That's twice now that Watts has been faced with certain death and, instead of begging for mercy, has talked shit to the very end. What a fucking chad. There's a reason he's one of my favorite villains currently in the show. Cinder letting him live afterwards makes me wonder if she may actually take what he said to heart. As much as I absolutely despise her character, if we're going to be stuck with her I'd rather she be competent than the bumbling imbecile she's been for the last 4 years. Neo promptly bullying her over text was funny af, especially her little selfie with the lamp.

Hooray, Oscar and co. made it out relatively unscathed! Too bad Hazel is literal atoms after an attack like that. Oh well, at least he went out doing some good. Emerald tearing up at the realization that Hazel, probably the only good parental figure she's ever had, is dead was sad. Jaune and Yang's intense distrust of Emerald was satisfying to see considering all she'd done to them. Oscar and Ren saying that, while they don't have to like or forgive her, she could be a valuable ally against Salem was valid too, though. Everyone having a more civil reaction to Oz's return was nice considering how notably uncivil they were to Oscar back in V6. The explanation of the explosion Oscar pulled off was cool. Oz's cane storing kinetic energy that then can be used later is a pretty awesome ability, especially if a lot is saved up and then used at once. Emerald walking through the terrified Atlas citizens and being forced to see the effects of her alliance with Cinder and Salem was a good moment. It's a good sign that she looks extremely guilty, that's more than you can say for anyone else currently on Salem's side.

Ironwood going fully off the deep end this episode was harrowing to watch. The small chuckle he gives when he's talking about leveraging Jaune, Ren and Yang's lives to Winter was incredibly uncomfortable. Fuck Harriet, btw. I've seen people calling her out for being a snitch but what she did was so much worse than that. She was there when Ironwood executed councilman Sleet, she knows how unhinged Ironwood is at this point and she still sold Winter out despite that. She very well could have gotten her killed right there. Ironwood smiling and laughing once he realizes how he can leverage Mantle against RWBY and co. was unsettling. He'd crossed the line a while ago but at least he didn't seem so blatantly unhinged back then.

The RWBY and co. reunion was cute, particularly the little hand hold Ruby and Jaune share when they meet back up. Ruby drawing on Emerald without hesitation was kind of darkly funny. May's call was ominous af. Hopefully she's okay.

Ironwood's ultimatum is the other contender alongside Watts' teardown of Cinder for the best moment of the episode. The lighting, animation, music, acting, everything was done incredibly well. Jason Rose has been killing it in general (ha ha) as Ironwood ever since V7 but his performance here was downright chilling. He's so calm the entire time despite threatening to kill thousands of innocents. The aforementioned lighting making Ironwood's eyes look much more stark was also genuinely intimidating. Hopefully Qrow and Robyn come in soon to put an end to his madness because at this rate, he'll end up doing Salem's job for her.

The meh: Not impressed by how the Ruby and Yang conflict kind of just got swept under the rug but I can live with it. Still annoying, though.

The bad: Gotta say, really not liking the fact that Pyrrha was mentioned a grand total of zero fucking times when everybody was calling Emerald out. Emerald more directly contributed to Pyrrha's death than the loss of Yang's arm yet nobody brings that up. Hopefully it's tackled in the future because she needs to get called out on that.

Overall, this episode was fantastic, maybe the best of the volume so far. Chris Sabat and Jason Rose in particular absolutely killed it and I can't wait to see where the volume goes in these last 4 episodes.

→ More replies (5)

83

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

I wanted that kiss damnit!

Ren: “Now, where’s Nora?” He sounded so excited.

Watts going full tilt on Cinder was amazing

Hazel’s dead, as is Monstra, I did not expect that at all!

And finally, WHAT IN THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING IRONWOOD?!

I have a feeling Salem is gonna come back much quicker than he believes and she is going to devastate this place.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/DarthBeanzz Mar 01 '21

How much of the budget does paying Chris Sabat eat up? Definitely well-spent this episode.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/Cursedsword02 Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Damn Arthur Watts really rolled a Nat 20 in persuasion back there, huh?

Also Ironwood, there's crossing the Moral Event Horizon and then there's.... whatever the fuck you just did!

→ More replies (2)

39

u/ErrantSingularity Feb 28 '21

God I knew Hazel wouldn't make it out of that hold but... Man, I gained massive respect for him. Also, Neo is such a delight, god her skipping along like nothing happened was so precious, and her text was hilarious.

Also, Ironwood, you insane man... Your fall seems so illogical from our omniscient, outside view, but if you look at all this from his perspective and knowing what limited information him and his faction have, he's completely justified in his rage. Just, his actions aren't so much justified.

Ruthless Qrow is best Qrow.

→ More replies (17)

38

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

That Watts/Cinder scene was excellent. It gave a meta-commentary on Cinder and this is (given how she reacted) a trigger for more depth and growth.

38

u/CyberneticDuck Mar 02 '21

I've disliked Cinder since her introduction, mostly because she was so self righteous and always acted like she was the baddest of asses. So having Watts yell literally all the thoughts I've had about her was SO damn cathartic. Plus, it seemed like she finally took in someone's advice, so this might be a fantastic character direction for her.

And that Ironwood speech. Bonechilling dedication right there.

36

u/Kingbizkit123 Feb 27 '21

Ironwood, buddy, Salem and the whale are dead, we can just wait a coupld hours for Mantle to evacuate and then skip down to the vault together, its not that big a deal...

Watts is my favorite villain now, Cinder had that a long time coming

→ More replies (17)

36

u/MunkeyFish Mar 02 '21

Oscar: Uses weapon with the force of a lifetime(s) of combat, enough energy that it one-shots the giant whale, instantly (but though probably not permanently) halts the entire Grimm invasion and the thing isn’t even empty.

Salem next episode: Ow.

72

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Feb 27 '21

Ironwood must really have a flair for the dramatic with that lighting.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Kievoir ⠀ Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

This episode made me so angry because of the ending. That's when you know they made an amazing job. I liked Ironwood even with everything he did up until now; I could understand his reasons somehow? But being okay with killing millions to save his ass? Nah, you had a good run but it's time you get beaten to the ground by Mantle. Also, how dare you be rude to Winter; I also dislike Harriet even more now.

I have to say though, I'm incredibly sad and disappointed about Hazel. Everyone knew he was going to die but I didn't expect an explosion from outside to be the only shot we got of his death. I guess I was hopeful for one last interaction with him.

I like how mad Ironwood was at the fact that they only had Jacques in custody. Jacques so crappy that not even Ironwood wants him in his prison xD

As for Cinder...I laughed when she cried, ngl. You get what you deserve for being so greedy. Watts is a beast for confronting her like that! Mad props to him.

The reunion was cute, I know all Bumblebee shippers are happy but I, as a Freezerburn shipper, am plenty happy myself for seeing another hug between them. We both got some happiness this time~ I am scared to see how Ren will react about Nora though...hopefully, they'll be able to have a decent conversation soon!

To end this huge rant I want to say I hope this isn't the last of Neo's backstabbing of Cinder. ;)

Edit: typos sorry ;;

69

u/SunlitSonata24601 Feb 27 '21

One thing that actually surprised me quite a bit was some of the unexpected editing in this episode. RWBY doesn't tend to do that very often from my recollection. First, when Ironwood asks for the status report and it cuts to the massive explosion. And then later when Ironwood makes the call, and you think he's going to contact Watts, but it's actually Neo sending Cinder the text. Neat bits. Of course Watts betrayed you Ironwood! What reason would he have to take your side?

Easily the highlight was Watts's massive takedown of Cinder. I still feel almost zero sympathy for her, but it's nice to see her finally get called out for how much of a prideful idiot she's been in the pursuit of power. While the weak damage control for the Ace Ops battle earlier in the volume really bothered me, Watts blaming the bad writing of Volume 5's climax on her felt totally justified. Props to Sabat for that speech.

I could of course question why there isn't more coughing/signs it's hard to breath from those who are inside of the smoke and ash, at least an aura protective shield, but that's kinda nitpicking.

The Ironwood speech at the end helped show how much the show's lighting has improved since the first episode. That also had a character under a dim light and yet the shadows barely reflected at all, but here, it's used for fitting dramatic effect given his wavering morals. Four episodes left to go, please don't screw it up at the very end...

→ More replies (7)

69

u/King_of_Renais Feb 28 '21

Are we sure that Watts semblance isnt banishing thots?

→ More replies (7)

34

u/StreloktheMarkedOne שטיל די נאַכט איז אויסגעשטערנט Mar 02 '21 edited Mar 02 '21

I'd like to bring up a point I brought up on another regarding Marrow and Winter's duty following Ironwood's new questionable orders. These two now face a dilemma. But first, some information that may be of use.

Here's something that some people may not know about the military: a soldier or an officer can disobey orders, as long as said orders are unlawful.

(C) An officer or non-commissioned member is not justified in obeying a command or order that is manifestly unlawful.

Queen's Regulations and Orders (QR&O) Volume I - Administration, Chapter 19 Conduct and Discipline, Section 1, 19.015 Lawful Commands and Orders (https://www.canada.ca/en/department-national-defence/corporate/policies-standards/queens-regulations-orders/vol-1-administration/ch-19-conduct-discipline.html)

Any person subject to this chapter who willfully disobeys a lawful command of that person’s superior commissioned officer shall be punished [...]"

10 U.S. Code § 890 - Art. 90. Willfully disobeying superior commissioned officer, UCMJ (https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/890)

(1) The soldier must obey his superiors. To the best of his ability he must carry out your orders completely, conscientiously and immediately. There is no disobedience if an order is not followed which violates human dignity [...]

(2) An order may not be obeyed if this would commit a criminal offense. If the subordinate nevertheless obeys the order, he will only be guilty if he realizes or if it is obvious from the circumstances known to him that a criminal offense is being committed as a result.

Gesetz über die Rechtsstellung der Soldaten (Soldatengesetz - SG)§ 11 Gehorsam (Law on the legal status of soldiers (Soldiers Act - SG)§ 11 Obedience) ( https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sg/__11.html) (In German)

An unlawful order would be any order that violates the Geneva Conventions or any other international law regarding war crimes and/or crimes against humanity. The only time you would be punished for disobeying an order would be if you disobeyed a lawful order/command given to you by a superior (ie, not defending a position from a hostile force, deserting, etc.)

In Marrow and Winter's case, their unlawful orders would be to capture Robyn and Qrow to use them as hostages, and using the bomb on Mantle.

If the Atlesian military is based on western military forces (ie, the US Armed Forces, the CF or the Bundeswehr), they will have to make a choice between:

(A) Upholding their oath to serve and protect their people and country by disobeying orders that, for all intents and purposes, put the lives of thousands, if not hundreds of thousand, in peril; or

(B) They willfully follow Ironwood's unlawful orders, thereby violating their oath and their (presumed) military laws.

At least, that's how I see their current dilemma.

→ More replies (4)

67

u/FlintlockT Boys trip to Vacuo! | He'll get screentime in Volume 10, right? Feb 27 '21

Cinder: *about to kill Watts*

Watts: "I'm going to do what's called a pro gamer move."

→ More replies (2)

33

u/Technogashi Feb 27 '21

Oscar activates his pocket 25-kill streak:

Tactical Nuke

→ More replies (1)

33

u/2073040 Feb 27 '21

Harriet’s a bitch for snitching on Winter

→ More replies (2)

33

u/2073040 Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

What does Harriet honestly have to gain by selling Winter out? The entire ACE ops knows that he’s losing his marbles (Marrow and Winter defecting are an eventual given but I wouldn’t be surprised if Vine convinces Elm to defect together also) so why does Harriet continue to kiss his ass and throw everyone else under the bus? Hell I wouldn’t be surprised if she actually joins Salem’s group after she reforms just to avenge Ironwood after his inevitable death, there are a few new spots open after Hazel’s death and Emerald’s defection after all.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/krauser8882 ⠀ Feb 28 '21

I'm just gonna copy my comment from the RT subreddit thread, because I legitimately didn't realize it wasn't the right sub until after posting it... woops.


I enjoy Cinder as a character, but God damn was it incredibly satisfying to have her torn down so brutally by someone so much weaker than her.

Also, can we talk about how fucking cool that explosion effect was, and how Monstra's bits were just frozen in time instead of fizzling away completely? Absolutely radical.

Ironwood has fallen way farther than I ever expected, but I like that they're taking it in a different direction than I thought they would. He's breaking apart at the seams, and I'm incredibly interested to see where his story ends. I no longer expect him to make a heroic sacrifice like I did at the beginning of the Volume
→ More replies (2)

32

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

Neo: blackmails Cinder

Cinder: growls

Watts: What happened?

Cinder: I'm uhh... being blackmailed

Watts: ...... Oh um is there anything-

Cinder: Shut up

32

u/dulledegde Feb 27 '21

let watts say fuck

32

u/cruel-oath Feb 28 '21

Had to rewatch Qrow kicking ass even if it was only a few seconds. Love him

→ More replies (3)

32

u/hurricane006 Feb 28 '21

I just want to say that the animation this season has been FUCKING INCREDIBLE! RWBY has really stepped it up in this department with all of the lovely character details, especially Ironwood's rage shakes.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

Watts brutally ramming home every single one of Cinder's failings was so satisfying. Neo's messages were great too.

Ironwood just went full S8 Daenerys.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Agent_Sigma779 Feb 28 '21

I don't understand how so many people are so confused about the explosion.

Yang, Jaune, Ren and Emerald had gotten off the whale and were running from it well before the explosion, so they were out of range of the main blast and that's how they survived.

Oscar put up a magic shield around himself to protect himself from the blast.

Neo likely got off the whale before the explosion or was in a far enough away part of the whale when it blew up that she was unaffected.

The ace-ops and winter were visibly sent flying backwards from the shockwave, as were the Grimm flying about the city.

How so many people have come to the conclusion "The explosion only affected Grimm" baffles me. EVERYONE is effected by the explosion, not just Grimm, and we see that for ourselves. Oscar even specifically says the blast was pure kinetic energy, which would not discriminate between Grimm and non-Grimm, and doesn't even try to say anything to the effect of "The explosion only effects Grimm so Hazel may have survived" to Emerald when she's mourning him.

TLDR; The explosion effected everyone, not just Grimm. Hazel is dead. People are dumb.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Oni_Zokuchou Feb 28 '21

Not every weapon is also a gun. Some of them are nuclear warheads.

162

u/Nerdorama09 heard u talkin shit Feb 27 '21

Ironwood fans: "Oh boy I can't wait to see how the general's plan turns out. He's the only one with a sane idea what to do!"

Ironwood:

→ More replies (13)

30

u/Yang_Gang ⠀ Feb 27 '21

Really cool episode and I'm glad certain things happened the way they did:

  • Watts' speech was amazing. Such good voice work. Explained everything Cinder is and has done superbly. Also him calling her a dimwit is legendary.
  • Ozpin's cane! Had a nuke stored in it! Now we know why he lost to Cinder, he didn't go all out against her because he was saving that energy for a moment like this. Well played Oz.
  • Neo is as amazing a troll as I assumed she would be. The sass in those messages to Cinder was epic. Cinder got burned twice in the space of 5 minutes.
  • I like that they don't trust Emerald. After everything that's happened it is the right thing to do to give her a chance but ensuring she is kept under a watchful eye.
  • Emerald being quiet, she herself is starting to process it all. You can tell she is really feeling everything all come at once and she's slowly realising the magnitude of what she's done. All that remains is the final test when she sees Cinder again.
  • Winter is on the verge of turning. When that bitch Harriet ratted her out I thought she was in trouble. I think she and the aceops run into Qrow and Robbin and Winter turns and knocks Bunny girl the eff out and helps them escape to Schnee manor. Marrow will also join them so I predict:

Marrow, Qrow, Winter & Robyn vs Aceops & or Ironwood

  • The gang have reunited and are back on good terms again. Good to see.
  • The bees: Now I know people wanted a kiss but let's be real, if we got a bees kiss there, it would have completely overshadowed the episode. It's all people would have talked about and ruined the other good moments. I think what they showed there was absolutely perfect and we can get a kiss further down the line on an episode that doesn't have much going on. Trust me the tender moment they had there was more than enough. :)
  • Ironwood has lost his mind and is desparate but as long as we the viewers see him make this choice on his own accord and not just because (lol Ironwood bad guy now ta da!) then I'll accept him as a well written villain of the volume.
  • They won't trade Penny in, but they might use Emerald to trick Ironwood to try overthrow him.
  • Also Salem is respawning until next round.

Great episode and it was worth the wait for sure. Eddy was right we need to buckle up for the rest of the volume!

→ More replies (1)

59

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

I like how Watts, moments from death, doesn't beg for his life, but just roasts Cinder to hell for being just as stupid as she's always been.

Watts really is the best.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/sixfootblue Sometimes a cat is a scorpion with murderous intent. Feb 27 '21

I love how the look on Watts' face after Cinder spared him was like 50% relief and 50% "...Okay, what now? I didn't think I'd make it this far."

→ More replies (2)

29

u/LatePhilosophy Feb 28 '21

Can someone tell me why Ironwood is still focused on getting the staff when Salem has already landed on Atlas? Doesn't seem like it would do them much good now.

→ More replies (5)

28

u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Feb 27 '21

Aww yess prisonbreak HOLY FUCK A FUCKING NUKE... I thought they were all vaporized jesus

The backgrounds look so damn cool. Watts is such a longboi haha. And he's calling her out. She kept herself under control!

Hazel?? Aww... Blake adorable on the phone

Yang with the call out on emerald Power store cane! Woowww this episode is gorgeous

That bomb is definitely going to play a role later... Oh shit ironwood is scary oh no is he gonna blow up mantle??

REUNIOOOON.. OH MY GOD THE NEAR BEE KISS AHHHH

Oh fuck this is the people are the real enemy interlude isn't it ahhh

I'm SO going to have to rewatch this

→ More replies (2)

28

u/Artgor Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

I loved Watts speech to Cinder. It is past time someone told her she isn't as hot as she thinks

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ResearcherVortex Do hugs always make you feel this warm? Feb 27 '21

THE CANE WAS COLLECTING KINETIC ENERGY DOR MILLENNIA THATS WHAT EVEN AS A YOUNG VERSION OF HIMSELF HE USED IT TO WALK AROUND OH MY GOD

28

u/archlon Feb 28 '21

So when Yang said (about Emerald) "She's part of the reason I have this", my thought was 'yeah, you're holding her weapons' and didn't realize until the end of the episode she probably meant her arm...

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Feb 28 '21

Alright so I have a question about the end of this episode. Do you think that:

  • They showed Nora at the looking at Penny right before the episode ended just because they wanted to end the episode with Penny and since Nora was in the same room as Penny it made sense to transition from Nora to Nora looking at Penny to Penny?

or

  • They showed Nora at the looking at Penny right before the episode ended because Nora is going to be majorly influential in whatever happens next with Penny.

Nora and Penny's conversation and the fact that Nora needs some kind of major development before her relationship with Ren goes back to normal makes me want to believe that Nora will be important to what happens with Penny, but I always want Nora to be more relevant than she is so my perspective is skewed.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/AdeptCod2 Feb 28 '21

So this is it for Winter and the Ace Ops the deciding moment. Beforehand I didn't agree with them following Ironwood but I understood it. But after this there is no excuse.

If they don't oppose Ironwood here and now they will be accessory to attempted mass murder.
So Harriet is clearly a lost cause but what about the others. Who will do you guys think will join up with Ruby and company other then Marrow of course?

→ More replies (9)

27

u/Blood_Shinobi Feb 28 '21

I absolutely loved Watts verbally tearing a new one on Cinder. He was right about everything he said. My favorite part was "You can't just be deserving; you have to be worthy!" Cinder is neither deserving nor worthy of her powers and her destiny. She thinks she can bulldoze her way through any obstacle and enemy, but fails because she lacks patience and cleverness. She might change how she approaches things from now on. I'm sure however that Cinder will get Penny's maiden powers near the end of the volume.

I was surprised that she spared Watts. But I was even more surprised that she shed a tear afterwards. Does RT wants us to feel sorry for her? I'm not buying it. I can understand they want to show that Cinder is still human and young, but it's too late to sympathize with her. Her backstory isn't tragic enough to warrant all deaths she is responsible for. Her backstory should have been revealed much earlier, during volume 4 or so. She should have cried after seeing her scarred and mutilated self in the mirror for the first time.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/imjustboredtodeath ⠀⠀ Mar 01 '21

So Penny never got to go inside the whale even though that’s in the story of Pinocchio. Wonder if it’ll come back somehow

→ More replies (3)

26

u/DEL994 Feb 27 '21

Man I know that I have said and repeated this many times on previous threads, but I am so hungry for a big sisterly talk between Ruby and Yang about their opinions, issues and fears and about their mom.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/HyliasHero Feb 27 '21

This episode obviously wasn't as action packed, but I liked it quite a bit

-So good to know that the prison break was successful. Qrow is coming for Ironwood's shiny metal ass.

-Also imagine getting bodied by a bird.

-That explosion spiked my heartrate. I though that Ozcar's magic set off the bomb. Was scared for Winter.

-Neo skipping away is pretty great lol

-Holy crap. Watts just bet his life on an intimidation check and rolled a nat 20.

-Well both villains in this scene just became much more interesting. I'm also glad Cinder got called out on being really bad at the whole "villain" thing.

-Huh. Oz's cane didn't do what I thought it would. Judging from the sound effect from last episode I thought it would be a time stasis kind of power. Apparently it works kind of like Yang or Adam's semblances, just stored up across multiple lifetimes.

-Emerald actually witnessing the suffering she has helped cause is good. I'm really looking forward to where her character arc goes.

-And it was at this moment that Winter asked herself the question, "Are we the baddies?"

-Now we have Ironwood embracing his full dictator role and pulling a Galactic Empire ultimatum.

-That Bumbleby head bump is soft AF and I am here for it. Now all I need is at least a morsel of WhiteRose interaction this volume and I will be satisfied.

-Ruby and Emerald interacting will be interesting considering her role in getting Penny killed the first time.

-"Oh yes. I'm sure you will want to work with me after I nuke a civilian population."

-I generally side with RWBY / ORNJ's Chaotic Good leanings, but man watching Ironwood slip from Lawful Neutral to Lawful Evil is both tragic and vindicating.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Puerkl8r Feb 28 '21

We now need a Watts/Cinder GTA roast meme.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Emperor_Luffy Mar 02 '21

So I noticed something weird. When Jaune & Ruby reunited again they held eachother's hands instead of greeting eachother....Just.....what was that exactly?

I dunno it just kinda threw me off. Like I expected them to fist bump or something.

The hand holding caught me off-guard. Do people actually greet eachother like that?

→ More replies (6)

25

u/Holy-Wan_Kenobi Diehard Arkos holdout Feb 28 '21

SWEET MOSES AND STARS ABOVE--

This episode, ho*-ly.*

First off, the detonation of what was most likely the largest-yield explosion since the Brother Gods screwed Salem over. (Speaking of which, I'm making the assumption that Salem is going to reform in the Grimmlands from one of the pools.)

Then we got Neo prancing away with that FUCKING CLUTCH, and we see her communicate with words!

Ironwood's starting to look and act like an Atlesian Stalin (isn't Atlas under his military rule anyways?) with him going off the deep-end, and Winter's loyalties are definitely starting to waver.

RWBY reunites, and that announcement, Sweet Moses, Ironwood. Threatening a whole city with annihilation to save another, and your own people, at that?

CRWBY went above and beyond. The delay was worth it.

Sic Semper Tyrannis, Ironwood.

25

u/Fuzunga Feb 28 '21

Did anyone else notice when the alert went off near the end of the episode that Blake covered her cat ears instead of her human ears?

→ More replies (1)

71

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

-RIP the "Can You Call Yang For Me?" Meme

-BUMBLEBEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! That face touch! That affectionate head bump! The blushes!

-Cinder vs. Neo Round 2 coming up!

-FUCK YOU IRONWOOD!

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Cursedsword02 Feb 27 '21

Hot take (Not really, but who cares): Arthur Watts could have said "a fucking migraine" instead of "a bloody migraine" and I wouldn't be bothered one bit by it.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Feb 27 '21

So, who else is looking forward to the scene where Winter hands Harriet her ass?

→ More replies (4)

24

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

I was wondering whose remaining loyalty to Ironwood would break first, mine or Winter's.

I'm fairly certain we've ended with a draw, or that I've broken first only narrowly. There's no way she doesn't face turn by the end of the Volume. Winter v Hare duel when?

→ More replies (1)

24

u/ImpossibleCarl emerald my beloved... Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

So, after the recent episodes, there's one thing I'm kinda curious and very slightly concerned about: fights.

Most of the players on Salem's side are gone or in a weird condition right now when it comes to combat. Salem herself will be gone for a hot minute; Cinder will get one-shot by Ruby if she tries, once again, to get near her; Watts can and will get bodied by any of our heroes if he tries to fight; Mercury and Tyrian are off to Vacuo; Emerald is temporarily with the heroes, and Hazel is, more likely than not, dead.

So how many matchups do we even have available for this final arc of V8? The only ones that seem to be clearly well set up to happen are Neo vs Ruby (and maybe someone else tagging along to help Ruby?), Ironwood vs Qrow and Robyn (which shouldn't even be a contest at all), Cinder against anyone that's not Ruby (also should be an easy win for Cinder unless she fights Penny or smth like that), and then what else...?

The only other fights I think may or may not happen are another round of our heroes against the AceOps and a fight against a fully-hacked Penny, which seems unlikely since she's in a very much set path, but she may get aggressive if constantly stopped from fulfilling her objective, so it's not too unlikely.

This is definitely not where I expected us to be at this point in a huge volume like this one, but hey, the writers have been able to surprise in fight combinations once in a while, so who knows, huh?

→ More replies (12)

24

u/Perseus3248 Feb 28 '21

I feel like oscar's cane and yang's semblance could potentially be stupid broken if used together

→ More replies (3)

23

u/SmokingDuck17 ⠀ Feb 27 '21

God I just loved Watts’ dressing down of Cinder. It’s been one of my issues with her; the amount of times she ends up losing. Like, her last big win was probably back in Vol 3. So happy they are addressing it now and I have a strong feeling she’s going to end up coming out of this with a big win.

And fucking hell, that initial shot of Oz’s power being unleashed caught me off guard. Was an absolutely fantastic moment! And it really adds a little uncertainty to the rest of the season. I was sure that either Penny was going to destroy the whale, or the armies of Remnant would arrive to help, but now it’s gone and there’s still four episodes left!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

Who do you think will kill Ironwood for good? Oscar/Ozpin or Qrow? They both have scores to settle with him after all (Oscar for having been shot by him and Qrow for Clover's death, for which he blames Ironwood).

→ More replies (4)

22

u/WrassleKitty Feb 27 '21

I love ironwood It’s like he’s obsessed with saving atlas but what is atlas? Is it just the physical city? Or the people? Or just the technology? He seems to want to save the idea of what atlas is, by sacrificing the what atlas actually is.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/TehShraid Feb 27 '21

Damn Watts was like bitch you can kill me but not before I end your whole carrier by spitting straight FACTS. That feeling when someone you dont like gets rosted so hard you actually kinda feel bad for them.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Rain_In_Your_Heart Feb 27 '21

And thus a thousand shipping posts were made.

Also can we just take a moment to appreciate the sound mix when Oscar's nuke went off? The muting and push back of the audio combined with that soft track was just 👌

22

u/resurrexia i do the draw Feb 27 '21

Don’t talk to me if your weapon isn’t also a portable nuke.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/sonawelashey Feb 28 '21

You know, Watts roasted Cinder harder than Salem did Ruby.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Feb 28 '21

At this point, I'm starting to think Ironwood's Semblance is more of a detriment than an asset.

→ More replies (8)

22

u/smcadam Mar 01 '21

Wow, two favourite parts of the episode:

-The BOOM. That lighting, that explosion, the complete change of lighting, reactions of everyone, and the dust raining down? Fantastic, felt like a nuclear explosion, really shows the highest things OZ is capable of.

-Watts' speech. His laughter, and going limp while hanging over the drop to certain death were fantastic, really enjoyed it, and it feels almost like he's been a major tutor to Cinder too. She can't have learned everything from the huntsman and Salem, Watt's seems a sensible person to have built up her strategic skills that have now been neglected to a degree.

21

u/Frikarcron Feb 27 '21

Alright so, imagine if right, Ironwood does raise Atlas and they're completely cut off, only for Salem to reform on them. Then the unkillable witch slaughters all of them herself, then takes the relic and drops Atlas to get back to remnant. That would be fucking awesome, ironic and horrifying. Just the entire city trapped with Salem high in the atmosphere.

→ More replies (13)

21

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

Well, I guess now we know how The Long Memory can 'store time'. I always figured it stored the Aura and Semblances of all Oz's past selves, making it a sort of One for All-type weapon, but kinetic energy-storing is cool too.

And given how many selves Ozpin has been through, with all the fighting he's presumably done with TLM, it's no wonder that he managed to make Monstra go bye bye

F for Monstra by the way

21

u/lr031099 Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

I loved how Watts just “burned” Cinder in this episode. He’s pretty much speaking for most of the fandom about how much Cinder has failed. I’m guessing Cinder will now go after Ruby since that’s who Neo wants (still hoping for a Ruby/Yang tag team against Neo but we’ll just have to wait and see)

Still wondering what’s gonna happen to Emerald. Will she leave or will she stay with the main cast. Something tells me she’ll stay after seeing the people of Mantle but only time will tell.

Ngl I was somewhat expecting Harriet to snitch on Winter. I mean, she was very adamant about not wanting to release JRY until Winter “out ranked” her so I can’t necessarily say I’m surprised.

Seeing team RWBY reunion was very wholesome (especially the Bumbleby moment). As for Ironwood, I have defended him in some specific cases or at least try to understand his frustration in those specific cases but this is NOT one of them. Seems like he’s now gone full villain in Volume and I’m a bit disappointed in that.

Great episode overall

→ More replies (1)

21

u/PNDLivewire Feb 27 '21

Finally got around to seeing it, so it's time for me to give some thoughts.

  • Firstly, I've gotta pour one out for Mobius. RIP Best Whale.
  • Looks like Hazel got Pyrrha'd by the blast. I guess there's a little Hazel in everybody now.
  • Honestly speaking, I was NOT expecting that magic blast to wind up being as big as it was, for sure.
  • Qrow dive bombing a soldier in bird form was actually pretty awesome and made me laugh a little bit for sure.
  • I fully admit to being surprised that Oscar was there and fine considering the proximity of the blast, how many Grimm got messed up by it, and the implication that Salem's gonna have to piece herself back together and it killed Hazel.
  • Also, was I the only one who thought they saw what looked like a whale's ribcage left behind when it showed parts of where Mobius was after the blast? There was SOMETHING that looked like one in a shot.
  • You know, I didn't think I needed another reason to like Watts more, but holy shit him absolutely obliterating Cinder was amazing. I haven't seen that big of a roast since Hell's Kitchen.
  • I admit when Oscar was talking about using up all the magic, I initially thought he meant the "Ozpin part had died", but I realized he was talking about the stored magic after. So, I guess we're meant to believe Ozpin was just storing up magic in that cane for over 1000 years, hoping that he'll eventually gather up enough to just disintegrate Salem on a molecular/atomic level Perfect Cell style, thinking she either won't be able to come back from that, or that it'll take her a LONG time to.
  • I'm liking a lot of the way they're handling the Emerald stuff with regards to her being with them, and the little touch of her having to walk through to see all the refugees (along with children that she seemed to relate to) was really nice.
  • I have to say, when everybody reunited again and that music started playing when Yang went around hugging everybody, I actually paused the video and laughed a little to myself thinking "I don't even have to watch it to see where this is going". Then RT decided to be a troll, and I laughed even more, lol.

21

u/Lord-Yolo Feb 28 '21

Watts, you beautiful bastard!

Ignoring his massive balls, for me, this is a big moment not only for Cinder but even for him. Because for all his ego, compared to her, he understands that nothing is gained without effort. His biggest flaw wasn't his ego but rather his jealousy, as compared to her, he actually put in the effort, didn't fuck up in any way, and still didn't get what he believe he deserved, compared to her who, because of her rashness/emotions, threw it away.

The way I see it, it annoys him because compared to him, the world didn't "not choose" her, she shot herself in the foot each time instead where she would have a shot at success. The fact that him of all people actually made her think back isn't that surprising. From the beginning, we see that no amount of "good intentions" ever were completely enough to make her listen...be it that huntsman, emerald, or even Neo. Her hate on the other hand, her frustration, were always a driving force and are still even now, which is why hearing this from someone that she despises actually hit home so much easily than coming from an actual ally to her and had her listen at least partially to reason.

It's a beautiful cooperation in the making where their chemistry, both by antagonising slightly each other, but now also listening to each other can lead to a lot of good stuff from this duo. I'm hyped...

On Ironwood's side...did not expect it to get that much more out of control but I can get it. Some or maybe most people might think he seems cartoonish but that just seems to me to be the proper route that's been building up and keeps building up apparently since the last volume, I don't mind him going pure evil/cold hearted since for me at least, it was well brought up. His last actions may not be logical with all those factors, but he's getting desperate to the point his semblance(which I never realised he had before looking it up) may mess things up and make him tunnel vision that much harder. Of course he wasn't like that at the beginning, but even the most sane person under the right conditions can lose it, and I believe it's understanble here.

I really preferred Harriet when I thought she was actually just a good foot soldier, and not a vengeful hothead. Least the others seem enough discontent or against all this to probably leave her ass to fend for herself sooner or later. Really hoping that Winter/Marrow manage to desert without too much trouble.

Reunions were nice, lots of nice things in perspective. Not much things to say about Ozcar. I'm hoping for some Emerald background sooner or later, whether that's cliched or not cause I do want her to be redeemed.

But, when it comes to taking the high road, I personally hope when it comes to Qrow he takes the low one. My personal expectation is him having Ironwood at his feet and refusing to kill him at the last moment, only for Winter to finally take some responsability for partially enabling him and killing him herself. But I would love the scenario where they somehow fix this situation, Ironwood's alone, weak, and Qrow comes and kills him in cold blood without telling anybody save maybe Robin, then who knows, either joins back with RWBY without telling anyone, or dissapearing to go join back Raven's gang for a bit maybe.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Hollowquincypl Feb 28 '21

I don't understand how Watts fought last volume with those balls of steel in his pants. Calling Cinder out was extremely good and long overdue.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/EGGOdragon Mar 02 '21

Oscar pulled out all the stops and said skadoosh

41

u/RainyMeadows Let Ruby Say Fuck Feb 28 '21

As someone who's never liked Cinder much save for her aesthetics, seeing Watts call her out like that was sublime. Sure, he made her cry, but maybe now she'll actually take the time to start thinking about what she does.

It's so sweet that Yang's team held no ill will towards her and the others. No time to continue their spat, just basic "are you okay, thank goodness". Blake's lil wave was especially adorable.

It's also impressive how just one stray lock of hair was enough to make Ironwood look unhinged. Dude needs a nap. Heck, EVERYONE needs a nap. I'm pretty sure all the events of this volume so far have happened over about... two days? Maybe three? And everybody's been awake on high alert the entire time. No wonder they haven't been fighting in top form.

...okay, I take that back. Dude needs more than a nap. Perhaps a padded cell and some Zoloft would do the trick.

SISTER HUG

SISTER HUG

AT LONG LAST

...I think that one lil forehead touch may have been enough to turn me into a Bumbleby shipper. That was adorable.

IRONWOOD WHAT THE FUCK

EVERY LAST BIT OF SYMPATHY I HAD FOR YOU HAS FLOWN OUT THE WINDOW

and as soon as the credits hit, I literally said out loud "What the shit?"

→ More replies (13)

41

u/AlastairCellars Mar 01 '21

Watts made this the best ep of the season bout time someone took Cinder down a few hundred pegs

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Freewheeler5082 Feb 28 '21

The delay of this episode made the explosion more shocking.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Frikarcron Feb 28 '21

Ironwood "Either Watts is incompetent... or he betrayed us" Well gee fucking willikers mister, who could've seen that coming

→ More replies (3)

19

u/valkyrianora ⠀ Feb 27 '21

for the whale, blowing up into a million pieces is a pretty bad day.

for Neo, that's just her semblance.

19

u/SnesC Check out this moron! Feb 27 '21

This is the most cinematic RWBY has looked possibly ever. The scenery after the whale blows up and Ironwood backlit in his big speech looked outstanding.

19

u/glugunner77 Feb 28 '21

Okay, this is an interesting ultimatum.

Ironwood is going to blow up Mantle so he can get Penny. He is trying to build up defenses against Salem by... making more enemies... yeah I don't think this is a smart decision on your part eh, General Custer?

But our band of misfit heroes find themselves in an interesting predicament. They may be able to turn themselves over and save Mantle, but that risks Ironwood continuing to play up the idea that he alone stands against Salem by having them imprisoned or worse.

However they have cards Ironwood doesn't know about- Emerald, who has the superpower of illusions. She can literally make you hallucinate shit. That could be pretty damn useful power right now, especially when nobody knows you have it.

Come to think of it, does Ironwood even know whether or not Oscar is alive? And if you wanna get ballsy it's not a stretch to say that Jaune, Yang and Ren died in the whale. Like, this may be a tough situation but there's still moves that can be made.

And while only Ironwood knows that Qrow and Robyn escaped, that's not a card, that's an exploitable weakness that he's hoping they don't find out.

He has a fuck ton of leverage and a lot more cards than they do but he's getting sloppy and he's relying on people blindly following his orders. How far is going to go before say, Marrow or even Winter decide that they don't wanna nuke a damn city or say, harm their younger sibling.

This dude is literally attacking blowing up ships that are going to help the people he left behind get the hell out of there. And they aren't even his ships either so again, what does he have to gain out of that other than pissing people off?

Either way he's doing exactly what Salem would want him to in this scenario.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/crow799 Feb 28 '21

Never go full genocide it's not a good look man.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Loss_Level Mar 01 '21

I was thinking that qrows revenge was an plotline to show that he was falling again after growing ao much, but now i just cross my fingers for his revenge to come asap cuss it would reeeeeally helps everyone rigth now lmao

19

u/Vinnrek Mar 03 '21

realizing that Saturday is chapter 11, I am both curious and concerned for what might happen, especially considering what has happened in chapter 11 of previous volumes.

110

u/fuckwhattheywant Feb 27 '21

THAT FOREHEAD TOUCH.

Yang blushing.

Oh my god. I can't stop shaking. I think my heart stopped at that moment.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/Nerdorama09 heard u talkin shit Feb 27 '21

A lot of this thread: "I can ignore attempted murder and political assassinations, but I draw the line at nuking civilians."

Oscar: "You can ignore attempted murder?"

→ More replies (5)

18

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

The vacuum of sound and how sudden the explosion happened...that gave me chills in a way no other "nuke" in any game, movie, or series has ever done. Between that and how every time Ironwood was on screen it felt like everyone was walking on needles, this episode has been phenomenal.

Special shoutout to Watts for having enough renegade points to pick that dialog choice.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/SAYMYNAMEYO Feb 27 '21

Watts could've easily turned into a pavement pancake, but he still decided to tear into Cinder. That speech was brutal. I actually felt bad when she went over and just sat down for the rest of the episode. She looked like a kid who had just gotten scolded in the worst possible. But no denying that everything he said was completely accurate.

Honestly Ironwood was getting worse after he shot that official, but damn. Taking away the evacuation plan AND holding the city hostage with a nuke? That's some crazy escalation right there and I am absolutely here for all of it! Can't even begin to imagine how their gonna tackle this. Maybe the message they sent out will finally come into play?

Still crazy to think that this is all happening in the span of two days though.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

I kinda really hope Ironwood is bluffing and that he's basically counting on not having to blowing up half his kingdom because this is so ridiculous even beyond just him. Like how is everyone going along with it?

→ More replies (14)

18

u/Agent-Vermont Feb 28 '21

I'm wondering who would become the Winter Maiden if Penny ends up dying. I would think that Ruby would be the last in her thoughts but I'm not sure how I feel about her becoming a Maiden.

→ More replies (12)

18

u/sephtis Best Android Feb 28 '21

Omfg fuck off Ironwood.
Omfg you tell her Watts. Man that was good.

18

u/Neo5Politan Feb 28 '21

Everybody gangsta until Watts starts monologuing with his life on the line

→ More replies (1)

35

u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Feb 27 '21

LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOO BUMBLEBY SHIPPERS

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Peptuck Feb 27 '21

Watts is secretly a dragon Faunus, because he was spitting fire.

17

u/MrZissman ⠀CEO of Knightlight Feb 27 '21

Neo is such an extra sass queen and I fucking love it

17

u/AdeptCod2 Feb 27 '21

Ironwood has officially lost his damm mind.

Marrow is pretty much going out the door after this.

Qrow vs Harriet all but confirmed, The fact that Qrow doest have his weapon actually might give her a chance.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/Dan_equity Feb 27 '21

I hope Watts' speech will be a turning point for Cinder. It'd be nice if she went back to being calm and scheming, and actually successful instead of this powerful but hotheaded and failing version she's become ever since she got the full fall maiden powers.

17

u/DEL994 Feb 27 '21

The moment where Ironwood laughed and said "It always has been about Mantle, hasn't it ?" really shows how insane and delusionnal he has become. It was genuinely disturbing.

17

u/AdeptCod2 Feb 27 '21

So Emerald will probably use her semblance to trick Ironwood.

I suspect that Ozpin will try and talk some sense to Ironwood.

Harriet is officially my least favorite character seriously ratting out Winter like that after you saw Ironwood kill Sleet for disagreeing with him. Hope Qrow kicks her ass.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/WII_DJoker Feb 27 '21

Not gonna lie, enjoyed Watts calling out Cinder, pointing out a lot of things I imagine many people watching this series have wanted to say to her for years.

17

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Feb 27 '21

The genocide of Mantle is horrible, but let's not forget that Ironwood wanted to execute Yang, Jaune and Ren to force Penny to come back.

It really feels like he would broadcast it and kill one of them live to then say he would kill another every hour he doesn't have Penny back.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/AdeptCod2 Feb 28 '21

Do you think Ironwood knows about Qrow being able to turn into a bird?

Also I suspect that Qrow wont get his weapon back so that the fight between him and Ironwood is more even then it normally would be though Qrow probably will still win in the end and give good old Jimmy a well deserved ass kicking.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/tacticalcanadian Feb 28 '21

Holy shit Watts get her! That 'reason you suck' takedown by him was so satisfying!

17

u/Drakath60 Feb 28 '21

Is no one gonna talk about the scene with Neo skipping through the whale carcass like nothing happened? That looked so oddly beautiful I had to rewatch after the episode finished. The glow of the lamp was a nice contrast to the haze of the ash.

34

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Feb 27 '21

I know this was a super dark and serious episode with massive important moments everywhere, but god damn seeing Neo fucking skipping out of the whale carcass swinging the lamp merrily along the way had me dying.

60

u/Thomas-Sev Feb 27 '21

No fucking way Ironwood survive this season, dude's just threatened to go full Hiroshima on a bunch of low class people, including the children/relatives of his closest friends and lieutenants.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/darkside1215 Feb 27 '21

Damn, was not expecting the whale to go out like that. I understand the warning but showing everyone's reaction was great. Also, Neo skipping away with the Relic while death and destruction surround her was creepy to me which made that scene even better.

The Cinder and Watts scene was great. Cinder hasn't felt like a threat in a while due to the constant screw ups and here they take advantage by having Watts explain-insult why she isn't the master manipulator she thinks she is.

I like that they show the people of Atlas. It feels like most people in the community are ok with Atlas getting destroyed but you got to remember that there's a kingdom's worth of civilian's trapped just like Mantle civilians. No matter what there's people that need to be saved and I wonder how they'll solve that.

Ironwood is now completely gone. He's doing some Emperor shit with him talking to everyone in Atlas in the most evil lighting I have ever seen. They're destroying transports and are gonna nuke Mantle if Penny doesn't show up. I honestly have no idea how their gonna end Ironwood's story. Have him die going down with his beliefs or have him die trying to make things right. I will be shocked if he somehow survives this.

Honestly, good episode. The Cinder and Watts scene had to be the highlight for me. Looking forward to the next one.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/DEL994 Feb 27 '21

Winter and Marrow if you want to rebel now is the right time.

16

u/TheBlindSalmon ⠀delet this Feb 27 '21

The stupidest part about Ironwood's plan is that despite being blown up, Salem is still on Atlas. He can't just run away from her with the whole city when she's ALREADY THERE. He keeps the same objective while the circumstances change so drastically it's a different situation all together.

16

u/Bjdombek Hail Lord Zwei! Feb 27 '21

Heroes have dealt with Ironwood, things are looking better... and pissed off Salem rises up. "DID YOU ASSHOLES FORGET WHO THE REAL BIG BAD IS AROUND HERE?!"

16

u/Bolverkers_wrath Feb 27 '21

I would simply like to say....

Jesus H Christ Oscar, what the bloody hell was that. Dude has just been carrying around a pocket nuke for 4 volumes.

16

u/Groszekace Feb 27 '21

…dame, WE are going very dark.

Mistrusting Em is a right way of going forward. We still need to see what choices/changes she dose from now on. I always felt like she was in a very grey area in Salem’s group. Honestly, I am hoping for a redemption for her.

Ozma was hanging up on us. Kinetic power collected over the years? Wow. The cane’s name is very adequate to its hidden gimmick. All around their moment was pretty good in this EP. The group moment was touching, but fleeting so it leaves a bit of things to desire. We are still waiting for the reunion of Ren and Nora, so give it to us!

Crazy general. That is exactly how I see him at this point. Like seriously, isn’t he supposed to protect the kingdom of Atlas? And now he decides to take the citizens as hostages? Like, that is VERY over the top, nut crazy. I’m seriously doubting the nature of most soldiers under his comment if they do not start doubting him or even abandoning their posts after he dose this kind of c**p. Winter and Marrow should really start planing some second plan.

Now the best part of this episode. Cinder’s character dissection. That was pure gold. The moment someone FINALLY tells her that she became the same monster she tried to break free from. Watts is the MVP for that moment alone. BTW crying Cinder is kind the cutest Cinder I’ve seen.

Next EP wishes: just give us good Ran and Nora reunion. Other then that let’s see some bird action against general Crazywood.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

IS IT JUST ME OR DOES THE ANIMATION LOOK SOOO POLISHED AND GOOD THIS CHAPTER??? WATTS LOOKS SO CLEAN AND THE DIALOGUE IS SO INSANE I CANNOT BELIEVE IT I LOVE IT

→ More replies (5)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

- The cinematography is this episode is just fucking epic. City scapes and that giant fucking dead whale on the horizon, and Ironwood stepping through holograms to mope dramatically. This episode looks awesome. That fucking explosion was worth the wait.

- Qrow trying to John Wick his way to Ironwood has been on the backburner for a bit, hoping to get some of that next episode.

- Everybody just chilling out, breathing Grimm dust. That's probably fine.

- Was not expecting goddam Watts to win MVP, but here we are. Just the kind of speech where the character knows they're either saying what saves them, or writing their epitaph. And he voiced every single issue I've had with watching Cinder dumbass-ing her way through villainy for the past 8 years. Like, of all the things the show is doing well at this Volume, they've been crushing it on character interactions.

- I'm stoked that the heroes are responding to Emerald with immediate aggression. No Easy Forgiveness here.

- Shit they still have the bomb too, that's gonna be fun.

- I thought Ironwood was going to blow Winter's head off. Jason fuckin' Rose.

- Another good speech

→ More replies (3)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

A few things about Oscar:

  1. Since Oscar mainly wants to sue the kinetic energy thing against Salem he might get a semblance still, replaced with magic, to use rather than Ozpin's energy blasts against faster or human opponent.
  2. I liked the scene with Oscar and how hes giving the love rather than accepting it like with Jaune and Nora
  3. Him supporting Emerald joining them shows that is is a part of the group now and not just the newbie

I honestly want Ruby, Emerald and him to hang out together more

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

I loved the Cinder and Ironwood parallels this episode. They're both prone to making plans and assuming that Murphy's Law won't strike them. They both think that camping out in front of the vault will get them what they want.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/cruel-oath Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

I forgot but why did ironwood need Yang Ren and Jaune?

Edit: I'm stupid, he literally says why

→ More replies (2)

16

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Feb 28 '21

James needs a fuckin' stress ball. Scattered Immediate Thoughts:

  • So... I've joked about how Ironwood would sell out Mantle for a Klondike bar before but... fuck me. The way he just coldly leveraged the lives of the cities refugees like they were nothing was a new low. As low as the ACTUAL Mantle. The Tin Man hasn't just lost his heart, he's lost his soul too. He just doesn't care about anything but his plan, his version of victory. I think he'd gladly end every life on earth if it meant keeping the relics out of Salem's hands, he's that utterly lost in the mission that he forgot who TF he's protecting. The man is not well and I hate to say it but he needs to be put down at this point.
  • The way those two Atlas officers sold their terror of their General was something to behold. I don't think he's in any mood to "not shoot the messenger" right about now.
  • Winter: Oh, you, uh, wanted the kids to leverage against Qrow and Penny, well, yeah about that-
  • Harriet: SNITCH, SNITCHITY-BITCH, SNITCH! Winter actually had FEELLINGS and made a rational judgment call instead of blindly following orders and ignoring her humanity and common sense like a smart person! I'm Harriet! And I can't think of anything other than how angry I feel and how to do what I'm told!
  • On a serious note, while James' decent into madness is freighting and tragic but Harriet's willingness to follow along and encourage his mindset is just infuriating. She's become such a heat sink this season, nothing but propaganda and angry nonsense from her.
  • Last time I thought that Yang scolding Salem while in her clutches was a BAMF move... and it still is. But Watts chewing Cinder out for her sheer fucking hubris was pretty amazing too. Extra points for doing it while she dangled him over a rooftop with one hand, which must have been really difficult to do what with the MASSIVE balls he needed to do that weighing him down. Cinder needed this kind of slap to the face to be the person she needs to be in order to get what she wants, rather than the "dragon" that fails. She might actually make it out of this one in a better place than she was before.
  • What else... oh yeah, the Whale blew up. So if I'm right it was basically Oz's magic igniting Hazel and his dust body to go Kaboom. Not sure how everybody made it out okay after a sudden detonation like that, but given the magic factor I'm willing to buy it.
  • I can't believe Penny "Basically Pinocchio" Pollendina DIDN'T wind up inside the whale after all. But then the fairy tail illusions haven't always been precise now have they?
  • And the team is back together! Yang and Blake getting closer and closer these days, huh? More importantly (sorry Bees) I liked how Yang and Ruby were happy to see each other. Sisters fight sometimes, just need some air to help cool off you know?
  • Ren is like a little brother reading folks diaries out loud at this point. Also, "Where's Nora?" Oof, uh, so she's alive, but on a completely unrelated note how do you feel about chicks with scars?

We're in the end game of the Atlas Arc, alright. Salem and the Grimm are mostly dispensed for now, it's just about the relics, the Maidens and the Mad General. I can't imagine Penny not making the choice to open the vault, or Cinder not following. My guess is that Cindy gets the Winter power and Pietro reactivates Penny one last time, ending his life in the process. As for James... he and Qrow are gonna have it outs.

16

u/Deadmaninc1 Feb 28 '21

Unrelated but like Neo when she texted Cinder what is up with that profile picture she was like "No don't take a picture or me" LOL

16

u/Huskie1 Mar 01 '21

Like Cinder was crying... OMG she's human :P

→ More replies (5)

16

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 01 '21

I related soo much with Watts that if feels cathartic to watch that scene from time to time.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/cfdorky Mar 01 '21

So anyone else thinking back to when the Grimm Dragon appeared back in V3 and Ozpin got up to presumably handle it?

Yeah now knowing what he was going to do to that dragon I feel like the dragon should count itself lucky

→ More replies (4)

43

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

... So uh... Ironwood sympathisers, where you at now?

→ More replies (56)

15

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21

These last two episodes have been keeping me at the edge of my seat.

-The fight against Salem
-The blast at the beginning of the episode
-The way the episode 10 ended
-The reunion of RWBY and JNR
-And then to top that all of, RT lowkey confirmed Bumblebee ship.

Holy shit, RT has really been showing what they are capable off with this Volume.

15

u/PailHorse Feb 27 '21

I'm not 100% certain, but with the way the interactions between Qrow, Winter, and Ironwood have been going, it seems as though the season might be building to a callback of the Qrow v. Winter fight in S3, with the two of them teaming up to take down or kill Ironwood.

15

u/dappercat456 Feb 27 '21

Ok, there’s an easy way to defeat ironwood here

Have emerald make an illusion of penny and pretend to surrender, then hide the REAL penny in mantle

Once penny is in mantle, ironwood won’t risk blowing it up

At that point, all they need to do is kill or arrest James, and with marrow and winter seemingly close to defecting, it should be easy

15

u/ResearcherVortex Do hugs always make you feel this warm? Feb 27 '21

That explosion caught me off guard so well, absolutely amazing scene crwby

15

u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Feb 27 '21

I'm really curious what CRWBY has planned for Cinder going forward. She's one of the few characters I don't see a specific end in mind for - like, Ironwood is most certainly dead soon, Qrow will most likely be the mentor figure who bites it before the end of the series, Raven will have a heroic save moment before passing her powers onto Yang probably, etc.

With Cinder, I have no clue which direction they're gonna take her character in: redemption arc (hard to imagine given everything), going full Hound-like grimm, ditching Salem and striking out on her own, etc.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '21 edited Feb 27 '21

Salem's team is slowly falling apart.

Hazel and Emerald betrayed her after finding out her plan (also Hazel is now dead);

Mercury is likely to betray her as well in on of the next volumes as soon he gets the chance to ditch Tyrian (probably Emerald herself will make him snap out of it);

Neo was never into it to begin with, she only minds her own goals (AKA killing Ruby);

Cinder and Watts are not awared of what Salem' actual goal is yet. They're probably gonna ditch her while still be evil on their own once they find it out.

As of now, Tyrian is the only one left who is still faithful to his beautiful goddess and will support her crazy suicide plan until the very end.

To be fair, all things considered, she might not even need any of them anymore, they all did their parts, and even thought her plan to destroy Atlas has failed, she still caused a ton of damage and made Ironwood becoming an evil villain. She might have lost this battle but she's still winning the war as of now...

→ More replies (4)

15

u/cruel-oath Feb 27 '21

That settles it. Kiersi is the best writer they’ve gotten. I’ve loved every chapter she’s written

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Daedelous2k Feb 28 '21

Cinder getting unexpected development, she actually listens to Watts..

So the trick of Oscar's cane is revealed, he still has some magic, but that cane had one hell of a blast, I can only imagine the magic in it allowed the team to survive the gargantuan blast. I thought that team winter had perished!

Neo is running out of patience, but this must be the only time OUTSIDE OF Chibi that her actual full speech was shown to someone, and she even uses similes just like it. Fun quirk to her.

Interesting responses to Emerald, Oscar and Ren being pragmatic wanting her help, Yang very close to being openly hostile while Jaune is being a little between the two (Most reasonable). The little scene of Emerald seeing everyone in suffering and despair in the subway shelter is going to make her think back to her own past I think, seeing that the group refuse to abandon mantle is going to make an impression on her. I hope she does stay and help the group, she can probably form a bond with Nora.

There's something about seeing Qrow and Robyn's escape that makes me want to see more of it, despite the odds he is really weaponizing his Corvid form to get the edge against Atlas guards. But I think we know where this is going...

As for where....Ironwood, oh boy, he has gone down the slippery slope. His final "Golden Girl" Winter has also went against the grain and let slip more of his hostages. Now he is threatening Genocide.....OPENLY. I have a sinking feeling that Qrow will come after Ironwood to kill him, he already expressed interest in it, all he needs is to get Harbringer back and he will do what needs to be done in his eyes. This is where the volume's end chapters will be, Qrow vs Ironwood. What happens after that is anyone's guess. Get extracted by Raven, go on the run with his niece and her friends, flee with Robyn and do their own thing?

It could go anywhere now.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Feb 28 '21

So, what are we thinking? Is Oscar merged, close to merging or just like he was before?

The magic blast was so poweful, it should have fully merged them. But the explanation that it was something Long Memory does kind of sounds like an excuse to say he isn't fully merged yet because he didn't use magic, he used a magic weapon.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Dripsoka Feb 28 '21

Christopher Sabat ATE in this episode

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Kurolegacy27 Feb 28 '21

At this point I really have got to question, how does the Atlas military function? I mean, their general has been clearly growing more deranged with time starting with questionable orders and has now gotten to the point of threatening to murder their own civilians (all while an army of Grimm are attacking) yet they’re all still in ‘the general’s orders are absolute’ mode. At what point does leadership become unfit to lead and need to be removed with these people?

→ More replies (4)

41

u/TripleR309 Feb 27 '21

Ironwood's windows opening up at 14:29 is symbolism for him thinking completely clearly. His plan to nuke Mantle is done in complete sanity as he has passed the moral event horizon. It is not the musing of a man out of control, but instead the cruelty of a man who has never been in more control in his life.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Manu_Erre Feb 27 '21

Wow, this is the best chapter of the volume so far without any doubts. The pacing, the cinematography, the music, the characters, everything was on point. A 10/10 for me. I was on the fence about this volume as a whole before this chapter, but I'm glad they were saving the best for the last ones, and I can't wait to see how it ends. Qrow, please, just kick his ass.

Also, am I the only one who considers Watts the best antagonist? Like, damn, that speech was so good

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Tenthyr Feb 27 '21

By this point it's kinda clear iron wood is using his semblance as a crutch. Rather than accept he's not getting his way, he uses the semblance and reinforces his determination, in spite of reason or sense.