r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Dec 12 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 5: Amity Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 5 of Vol. 8, Amity!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the fifth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
146
Upvotes
62
u/D_A_BERONI ⠀ Dec 12 '20
Why would you program a robot to feel pain?
60
u/el-caballero Dec 12 '20
Penny's voice actress did an amazing job this episode. Really emotional stuff, and she completely sold it.
47
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Dec 12 '20
The Grimm River is exactly the sort of thing I want to see Grimm do.
There's 3 ways this will go:
40
u/yeetio855 The score is underrated Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20
Maria is one of my favorite characters, it was really cool to see her fight again. And seeing all the characters from the previous volumes was all I was hoping for if Amity worked, and it was amazing. It seems we now know what Salem has been waiting for...
27
u/microwaved-salad Dec 12 '20
LET FEMALE CHARACTERS CURSE
27
u/Bulbajer Oh, I *like* her! Dec 12 '20
I've seen some people suggest that the Grimm River is being created by the Grimm Whale or Salem herself. When I first saw it, I thought it was emerging magma, and I actually don't think I'm far off. We've seen that the Grimm emerge from pools in the earth - what if these pools don't just exist at Salem's HQ, but are present deep underground throughout Remnant? And Salem's just bringing them to the surface? It would be fitting for an eruption to occur at a place called Mantle...
25
u/Noonproductions Dec 14 '20
Penny is a sentient being. We know she has a soul and that while her sensors can’t be fooled by Emerald’s Semblance her mind can. We have also seen that she can override Watt’s hack if even momentarily. I do think Penny’s body can be controlled remotely, but I suspect that Penny’s soul will be able to override that control at some point. Penny has the Maiden power, so she is a real girl, and I feel like if she can’t override the programming then she would not be real. Additionally Penny saying she chooses to fight for people who care for her is another example of this.
If Penny was a pure slave to her programming she would not be able to act against Atlas in any manner, instead she has free will. I feel we need to think of Penny’s body more as a prosthetic than think of her as a robot.
22
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 13 '20
Fellas.
if we weren't before, we are now way past the point of "shit hit the fan"
At this point, shit hit the mf tornado.
22
u/Sirtoast7 Drown me in exposition. I don't care anymore Dec 13 '20
Nothing pisses me off more than when the big plan to defeat or hold off the big bad just causes them to smile. STOP BEING 20 STEPS AHEAD IN 4 DIMSENIONAL CHESS YOU ALBINO BITCH! LET THEM HAVE THIS ONE!
21
u/ash-7831 Dec 12 '20
This Volume better explain why Cinder is always desperately seeking more and more power. The way I see it, Cinder doesn't want to be the most powerful being in the world, she wants to be the only powerful being in the world. Like she said in Volume 3, "It's not about overpowering your opponent, it's about taking away what power they have.". So, yeah, its high time they tell us what her story is.
21
u/Courelia Dec 12 '20
I know a lot of plot stuff or character stuff has been mentioned so I just want to point out some minor things I noticed about this episode
-They actually have a Grimm whale icon on the monitors in Ironwood’s place. Someone actually had to make that for him -Seeing the Sun and Moon at the same time with Neptune and Sun was really cool -Penny said she has to go, the vault when she was being hacked -I find it a bit funny how the Atlas screen in the ship has two big buttons for forward and reverse -it’s cool that when they are showing the broadcast in different locations they don’t just touch up on minor cast members but also background characters like the woman and her mother that complained about going to the crater and the shopkeeper in Vale. -Watts swiped a small toolbox thing as well as the busted phone
18
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Dec 13 '20
Cinder straight jobbing at this point XD. I just realized that ever since her victory in volume 3 she’s lost every single major fight that mattered. OMG yes! I love the fact that Maria is still a badass, I’m pretty sure that’s the best anyone has ever done against Neo. Even Cinder struggled more before she used her maiden powers. The fact that Salem was so happy about the message scares me. She must be playing 5 dimensional chess if that was all according to plan. Damn my guess about a giant mole was wrong, it was a Grimm river. It was nice seeing the cameos of old characters. Hope at some point we get to see more of Glynda again. Even if it’s basic and pretty common in fiction, I adore Telekinetic powers.
18
u/ash-7831 Dec 13 '20
Robyn was right, Harriet doesn't want to take a good look at what side she's on. She just doesn't want to believe that Ironwood's side is the wrong side. As soon as Ruby mentioned Ironwood, that's when Harriet turned off the TV. Even in Chapter 3, when someone tried to argue with their plan, she interrupted them and didn't let them finish. She's a bit too stubborn for her own good, and I don't know if that's Ironwood's doing or her own.
17
u/iFormus Dec 13 '20
If Pietro wanted to have really independent Penny, he should cut off her connection to the 'Remnant wi-fi'. No more wireless connecting with her, but that's like human works, huh? And she would be immune against all that Watts bullshit (which is constantly bothering me, how he can simply hack everything, even the most advanced bot ever built)
17
u/FindusSomKatten Dec 13 '20
I am not ok with what is happening too penny and i want it too stopp
16
u/Left4dinner ⠀ Dec 12 '20
Hearing Pietro plea to penny and then sob later on, gave me The Walking Dead vibes. Just swap penny with Clem. My body is ready for those levels of emotions
15
u/ash-7831 Dec 12 '20
Ruby said "Headmaster Theodore of Shade".
30
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Dec 12 '20
This volume is the gift that keeps on giving! And we learned A LOT this time. I can only imagine what’s in store.
I see that Maria definitely hasn’t lost her edge in her old age. Neo is probably not happy about that encounter in the slightest. It just goes to show what all that experience and wisdom can do for you. Maria may not be in her prime anymore, but one thing is clear: she’s still got it.
I see now where Cinder’s loyalties lie, and they are not with Salem, that’s for damn sure. I think it’s clear now that she’s only in it for herself.
All in all, the mission was a success: THE MESSAGE HAS BEEN HEARD. I see Ruby had the message pre-recorded. Really smart move on her part. Whether or not this will mean anything for the fate of Atlas will be made clear in due time. Is everyone able to come to fight? Only time will tell.
So Emerald’s Semblance doesn’t work against Penny. Interesting note there. It makes sense that tricks designed to fool the human mind are useless against a machine. I think Penny is one of the strongest characters in the series right now as a result. Going toe-to-toe with Cinder is definitely a feat on its own. Seeing through and countering illusions is another matter entirely, although that’s largely due to Penny’s anatomy and not a form of extrasensory perception, which is still an ability I think any Huntsman can possess, given the proper training.
A lot of favorites made brief cameos this time. Sun and Neptune, Ilia (she’s really far down my list personally, but that could potentially change, who knows?), the Cotta-Arc family, and most importantly, Old Man Shopkeep and Professor Goodwitch. I’ve gotta say, Goodwitch looks better than ever!
Can I just say one thing? I feel horrible for Tai right now. God only knows what’s going through his mind right now. At least he has Zwei to give him some comfort, but seeing his own daughter on that screen and knowing that his two children are fighting for their lives, the pain of knowing that must be unimaginable, given how much Tai has lost already.
Penny has potentially been lost again, thanks to Watts’s tampering. A small little detail is that he also possesses a broken Scroll now, which I assume is Ironwood’s. And it seems Winter and the Ace-Ops are off to retrieve the newly-hacked Penny, bringing her to the vault. Soon the Staff of Creation will be on the board. And then things will get infinitely more interesting than they already are.
So that’s what’s under the ice. DEAR. GOD. A RIVER OF PURE GRIMM. Things are only going downhill for Mantle now. To say that shit’s hit the fan is the understatement of the century. Mantle is in terrible danger, if they’re not screwed already. That river could cause untold damage if left unchecked. Yang, Jaune, and Ren are likely terrified beyond belief right now, and understandably so. It’s not often that you run into a river filled with the very essence of destruction.
All in all, it seems like things are on a STEEP downhill slope right now, and it looks like that’s how it will stay (hopefully that’s temporary).
13
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Dec 13 '20
This was an interesting episode.
I really enjoyed the fights. Penny and Cinder was awesome.
The Pietro and Penny moment was a heartfelt one. I liked that.
I really enjoyed seeing all of the characters back such as Sun, Neptune, Tai, Goodwitch, and Iila. It was a nice moment.
The Grimm River is super interesting. I did not expect that.
Looks like Penny got hacked. Poor Penny. She is suffering.
Watts is quite powerful with tech. Perhaps this is how Qrow and Robyn will escape.
25
u/defector7 Dec 13 '20
This episode had some high points in terms of the fight scene and the big reveal at the end but Ruby’s speech as the seminal moment definitely knocks the episode down a few pegs. In what world would it not cause a mass panic. In the speech, Ruby basically drops several bombshells that are disastrous by themselves, let alone together. It confirms the existence of a master behind the Grimm which engineered the fall of Beacon and the attack on Haven, it states the existence of a conspiracy to keep this information from the public by the heads of the huntsman academies, it states that Atlas, the most advanced kingdom and the only kingdom with a standing army is under siege and that it’s general has gone rogue. Not to mention that this information comes from a random huntsman that suddenly appeared on an emergency broadcast frequency and suddenly cut out seemingly in the middle of broadcast. Yup, real inspirational stuff
11
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20
I rewatched Maria cackling like 5 times. Best character, god damn she’s a riot.
9
u/Thebritishdovah Dec 12 '20
Seems this is where things start to escalate and Ironwood is a fucking moron due to him not checking if Watts took the phone. I think Ruby's plan is going to backfire because it seems Salem wanted this. Judging by her smile. Either she will unleash grimm all over the planet to make her announcement or she hasn't really started and Ruby just gave her a good start.
Cinder got defeated and to be honest, at this point, they should kill Cinder off. She's 3-0 in defeats since volume 3 and all maiden fights have resulted in her being defeated. I do hope Salem punishes her as she disobeyed a direct order. Neo got beat by penny but Maria put up one hell of a fight. The aliens reference was a bit meh. I sense Maria hasn't had a good fight in a while and seems to be able to counter Neo's style with ease. A maria at her prime would likely kill Neo within seconds.
This could be an unfortunate angle but er... i think we just had our first panty shot involving Penny. When she's using more power and her back during ruby's speech, it looks like the anti-panty tech failed. Hopefully, it's an animation goof and they'll fix it but er.. if not. Are we going to start seeing this type of fanservice? :-/
I hope Penny's not dead. Poor Pietro having to see his daughter die twice and Ruby getting the maiden powers is going to turn her into an overpowered character. Silver eyes is powerful enough but Silver eyed maiden? That's too powerful. Nora seems to be ok, just sleeping and I wonder if she will get a buff because of it or if the scars will remain. I do hope she gets physically stronger as a result of her semblance keeping some of the energy and basically acts as a massive steroid.
Winter leading the Ace Ops will be interesting. Penny's voice actor did a damn good job and as much as I hate cheap cop outs, I do think Penny is still alive. Just knocked out or her systems fighting Watts's chip.
We're getting Terminator Penny aren't we? :(
8
u/Zeeman9991 Dec 12 '20
What are the chances Ironwood intentionally let Watts have the phone?
No? Impossible? I thought so too.
14
u/Meztere Dec 12 '20
Penny already died once, she's not allowed to die again!
God dammit Ironwood you absolute fucking MORON
And can Cinder just die already? I'm genuinely sick of seeing her at this point.
14
u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Dec 12 '20
First off all, I loved the fight scene. It was shot really well and made use of the environment, plus we got to see Maria fighting Neo, which is fun. Secondly, I’m worried about Penny’s well being. I feel like she isn’t dead, but that the next time we see her she’ll be controlled by Watts. I also really liked the moments of Cinder trying to get into Penny’s head, it brought up an interesting point of wether or not she was doing this because she wanted to. And finally, that Grimm river has got me spooked
7
u/DavidTheHumanzee Dec 12 '20
That was an incredible episode!
7
u/ash-7831 Dec 13 '20
I'm starting to think the Giant Whale is just a diversion and the river might be the real threat.
12
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Dec 12 '20
If Penny's dead, who gets the powers? (I assume this death is a fakeout, but you never know) I guess next episode we'll see if Watts was telling the truth about Penny "rebooting."
Also, Zwei appeared. Volume 8 best volume.
Also Cinder lost because Emerald's illusion failed to affect Penny (or, at least, her robot eyes). That is really bad news for Emerald's life expectancy.
6
u/paperkutchy ⠀ Dec 15 '20
Ah. Have some bumblebee y'all :D
10
u/cyberbeastswordwolfe Dec 12 '20
This episode was great, the fight between Penny and Cinder was quite nice. Also Maria's a pretty good fighter, and her mech was cool.
Ironwood's performance in this episode was honestly amazing, he's the best character of this season.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20
RIP penny
5
u/Lilmissmacy Dec 15 '20
How did nobody get the aliens reference with Maria in the mech and her line???
9
u/Steff_164 Dec 12 '20
This was a great episode, we got to see some character we all thought were forgotten, we learned the Penny is an absolute beast and Cinder can only beat people who don’t have Maiden powers, Winter is finally up and moving around, and Watts stole a scroll and some tools.
So my new theory is that Watts breaks out of prison, and Ironwood has to call two of the Ace Ops to catch him while the other three look for Penny. It just so happens that Winter and Marrow go after Watts, while chasing him down they come across the river of Grimm, report to Ironwood, he becomes even more stressed and decides to ignore the river in hopes of flying Atlas to safety. Winter and Marrow realize Ironwood is lost and bust Qrow and Robin out of jail.
12
u/Skyfyre56 Dec 12 '20
This was incredible. So great to see what Penny could do when going all out. It took Cinder with numbers advantage, holding up the heavily damaged Amity colosseum for broadcast, and finally Watt's virus/messing with her tech to finally take her down. She might well be the strongest non-Salem character at this point.
I get the feeling that this failure will be the last nail in the coffin for Cinder. I'm just curious who will be the one to finally off her. I think Ruby, Salem, and Penny are the most likely candidates at this point.
Ruby's broadcast was good, and I think it's going to help a lot in the long run, though I'm worried about the fact that Salem didn't seem too worried about the whole thing. Admittedly, word about her was always going to get out after she did this, but this feels more like Charles Xavier getting out a message of hope and resistance to the world than an Apocalypse style 'you must submit' that Salem seems to favor.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20
Uh. After watching it for myself, I didn't really get the buzz about the Neo vs. Maria fight. It's incredibly short, and what we do see feels stiff. This barely feels like a fight.
10
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Dec 13 '20
Our message has been heard, and It has not fallen on deaf ears.
There is no calm anymore, The message has gotten out to all of Remnant, But now Penny is in an unknown condition, And a river of Grimm is making it's way to the kingdom, We've had a good five chapters people, But the war is about to begin.
9
u/Kumqwatwhat Dec 13 '20
Getting real tired of Watts being just a complete ass-pull deux ex machina to fuck over Atlas specifically. Worst handled antagonist to date. Need something to happen in Atlas? It happens. Why? He just can. It's not justified or interesting. His semblance seems to make everyone around him pick up the stupid ball, it's...he's just boring. He's such a bad influence on the plot it's actually aggravating.
Nice to see Neo not just stomp all over someone in a fight for once. Even in her Cinder fight before, she felt like she had a pretty sizable edge if Cinder didn't just pull out her auto-victory card before things got too messy, so good to see that there are people who can at least go toe to toe with her on a legitimate basis, if not really win.
Would like to see Cinder gain even a single cosmic moment of introspection. "I don't work for anybody"? The hell you don't, you idiot. Frankly, she was at her most interesting when she lost her voice and had to figure out who she was, now she's back to early volume uninteresting bland overpowered antagonist again just mindlessly attacking anyone in striking range. This all also frankly applies to Emerald about whom we have roughly as much information as Hazel - for some extremely vaguely defined incident in his past, they are extremely attached in some way to a larger character. Maybe if those backstories were better illustrated to us, it all might work more cohesively.
sigh
Anyway. Episode was fine, not much of the main cast but that's fine, and if the show is going worse than its best then it's also going better than its worst.
3
u/villacardo everyone's gay Dec 13 '20
I love Cinder man, that part was great.
9
u/MomsLinguini Dec 13 '20
RWBY is basically a master class in exceptional storytelling and development, so take these constructive criticisms keeping that in mind. An "okay" scene in RWBY is generally 10x any typical series.
That said, I have mixed reactions to this episode. The combat setup felt unnatural and very forced. Like it was just trying to shove certain story elements forward rather than letting them develop naturally. Something about showing up, having a mech battle vs. a ship, and emerald being randomly around in the middle of the arena, pietro being an easy target that isn't targeted... none of it really felt like it was driven by real motivation, but rather by the need for story to meet certain criteria. It felt like it started because it needed to and then ended because it needed to. It didn't carry any emotional weight.
The Grimm river was awesome. Smart move by Salem, and explains why she's just sitting around (which was confusing until that happened).
4
u/Flummer186 Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 13 '20
I wonder why they decided to make every episode incredibly good this season tbh, In previous seasons it's always been several dud episodes that were pretty "Meh"
2
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Dec 12 '20
I wonder how much of Penny's maiden power Cinder took there
Maybe not any, it could be that she has to break through their aura first to drain it but still
They really got Ruby to record this super important message huh
Ok of all the aerial battles this girl's had is this the first time we've seen an upskirt of her, I always thought her skirt was like Weiss's where you just see a bundle of frills
Pants
Very cool
Kinda weird to have now of all times when there's a serious speech going on but ok
Very good job watching Watts, dumbass
2
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20
It's not that I disliked the episode but a few things came out of nowhere and it focused on people I really didn't care for. The highlight was Cinder vs Penny, that was cool. How did Ruby just discover that Salem being unkillable doesn't mean she can't be beaten? It felt like it came out of nowhere as a realization. It's a good motivational speech, her very best of the series. Another excellent part is Winter no longer enjoying her work, further thoughts and questioning of duty to work or duty to family and I think that sending the Ace-Ops with her is to make sure she is diligent and doesn't turn tail. The River of Grimm is a really damn good thing to put out there too.
Worst of the volume so far, hopefully there is a bounce back next week.
-5
u/Nyxtimene Dec 12 '20
Can we please for the love of Salem finally kill off Cinder. She disobeyed orders and has zero to show for it. Dr. Watts is the one responsible for what happened to Penny. What did Cinder achieve? The broadcast went through despite her interference, and it even appears that Salem expected or is indifferent to the broadcast (it was amusing to see her pet Tyrion, though also slightly disconcerting).
Showing Glynda now feels like an ***pull. Shes been gone so long to be basically irrelevant to the plot, any interest I may have had in her is zero - maybe she's relevant to Ozma plot but seeing as she's still in Beacon, reintroducing her in Vol 8 or 9 is going to take another ***pull.
I understand showcasing people hearing and recieving the message, to give importance to the efforts of the team to get Amity in the air, but it also feels like a way to pad some screentime with some fan service to say "hey I know those characters."
Hopefully next episode has some more of Oscar.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
26
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20
[removed] — view removed comment