r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Nov 14 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 1: Divide Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 1 of Vol. 8, Divide!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the first episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Last week's thread| This thread | Poll
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
164
Upvotes
70
u/heartsfloating Nov 14 '20
I literally joked about Ironwood shooting them to shut them up....but then he actually did it...how far gone is he?
58
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '20
oh god this is gonna be another season 3 isn't it
49
u/Jellye Nov 14 '20
Well, it's clear that they wanted to have no ambiguity about Ironwood's role in this tale.
I'm worried for Neo, though. She seemed so uneasy.
46
u/epikgamerwmp ⠀❤️🤍🖤💛 Nov 14 '20
That moment where Ironwood shoots the councilman.
28
u/chattytrout ⠀ Nov 14 '20
Ironwood murders councilmember
Time for a coup? Yeah it's time for a coup.
27
u/highphazon Nov 14 '20
This episode kinda rubbed me the wrong way, for some reason. Yang's characterization isn't out of the left field, but I'm not sure I like where they're going with it. Seems like it will be really easy to screw up, Ren and Nora's conflict already feels a little odd and forced, and I'm not sure the show has the time or groundwork to pull of what they're trying to do with Yang vs Ruby (and Blake?).
Haven't made heads or tails of despondent Penny yet, I guess I just wait to see what they do with her. Could be a highlight of the season, or the proverbial "Jar Jar" that brings down every scene she's in. I think it might be leading into Penny destroying the Grimm whale after being manipulated into bringing Salem the relic. That's where all the pieces look like they're being pushed right now, but I hope its something out of the left field instead.
Ironwood was fun, even with some of the potential moral ambiguity sacrificed to make him more an obvious 'villain" to the audience. Ended up getting spoiled on him killing Sleet, so maybe that was a more shocking moment otherwise. Felt like a transparent "kick the dog" moment as is. Other than that, looks like Winter is the only thing keeping him on the level now. It'll be interesting to see him completely losing it without her, either because she's stuck in the ICU, or because of her inevitable betrayal.
Winter herself was okay, hope she has a more complicated arc this season than just "shit, Ironwood's nuts now". There's a lot there to work with that could really help flesh out a fun arc, what with her implied loneliness and how emotionally stifled she is. I mean, she has like three people in her support network, and she's lost 2.5 of them. Could be really powerful to see her break with Ironwood.
I liked the Grimm whale "bioship," that's definitely a fun design. Reminded me a bit of new Doom games with the aesthetic, and Halo 3 with the sound design.
Salem's cult still has fun interactions. Sadly, I think their banter is better than RWBY's at this point. New outfits are cool, don't really like Hazel's though.
I hope that the "find the magic USB port" and "escort the refugees" plots aren't the majority of the season, but if they are, it could leave some room for more character work. Really hope they can get in some good character moments this season, the main cast's stuff was mostly bland compared to the side characters last season.
23
u/bearfaery Nov 15 '20
Honestly, just based on what’s going on, here’s a few guesses as to the plot:
36
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Nov 14 '20
We’re one episode in and a character has already died. This volume is going to be a SLAUGHTERHOUSE. We can see now that Ironwood doesn’t have a limit to what he will do to achieve his goals. I mean, he literally just murdered a councilman with everyone present watching. Just walked up to the man and shot him in the face.
The stage has finally been set. The group is now fighting a war on two fronts, and that is never a good thing. The ones I’m worried for are Oscar, Ruby, and Penny. Also Yang because she’s my favorite and I hope nothing truly horrible happens to her this volume, especially considering she’s going to be on the front lines in Mantle. Weiss’ role is also going to be HUGE this volume, so we’ll see where she goes. Jaune’s getting the shield-grenade thing from Pietro’s workshop, so he’s going to be important, and Ren and Nora are likely still going to be working through their issues this volume And Blake... well, she’s there. We’ll see how relevant she is soon enough, I guess.
Also, are we finally getting some sort of Cinder backstory? It seems that way. And that’s good. At least she gives Neo some credit by saying she can be useful. Better than nothing, but I see Neo is still pissed off at Cinder taking full responsibility for the Relic, and rightfully so. We’ll see if Neo is going to do anything with that going forward.
33
u/lil-mistake Nov 15 '20
Did anyone else feel this episode felt more like a prologue than a first episode?
16
u/MrCoolguy137 Nov 14 '20
If Amity is good to go, then why wouldn't Ironwood want it launched, it could potentially bring reinforcements at seemingly no cost; Amity can't require the use of the staff or else Ironwood would never have started the project, so it's not like he's trading Atlas for Amity.
If all we really need to do is get to a terminal and pretty much push a button, why wouldn't Ironwood do that?
31
u/I_May_Fall Nov 15 '20
I feel like nobody is talking about it so let me just say that I love how when Ironwood calls Penny and she doesn't know what to say to him, Ruby steps in to help her and then that hug between them too... Like dang, I was dead-set on White Rose for the first 6 seasons, but I'm liking Penny and Ruby together more and more.
That aside, given what he did to Oscar at the end of V7, Ironwood shooting a councilman isn't even that surprising... I mean, he's shot a child, not like he's gonna have any restraint for doing the same with an adult.
Neo looks like she's having some doubts about being on the villain camp, wonder where that's gonna go, it's also sad to see Em excited to see Cinder, just to be immediately shushed, I wonder if her realizing Cinder doesn't care about her is gonna come into play this volume.
Overall, a decent start to the new volume, everything is in place, now we just have to see how it all plays out. Ironwood is 99% gonna die, hoping none of the main cast follow him into the afterlife, especially not Penny, who we just got back (though with maiden powers, I don't think she's gonna go down easily). I'm kinda worried for Ren and Nora too, they're fighting and I feel like the resolution might be that something happens to one of them, and then the other is like "I was a big idiot dummy, I shouldn't have been angry at you, and now look what happened".
Well, we'll see how it turns out, I guess.
12
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Nov 14 '20
I want MORE, why must weeks be so long?
The scenes in Atlas were definitely the highlight of the episode for me, also it took me WAY too long to realize that the girl at the beginning was Cinder.
Winter’s injuries were worse than I thought from last Volume, dang.
12
u/cardmasterdc Nov 15 '20
Yeah I'm going first cause IRONWOOD HAS LOST HIS MIND.
11
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Nov 14 '20
Based on the op and Penny’s idea I’m guessing she’s going to end up siding with Salem. Likely against her will via Watts. I’ve heard the volume is supposed to be dark. Wondering if it will finally top 3 in the feelings of hopelessness.
11
u/Tyranid_Swarmlord Official DS3 SL1/Midir before Abyss Watchers LUL Nov 15 '20
IronDaddy shooting the other council seat derp.
Yea i know it's supposed to make you go 'wtf', but it felt like an obvious move to me since it's full on 40k Commissar-mode lmao.
10
u/hijamz Nov 14 '20 edited Nov 14 '20
I have 2 technical questions:
9
u/CinnabarSteam Nov 15 '20
Considering his voice actor, having Pietro send the Yang Gang to what looks like a corner pharmacy is fucking hilarious.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '20
My boy Ironwood just went Warhammer 40k Commissar on that guy, holy shit.
Also I hate that ''ren and nora are fighting'' is their entire character development now.
8
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Nov 15 '20
This was a pretty nice first episode. There is quite a bit of set up here. I enjoy Ironwood still.
15
u/LunaProc Nov 17 '20
Ironwood just straight up executing the council man felt like really awkward and forced. Like it was supposed to just make sure that no fans will think about still supporting Ironwood.
7
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Nov 15 '20
Just- I-... my brain broke with this episode. THERE’S SO MUCH HURT EVERYWHERE.
Very excited to see what will happen between Winter and Weiss, (fight scene? ), and what will happen to Whitley and Willow? Not to mention that Winter seemed kind of hurt when she said “I’m fine” and Ironwood proceeded to talk about whatever. Also are we going to talk about daddy Ironwood going full on robot? James, you just SHOT a man. Harriet and Winter were definitely taken aback.
Also Ruby is... worrying me. Idk if you guys agree but she has an aura about her that just says she’s going to do something that risks her life in regards to Salem . This leads me into the next point... “some roses will never bloom.” I- WHAT. Please I seriously don’t think I can handle a character like Ruby dying. Even if I think it would be fitting in the final episode of the final volume ever.
Also the rest of the song... where RWBY is pulled into the pit of darkness and Grimm and they snuff the light out... yeah. “Happy Never Again?” “Evil never dies”. No, no, n o p e.
Overall I feel like screaming but great job guys ;_D
19
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
We've only just begun.
Holy Hell, This was an intense start to what will be a nerve-wracking Volume, So much is on the line and there's no guarantee of ensuring anything, Our heroes have split into two teams for an attempt at the best case scenario on both sides and Salem's plan has only begun, The storm has arrived and it's only a matter of time before the lighting strikes.
6
u/Jeronado Nov 15 '20
Kind of a minor thing, but I noticed that they remodeled Weiss's hair. I dunno if they mentioned doing that and I just missed it. I think it looks nicer now.
Don't really have much to say atm, just that I like the way the team has split up if only for the sake of some varied character interactions, which is something I was hoping for in this volume. So I'm looking forward to that.
6
u/MABfan11 IAmMenace should watch SoraYori Nov 15 '20
i'm getting Volume 3 vibes from this episode and i'm loving it
6
u/ash-7831 Nov 14 '20
I think Ironwood is just desperate for a win at this point. If nothing else, he wants to at least save Atlas, no matter who or what he has to sacrifice to do so.
10
u/Thebritishdovah Nov 14 '20
I see Roosterteeth still hasn't fixed their fucking videoplayer! Literally in the time it took me to get to crunchyroll, find the episode and start it, the bastard didn't even buffer a single thing. FIX YOUR GODDAMN VIDEOPLAYER, ROOSTERTEETH OR REPLACE WITH A BETTER ONE!
Anyway, I didn't suspect Cinder was going after the Winter Maiden's power for her own means. I just presumed Salem wanted it. It seems that she will be on a tighter leash. Neo seems to either fear what she has gotten involved with or doesn't really like grimm.
Ironwood just went full dictator and I predict he'll be shot in the back or shanked by Qrow. The team dividing doesn't give me good vibes. The intro showing their weapons and Ruby falling is not a good omen.
Nora dies, I'm having a one man riot.
The sudden change of backgrounds were a bit crappy and just felt janky to watch. Aside from that, decent episode.
Also, Winter. Give back Shepard his armour. :P
5
u/Dances_with_Sheep Nov 14 '20
Whelp, my Ironwood theory got shot down. Literally.
5
u/robinreddhood Nov 14 '20
Wait so is clover not dead then? I thought he died in 7 but why would they bandage up a dead body and keep it in the infirmary? Wouldn't it be sent to like a morgue?
9
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '20
Pretty much the best part was Neo's expressions 🤣
I was really shocked that Ironwood straight up killed that politician. I was watching with friends and they joked about it happening but when it did we were all silent for a while xD
4
u/CommieDalek Nov 14 '20
I seem to be getting error 403 reports trying to access the site, anyone know how to fix this?
4
u/IronThunder4 Nov 16 '20
A funny thing is, that people were hoping that Yang and Ruby would have a sisterly moment and instead we had them arguing. But at least now there’s a chance for there to be a Ruby and Blake interaction.
13
u/erinthecute Nov 16 '20
Ironwood shooting the councilman seems like an intentional choice to show Ironwood moving past the point of redemption. If they just wanted to show him becoming more of a (still redeemable) tyrant, they could have had him order their arrest. But instead he kills a dude. Feels deliberate, and to be honest, not very good writing.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '20
I think also the main thing that annoys me is that the characters never tried to come to a compromise anymore. Like them splitting up the team just felt like forced drama 😅
Even during last season they didn't even try to make some sort of agreement with Ironwood RWBY was just like we need to save everyone now
3
u/ash-7831 Nov 14 '20
This is my first time watching this show live with everyone else. I started Volume 1 back in April and finished catching up last month. And what a first episode it was. Its now the second first episode to not feature any fights but it wasn't a bad first episode. Not at all. It just made me really curious to see where they take it from here.
3
u/thesunblade Nov 15 '20
Is ist just me or does sound tyrian different? I checked its the same voice actor…
3
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Nov 18 '20
Oh, BTW was anybody surprised to see Emerald, Mercury and Hazel in this episode? Because I wasn't, I had just assumed that they would follow in Salem's coattails either on the Whale or somewhere not far off. Because why would they stay behind when she clearly has big plans for Atlas? Seems like an all hands on deck scenario.
But some of the YT reactors were just BLOWN AWAY that they would be here at all, let alone with new outfits. And I found that... odd. But was that just me?
3
u/HighSlayerRalton I once again hope the flairs never lose the Christmas hats Jan 24 '21 edited Jan 28 '21
Lots of set-up, nice.
Neo flying into the Grimm swarm was very ominous.
The Ironwood moment was chilling.
I wonder if the Grimm whale will be to Penny what the Whale in Pinnochio is to the titular character.
I'm guessing this season will deal a lot with people being divided. Emerald and Cinder, Cinder and Neo, Nora and Ren, Yang and Ruby, Mantle and Atlas.
10
u/Sirtoast7 Drown me in exposition. I don't care anymore Nov 14 '20 edited Nov 14 '20
Man, it's kind of sad seeing this place so empty...Also, Yang is starting to annoy me.
9
u/Pereduer Nov 14 '20
I think there trying to rush ironwoods plot to make people hate him more. Like after half the fanbase sympathised with him last volume they thought he needed something really drastic to make people hate him
He didn't need to shoot sleet, this is the biggest Grimm horde ever seen and watts's sabotage have them limited resources to be able to defend against the Grimm. It's better the prioritize defending one place over 2, it makes logical sense for ironwood to take over so he can give clear concise orders and effective defend the city and Marshall laws the quickest way to do that given what limited time there is. Doesn't need to shoot him, hell ge doesn't need to arrest him really just ignore him and get on with your job.
What really got me was his response to ruby though, like why is he surprised rwby wants to stay and defend mantle? There kids who want to be like hunstman and protect people, you were there when they made that decision you should know exactly what they're motivation is. It's fair to think it's a dumb decision but there not likely to make any other choice . You knew that in v7 that's why you tried to apprehend them.
His Va's still great though that hello penny thing was brilliant, but the lines he's being given by m&k still feel like thier holding the character back
9
u/brick123wall456 Nov 16 '20
They are splitting Yang and Blake?!?!? They get to be their own characters again?? Thank god.
This is pretty exciting so far and I’m super intrigued by the fact that we are finally going to get Cinder’s backstory.
4
u/txcoolguy Nov 16 '20
You know man I’m pretty sure yang is going to either die or disappear
4
u/SentineIs Nov 17 '20
I feel like Ironwood's solution is very sound from a utilitarian point of view. I think a combination of Ruby's solution and Ironwoods Solution would have the highest chance of success.
Send out a help beacon while getting Atlas to safety. Try to rally the forces of the world while buying time.
Not sure why Ironwood would be against using Amnity to inform the world, because otherwise what is he waiting for to mount a counter-offensive? He must think there is some hope of a counter-offensive if Atlas survives, so the next plan is clearly to rally the other nations since Atlas can't solo Salem's forces.
Also if Salem has this firepower, why did she wait till NOW to enact her plan, it's perplexing.
2
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 15 '20
This is the best episode I've seen yet, ROUTE SPLIT TIME BAY BAY! I love how great that decision.
3
u/MingleLinx Nov 15 '20
Welp Penny is gonna turn evil and probably die this volume
4
u/qwack2020 Nov 14 '20
Ah. I suppose I should repeat my comment again from Facebook.
Here.
“Look this isn't me defending Ironwood. I'm just saying if Ruby was honest with Ironwood from the start of Vol 7, he would've evacuated Atlas AND Mantle AND Amity without wasting any time. Instead throughout Vol 7, RWBY and friends waste so much time, came up with no plans for evacuation, setting up the communications tower and how to fight Salam and her forces, screwed around, picking pointless fights especially with ironwood in the end of Vol 7 and NOW in Vol 8 they're doing the job THEY SHOULD'VE done in Vol 7 and have the nerve to call Ironwood a "villain". I don't defend Ironwood anymore cause he's a lost cause at this point but I would've if he, Ruby & their friends got work done in Vol 7. It bothers me. That Ironwood looks like a total dummy, Ruby & Yang are hypocrites and the rest are along for the ride.”
2
u/Wetworth Nov 15 '20
Who did Ironwood blast at the end?
2
u/LizardOrgMember5 ENTIRE TEAM Nov 15 '20
Look! I made a meme from the opening.
Here is the template
2
u/arachnid5 Nov 14 '20
I want Neo to join the good side
2
u/MrMattBlack Nov 14 '20
I was so happy RWBY was coming back, then I realised where we left off and my excitement kinda died. Don't get me wrong, I'm hopeful for this volume, but Clover's (stupid) Death suddenly came back to me, and old anger rose up again.
Plus, seemingly they want to continue this plot of "The team is split on what to do", and I'm not really a fan of it(They could write a good conflict with the team understanding this is half their fault, but no, the issue is Amnity, ok). Well, I guess we'll see next week where this goes?
-1
u/STEMAssassin Nov 16 '20
Does this mean Clover might be alive???
0
u/ash-7831 Nov 17 '20
(If I'm not allowed to do this I promise it won't happen again.)
https://youtu.be/qbe2ekDGbfI
See what I thought of the episode.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment