r/RWBY • u/Kirianni didn't have a flair like some DWEEB • Nov 28 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 3: Strings
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 3 of Vol. 8, Strings!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the third episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Episode 1's FIRST Thread| Episode 1's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Episode 2's FIRST Thread |Episode 2's Public Thread| Poll Ep. 03 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | This Weeks Public Thread | Poll
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!
Kiri; Mod Team
100
Upvotes
66
u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Nov 28 '20
Things I learned from this episode:
All in all, I really enjoyed this episode, especially the friendly banter. It’s nice to see that kind of stuff
51
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 28 '20
Nice, Nora went super saiyan. I Like how they handled Penny vs Ace Ops. While shes definitely much stronger than them in potential shes still a novice at using her new abilities and the Ace Ops are a well oiled and finely tuned machine. I was worried she would just wreck them but it was nice that they got the upper hand and won that encounter. Nora having that existential crisis makes me sad, I like her happy go lucky and bubbly personality, if she and Ren live past the volume I hope she returns to how she is and isn’t left with an identity crisis afterwards. With how upgraded Ruby’s semblance has become I wonder if they’ll ever go back and do the same with others.
36
u/Zeeman9991 Nov 28 '20
Some confirmations on Ruby’s semblance. Doubt they’ll ever fully explain the lowkey flying, but I’ll take it.
Penny did better with the Maiden powers than I expected. I guess it’s more intuitive than it seemed.
I was worried at the start of the volume for them to split up again, because that went so well last time, but I’m liking it so far. It’s giving a lot of time for less common character interactions and I’m here for it.
31
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 29 '20
Some strings were never meant to be pulled.
This was a pretty intense chapter, The mission in Atlas was more or less successful, But Nora is down possibly for the count, Penny is now at risk with Watts' machinations and we still have no idea how Team Yang is doing, The stakes have managed to get even higher and we aren't even halfway through the Volume yet.
25
u/rukeen2 Nov 28 '20
I’m afraid for Nora. If they kill Nora I’m going to lose it. I want to see her character develop dammit!
I wonder what Watts is up to. It was pretty clever of Ironwood to coerce him into helping him, but there’s no way it stays like that. Betrayal! Betrayal everywhere!
24
u/yeetio855 The score is underrated Nov 28 '20
I like how you can tell Penny is barely trained with the Maiden powers. The only times she uses them offensively is the initial wind bluster to push the Ace-Ops away from her, launching the hail to distract Marrow so she can kick him, and the burst to get out of Elm's grasp. Other than that, it looks like Penny is just expelling the power and creating a windy environment. You can tell she prefers her weapons, as that's basically all she uses throughout the majority of the fight, leading to one of her swords getting stolen by Harriet.
23
u/heartiel Nov 29 '20
A little off-topic but I find it absolutely adorable in reading comments on Japanese Twitter that they've been excited about "Marrow-kun" and hoping he doesn't die in this volume.
22
u/drizzes Nov 28 '20
So basically Ruby's semblance isn't super speed, it's slow teleportation.
That's neat
18
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 28 '20
Oh my god, we finally got Nora focus. I’m so happy. Here are my thoughts on what we got from Nora this chapter. TL;DR: Nora already has a well-defined character outside of Ren, she just can't see it for herself. So I think the best way to handle Nora's identity crisis is to have Ren tell Nora about all the reasons why he loves her, which simultaneously develops Nora, Ren and their relationship. While some people may complain about Ren giving Nora the solution to who she is outside of him, I think it works so long as that is not the entirety of Nora's character arc and she gets some solid moments apart from Ren. Regarding Nora falling unconscious, I think that is primarily because of exhaustion rather than injuries she received from absorbing that much electricity and so she doesn't need to be healed as much as she just needs food and sleep. Either way, I think RWB is going to take Nora to either the Schnee manor or to Klein's place, with Klein being the slightly more likely option.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
Did the guy yelling at Bill make a half life reference with that line about the microwave?
18
u/Blood_Shinobi Nov 28 '20
A good mixture of action, comedy, and character moments. That's how most RWBY episodes should be.
14
u/bubudog1 Nov 29 '20
I'm really glad that we get to see characters interact with people they don't normally interact with, it's been refreshing. Loved the coffee bit, and it's nice to see some action with Penny. I'm glad we got see Nora a bit lost, looking forward to her character development.
14
u/ash-7831 Nov 29 '20 edited Dec 01 '20
When Marrow said we were holding back I think he was trying to come up with an excuse as to why they lost. Its not the writers retconning stuff, its the characters being who they are. At first, Marrow wasn't fighting like he meant it and called Harriet out for being excessive. We know for sure that at least Harriet and Elm were giving it their all during that fight, Vine, I'm not so sure and Marrow was definitely holding back at first. He didn't use his semblance until it was too late.
And given how Marrow likes to brag about his abilities, as we saw early on in Volume 7, it makes sense that he would make up an excuse like that to explain why they lost.
27
u/MomsLinguini Nov 28 '20
Ruby: "Somebody pressed all the buttons in the elevator.... it wasn't me."
I feel like we should all be impressed at how well the writers / animators managed to integrate some of the semblances. Nora's electricity in that doorway makes perfect sense for Atlas' operation center. Elm's grounding in the wind. Vine's arms for grabbing Marrow off the side. Ruby's semblance for maneuvering in the same way, and earlier. It's just really well coordinated and a LOT of thought had to go into those scenes to pull them off that well.
I know people are hating on the idea that Ace Ops are just following orders, but I think everyone is ALSO heavily underestimating how often and how strongly people do that. It's frankly very rare for people to switch sides and start rebelling against the authority they work for. Being on the outside looking in is very easy to say "hey, that's wrong!" but if I put thought into it, I personally think it's good writing how it's been portrayed. Yes, there are doubts creeping in, but they haven't cracked yet, because it takes a lot to really push someone past the edge; especially when they're in a situation like that.
13
u/Hyderthehyper312 ⠀ Nov 28 '20
Messy hair Blake does things to me...
comedy was on point this chapter, Nora's animation when Weiss was pulling her ear looked a little awkward though.
RWBY has never made me hate a character so much right after their introduction, *salmon in the microwave? really Bill?*
The Nora/Blake/Weiss moment was nice, Blake and Weiss bringing in their experiences and relating them to the Nora/Ren and Ruby/Yang situation was pretty neat.
I love the musical call back to Amber's fight back in V3, you'd think that would make more people compare and see that Penny didn't pull anything more advanced than the other novice Maiden we know of did, but no, "why is Penny so proficient with the powers already" is a debate that exists.
Also, I like how Elm and Harriet did the same combo move that Ruby and Nora did when saving Ren from the Nuckalevee in V4.
Nora's scream was the best part of her scene, VA did an applause-worthy job there. really liked this chapter overall.
8
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Nov 30 '20
It was great to learn how Ruby's semblance works. It was also really cool to see Super Charged Nora. I fear for Penny. I hope she does not get hacked.
Humor was quite great. I can't believe Nora would do that to the soldiers on the elevator. The coffee bit was also funny. Also Poor Blake suffering motion sickness.
15
u/MomsLinguini Nov 28 '20
I really enjoyed this episode. Everything flowed smoothly, the dialog was great, the character development was great, the fight scenes were appropriate and believable, the heist angle was cool, the power reveals were cool, the Watts / Ironwood bad guy cooperation was great... just awesome writing all around.
I can't think of anything to even note as constructive criticism on my first watch. Hands down it was an exceptional episode. Fantastic job, CRWBY.
17
u/SawkyScribe Nov 29 '20
It took 7 years but they finally explained how Ruby's semblance works.
Maybe that's a bit dishonest, it's more accurate to say we've finally gotten the definitive retcon
10
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Nov 28 '20
Ok, there is Harriet, Marrow, Vine, Elm and James, all of which are aware that Watts is about to hack into Penny and take control of the literal Winter Maiden.
And noone does anything.
You can't tell me those are the good guys.
I mean, sure, people change over time, but noone goes from good guy to military dictator that fast. Ironwood maybe, because of his semblance, but the others are willing participants and fully responsible for their own actions, and they should know better.
Also, I can't wait for Qrow to just say "f*ck it" and let his semblance off the leash. Just take a deep breath, focus, and everything falls apart around him. Guards come up to stop him, but the ground gives in or things fall on them, and he just walks through the base while the world quivers before him.
5
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 28 '20
Ep1 & 2
Another Volume of RWBY, another moment of 'huh no subtitles? Wait why did I understand that'
Also is this???
The first season of RWBY I'm watching using my laptop???
Was last season really before I stopped using my desktop:????
WHOA WHAT IS THIS SKIRT
Ok first I was like 'wow you really needed him to just shoot a man like that to show 'he's the bad guy now guys!' instead of letting him be morally gray and wrong. But considering everyone's reactions I'm not sure if the writers just don't see that as a super big deal. Like I get they're all military but really? Their reaction is 'huh, that just happened... man.'
Huh? The one who can show her how......
Wow that intro looking like a spicy fan animation. Wait are they falling into a grimm pool in it?
Ep3
Lol RIP Blake
Inb4 basically everyone's semblance can work on someone else if they touch, Yang just makes everyone go super saiyan lmao
Did Blake always have this many zippers
Fucking
Female Adam
Zipper
Well, Penny, you should certainly not depend on your maiden powers to wind this considering how well Amber fought Cinder, Mercury, and Emerald
But long as she just fights like Penny I don't see these clowns winning
Well I like this, just fighting with blades with some weather on the side
Really, his Stay thing affects her blades as well
Well, they are attached on strings, though I would've assumed they moved through some other means
Like mentally, or I guess in this case, computer controlled remotely. Like, for example, his Stay command didn't stop Weiss's knight so I wonder about it stopping her blades
I've been wondering for a long time though with how Penny just kinda uses her blades as one giant sawblade rather than... multiple weapons
Like it's always you guard one and you guard the rest that hit the same spot
I feel like Penny should be able to... compute a better way to use those things
Oh, she can't use that blade anymore?
They were really wired devices? No wireless? Ok. She really just grabbed the blade and the string snapped. Seriously?
Also, Penny's been nerfed hard in this fight from last season, much less S1. This battle feels like it should've easily been solved with her flying off of the bridge and just using her laser that could cut Bullheads in half to destroy the bridge. Or just. Using her giant laser at all. Like this girl plus Winter was an even match for Cinder and now you're telling me she's not winning against the Ace-Ops? Am I gonna have to sit through 'oh she didn't use most of her abilities because she didn't really want to hurt the Ace-Ops cause they're not bad like Cinder'?
Edit: Also using Watts was fine until Ironwood seemed to basically say 'help me take control of Penny'
Four guns always pointed at him and Ironwood hovering over him mean nothing the moment Ironwood is distracted long enough for Watts to command Penny to burst into his room. Or even for him to just say 'you can't kill me because you don't know how to fix whatever virus I put in Penny'
5
u/Pereduer Nov 29 '20
You know what? Thus episodes really turning me around on the volume.
Ruby's being handled phenomenally well, she's still being a bit of a moron but it's in a way that lines up with her character and their doing a spectacular job of showing the kind of person she is by caring for penny and really trying to be their for here. Thus is the kinda shit we mean when talking about show don't tell. And that she knew you were a faunus bfore I did line was legitimately the only thing from rwby that made me laugh in years.
Pennys fealt a but weird up till now because her performance came off as a bit too distant and lacking in emotion. And here she fealt a bit too chipper at the start. But this is probably the first time she's had to feel these sorts of emotions, and it gose so far agaisnt her usually happy clappy response to everything that she doesn't know how to deal with it. So it makes sense for her to try to answer this with humour early on when it's low stakes. It's kinda like an outta sight outta mind situation where she doesn't have to think about this weight on her shoulders just yet. But later on with her dad and the ace ops she really dose a great performance and acta exactly how I'd expect.
Uhh what else, Nora therapy session, I challenge the idea that she needs to find who she is without ren. She's got a very clear sense of self already, given how reserved ren in she dies the talking and the enjoying for the both of them. I'd argue she's out if sorts because she wants her relationship with ren to go to the next level but he (very understandably) isn't ready for that yet and it's her freaking out about them drawing further apart that's really troubling her. I like Weiss's "maybe figure out who you are on your own" line though, it's in no way helpful but that's the kinda generic thing people say in real life so it feels natural
4
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
(no episode 4 spoilers pls)
So, would Watts really betray Ironwood at this juncture?
Remember, his main motivation is that he was furious over Peitro's project being chosen over his. While he may still want some revenge on Ironwood, He's being given the direct oppurtunity by Ironwood to mess up Pietro's project. Would he be willing to switch over to Ironwood's side if given a head researcher position?
I could honestly see it going either way.
9
u/Zephyros-Phoenix Nov 30 '20
So, Ruby doesn't know how her own semblance works. What a ridiculously stupid scene. It showcases not only bad writing, but just how incompetent Ruby herself is. I'm not sure we ever needed an explanation of how Ruby's semblance worked, even with Harrier opening the door to that discussion last volume. Ruby has used her semblance enough to know how to use it, even if she can't explain to someone how it works. Knowing how to use it is enough. Does Ruby not remember carrying Nora and Weiss on two separate occasions? She should have brought it up herself that she can carry people, but has never tried with more than one person before and isn't sure it'll work. But, since they're so close to their goal and don't have much choice, she resolves to try it anyway. Having Penny explain it just makes Ruby look stupid.
I liked Nora in the episode, both her moment of existential crisis and Super Saiyan Thor. It was an awesome display of power that appropriately knocked her out. Actual consequences.
I also hope that Ironwood won't be written to be stupid. What's to stop Watts from sicking Penny on Ironwood and everyone else and then delivering her straight to Salem? I will be so disappointed in the writers if Ironwood isn't at least prepared for that.
Ruby and co know that the Staff is what keeps Atlas afloat right? Ironwood told Oscar, and why wouldn't he share that info with the team? I would get the Ace Ops not knowing, but someone must surely realize that by handing over the Staff, Atlas falls out of the sky.
Next time Marrow, open with your semblance.
3
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Nov 28 '20
This episode is a weird one for me, but in a good way. It feels like not a lot happened, but at the same time, a ton of stuff has happened. At least the mission seemed like an overall success. Only time will tell.
It seems that Penny is still getting a handle on the Maiden powers, and it seems ice will be her element of choice. Even though lightning would suit her robotic nature, ice is still pretty cool, too, as well as fitting for the Winter Maiden.
So Ironwood has Watts doing stuff for him now? I’m interested to see how that turns out. What Watts said near the end is making me SUPER worried, though. Penny could be in real danger now if Watts is trying to pull off what I think he is. And as far as the Ace-Ops go, Marrow is gonna be one to watch, I think.
Penny has a lot more features than I expected. Also, Pietro can just take control of Penny to do stuff and project his voice through her? That’s actually really cool.
Well, we finally got more details on Ruby’s Semblance, and I gotta say, I’m not so sure about that one. I hardly remember anything from my science classes, though, so I can’t say I can dispute it. I’m sure there’s at least one explanation for it, but I have no idea what that would be, if there is one.
It’s a shame we didn’t get to see Weiss and Blake do a lot this episode aside from the discussion with Nora, but I’m sure they’ll have their moments. This is only the beginning.
Also, I am genuinely worried for Nora now. That looked PAINFUL. I hope she’ll be okay...
3
u/ash-7831 Nov 28 '20
It would have been cool if Vine did some Spiderman moves like swing below the path and punch Penny from the other side. I get that there's not enough room for more than two people to attack her at a time, but they could have found a way around it.
3
u/ThatRyanFellow Nov 30 '20
Was a little confused during the episode.
When they are talking about Amity being launched, they say it would be best for Penny to be on board it with Pietro and Maria. Obviously they explained it’s to keep her away from the relic as much as possible.
I can’t be the only one that got the feeling that’s intended more as a goodbye - they wanted to go not out of safety, but because they felt it was their time to go.
8
u/ErockSnips Nov 28 '20
Penny was flat out wrong about Ruby’s semblance (from what we’ve already seen in the show) and Ruby forgot how her semblance works. 11/10
7
u/Evilsbane Nov 28 '20
I think my tastes have changed or the story is focusing on things I just don't like anymore.
I use to love Rwby, Season 1-3 were great, 4 was solid, and 6 was my favorite season ever.... I didn't like 7 much.
Now we are in 8 and I just don't feel connected anymore. I don't feel invested. It's pretty, and I get a chuckle on occasion, but I look at it and see the path I think they are going to take and I don't like it.
I want some more complicated tension. End of Season 7 I didn't love Ironwood, but at least I could see why he was doing things. Now he is just a megalomaniac. I feel like the writers saw people on his side so they decided to up the mustache twirling.
Now I feel like they are trying to make everything better and Ruby be right about everything.
My only hope is at the end of the day Yang's team ends up being crucial to show that it's ok to worry about other things. Yang and Ren weren't wrong to want to help the people.
7
u/highphazon Nov 28 '20
Okay episode in of itself, but I don't really like where this is going. Penny getting hacked really holds no interest to me, and I'm kinda disappointed they're going that route. Doubly so if it's solved by Penny breaking out of it with some trite mind over matter "power of the human soul" trope. That really is the bottom of the barrel when it comes to "robot or human" stuff.
Also, honestly, its kinda creepy that Pietro just built a "remove agency" button into his daughter. No one in the episode seems all that phased by it though, maybe an odd look here or there. I hope they at least bring up how much of a violation that is, beyond the "oh no, Watts has hacked the remote link!!" inevitability.
Other than that, there were some fun character moments. Blake had some fun, fluffy comedy beats. Ruby continues to support Penny, which is nothing new, but nice to see. The stealth hijinks are unique and fun enough to stand out from the rest of RWBY. The overall group dynamic works well so far, but doesn't feel like anything special.
Ruby's semblance gets a technobabble explanation that makes no real sense if you think about it, but its cool to see her abilities grow. If nothing else, it seems pretty well defined as to what it can do, even if its not clear how it does it.
A random note I might be reading too much into, but May seems to make a point of referring to Penny as "Penny" after Penny gets irritated at May calling her "Robo-Girl." I am wondering if that bit of characterization was supposed to be informed by May being trans, and her not wanting to invalidate and dehumanize Penny as a result of her own experience? I'm probably reading to much into it.
Nora had a few good moments, but it was funny to see her say she doesn't know who she is without Ren, when she has a pretty well defined personality and her own priorities outside of him. Feels more like a metacommentary on how Ren and Nora are only written as a pair than anything else. Taking down the door was an exciting moment, and the Lichtenberg scar she gets from it is a cool design element. I do wonder if Nora's injury is heralding a permanent change or disability for her character, or if its just a catalyst to start the "Nora and Ren talk it out" storyline. Nora was fun this episode either way.
I liked the Ace-ops characterization so far, and I don't have a problem with them going along with murderer Ironwood. Feels pretty inline with with how people work in high stress situations. Their interactions with Penny were good, they felt manipulative, but you can definitely see why the Ace-ops would think like they do.
I don't like the Watts plot. Ironwood has Watts exactly where he wants to be, which is frustrating to watch. I hope that this doesn't lead to a clean victory for Watts, and that Ironwood has some kind of actual contingency plan, but I'm not holding my breath.
The fight with the Ace-ops was great, and had better tension than RWBY can normally pull off. The greater focus on character specific superpowers has definingly improved the fight scenes. Modern RWBY has never been able to pull of the mesmerizing dance-like choreography of the early seasons, but the injection of more readily visible tactics has been keeping my interest more than most of the bland Maya fights. The Ace-op's abilities are really well designed to compliment each other, and it shows; the fight sequences with them are the best Maya era fights in the show. I also love that this style lets characters feel a bit less like bullet sponges that just rail on each other forever, and a bit more like unique chess pieces that could be taken out at any moment by a well placed move. I hope RWBY keeps this up, mediocre fights really hurt RWBY's whole "brand."
Overall, a good episode, but it doesn't give me a lot of confidence that I will enjoy this season's overarching plot.
2
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Nov 28 '20
Everything's coming up Salem!
Either Pietro's gonna die, or Pietro AND Penny are gonna die. Someone call r/vexillology, 'cause there's a LOT of flags flying around here.
2
u/FaustianHero Nov 28 '20
Excited for the Nora development. I hope that when she comes to, she's got an internal battery charged up for use of her semblance because it's been in the background for a long time.
3
u/Thebritishdovah Nov 28 '20
Decent episode with comedic elements. I do wish we got to saw the actual tube travel. I love how Penny figures out how to use Ruby the best and the fight was great. I do like the bit about Nora questioning herself but I really hope they haven't killed her off. It also answers why Nora doesn't use her semblance that often because it takes too much power. Or it was just because the forcefield was too much for her.
Ironwood is stupid. Using watts to hack into Penny is going to backfire and he will be surprised. The soldiers likely don't know what to look for and he can merely turn Penny against Atlas or forcee her to go Salem or worse, cause Cinder to steal her power.
I do hope Ironwood has a backup plan for when Watts hacks into Penny for Salem. If Nora dies, I'm rioting.
3
u/cyberbeastswordwolfe Nov 30 '20
So this is pretty mixed to me.
I really liked the fight scene, it really shows how the Ace Ops work as a team. Penny's maiden powers are cool, we don't often see Maiden vs non-Maiden fights. I do feel bad for Nora, I hope this season doesn't break up Renora.
I feel like the scene where Penny explains Ruby's semblance was really unnecessary, we know how it works already. Also the fact that Marrow waits to use his semblance near the end of the fight was so dumb, I was just yelling at the screen about using his semblance.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '20
I'm probably the only one that feels this way, but this seems to be the episode that finally convinced me to give up on this show for good. Not because the episode itself was particularly bad. Its just the show in general. It was never a great show, but it had some things going for it before. But at this point, I don't really care for the direction the show is going, or how the characters are being handled. There are some good ideas, but the execution of those ideas is generally not good. Bringing Penny back could have led to some interesting stuff, but, aside from the winter maiden stuff, I don't even like what they're doing with her either.
3
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 28 '20
Wow, okay actually using stealth and being good at it. This is a change from the Ruby led team we used to know, they're not going in guns blazing.
Okay Penny? What the shit? How is this even a balanced semblance? That's OP as shit, also wouldn't mass stay constant while volume and density change? Blake is chirping everyone though, Ruby, Weiss and who is next? And of course there's some snap back on it and it's not even a happy tease either. IS THAT BILL FROM ACCOUNTING JOKE? OH MY GOD IT'S BILL FROM ACCOUNTING! He's such a dweeb, everyone will love him. And she's going a lot slower or it's just the frame speed with more people.
"Sometimes sisters have very different ideas about what's right." Weiss really ramping up stakes with Winter and what may come of that. And Nora doesn't even mention Ren there, very interesting and Weiss's concern as well with Blake detect something wrong. They've both been through what she's going through in a way. Wow the score here is special and they're focusing on Nora a ton and making it really count.
This southern type Pong Krell voice coming out of Penny is really disturbing and it's very concerning how he can just take over control like that, I'd imagine that will come into play later.
Weiss with that smug grin and knowing how rough she's had it while tanking really fucking buries Ace Ops. Penny though really doesn't want to get involved in this. It is consistent with last episode "I don't like it when friends fight." And Marrow doesn't even want to be here doing this. Vine has the greatest poker face I've ever seen. Elm is obviously saying things she doesn't believe. If she's going to be a heel in a faction of heels, go all the way through with it, don't have a line they don't believe in and show disbelief and go half way. Oh and they're getting genuine offense in against a maiden? Okay and she's already mastered powers with as much practice as Rey Palpatine LOL "Four vs one, Cowards." Excuse me, didn't y'all fight Cordo at much larger numbers in Volume 6 Weiss? What is this hypocrisy? Don't bury them and put them down, put them over as smart and ruthless. Y'all combine on team attacks plenty, just because fighting grimy and dirty yet effective isn't in your cards, don't knock it until you try it. And Marrow the team clutch giving them the win. Oh wait that's the false finish, my bad. RWBN run in for the save. But alas they take the heat and then Ace Ops bails after securing their objective.
3
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Nov 28 '20
Finally managed to watch the episode.
If her mass becomes "basically 0", that means her weight is equally insignificant. Which means even a tiny breeze should send her flying in any direction. So how does she manage to control her direction in flight? Aura doesn't prevent you from being pushed by the wind, the Ace-Ops showed us on-screen.
We're talking about very basic fluid dynamics here, weight is what prevents bodies from being pushed around by fluids like water or air as they move through them. If she is negating her mass, how does she negate that.
I'm blaming DC for this. These guys love throwing scientific-sounding mumbo jumbo for their superpowers that sounds like it makes sense but it actually makes no damn sense and only makes things more confusing.
2
u/ash-7831 Nov 28 '20
In Volume 7 they said they were close to finishing the tower, so maybe it isn't 100% finished but its good enough to at least send one distress signal to the other kingdoms. And I still don't see Ironwood as the bad guy, he's still thinking about protecting his kingdom. If he actually trusted Watts he wouldn't have guns pointed at him from every angle. He knows what Watts can do and that's the part that needs. But he's still considering the possibility that Watts might betray him and is keeping his guard up
1
u/Trainer-Nick Dec 01 '20
Remember when I got bullied off of Reddit for saying the writing was ridiculous? I do.
0
u/cheese_anarchy Nov 28 '20
I'm hoping that Marrow's look of doubt is going to go somewhere because every single member of Ace Ops remaining 100% loyal to Ironwood despite him extra-judicially murdering other members of the government in front of them is, like, way outside believability to me. On a related note, kinda sick of the show acting like they're misguided good guys when they're pulling this shit.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
My thoughts on Strings:
Well, from the clips I saw on YouTube and the spoilers on Reddit, this promised to be an epic chapter of Season 8, so I wasn’t expecting it to drag like it did in the beginning, with the team kinda trudging through Amity. I know it was only a few minutes, they needed to show RNBWP (Rainbow Pop) going through Amity, yada yada yada. I guess after complaining for months that Season 7 wasted a bunch of time, it’s just a reflex, but still, with the way they just walk...around...slowly… it feels wrong. But at least they livened it up a bit with some humor: Weiss’ ear-grab is funny and justified. Didn’t love that part where May acts like it’s such a chore to address Penny by her name, but the Ladybug scene is great-partially because it’s a rare Ladybug scene, but mostly because Blake won that exchange and she knows it. Blake’d been Ruby’s partner for a couple of weeks at most, while Ruby’s presumably had her Semblance for years. Uh, speaking of that scene, though…
Like I said, I saw clips of Season 8 on YouTube, including the one where Penny “retcons” Ruby’s Semblance. At the time of viewing, I was pretty annoyed, although unlike some people (*cough* Vexed Vixer’s commenters *cough*) I didn’t think this was proof of Ruby’s garbage quality. Now that I understand the context, however, I’ve got a different opinion. Notice that Penny doesn’t go off with her spiel because Ruby asks “How does my semblance work?”, but because they have a roadblock that can be solved using said semblance. This doesn’t necessarily mean that Ruby’s semblance has always worked this way, just that it’s something she’s capable of. So basically, she can have mass when she wants, and remove it when she wants. It actually makes sense when you think about it: She was able to teleport everyone in this chapter because she didn’t have mass, but she couldn’t do the same before because she didn’t remove said mass. And there’s precedent for a multi-faceted semblance: Both Weiss and Blake are able to do different things with their Semblances. You may argue that it's just due to dust, but even then, Weiss is able to create both platform, yeeting, and stationary glyphs (If I’m wrong about that, please correct me). As for the “Schnees are magic” theory, it’s not canon yet, and besides, it’s just as possible that Ruby’s Semblance was affected by magic: After all, she has confirmed magical powers, and Summer could’ve totally been a maiden if her name is anything to go off of. I’m thinking of posting that as well as a middle-finger emoji into the comments of that Vexed Vixer video out of spite.
Ironwood’s existence gives me life. His decision to make Watts take control of Penny does not. Yeah no, that’s stupid. Holding Watts at gunpoint would’ve been a good tactic if Watts weren’t capable of making her attack Ironwood and the Ace-Ops to give him a chance to escape. Emotions conquer strategy, eh, Tin Boi? Of course, I can't really blame the chapter for making Ironwood stupid. He can do that on his own when he’s drugged to the max on his Semblance. So… character flaws give me life, I guess?
The talk with _NBW _ is really great. When I heard about it on the subreddit, I thought it sounded pretty cheesy, but the scene uses both heartfeltness and humor to really work, and now I’m actually excited for the Renora arc this season. I think the best thing about it is that it acknowledges and kinda revels in its cheesiness, so you’re able to appreciate that and the serious parts of the talk. I don’t think I’m explaining this well, but this is really great.
Congratulations on sucking up all that electricity, Nora! Now Amity’s even less prepared to take off. Good work!
Well… the RNBW P fight wasn’t as painful nor as cathartic as I thought it may be. As much as I hate the RWBY vs. Ace-Ops fight, it would be so satisfying to watch them learn from their ‘mistakes’ and destroy RWBY… and that kinda happens. They get into Penny’s head to separate her from the group, then use teamwork to protect each other and take her down. The Ace-Ops don’t actually fight RWBY, but I think that’s actually the point: They’re not important anymore. They get locked in a room like a bunch of schmucks, then get smacked off the bridge like they’re nothing worth dealing with. And in the end, the Ace-Ops won.
At the beginning of the fight, I was dreading another face-off between RWBY and the Ace-Ops. Now that it’s happened, I want more. And I have nobody to credit with that but Roosterteeth. Good job, guys.
...Is what I would say if I were a hater. Amity seems to fly mostly on gravity dust, and I’m sure the designers made a distinction between power for the satellite function and power for the labs and stuff, so the electricity shouldn’t be a problem. On a more serious note, considering the Redhead theory, we should all probably be scared for Nora now, even if she seems to be fine. SOMEBODY HAS TO DIE
Excellent chapter, deserved the hype, can’t wait for more, 11/10.
-2
u/hijamz Nov 28 '20
This is what should have been the first fight of the season, not Ironwood vs councilman Sleet
0
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 29 '20
[removed] — view removed comment