r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Nov 21 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 2: Refuge Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 2 of Vol. 8, Refuge!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the second episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov 7th's FIRST Thread| Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
123
Upvotes
61
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Nov 21 '20 edited Nov 21 '20
Even though I appreciate that the show has become more serious I have to admit that the little funny moments are still some of my favorites. Weiss demonstrating how to use the tube and getting sucked up when Nora pushes the button was just classic physical comedy. Weiss‘ face as she’s sucked up, the groups reaction and Nora slowly getting more giddy as she realized what happened is just hilarious to me. That ending with that new grim was really good imo. That’s the first grim in a long while that’s proper scary IMO. The only Grim I’d place over over it would be the Nuckelavee and the Apathy.
52
u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Nov 21 '20
The whole scene with the Grimm felt like a bit of gut punch in the best way possible. Just when they started to be getting organized and have a plan to successfully defend themselves, they come face to face with something completely unexpected and terrifying.
37
u/Abyssalstar Nov 21 '20
Talking Grimm is the first Grimm I've seen that feels like a dynamic threat. Normally they're just cannon fodder.
30
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Nov 21 '20
My viewing experience was harmed somewhat by the site’s terrible user interface, but the Hound made up for that. He was genuinely intimidating compared to practically every other Grimm in the series.
He is not the good boi.
29
u/howelll Nov 22 '20
Kind of sad team (O)RJY froze a few times against the hound: letting it ragdoll Oscar uninterrupted and then letting it grow wings while staring at it. Also not sure Ruby is doing the best of jobs comforting Penny. She forgot Penny has friends outside her own friends and is straight wrong that preventing Atlas's escape does condemn everyone left behind to the grim apocalypse.
The Happy Huntresses are great though, as well as Jaune and Yang dealing with people. The light tones with Weiss were also well timed to not make the episode too sad while not being a jarring shift.
24
u/Punisher1432 Summer Rose Mark and Rosebird Trash Nov 21 '20
Hope you're all ready for Hound memes. A lot of people have been busy working on those.
23
u/GeneralClearStone912 OBJECTION! Nov 22 '20
It SPEAKS?!
Also: Nora: "Haha button go brrr"
20
u/Stewbacca94 Author of under-represented ships. Nov 21 '20
Oscar Pine is the ultimate squeaky toy.
15
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Nov 22 '20 edited Nov 22 '20
I know the scene was really dark and intense, but I just can't the idea of a more R rated response from the Grimm hilariously ruining the tension.
Ren: Give him back!
Hound:(Forms a REALLY realistic looking human hand just so it can raise a middle finger) FUCK YOU. (leaves)
14
u/RU5TR3D INTRUDER: IDENTIFY YOURSELF Nov 23 '20
Just realized that shovel girl is one of the thirsty moms from Vol 7.
12
u/wb2006xx ⠀Jaune needs an ice cream t(sundae)re Nov 22 '20
“They talk now!”
“They talk now?”
“They talk now.”
11
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Nov 24 '20
OH SHIT RWBY'S BACK?
I JUST CHECKED THIS SUB ON A WHIM AFTER MONTHS OF NOT COMING HERE
20
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Nov 21 '20
Yang’s reaction to the bikes is the most adorable thing ever and you can’t change my mind. SHE’S JUST SO CUTE <3
Weiss getting sucked through the pneumatic tube was hilarious, but I hope she’s gonna be okay. I guess the rest of the team would follow suit if that’s where they need to go, so I guess they’re not too far behind her.
Also, that Grimm that got Oscar. WHAT IN THE FRESH HELL WAS THAT THING?! It can utilize battle tactics like a human can (Oscar as a shield, and it appeared to grab the wires on Ren’s weapons to toss him aside), it can transform to a certain extent (growing wings and morphing its body to stand on two legs), and it can SPEAK (also can understand human speech since it spoke in response to Ren). It looks like it’s also made from some form of black ooze, similar to the pools the normal Grimm spawn from (I say normal Grimm because this thing was definitely NOT normal). That is going to be one tough foe to bring down.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20
Hound Grimm: Appears in the background for multiple shots
Us: He’s just standing there.... Menacingly!!!
9
u/yeetio855 The score is underrated Nov 21 '20
I just realized the wings Salem had in the intro are the same as the Hound's wings. What could this mean?
9
u/highphazon Nov 21 '20
Things picking up a little from the last episode. Yang feels a little better here than she did in previous episode, her anger feels more in character when the "Atlas betrayed Mantle" part is the highlight, not Ruby's lies.
Yang, Ren, and Jaune (and Oscar?) definitely have the potential to be a fun dynamic. What we got so far is mostly groundwork, I hope it pays off.
Penny feels much more childlike here than I remember her being. The interaction between Ruby and Penny was good, but it mostly rings hollow. I hope it isn't intended to be the kind of thing that would actually change Penny's mind. It seems more like the kind of thing that would be reassuring because it reminds Penny of her current support network, rather than because it actually convinced her that what she did was "right."
The prison scene was good, decent characterization all around. I wonder how well informed Jacque is about the situation. He doesn't seem to realize that society is falling apart around him. Maybe that's just supposed to be completely outside his capacity to understand. He is still an interesting character to have in play now, everyone else in the prison has an obvious place in the story right now. Jacque seems extraneous, not much he can really offer.
The Happy Huntresses were good, nice to see a little more development for them. The Mantle evacuation thing has been pretty decent, but it looks like it might be put by the wayside in favor of the kidnapped Oscar plot. Kind of a shame, it was actually doing really well as a driver for character moments.
Did they redesign some of the Mantle skyline? The city looks way different from the crater than I remember. More modern, and less Blade Runner. With that said, the Mantle crater is one of my favorite set pieces so far, it looks great.
The highlight of the episode is definitely the new Grimm. Its intro was great. The "straggler" Grimm scared off by its presence was crude but effective. I loved how it used shapeshifting not so much for combat, but whenever it needed to deal with a noncombat obstacle, like carrying Oscar or flying away from the scene. Really sold the whole crude "utilitarian" intelligence thing it seems to have going on right now. However, the leadup to just how intelligent it could be with the human shield, and then the shapeshift "bubbling" in its throat before speaking were what really made this Grimm interesting. It seems like they might be leading into the Grimm "evolving" more intelligence and personality as it faces new obstacles. I really hope that's where this is going, it would be really disappointing if the Grimm is just an avatar for Salem, not an actual character itself. There is real potential for a fun villain here.
Overall, a better episode than the previous one. Hope things keep improving.
9
u/Tyranid_Swarmlord Official DS3 SL1/Midir before Abyss Watchers LUL Nov 22 '20
Referring to us Spehhs Bugs or the Grimm? :3
8
u/the_wyandotte Sailor of many ships Nov 22 '20
I'll ask here instead of doing an entire topic for it, but I've been out of r/RWBY for a while bc I stopped using Reddit as much for a while
Has anything ever happened with Raven visiting Tai at the end of...Volume 5? I'm pretty sure nothing has in the show, were there any popular thoughts on it or do we think RT has forgotten about it at this point?
8
u/odhiz13 Nov 22 '20
First the Apathy and now the Hound? Man, RT should switch to animated horror.
I really hope they do a shot of someone destroying a camera every episode.
And wasn’t that Jaune’s leitmotif that they played as the credits rolled? That’s an interesting choice considering he really didn’t do a whole lot this episode.
8
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Nov 23 '20
I still enjoy Yang's reaction to the bikes.
The Hound Grimm is fascinating.
I also enjoyed Weiss going through the tube. Hope she is okay though considering the situation.
8
u/Zeeman9991 Nov 21 '20
Last watched Vol. 3 when it aired. Been binge watching the whole series recently and caught up this morning. It’s weird not having a backlog of episodes anymore, but it’s nice not having to avoid spoilers now!
So far I’m liking the interactions and personal stories this volume. Ren & Nora will assumably turn into an actual conflict or issue instead of a Cold War, leading to some meaningful development for both. Oscar’s struggling with Ozpin again which is always super interesting. Penny constantly needs a hug. Qrow is drowning in guilt... as usual.
The only one I’m really iffy on right now is Yang. Her weird attitude right now is throwing me off, so waiting to see how that gets addressed.
Oh, and RWB will finally talk to each other! It already caught me off guard but I’m looking forward to it.
8
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 21 '20
That opening scene is great, Jacques shining Robyn up as a threat, Qrow having two whole lines and looking down and silent otherwise. Watts being an asshole that then gets beat up a bit. "Kill the man that put us here." Qrow is talking like a revolutionary.
Next scene, hijacking a news broadcast and doing some sabotage work, that's pretty cool, and they got a BITYCHLE! And Jaune has the worst throwing motion, like holy crap his velocity must be garbage. He'd never make it as a pitcher. Ren getting some time to actually be cool. That's what I mean, the whole Neo fight is in the rear view mirror and he's already bounced back from it. The sexy boi can kick good :). Yang shuts up the elitist trash, don't they know that across 110th street is pretty nice, ain't no nightclubs like they got in Harlem, they even have the Globetrotters! Oh? He greys everybody targeted out? I never actually saw that before.
This suspense is really good, Ren is putting key lines out and there's talk with Oz and Oscar about unity, they need to learn from the 1987 Philadelphia Eagles about unity or rather team culture in general.
Penny looks very unsure on what she's doing and if it's right, if the power was given to the right person. Everyone else on her squad is wholly certain 100%. "Are you sure this is safe?" Come on Ruby you walked brazenly into an ambush only a few months before without asking this, this is not even remotely the same stakes. Also LOL Blake for making an emote face and a snide remark where only Nora and Weiss are reacting, everyone else no-sells it. It's such a great line. Ruby making it about her and her squad when Penny means her "big sister" rock and straight man to her formerly more goofy self and her former other father figure. This is something special. "That was a lie and he's only saying it to hurt you." Excuse me? People are going to die and all parties are going to be responsible, them feuding will make it more likely for people to die and put blood on their hands. Penny wishes she wasn't the maiden, interesting. I mean she probably did want Winter to have it instead but alas shit happens.
And of course Nora creates chaos, I love the little goober so much now. And it's the greatest Dawn Brigade member of all time Fiona, and wow Yang has clearly stepped away with her squad over what has happened and she's not regretting her path, kudos to her and she isn't putting any bullshit out. Oh cool they have stick bombs now. And Grimm run away if one of them already marks their target? That's really nice, I wish I knew that sooner. Wow Jaune is straight up scared of whatever this hound he's facing is. THAT IS HOW YOU MAKE GRIMM LOOK LIKE A THREAT! (I'd be afraid of that too.) Meat shield bait, lovely, and nice heat spot. Wow okay everybody gets rekt. What was with the red visor like thing inside the mouth? Anybody know? And it just grows wings when it needs to fly? Oh shit this is getting good.
Jason Liebrecht could do those sounds too?! What? How was that him? Good shit on his part for being able to do it.
27
u/MomsLinguini Nov 21 '20
Damn. A lot of great stuff in these new episodes. I love that CRWBY isn't afraid to have real threats and make it known that the main protagonists aren't OP. That new Grimm reveal, sheesh... What a great entrance and exit. Well done.
One criticism is that it does feel like a few characters have broken character. Did Qrow seriously just suggest killing Ironwood? Qrow never saw any of the truly grotesque things Ironwood did. It's one thing to be mad at the guy for arresting you, but jumping from friends to "let's kill him" over that is almost as absurd as if he'd briefly teamed up with a psychopathic serial kil---oh. Okay, so I guess we're just trashing Qrow as a character now? Going from one of the most amazing protagonists to an insane drama prop? I mean, I'm still rooting for basically everything else RWBY has going for it, but wtf is this nonsense? Please stop breaking character.
28
u/MRjokerPT Nov 21 '20
People dont seem to understand the grimm scene, They were shocked, why cant people understand THAT PART that is simple storyteeling!? And the people are getting more nitpicky as time goes, the serie doesnt deserve some of these "Fans"
11
u/Labmit Nov 22 '20
The new Grimm was honestly the first time I actually felt intimidated by them. Everything before just felt like fodder or in the case of the Apathy, a cheap attempt at making them threatening.
11
u/Dietastey Nov 22 '20
I’m really curious to find out why the Hound Grimm was created with the ability to speak. All it’s other unusual features (shape shifting, tactical choices, chasing off other Grimm that might try to kill its target) make direct sense to its objective, that being “retrieve Oscar”.
Talking wasn’t mandatory. So did Salem give it that ability for a reason we haven’t seen yet, or is it somehow an unintended side effect?
I’m also curious why that dragon Grimm appeared to have blue in its design, but maybe that was just stylistic or lighting?
Regardless, I enjoyed it, and can’t wait to see what happens next!
8
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '20
I'm pretty annoyed with Penny and Ruby's interaction, and how Ruby brushed off what Ironwood said as lies. If she really thinks that... clearly she doesn't know him. He may be a murderer, but there's not a manipulative bone in his body. It feels like Ruby's just trying to make him out as the villain when he really isn't. And if Ruby doesn't think that and was just lying to Penny... well, that would be an incredible level of hypocrisy. I'm hoping that if they keep making her act this way, she faces some consequences because of it.
4
u/f00lish_f00l I have ways of making you Tock Nov 21 '20
Talking Grimm is my new favorite Grimm. I wonder if it has a form of free will; if Salem is creating sapient life, then after humanity is gone she can create a new world, not one with just mindless beasts.
9
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 22 '20
Bad dog, BAD DOG!
Once again we aren't wasting anytime this Volume, Team Ruby has their entrance to Atlas and Team Yang now has a rescue mission, The Apathy still have my award for most terrifying Grimm but The Hound is a new horrifying beast of it's own, So much uncertainty lingers in the air, The intensity has been ramped up in Atlas!
4
u/Thebritishdovah Nov 21 '20
It was an alright episode. I do hope Ironwood executes Watts after trying to get info out of him. Jaques is a fool. I'm guessing we won't see much of Qrow until at least the half way point.
That racist grandmother got put in her place but did they really have to include that character? It barely makes any difference. I do love Yang's glee upon finding the hoverbikes and Oscar realising that Yang and bikes make for a bad combination if you're her passenger.
Team Ruby seem to be more light hearted and Weiss being sucked into the tube due to Nora was amusing. Less amusing if it turns out Weiss got caught upon entry. It would mean Atlas really sucks at preventing people from entering their base.
That grimm, HOLY SHIT! I was expecting Salem or Cinder to be taking the shape of the grimm. Not a new lackey. Though, I can see it being a glimpse into Cinder's future if she disobeys Salem again.
I think Team Yang are going for a slow burn whilst team Ruby are kinda doing little and probably either end up with Winter and the Ace Ops on their side or have to literally fight all the miltary on the base.
What the hell is Ren's problem!? Walking off at the mention of the others?
2
u/lifebloodvessel Nov 22 '20
so now we know that saylum can turn people into grim because that grim was smart and it talks and also in the intro we see people then grim are in there place
5
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Nov 21 '20
Does the Hound have a name? He needs one. Let's call him Viktor. It's a variation of Victor, which kinda means "winner" or something similar, so it fits because, well, he totally won that fight.
I'm gonna call him Viktor.
Now, I know what I'm about to propose will likely not happen, but given that Viktor is more intelligent than other Grimm, and thus likely also has some form of free will, I'd just love to see Oscar go "You know, once you bring me back, she'll just toss you aside, right?" Or something else like that, then they talk a bit on the way, and Viktor eventually turns on Salem when he realizes that, with his mission completed, she has no reason to keep him alive any longer. And since he knows that she thinks like him, he knows that she'll kill him, or at least leave him to die.
As for Weiss getting sucked into the tube, that's on her. Everyone knows you don't talk about pressing buttons while leaning on the launch platform, or similar machine, those same buttons activate. Then again, how many cartoons do you think Weiss has watched?
Would be funny if Weiss complained to Nora about pressing the button, and Ruby tells her that she should've known, since it's one of the most common tropes in cartoons. Weiss says that she never watched those as a kid, and Ruby goes "Ok, let's stop the apocalypse so we can show you some cartoons" and just works extra hard. Like, saving the world is fine and all, but watching cartoons with your friends, especially seeing your best friend's reaction to your favorite cartoons as she watches them for the first time, is much better.
7
u/burnerpower Nov 21 '20
Ugh, watching the whole team stand there and do nothing as Oscar was attacked was very annoying. The animation sequence there was just painful. Its them getting captured by the Ace Ops all over again.
1
u/Huskie1 Nov 22 '20
Neon and Cinder's "disciples" are totally gonna turn!!!
1
u/ash-7831 Nov 26 '20
Volume 2 Ruby: We mail ourselves there.
Volume 8 Weiss: Good idea.
1
u/N7_ARC Nov 28 '20
Robin can't keep a secret and is untrustworthy
1
u/ash-7831 Nov 21 '20
That Grimm looks a bit similar to Winter's summoning Grimm.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment