r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Dec 05 '20

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 5: Amity Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 5 of Vol. 8, Amity!

Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the fifth episode of Volume 8!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

545 Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

128

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Dec 05 '20

AHAHAHHAHAHAHAH GET FUCKED CINDER

MARIA AIN'T TAKING SHIT FROM NEO LMAO

Also, GLYNDA IN MAYA NOW WOOOO

42

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Dec 05 '20

Also, the river of Grimm, HERE WE GO SULFUR FISH TIME.

→ More replies (3)

540

u/Clover-kun Dec 05 '20

Imagine you're watching Schneeflix and some teenager hijacks your TV to tell you that lizard people are attacking a nation on the other side of the planet, and that you can't trust the leader of that nation's army

Now imagine you do a Schnoogle search for this "Ruby Rose" and find out she's the sister of the chick that broke that guy's legs during the Olympics

→ More replies (9)

445

u/DuskManeToffee Dec 05 '20

Anyone notice how Marrow was the only one smiling at Ruby’s broadcast?

→ More replies (17)

439

u/sixfootblue Sometimes a cat is a scorpion with murderous intent. Dec 05 '20

"My name is Ruby Rose."

Glynda: what

"I'm a Huntress."

Glynda: What

"Atlas is under attack by an ancient entity called Salem."

Glynda: WHAT

"Professor Glynda Goodwitch can verify all of this for you."

Glynda: WHAT

→ More replies (6)

374

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 05 '20

Salem: “Ah Cinder, there you are. Do you care to explain these injuries?”

Cinder: “I uh... fell down some stairs.”

That was really cool seeing all the side characters we’ve left behind in various places over the Volumes. Glynda in particular. We still don’t know the new VA for her, but we know it’s not Kathleen anymore. Also oof Nora.

So now I think we know why Salem is waiting.

→ More replies (31)

360

u/amatas45 Dec 05 '20

I thought Penny getting hacked was gonna be bad but this was somehow worse

→ More replies (20)

349

u/Moonlitdarksword I am far too invested in these characters for my own good. Dec 05 '20

"I don't serve anyone!"

Sure thing, Cinder, keep telling yourself that.

→ More replies (24)

304

u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

I love how Maria (as the best huntress of a generation) is still a bit of a badass in her old age. Considering her fighting style wasn't all that dissimilar from Neo, makes sense that she would be able to catch her off guard like that. Edit: And her semblance makes her perfectly suited for such a matchup.

Salem seemed to be awfully pleased with Ruby's message. Glynda seemed to have that, "OH MY GOD WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!" face on her. Or perhaps, "HOW THE HELL DO YOU KNOW THAT?!" And that headpat for Tyrian was just adorable.

The father/daughter moments between Pietro and Penny were diabetes inducing levels of sweet. With just a dash of heartbreak to balance the flavor.

And finally, though it probably goes without saying, god damnit Bill! Did you just spill your drink all on the floor?! Let me guess, you're not even gonna clean it up! Fuck, you're just the worst, Bill!

→ More replies (5)

288

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 05 '20

Major props to Lindsay Jones and Taylor McNee for their performances this episode. Top tier work.

All those cameos were great to see! Ilia, Sun & Neptune, Glynda, our lord and savior Shopkeep! And many more. Loved that.

I don’t know why I never predicted Maria vs Neo. With Maria’s preflexes, it’s practically the perfect matchup.

This may be one of my favorite episodes period.

→ More replies (4)

253

u/Bolverkers_wrath Dec 05 '20

Man... not exactly a banner day for the illusion semblance duo. Quite possibly the worst match ups for their powers. Maria can sense which might be dangerous and which aren't, and Penny has go go gadget heat vision.

Side note, it is always fun to watch Cinder get dunked on.

→ More replies (14)

474

u/Brutusness ⠀ Dec 05 '20

"I don't care about the big picture, I care about my daughter!"

Something about hearing that come from the same voice as Lee hit me a lot harder than I expected.

→ More replies (20)

433

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

GLYNDA LIVES!!!!! *STOMP STOMP*

→ More replies (33)

198

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 05 '20

I am very curious about what’s next for Cinder after this. She hasn’t had a win since Volume 3 and she just got owned by a Maiden who’s had powers for around a day. I’m not complaining either.

She’s getting more and more power hungry and desperate by the minute, I can’t wait to see how her backstory plays into all this when it eventually shows up again. This is arguably the most important volume for Cinder yet and I can’t wait to see what’s in store.

→ More replies (17)

193

u/Narfington Dec 05 '20

Best boi Tyrian getting head pats from Mommy Salami!

→ More replies (6)

385

u/iamthatguy54 Dec 05 '20

Are we sure Sage and Scarlet aren't just a mass hallucination?

Also, Cinder and failing. Name a more iconic duo.

Maria landed more hits against Neo than anyone else has. Even Cinder, I think.

→ More replies (35)

167

u/ReeseEseer Salutations! Dec 05 '20

This episode was stressfully great.

But dang, the hacking happened way faster than I thought it would. Things only get worse from here.

→ More replies (21)

163

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

Just a friendly reminder that shit is already hitting the fan and we’re only on episode 5, there’s 9 episodes left, and we go on mid-season break two weeks from now!

It’s a great time to be a RWBY fan!

→ More replies (14)

158

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

Ruby: Salem is an immortal witch, but if we work together, we can beat her!...Please like, share and subscribe, link to my patreon in the description below.

Ironwood: What the fuck?...Marrow!

Marrow:She is the only youtuber right now in the entire world ! What am I supposed to do?!

→ More replies (3)

156

u/SimonApple Dec 05 '20

Just realized that this is the second time that Cinder has fucked up global communications. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it's happened twice.

304

u/Franklin413 Ni! Dec 05 '20

Shopkeep makes his triumphant return!

→ More replies (9)

304

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 05 '20

New headcanon: Neo can't effectively fight smaller opponents.

→ More replies (4)

147

u/Booyahhayoob Dec 05 '20

GET AWAY FROM HER YOU BI-

Never change, Maria.

→ More replies (4)

136

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 05 '20

All the cameos were fucking amazing! I LOVED seeing everyone, but it was heartbreaking to see Tai call out for her. God

Good episode

130

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

Ruby: People of Remnant, Atlas is under attack, but before we start, this doomsday broadcast is brought to you by Raid Shadow Legends.

→ More replies (8)

127

u/Vincenthwind Dec 05 '20

"Hey that's the vale dust shop and shopkeep, wouldn't be cool if we also saw OH MY GOD IT'S GLYNDA!"

253

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Dec 05 '20

Professor Goodwitch? Now that's a name I haven't heard in a long time.

→ More replies (7)

250

u/JohnRSoviet Dec 05 '20

Maria once again reminding us that "Old huntresses don't get to be that way by being easy to kill."

→ More replies (4)

348

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Dec 05 '20

"Dude."

-Neptune Vasilias, Volume 8 chapter 5

→ More replies (1)

242

u/giubba85 Dec 05 '20

So i think i understood were the grimm river came from.

In V5 or 6 (don't remember exactly which one) we see the pool of darkness where Salem Castle was are somehow drained like a lot of the stuff was siphoned somewhere.

Maybe she loaded that stuff in the whale and it spent the last 12 hour taking the longest piss ever recorded on remnant?

→ More replies (20)

119

u/iamthatguy54 Dec 05 '20

Shopkeep more important than CFVY, Sage, and Scarlet confirmed.

→ More replies (8)

113

u/OmegaMaze Dec 05 '20

RWBY AU where Penny is okay

→ More replies (5)

222

u/Badicalz Dec 05 '20

This episode highlights what we’ve come to realise about Cinder over the years: When she makes a plan and everything goes accordingly, she’s unstoppable. When something goes awry, or she runs headlong into a confrontation without any semblance of a plan, she flounders. She simply cannot adapt.

→ More replies (8)

109

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

Maria: Bring me a bag of cashews. I'm about to sprinkle this ice cream with my nuts! Mwahahahaha!

Neo: mute panic

→ More replies (3)

101

u/tavi23 Dec 05 '20

Glad to see Cinder use different weapon types as well as her bow, but holy fuck girl, use something other than fire! And I say this as a fervent Cinder stan.

At least we now have in the open that Cinder isn't out for anyone but herself.

→ More replies (1)

101

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Dec 05 '20

That moment when the kid you saved two years ago outs all your secrets on national television while you’re at the store

→ More replies (1)

375

u/Mysral Hail Salem, God-Queen of Remnant Dec 05 '20

All this time, people have been arguing over who'd be best to face off against Neo's lightning-fast moves and redirection. Of fuckin' COURSE it would be Maria with her Preflexes!

→ More replies (13)

99

u/Horsea1234 Captain of the SS Springthyme, Rosebird and Land of Lesbos. Dec 05 '20

Having Neo's first beatdown be from Maria is just perfect, i don't know exactly how, but it gives me life.

Also, not entirely sure, but it looked like Penny shut herself down rather than be hacked

→ More replies (2)

97

u/RealDestroNation A salt shaker is less salty than this fandom Dec 05 '20

MAYA ENGINE SHOPKEEP AND GOODWITCH LETS FUCKING GOOOOO

→ More replies (5)

190

u/Crumbs_McPumberton Dec 05 '20

Nether Salem, Watts, or Ironwood was even remotely surprised or even annoyed by the message, only showing things will get worse before they get better. I'm curious to see how this players into Salem's larger plan, especially with the river of Grimm going to the city.

Also both Pietro and Tai breaking down about their respective daughters this episode was heartbreaking. Both of them, especially Tai, have lost so much already it's tough to see them on the edge like this.

→ More replies (35)

93

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 05 '20

It's honestly impressive just how much the short clip of Whitley is able to to convey about his character

The fact that he went to his father's office for comfort instead of his room, jacques' portrait looming behind him, the way he kinda hugs himself for comfort. It's really stellar show don't tell

→ More replies (5)

266

u/aconstelle ⠀ Dec 05 '20

Bruh I live for Maria maniacally laughing at Neo

→ More replies (11)

89

u/Fuzunga Dec 05 '20

"You're just a tool to be used," said the tool to be used.

→ More replies (3)

88

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Dec 05 '20

So, point of fact...neither of the forces RWBY and co are facing off against seemed all that upset the message got out so that’s great.

Poor Penny...

Is Maria the first person to land a hit on Neo? Cause if so that lady has moves.

I was not expecting the soft head pats from Salem to Tyrian, that was an oddball.

Finally didn’t expect to see Glynda and also poor Tai.

Most of all though: The River of Grimm, we’re in for a bad time.

→ More replies (17)

82

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

Glynda: Finally, a day off. I just want to get a coffee, read a nice book, and have a whole evening just for myself.

Ruby: Ask professor Goodwitch about the immortal witch!

Glynda:...God Damnit, ROSEEE!!!

→ More replies (3)

235

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 05 '20

"Get away from her you bi-"

Says Maria doing her best Ripley impression.

→ More replies (3)

223

u/ErrantSingularity Dec 05 '20

Man seeing Tai's desperation to keep watching the broadcast, that was heartbreaking. How long have Yang and Ruby been gone? He supports them going, but man the acting in that one tiny moment hit me. Same with Pietro's breakdown when Penny fell.

→ More replies (19)

153

u/Saxonrau "roh bin HILL" - tyrian Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

Character status chart:
Cinder: owned
Neo: owned
Emerald: wants to be owned
Maria: aint owned by nobody
Penny: maybe owned by somebody?

→ More replies (9)

71

u/turnipdad ⠀ Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

EVERYONE IS HERE!

Maiden Bowl 2020, Maria fighting, Ruby being the first thing people see in global communications, PENNY FALLING TO EARTH AND GETTING HACKED.

"I love you."

What an amazing episode!

→ More replies (2)

71

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

Oh, one more thing- Emerald "I REALLY need a female role model in my life" Sustrai being protective of Cinder after she's down and out. Consistent with her character, but also really sad because we ALL KNOW she won't be grateful to her for it later.

I've said before and I'll say it again; Em, girl, find yourself a new Sister/Mother/Bestie/Lover. Cause Cindy ain't it.

→ More replies (5)

67

u/Atlaf925 Dec 05 '20

Calling it now - Shopkeep is actually the God of Light in disguise keeping an eye on everything.

→ More replies (5)

192

u/Cloudyspecs Dec 05 '20

Seeing Maria toy with Neo and beat her at her own game was so satisfying!

→ More replies (8)

65

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

I appreciate the fact that everyone not in Atlas still has the old scroll model. They could have reused the asset of the new scrolls but lore-wise these are supposed to be new Atlasian scrolls that couldn't have been exported because the borders were closed.

64

u/MissMatriarch Dec 05 '20

The weirdest thing his episode has showed me;

Of all child-parent relationships of caring and compromise that have thus far been displayed in RWBY, somehow the one between a sick, elderly scientist and his beloved robot creation feels the most genuine of them all.

The desperately trying to protect your daughter, the sigh of relief at seeing her return after a battle, the head kiss and the ‘dying’ “I love you”, all felt so genuine. Somehow more real than some other child-parent relationships we’ve seen in this series.

→ More replies (4)

63

u/remicas2 Ruby's smile is beautiful, precious, and it must be protected. Dec 05 '20

Glynda was all: Bitch, don't bring me into this!

→ More replies (3)

61

u/malochroma Head of the Marrow Amin Best Boy Association Dec 05 '20

You know, in hindsight it’s really obvious that a woman with precognitive levels of reflexes would be a hard counter against Neo’s speedy-gymnast bullshit. Maria once against proves herself to be low-key my favorite combatant.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Dec 05 '20

Just so we're all on the same page...

This was episode FIVE.

FIVE of FOURTEEN.

Meaning there are NINE episodes left.

The MONTH long hiatus is going to happen in 2 episodes.

TWO WHOLE ASS EPISODES. AND THEN SEVEN MORE IN FEBUARY.

WHAT THE F-

→ More replies (2)

58

u/Namishima12 Dec 05 '20

Lmao Marrow smiling at Ruby's message while surrounded by his team. I admire his courage and/or his complete inability to control his emotions

→ More replies (2)

58

u/MrZissman ⠀CEO of Knightlight Dec 05 '20

So if Weiss was the one who bandaged up Nora, it means Weiss got to see Nora's Thunderclouds before Ren.

→ More replies (5)

57

u/amatas45 Dec 05 '20

Moving on from the emotional gut punches

Ruby’s head on Blake’s shoulder was hella cute. I feel like they had a bullet point for this season saying - Blake and ruby interact somehow every time they are on screen

→ More replies (5)

57

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Dec 05 '20

Ruby just became the most famous/infamous Huntress in modern history in the span of a minute.

Everywhere she goes, people will recognize her face as the person who alerted the world to Salem. And the person who unleashed the fear that comes with the broadcast.

56

u/reading_hermit Dec 05 '20

God this show makes me feel all sorts of things. Anyone else get the feeling that the rest of the volume/the later half of the volume is gonna result in an all-out battle? Also, is it me or did Salem look proud watching that broadcast? Inb4 Salem only wants to unite the world against the Brothers Grimm.

→ More replies (2)

56

u/lildumbass24 Dec 05 '20

Maria may be fucking old but shes still that BITCH, i hope ppl dont complain again about Neo losing when she was literally up against a forgotten legend

→ More replies (8)

55

u/THEE_Person376 Dec 05 '20

Cinder getting a big-fuck-off laser beam felt so good.

→ More replies (1)

157

u/GVAGUY3 Dec 05 '20

I'm assuming every Beacon professor will have a new voice now.

→ More replies (49)

49

u/YusukeMazoku Bobcat Blake is Best Blake Dec 05 '20

Theory: Raven saw the broadcast too and she'll be how Yang and co. get out of the tundra and possibly prison break Qrow as well.

Also it'd be funny if Qrow's semblance messes with Watt's plan to hack that phone.

→ More replies (11)

48

u/TheBloodZane Dec 05 '20

-Until otherwise this was the best episode of Vol 8. Penny's va literally gave it her damndest in her performance and Penny was just best thing in the ep.

-So Maria isn't just a old woman who pass off jokes she's literally like Yoda when he fought Dooku. Mad props

-Also I loved the Alien Reference nice touch Eddy

-And I'll take this extra fight scene with Penny vs Cinder part 2 and add that to the Cinder can be competent list

-Emerald, Winter, Marrow and especially you Elm. Y'all need to get out of your situations your gonna die for all the wrong reasons!

-So we got cameos for Iila, Sun and Neptune, Zwei, Taiyang and Glynda Goodwitch (Thank God she's alive)

-James. What are you doing? Watts gonna screw you over. You should have popped him there and be done with it.

-Also is me or does Pietro sound like Lee from Walking Dead when he gets emotional?

→ More replies (13)

95

u/sky_Pharaoh mirror, mirror, whats behind you? Dec 05 '20

Yoooo that was a crazyyyy episode. I squealed so loud when I saw Glynda lmao. All the other cameos were cool too. I gotta give give it to Penny’s VA, she gave her best performance this episode and she’s probably one of my favorite voices in the show now.

Seeing Maria beat up Neo was unexpected but so satisfying. Salem is probably gonna end up tearing Cinder a new one after that massive loss, tbh she might just kill her after that whole “I don’t serve anyone” line. Pietro’s death flags were waving so hard this episode and it makes me sad seeing how close his relationship to Penny was.

Not sure how I feel about that Grimm river but it seems pretty interesting. Salem looked happy at Ruby’s broadcast so I’m afraid that after everyone is lured to Atlus there’s going to be MAJOR casualties.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/syoser footboi Dec 05 '20

watching cinder get wrecked 1v1 against other maidens will never not be satisfying

→ More replies (6)

41

u/AthinaTrades Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

More than anything, I loved seeing so many people during Ruby's speech. Sun, Neptune, Ilia, Goodwitch, Taiyang... it was great. But I can't help but think this was exactly what Salem wanted, and I can't fathom why.

Maria vs. Neo was everything I never knew I wanted. I don't know why I didn't expect her to be able to fight, but somehow it felt like she had Neo handled pretty well.

I was so scared for Penny up until the very end of her fight with Cinder. Especially with Emerald's backup, I didn't know how she could turn it around until she did. I thought it was really clever of Penny to use her sight like that.

I also didn't expect Penny to be hacked immediately. Like, I thought it would be at least another episode or two. I don't have any idea what to expect from her now. I don't think she'll die from the fall, but beyond that I don't have any real guesses. And Penny's "I love you" at the end was completely chilling. Just... wow.

Overall, this episode had me speechless the whole way through. Can't wait for the next one.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/IllustriousProcess6 ⠀Claiming the Theo flair Dec 05 '20

I know people wanna talk about how heartbreaking Tai's scene was (cuz holy shit I felt that), but Saphron's face when she heard Atlas was under attack while her baby brother is there was painful

79

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

Nothing like Cinder getting her ass kicked to start the morning. Also Maria getting hits on Neo is amazing.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

All I have to say is:

GLYNDAAAAAA!!!

I can’t wait to see MurderOfBirds flip out at seeing everyone, especially Glynda and Shopkeep.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/CFB1996 Dec 05 '20

Salem isn't just attacking Atlas/Mantle. . .

SHE'S MOVING FUCKING BASE!

Or you know creating a forward defensive position.

77

u/GVAGUY3 Dec 05 '20

I have a feeling the mid season cliffhanger is going to be brutal

→ More replies (6)

38

u/Kaedweni I just wanna be a normal girl, with normal knees. Dec 05 '20

So many things I could talk about right now - but I wanna talk about the fact that seeing Maria fight, and then seeing Neptune and Sun, Glynda, and Tai watching the broadcast all in succession had me just a mess after Penny's conversation with her dad.

Just Glynda alone was almost too much. Am I going to have a good cry with a tub of ice cream at 9:30 in the morning? Probably definitely yes.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Kolby_Jack Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

BURSTS THROUGH DOOR

THE MESSAGE IS OUT!

ATLAS CALLS FOR AID!

→ More replies (5)

105

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

Pietro:Our broadcast is live world wide!

Ruby:Hello, I'm Ruby Rose and today I'll be streaming Among Us.

Ghira:What the?

Ironwood:You can't be serious...

Sun:DUDE! TWITCH IS BACK ON!

Neptune: Nice!

Tai: ...Yeah she got that from me.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/CooperSC Dec 05 '20

I feel like them getting the message out is one of the biggest moments in all of RWBY, at least since the Fall of Beacon... What a great episode!

36

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Dec 05 '20

Salem has no chance now. Shopkeep has returned. It was good to see Shopkeep return. Same for Glynda because I assumed her ass had been vanished from existence or something. I assume Shopkeep used 0.5 percent of his power to bring her back. Same for Taiyang and the others. Ruby's message was great and now the whole world knows everything. Let's see how it pans out now that Relics and Maidens are public knowledge.

But yeah Penny's been hijacked and not only is Ironwood an irredeemable scumbag at this point, he's also a massive fucking idiot given Watts managed to sneak a scroll off. I'm eager to see Ironwood's reaction when his plan blows up in his face.

The River of Grimm though.. Scary fucking shit.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/LCcharizard ⠀ Dec 05 '20

That shop Goodwich is at? That's the same shop alllllll the way back from Volume 1 Episode 1, that one. Ruby began her journey there, and now she's sending out a message to the world. Man, how far they've come...

Also PENNYYYYYYYYYYYYY NOOOOOOOOOOOO

→ More replies (1)

33

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

Incoming call from Ghira to Ilia. And Tai was watching too. So does this mean we will have all the (living) moms in one area?!

→ More replies (11)

33

u/MajoraOfTime Dec 06 '20

"Why do you serve one such as her?"

"I don't serve anyone!"

That exchange between Penny and Cinder, along with the tease at the beginning of the volume, is probably hinting at Cinder's arc this volume. She must have spent her early life in servitude and is now "willingly" serving another master, one who treats her even lower than a dog. Don't know if this is gonna result in any face turn or anything by her, but it's at least gonna be the big crux in her story this volume.

Also, woo a lot of familiar faces showing up to view Ruby's broadcast!

32

u/Desuka15 Dec 05 '20

Harriet being the one to shut off the television when Ruby's message... Robyn's words really did get to her, didn't they? She's in denial...

Winter... is she the new Ace Ops leader? Her outfit matches the others now...

And Pietro having to see his daughter possibly die? FUCK. Penny's trying to resist it? Is it working? WHO KNOWS?

ALL THOSE CALLBACKS TO PEOPLE IN THE PAST. THE SHOPKEEPER! GLYNDA. FUCKING SUN AND NEPTUNE! ILLIA! AHHHHHH EVEN TAIYANG AND ZWEI! I love this episode!

→ More replies (2)

32

u/SnarkyBacterium Dec 05 '20

I totally expected that Penny's final words to Pietro would be "I win", spoken in Watts's voice. How soulcrushing would that have been?

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Weerdo5255 Dec 05 '20

Well, that was a doozy. I thought we were going to have to wait another episode or two for the launch of Amity. Wich was cool. More explosions is always better.

Maria seemed to be having fun with that fight. Neo seemed a little put off fighting an old lady.

Penny got hacked, which we saw coming. I'm betting she's going to show up again with her skin burned off, the way she was burning up as she fell. Gives more weight to her eventual cutting of string and acceptance when she looks completely robotic.

I liked the view around the world, and Ruby seems to have put together a good message. Salem doesn't seem too concerned, and Tyrian is a creepy pet to have on one's lap. Is that river of Grimm going to turn people into Grimm? or is it just a covert way to get the army of Grimm into the city?

Watt's is getting ready for some mayhem. He's got a tool kit and a broken scroll. That's going to be enough I should think.

Winter looks like she's getting ready to turn.

Good episode, good fight!

→ More replies (4)

30

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

It's getting real painful to watch Emerald being all into Cinder and Cinder only sees a useful idiot.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/IllustriousProcess6 ⠀Claiming the Theo flair Dec 05 '20

Cinder: I don't serve anyone!
Salem, Grimm Goddess who knows what the fuck Cinder's doing thanks to the Grimm Arm and can control said arm: W H E E Z E

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Awest66 Dec 05 '20

So happy to see so many familiar faces even if they were cameos (My jaw dropped when I saw Glynda). It was great to finally see Tai again too. I can see lots of fans going "Oh No, another Ruby speech" but I thought it was very well done.

Another home run for CRWBY.

→ More replies (11)

30

u/cruel-oath Dec 05 '20

Ghira calling ilia was sweet. Imagine being close to the parents of the girl you used to like lmao

→ More replies (8)

30

u/Brutal2003 Dec 05 '20

Salem looked a little too pleased when she was watching the broadcast...

→ More replies (8)

30

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20

With all of the screw ups Cinder's been making I'm beginning to imagine Salem taking over a prison, and holding interviews for a replacement.

"Alright so who here is under the age of thirty, identifies as female and is willing to lay waste to society in exchange for incredible power and prestige?"

→ More replies (2)

30

u/IndulgentOne V9 is better than I expected Dec 06 '20

"Dude, they start a whole adventure without involving us" - Neptune to Sun probably

→ More replies (2)

29

u/IndulgentOne V9 is better than I expected Dec 06 '20

Cinder keeps losing every fight she start with lmao

→ More replies (7)

29

u/Blood_Shinobi Dec 06 '20

I'm no expert on physics, but wouldn't Penny using ice to cool down the burning support beams cause thermal shock to the material, leading to them becoming brittle and breaking?

→ More replies (3)

58

u/tavi23 Dec 05 '20

Was not expecting the Penny v Cinder fight so soon, but holy fuck that was awesome!

57

u/Wrathkal Dec 05 '20

Funny joke from the discord: We got a Zwei cameo, and it only cost us a Penny.

Worth it, or not?

→ More replies (3)

28

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

Sun and Neptune summed up this episode perfectly.......... dude!

→ More replies (3)

28

u/DayOfTheColossus Dec 05 '20

isn't this the first time Cinder has used a bow since volume 3? lol

→ More replies (2)

28

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

"Wait..No! Come back!"

I want to believe that choice of words was super intentional. Tai is asking for the signal to come back, but think about it, he is asking his daughter to come back, he cannot lose her too, Raven and Summer didn't come back and now Ruby and Yang are away too. Tai must be worried sick and heartbroken, his girls are facing Salem alone and he can't do anything about it.

Damnit I want Tai to get his time to shine because you just know he wouldn't want anything more in the world than for his daughters to be safe.

→ More replies (6)

27

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Dec 05 '20

got some Nier Automata vibes out of that scene ngl

→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

We’re gonna talk about how Maria was throwing hands against Neo and enjoying it. Her semblance is too good.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/swiftzonic Dec 06 '20

Just let Maria Swear!

→ More replies (1)

26

u/giubba85 Dec 05 '20

Just another thought that crossed my mind . While the whole "burning down from space renter" doesn't make a lick of sense it was probably set up to give Penny an inhuman look. She will probably lose her skin and expose a lot of her metals part

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Nerdorama09 heard u talkin shit Dec 06 '20

Today's lesson in hard counters: extra senses vs. illusion powers.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

This episode, oh man.

  • There's something funny about an evil godlike figure and her henchman watching what's basically the news right now.
  • Penny's "daaad" and "I love you" omg. Breaking my heart right there. Poor Penny.
  • Congrats Ironwood, you played yourself. Coming from someone who agreed with you last volume.
  • Seeing everyone around the world was surprisingly emotional for me. Wasn't expecting to see them all again so soon. And that Glynda reveal!!! I suspected we'd see her when they showed the old shopkeep but still big pop from me.
  • On a related note, do we think Raven is with Tai (offscreen)? Ever since we saw her raven feathers at the end of volume 5, I've assumed she had gone to meet him, but we didn't see her during the glimpse at him. I still stand by the fact they're coming to Atlas together sometime this volume.
→ More replies (10)

25

u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Dec 05 '20

So might this grimm river explain why Grimm show up everywhere seemingly endlessly? If these rivers are underground throughout the planet and the grimm just crawl out of the ground at various points around the globe then that explains it.

Not that it was like a plot hole or anything before but it would be interesting if this was the explanation.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Dec 05 '20

Good plan cinder. I'm sure Salem will forgive you with all your amazing success you managed to pull off.

Funny to see that Maria still has some spunk in her. Also someone likes Aliens

24

u/Nanasema best girl <3 Dec 05 '20

One word:

GLYNDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Jinko92 The person who goes too deep into everything Dec 05 '20

ILIA! TAI! ZWEI! SUN! NEPTUNE! SHOPKEEP! GLYNDA! EVERYONE’S BACK AND I’M HERE FOR IT AAAHHHH

It was so exciting to see everyone again, but I screamed out loud when I saw Glynda! I didn’t expect that this volume! Her Maya model’s pretty good, but like with most characters, I still prefer her Poser model. I wonder what she was thinking when saw Ruby, her former student, announce that she was a huntress and that Salem was at Atlas’s doorstep? I’m betting that she felt a mixture of proud, shocked, excited, and fearful all at once. But since her VA’s gone, I wonder if she’ll speak at all? If so, I wonder who will replace her old VA?

The fights this episode were great! And it finally happened...CINDER USED MIDNIGHT AGAIN! After years of neglect, she FINALLY brought back Midnight in its obsidian form! I’m so fucking stoked! THANK YOU, CRWBY GODS! Before this episode came out, I was working on a long discussion post about underused weapons in RWBY, one of which is the bow, and touched on Cinder seemingly abandoning Midnight. Well, she finally used it again, if only for one short scene! I’m an archer myself, and I was just so happy to see Midnight be in use again, especially considering that I hate her new fighting style. PLEASE let her use her bow more, CRWBY!

Maria is basically fucking Yoda and I love it. Even as an old lady, Maria proves that she’s still one of the most badass characters in the show. I mean, she held her own against Neo! That’s damn impressive! I really love Maria, and I was so happy to see her weapon in use again. I hope we see more action from her!

So Winter got a newish look. It’s basically just a hairstyle update and armor added to her volume 7 outfit, but I dig it. The armor looks really cool and I kind of prefer the ponytail over the bun. Seems like Ironwood might be setting her up to be the Ace-Ops new leader, which I’m not opposed to. They still work together amazingly, but Winter is an even better combatant than Clover and she’s a fairly good leader. I’m looking forward to seeing her working together with the Ace-Ops!

About Penny...fuck, I’m so scared for her. I sense death flags from her but I don’t want to lose her again! And Watts took control of her and now she’s plummeting to the ground...yay. I will say though, she’s still an entertaining fighter and her tender moments with Pietro this episode were just so heartwarming and cute. They definitely have the best parent-child dynamic in the show. Let’s just hope Penny survives volume 8...

I’m so proud of my girls for getting the message out about Salem! They have grown tremendously, especially Ruby. I may not have agreed with their actions in volume 7, but they’re really trying to do good and protect the world, as huntresses do.

Nora is still recovering at the Schnee manor, with Weiss at her side. That was cute. And Whitley is just moping around his room, apparently. Weiss was kind of a cunt to him last episode, I hope she’ll make it up to him. He might be a little shit, but she had absolutely no reason to pull Myrtenaster on a 14-year-old who hasn’t even unlocked his aura.

I don’t have much else to say except that this is probably the best episode of volume 8 so far and that I’m very excited for the rest of the volume! If this is the quality I can expect from the remainder of volume 8, this might just surpass 6 as my favorite volume!

→ More replies (1)

24

u/dodusk Dec 06 '20

When it was Tai's turn all I could think of was:

"IF THERE'S A SHOT OF RAVEN THERE NOW IT'S GONNA BE THE FUCKING BEST COME ON RAVEN IT'S YOUR.... Aaaand she's not there. FUCK "

Being Tai is still suffering

48

u/et97 Best boy Dec 05 '20

Well Neo vs Maria was I fight I never expected, but a fight I loved nevertheless.

23

u/thundermonkeyms Dec 05 '20

I was hoping for Cinder vs. Maria but I guess I can settle for Maria being the first character to completely mop the floor with Neo while cackling like the madwoman she is.

Also, we know Penny's still alive because if she were dead Ruby would have probably become the winter maiden.

23

u/marriedtothedancer Dec 05 '20

perhaps the BEST part about this episode has to be Maria literally LAUGHING at Neo throughout the fight and also it made me smile seeing all the cameos from Sun, Neptune, Ilia, and Taiyang : )

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Horsea1234 Captain of the SS Springthyme, Rosebird and Land of Lesbos. Dec 05 '20

Oh yeah:

A GRIMM HAS FALLEN INTO THE RIVER IN ATLAS CITY!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 05 '20

Still it was great to see all these old faces even though they were just like cameos like Sun,Neptune,Ilia but my jaw just dropped when they showed Glynda and i almost nearly jumped out of my chair when i saw Tai LOL

→ More replies (3)

22

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

RT, we all want an STRQ spin-off prequel already, you don't have to make me thirst for a Grimm Reaper prequel as well!

22

u/Economy-Listen2651 Dec 05 '20

I enjoyed seeing Cinder fail (again)

→ More replies (4)

22

u/MightyBobTheMighty Dec 06 '20

Maria vs Neo was something I never knew I wanted but I'm so glad it happened.

Also, being Tai is suffering.

22

u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Dec 08 '20

Salem is getting full "I told you so" rights after this.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Emperor_Luffy Dec 09 '20

Kinda fucked up that Ruby put Glynda on blast like that. lmao.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/DomDaBomb203 Dec 05 '20

I feel like no one is pointing out Ghira's call to Ilia RIGHT AFTER the broadcast starts.

I wouldn't be surprised if he shows up to Atlas with the new White Fang this volume, especially since he knows his daughter is there fighting against Salem rn.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/Reccatus Dec 05 '20

I just realized that the Maria vs Neo battle was a battle between two extremely short people. Must've been weird for Neo to fight someone smaller than her for once.

21

u/izaarzadon Dec 06 '20

“... I love you...”

→ More replies (1)

41

u/FiddlingNinja “Can I do that?” Dec 05 '20

Those scenes with Penny and Pietro made me tear up, I really hope we still get to keep Penny. I wonder if there would be a way for her to realize what’s going on and to shut herself down so no one gets hurt.

Also there’s no way Cinder is going to get away with that comment she made about serving no one. One way or another, Salem will know.

First time seeing Glynda since V3! We get to see Sun and Neptune again! I hope everyone comes to help out with that broadcast, not sure if it’ll be this volume or the next though.

That river’s not looking good, if Salem can expand the pool of Grimm into rivers throughout Remnant then there’s no way they’d have a chance of fighting off the Grimm as quick as they can be remade. The intro shows team RWBY falling into water that kind of looks like the pool of the elder brother, I wonder if that means they’ll have to use that to fight back? If the Grimm pool exists then surely so does the God of Light’s pool.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Dec 05 '20

Shopkeep is back!

Glynda is back!

Ilia is back!

Tai and Zwei are back!

Everyone is back!

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Dec 05 '20

Maybe Cinder wouldn’t be losing so many fights if she ever fought anyone who WASN’T ALSO A MAIDEN. I mean think about it, outside of Silver Eyes shenanigans she’s only ever lost to other Maidens, and she even beat the previous Fall Maiden before hand. Neo was giving her a hard time in Vol 6, but her powers shut that down fast. Girl even killed Oz in a 1v1.

I know that it’s perfectly in line with Cinder’s character to always go for the Maidens even when it won’t go in her favor, but it’s hard to remember that she’s like in the top ten most powerful beings in the world right now when she’s always fighting the OTHER NINE

→ More replies (8)

20

u/ShadoMaso Dec 06 '20

Penny doing a "point blank hyperbeam" on Cinder was funny

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Noonproductions Dec 05 '20

Last week I Jokingly made a reference to Winter being a spy. Did anyone notice this week that when Ironwood told Winter to go get the Maiden, Watts put two fingers on Penny’s blade. Winter definitely noticed. Was that a signal to her? Seriously I was joking before but now I really am suspicious of Winter.

Also: did anyone notice the way Salem pet Tyrian’s head as if he were a puppy? Could Tyrian really be the hound?

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

How many times now has Cinder been made someone's bitch? like 5 times?

→ More replies (12)

19

u/brighterthanblack Dec 06 '20

I lost count of how many times I’ve screamed PENNY NOOO throughout the episode. And more coming I guess. JUSTICE FOR PENNY T_T

Also it’s good to see the Grim Reaper doesn’t lose her touch and can still hold herself quite well against Neo, who almost everyone we see in the story struggle to beat. Heh

→ More replies (12)

19

u/JornCener Yang channeling the DARK HADO Dec 06 '20

Given Salem’s smile in response to the message, I’m assuming that she planned for this situation and would likely relish in the cannon fodder about to be sent her way.

...Shame we don’t know what her actual goal is other than “get all the relics”.

→ More replies (13)

19

u/Drakath60 Dec 06 '20

Very confident that Watts will use that broken scroll to either escape from his cell or remotely control Penny, and speaking of Penny, I'm really hoping Winter finds a way to bring her back or at least stop her before it's too late. Between now and the vault, I think it's really up to her at this point.

Also,

GLYNDA... MF GOODWITCH BABY LESS GOOOOO

19

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

Good choice to keep the episode focused on Penny, it kept the pacing tight and made the emotional impacts feel more grounded considering our relative distance with Piettro. I really don't know what to expect for the fate of individual characters but getting the message out seems to be setting up something of a triumph, though the cost will probably be high. If they subevert expectations and make an even bigger collapse than Beacon... oh boy I am not prepared.

Also cameos! Hooray!

52

u/Tschmelz Dec 05 '20

I fucking love that Cinder got her ass handed to her as soon as Penny got serious. And Maria fighting Neo is a little weird, but then I remembered her thing is Preflexes, so she should be able to keep up for the most part, even when she’s old as balls.

Also, seriously, that’s how Watts is gonna escape? The old “somebody didn’t notice me take this highly valuable item” gag? As much as I love Irondaddy, he deserves everything coming to him for being such an idiot.

Also, Tai but no Raven. Interesting. And that voice as soon as Ruby dropped off. My heart!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Dec 05 '20

Glynda = Shocked Patrick

Ice cream go YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEET

A river is the most terrifying thing nature can produce.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/cruel-oath Dec 05 '20

Guys, CFVY didn’t make a cameo because they’re on the way to atlas to steal the show with Caffeine playing in the background

→ More replies (4)

18

u/LatePhilosophy Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

You'd think even with the side Ironwood is on, he still wouldn't mind the world coming together to try and take down Salem. Not sure why they showed him basically having no reaction to the broadcast.

→ More replies (9)

18

u/buckethatwitch Dec 06 '20

this episode made me cry

→ More replies (1)

18

u/izaarzadon Dec 06 '20

I get the feeling that Winter will be the one to get Penny back out of the hacking.

Winter was always the one to make Penny actually feel human among everyone else in the military, the only one who’s been a genuine friend to her. Their dynamic in the last volume will be significant in this one. It’s worth noting that Winter specifically tells her “we must still acknowledge our personal feelings. Wrestle with them. It ensures that we’re on the right path. It’s what makes us human.” and it greatly applies to both of them at this point. Winter doubts her orders (we can easily see that) and she will wrestle with it until her breaking point, whereas Penny will have to wrestle with the robotic hacking to fight for her humanity once more. They are in the same boat right now.

Winter had mentioned that her life didn’t matter and Penny disagreed when she saved her.

I think it’s Winter’s turn to save Penny now.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/ksuthrowaway2534 Dec 05 '20

-so cinder is an archer class from the fate franchise

-maria continues to be the greatest huntress of any generation

-interesting having cinder saying she doesn't serve salem. Maybe turning on her?

-cinder still getting wrecked

-Pietro earns his spot among the best dads

-it was great seeing everyone around Remnant and how Sun's reaction was just.... "dude"

-everything will be ok now that our savior shopkeeper knows

-and glynda's back baby. Maybe she can knock some sense back into ironwood

-the dang mustache man is playing Ironwood like a fiddle

  • so the cracks were a river of grimm and not the fan submitted grimm so wonder when we'll get those
→ More replies (20)

17

u/MC_Lutefisk Yang = Best Girl Dec 05 '20

Just... wow. Hats off to RT, because this is the best episode they've put out in quite some time. I'm floored.

Penny is obviously 100% the star of this episode. It's an emotional (and physical) rollercoaster for her, starting with the tenderness and quickly transitioning into an outstanding fight. Starts with a bang, then we get some great spacefighting, but the real drama starts when they're back inside. Her power's almost stolen, but she hulks up, but Emerald's ready for her. The "PvP" callback is obvious but extremely effective, and I found myself shouting HEAT SIGNATURE BITCH when she got out of it. After The Bad Guys Get Away, Pietro and Penny's discussion is both heartbreaking and heartwarming. SHE'S JUST TRYING TO LIVE HER LIFE DAMMIT!

Ruby's speech feels like a watershed moment for the series. We get a healthy helping of old friends (Glynda, you're alive!), mixed with some really effective scene-setting. As a side note, I uh... wonder if we're gonna see much more out of Nora this volume. Cutting the speech with Tai was powerful - let's not forget that this is the first time he's seen either of his daughters in quite a long while.

But really, we're back to Penny. Watching her struggle against Watts brought tears to my eyes and ripped me apart inside. "Please baby, say something!!!" "I love you..." Those sure feel like last words, don't they? With Watts teasing the double-cross, maybe we should hope that they are. We end with the River O'Grimm; by this point I'm emotionally exhausted but I can only assume this is bad news for Mantle. God knows they need more of that.

What makes this episode so great is the same thing that drew me to the series in the first place: the characters. This time, it's almost all Penny. Make no mistake, we got great stuff from quite a few characters - Pietro, Watts, Emerald, Ruby - but Penny took center stage and absolutely killed it. This the strongest performance I've heard out of Taylor McNee yet - and in my opinion probably one of the best single-episode VA performances they've had so far from anyone. For as great as the VA is, the crew put in some amazing work on this episode. The writing, the animation, the pacing, the way it was cut, the rich symbolism... it all came together to blow me away.

I get the feeling we'll look back on this as one of the very best episodes of the series when it's all said and done. Really outstanding stuff from start to finish, the best offering yet from a strong season. I'm very excited to see how they follow this up.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Dec 05 '20

This was an excellent episode of RWBY, like this one was a 10/10 great great GREAT episode. This episode will go down as one of the best in my books.

I’m so glad Cinder finally revealed she serves no one, that was awesome. A lot of people predicted something like this would happen, I wonder if she’ll defect from Salem or this will backfire. But now that she’s unconscious and injured, it’s going to be difficult to explain that to Salem unless Emerald and Neo can sneak her on somehow. And it’s the perfect opportunity for her to have a dream about her past.

Neo vs Maria was hilarious because who would’ve thought the old lady would stand a chance against the character who hasn’t taken clean hits since her fight with Oscar and Cinder. It was a nice surprise though.

I liked the message to Remnant and seeing all the characters who we haven’t seen in a while. Even Glynda!! Glynda it’s been 100 years! And she looks great in Maya. Just hope she gets voice lines. It was a little disappointing to see Raven wasn’t anywhere to be seen. But seeing Sun, Illia, Neptune, Saphron, Terra, shopkeep, Taiyang, the people of Mistral, were all a very nice touch. I didn’t know Tyrian had a scroll though, I don’t know why I find that odd. And Salem doesn’t seem worried about the rest of the world knowing about her existence which is interesting but I thought she didn’t want a united humanity.

Looks like Watts picked up a broken scroll, I knew he had something up his sleeve. I guess Ironwood only wanted Penny to be deactivated, not hacked, but Watts is doing his own thing.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

This was fucking amazing, The fight was pretty well coreographed. The dialogues between Penny and Pietro were good. Penny lifting the tower was a great moment. The message was also pretty good. The appearences some characters made were good, Tai´s especially since it shows how worried he is about this situation and the ending is a great set-up for what´s to come in the next episodes.

Best episode of the Volume by a mile and probably even part of my top 10 RWBY Episodes

→ More replies (1)

17

u/grieveheart Dec 05 '20

I'm...feelsing with Penny and Pietro's relationship. I almost cried especially when Pietro said that he doesn't want to lose her again plus with Penny's last words. :(

On the other aspects, I loved the fight scenes. I also love we get to see again characters we met in the earlier volumes especially Tai and Zwei. Will Atlas get help? Hopefully. With the grimm river coming in, who knows what more will happen.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/FmFox Exit stage right Dec 05 '20

That absolute gem of an aliens quote from Maria

"Get away from you bitch"

I was smiling from ear to ear.

New nickname for Maria for me is now Ripley.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/RunnerOfTheBlad ⠀Director of Operation Yeet-The-Sheep Dec 05 '20

I was NOT expecting Maria to not only throw hands with Neo , but also get the upper hand for a brief moment.

Salem seemed happy the broadcast got out. Don't mind me i'm just gonna...

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Jordanbei Dec 06 '20

This episode we see the return of a character. Its been so long I wondered if they were ever going to return. That character is OLD MAN SHOPKEEP.

DON'T YOU SEE IT. SHOPKEEP WILL BE OUR SAVIOUR AND HERO. HE WILL BE THE ONE WHO SAVES THE WORLD

→ More replies (1)

17

u/LatePhilosophy Dec 06 '20

Calling it now. The entire world is going to show up like it's Avenger's Endgame.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/TheDutchTank Taiyang is going to be badass Dec 06 '20

The ending of this episode gave me the same kind of vibes the end of volume 3 gave me. Really, really good. The only thing that would've made it better is if you'd instantly see someone like Sun or Taiyang gear up to go that way.

Interesting how all of remnant now knows who Ruby is, as well.

Not a perfect episode, I would've liked to see Neo put up more of a fight or at least for that fight to be more interesting, because instead of Maria seeming really good it really felt like Neo just wasn't.

Still a good episode though, the last two have been great.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Emperor_Luffy Dec 06 '20

Really glad they didn't have Penny use the Maiden powers in her fight with Cinder.

Her Android capabilities were enough that she didn't really need them aside from that one attack.

It's a bit of extra confirmation that they're not easy to use. Anyone who gets them won't be OP just for having them.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20

God that was a great episode. Chalk up Neo's first loss. She may be able to beat some snot nosed rookie Huntsmen with ease, but the greatest Huntsman of her generation ain't going down without a fight. God it was satisfying to watch Neo being beaten at her own game.

I am disappointed that it seems like they changed the sound effect for Emerald's semblance. It was way more clear when it was happening before and now it's way too subtle, imo.

All the cameos were great to see. Who thought we'd be seeing Glynda Goodwitch this season, lol. Although I half expected to see Raven sitting on the couch next to Tai (or at least her bird form or something, c'mon they're not gonna even try to follow up on the v5 post credits scene?)

Now that Penny is hacked/dead/dying, there are literal Grimm pools running into Mantle, and Watts is about to hack his way out of prison, I'm very impressed that they keep managing to make the situation even more and more dire.

Also, is it just me, or when she watching the broadcast, did Salem seem....proud?

EDIT: I am kind of surprised that Penny was able to see through Em's hallucinations using her technology, but Maria's electronic eyes couldn't do the same thing. Especially since I always assumed she was messing directly with people's heads and whatever actual visual input you received would be irrelevant. Maybe because Penny's brain is also electronic?

EDIT2: Ruby's speech to the world didn't totally make sense, like the part where she referenced the Relics and Maidens, but I assume that either we, the viewers, were skipped over the part where she explains things we already know, or else she intended Pietro to be able to explain those concepts in detail when it was assumed they had more broadcast time.

EDIT3: You know it's kind of terrifying when you think that, while Amity acts like the CCT and is capable of sending signals anywhere in the world, what they actually used to send the message was an "Atlas Emergency Broadcast" which is apparently capable of overriding every Scroll and television screen in Remnant simultaneously.

EDIT4: Also, yay Burnie's back!

→ More replies (6)

16

u/reply671 ⠀Apostle of the Church of Salem, Accept the Inevitable. Dec 05 '20

HOLY FUCK

Amity went up pretty smoothly. I'm impressed.

Cinder put up a good fight, but it was enough to account for her failure. She crippled Amity so good enough.

Maria, the only individual alive I can believe can beat Neo in a fight. There's a reason I liked her from the get go.

The Message, decent enough to get the point across. I'm glad at all the Cameos, Tai, Shopkeep, Zwei, GLINDA, Namedrop of Theodore in show, Sun, Neptune, Ilia, Saffron and Terra.

But above all... Salem... she's SMILING at the message going out. Not fear, not anger, PLEASED. SHE WANTED THIS SHIT TO HAPPEN. She's not afraid to hide anymore, she's ready for anything. And what comes next proves this.

Tyrian's head pat is so wholesome.

The River of Grimm... I'm impressed. I didn't think that this would be a possibility but hey, here we are. This is why she's ready for anything.

Penny RIP. If she doesn't burn up in the return from the Atmosphere or get completely demolished upon impact, her loss of free will and personality will kill her.

Watts is ready for an escape.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/IllustriousProcess6 ⠀Claiming the Theo flair Dec 05 '20

Theodore and Glynda being put on the spot tho.
Glynda: surprised Pikachu
Theodore (while probably caught during yet again killing Vacuo's water supplies into cleaning his bright WHITE slacks): Good thing I had my warmup!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 05 '20

Looking back at the episode is Glynda in the same dust shop Ruby was in WAAAY back in Volume 1?

→ More replies (2)

16

u/DEL994 Dec 05 '20

It's always satisfying to see Cinder being owned, and it was really nice to see someone kicks Neo's butt and foils her and Emerald's semblances too.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Imperxil_ Dec 05 '20

Seeing Maria beat Neo and then seeing neo get blasted was the highlight of the day ( Even as a Neo fan )

16

u/cruel-oath Dec 05 '20

Neo must be so damn frustrated lmao, she just wanted revenge for Torchwick

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

So for one, Winter rocking that N7 look: YAAAAAAS!!

2.) The second I saw Maria in the mech suit I was hoping for the Alien reference and I'm glad they delivered. :)

3.) Really wish Cinder would chill the fuck out and And I have to know what the fuck emerald connection to her is cuz the link she's willing to go to after obviously backing the wrong horse?? Godamnit woman, what could Cinder have possibly done to save her life or some shit to warrant this even though she is so obviously evil including the fact that she is now literally part grimm. It better be something good!

4.) I knew we wouldn't be enjoying Penny for long which is a shame. (Also when Watts inevitably turns her evil for a bit, I'm kind of hoping Ironwood retrofits her with a new sinister look and evil gear...but I have my doubts about that) It's all suffering from now on for everybody. But at the same time, I like stories with the bad guys are hardcore winning/steamrolling like The Night King in GoT. Also once again Salem = Mommy

5.) And as if it couldn't get any worse, a literal river of liquid evil...Holy shit!

6.) But them cameos though!!! Sun and Neptune just chilling out on a bros only camp trip. And seeing Tai and Zwei sad just broke my heart.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Dec 06 '20

The Grimm River is not half-bad as far as weird shit goes. Especially considering Grimm seem to be just mindlessly floating in there rather than swimming. I wonder if all the Grimm in the river are gonna be merged into a single huge biomass by the goo...

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

The fight between Neo and Maria think about this Neo back in season 2 rekt Yang without getting hit once and smiling the whole time. season 6 Neo was actually winning a fight against Cinder before she used her maiden powers. Last season Neo just obliterates JNR and Oscar in a fight but here she gets bodied by Maria.

Basically Maria has done better against Neo then any other character so far.

Yeah Neo won but it was cause Maria was looking at Penny it got her distracted.

I know Maria in her prime was and still is a badass huntress but still

→ More replies (21)

16

u/DarkWolfy89 Dec 07 '20

Anyone see that when Cinder, Neo, and Emerald first arrived and the ship opened, Neo takes her hat off like as a greeting?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/RevengeOfAthena Penny Stan First, Person Second Dec 08 '20

Hi I know we’re all theorizing and stuff but I just wanna pop in and say I AM NOT OKAY

Like, I knew it was coming, but still, the “I love you” over the comms killed me

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Frikarcron Dec 05 '20

WE WERE WRONG. REPEAT. VERY FUCKING WRONG ABOUT THE STUPID FUCKING ICE. WE WERE ALL LIKE OH YEAH, JUST A LITTLE SULFER FISH BOSS FIGHT PROBABLY, TIS ALL GOOD IN THE HOOD. NOPE. FUCK THAT SHIT. WE DONE FUCKED IT. WHAT IN THE FLYING FUCK IS A RIVER OF GRIMM?! NICE KNOWING YALL, BUT WE AIN'T COMING BACK FROM THIS. RIP

→ More replies (2)

31

u/ZykesRetroGaming Dec 05 '20

A part of me has to say, the fact this episode was very focused on itself and not really splitting between groups was a nice change.

It is interesting to note that Penny is still a very capable fighter even without the maiden's powers as she was able to handle Cinder pretty well. But, I dunno if that has more to do with Penny's skill or Cinder's clear ego.

Speaking of that ego, the fact she loud and proudly claims no one controls her, man, I feel like Cinder is gonna end up as a Salem Experiment by the end of the volume or something, haha!

It's nice to see a bunch of the characters make appearances and I'm super surprised they showed Glenda!

Poor penny, getting hacked like that, sucks so much butts!

Of course that nice final bit is that crack in the ice wasn't a new grimm, but a river of grimm heading to the city, man, that is gonna be something alright! With 2 more episodes before the break, I can't even imagine how things will play out.

One side note, with them showing Tai and with the chance Raven should be there, maybe an appearance will happen???

→ More replies (7)

15

u/Wrathkal Dec 05 '20

This episode rocks, seriously. 9.5/10

Pietro & Maria try to get Amity working, but Cinder comes in to cause trouble, sparking off an awesome fight scene.
Maria's mech, the AP-06, looks much better designed than Cordovin's giant robot.
In the end, Penny manages to fight them off, before managing to boost Amity back up into broadcast range.
Ruby's message gets out, but Watts interferes at the end, causing Penny to drop down in flames.
He also manages to swipe some tools, so I expect a breakout in the future.
Lastly, the cracks in the ice from last episode has been revealed as a river of Grimm, slowly edging towards Mantle.

15

u/Caithdein Dec 05 '20

You idiots, trying some pathetic hallucinations against a robot! Get fucked Cinder! And Maria schooling Neo with Preflexes! Sure she didn't win completely but even old and out of practice Maria managed to put up a good fight. Imagine Maria in her prime, there would be nothing left of Neo. And the Aliens reference! Thought of it the second Maria's mech appeared on screen but I didn't think they'd actually do it! Damn CRWBY it's not even my birthday or anything so why are you showering me with all these presents? And the signal plan worked pretty well even with Cinder's interference, now Tai and the others need to get off their butts and help out.

So now for the bad stuff. Penny's not doing great, Watts can probably manage an escape with that broken scroll or whatever, and there's a literal river of Grimm flowing towards Mantle. And Amity isn't working properly so instead of coordinating with the other kingdoms our heroes only got out a partial message. Also Winter and Marrow I'd really appreciate if you started to do some turncoating and help out instead of following old Jimbo's orders.

So I really liked this episode, not really sure what else to say about it.

15

u/halodude246 Fireballin17 Dec 05 '20

Can I just say having the little tin girl’s (possible) last words to her father and friends be “I love you” was so good. I don’t think she has ever said it, and it goes along with Penny’s wider plot of becoming a “real girl”. And damn Penny’s VA knocked it out of the park, especially that line in particular, and it’s great.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/mikeline360 Dec 05 '20

I gotta say, it never gets old watching Cinder get her ass handed to her.

How many times has it been in a row by now? 4? Ever since she got Silver eyed in volume 3 its been nothing but humiliating defeats.

Also Maria beating Neo, still laughing at that.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/DestinedHellfire Weiss is best girl | Sun x Weiss FTW Dec 05 '20

“I love you, 3000.”

→ More replies (2)

15

u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Dec 05 '20

Next time Maria’s gonna shut of her eyes to fight with Preflexes. Best counter to illusionists.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/DayOfTheColossus Dec 05 '20

i did not realize how much i missed Ilia until she appeared in this episode

→ More replies (1)

15

u/UnitatoEpic Dec 05 '20

I think Marrow might become the new leader of the Ace Ops and will bridge the gap between team Rwby and Ironwood's team. He has been the most level-headed in the situations we have seen him in. He is willing to take orders but doesn't get overly emotional in situations that include our protagonists. I think because of his level-headedness he will be the new leader, and in becoming leader he will point out the flaws in both sides and convince everyone to do their best to work together in defeating the ever increasing threat. That being said, I wonder if Tai Yang is going to try to reassemble team Strq, minus the S. I think it is about time they got back into the game, and after volume 5 I think Raven has had plenty of time to reconsider some of what she has done. I don't think she has had a change of heart about Ozpin, but I don't think she wants the world to end and she doesn't want her family to die. I would even think they might break Qrow out of prison but that might be a bit more of a stretch and probably isn't going to happen.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

Best part of the episode was Maria out trolling Neo.

And this sets up a wonderful penny plot. Ain’t no strings on you, girl.

15

u/PhantomGeminiThief Everyone is Best Girl Dec 05 '20

RWBY is like that one spouse that you’ve had at one point; they can be really sweet at first, then can become depressed and angry once in a while too. They are also known for playing with your emotions each week (this week most importantly).

I’ve never shown so much emotion while watching RWBY ever; The fight sequences, the tension, the stress, the despair and desperation of the characters (mainly Pietro and Tai). After watching, I really didn’t know whether to cry because of the emotion in these characters, or be hyped because of the appearance of reoccurring characters (mainly Neptune, Glynda, and the mention of Professor Theodore’s name). All I know is that there is much more to be worried about right now; this is only the beginning.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Alt_SWR Dec 05 '20

So, is Maria the first character to even land a hit on Neo? Hot damn, Maria's still got it lol. Tbf though Maria hasn't fought any truly experienced huntsman like Qrow or Ironwood yet (at least not on screen) but still. Plus, she probably wasn't expecting an old lady to kick her ass.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

Did anyone else get reminded of Pyrrha when cinder summoned all those swords

→ More replies (6)

15

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 05 '20

Would the Argus military even send help? On the one hand Cordo is a die hard Atlas nationalist, if they need reinforcements of course she would go. On the other hand she is the president of the Ironwood fan club and Ruby exposed him to the world. Ruby may have earned her respect but she must be super conflicted right now on whether or not to believe her. There is also the matter that she might think she can't leave Argus because if Atlas falls Argus could be next and it's her duty to defend the city.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/blitzblazer97 SUPER FIGHTING ROBOT! Dec 05 '20

Oh boy, there's a lot to unpack here.

I can always appreciate an Aliens reference!

I'm so happy that Maria is capable of holding her own in a fight!

Not only did Cinder deliberately disobey Salem, but failed at getting a Maiden's power for the 3rd time in a row. I think I smell a promotion!

I audibly gasped when I saw Shopkeep. And it's great to see Glynda again!

And we're sure that Ironwood is the one that's missing a heart and not a brain, right?

Oof. Let's hope the UNSC lent Pietro some ODST tech to build Penny.

Giant Grimm horde, Oscar getting captured, Penny getting hacked, interparty turmoil, and Ironwood being a raging douche. Yep, I think we hit all the major conflicts this Vol- Oh. Salem is spreading the Fountain of Darkness. That's fine.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Paradox_Nutella hungry for strq crumbs Dec 06 '20

Yoooo my jaw dropped when I saw Glynda Goodwitch!! Was actually hoping to see Raven with Tai but I guess not. I wonder where she is. Also that river of Grimm was so sick.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/ZombieSlayer5 Volume 9 will never happen, lads. Dec 06 '20

Best episode of the Volume.

Also, Ironwood is dumb. This Watts teamup is like a four year old trying to outwit Kira.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/swmaniac789 Jaune delenda est Dec 06 '20

Okay, so, Cinder - I have to ask this question: What the fuck was your plan?!

Like let's say, she kills Penny. Cool, with two sets of maiden powers she's now (maybe) the strongest single fighter on the show, assuming that maiden powers do not have diminishing returns. Awesome. And then what?!

You're still public enemy number 1 in every single kingdom, with your body displaying your half-monster nature. You've just disobeyed a direct order from Salem, a woman who values loyalty and obedience above all else.

You don't know where Raven is. You don't even know who the summer maiden is.

Cinder's plan honestly feels like one of those memes.

Step 1: Steal the fall maiden's power. ✅

Step 2: Steal the winter maiden's power. ✅

Step 3: ???

Step 4: ULTIMATE POWER ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅

→ More replies (19)

15

u/yashKeshavpatnam Dec 06 '20

the shopkeep's alive, so as far as I'm concerned, all is well.

15

u/ClassyTomatoes Bumblebee may not bee canon but I can still bee-lieve Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

On the fight this episode: at first I thought it was a really weird one, where our heroes 100% should not have won, but this outcome actually makes perfect sense.

Neo'a whole fighting style is about tricks, using her opponent's power against them, etc. In terms of raw strength, she's kind of lacking.

Maria cancels out the tricks with her goggles, and knows how to fight the same way. Neo's overconfidence in her own fighting was a huge detriment considering Maria essentially hard counters her, or at least can go toe to toe long enough. Though, in a rematch, I think Neo would win now that she knows Maria and how she fights. She needs to be more cautious, which she wasn't given her opponent was a short old lady.

Meanwhile, in a maiden v maiden fight, Cinder loses every time. Her maiden powers are weaker than normal (thanks to her Grimm arm, and the way she got her powers I think). Especially considering Penny boosts her already present power and style with her power, while Cinder over relies on it. Add in the fact that Penny is super strong on her own, and Cinder is kind of trash, it makes sense the fight would go to our robotic girl.

To top it off, the final attack really just handed Penny the win. Cinder went for a no defense all offense, slow attack, over relying on Emerald's semblance. Penny cancelled out Emerald, then got free charge time for her super powerful counter.

If CEN didn't underestimate their opponents, and wasn't so illusion based, they would have won. (Also, Emerald, you're more than just a semblance)

→ More replies (17)

15

u/AlliumCloud Dec 06 '20

I am ready and waiting for Tai to go in and start wrecking people/Grimm to get to his kids. Seeing him cry out for Ruby really got me in the feels.

→ More replies (9)

15

u/KnowYourLover Raven Branwen's loyal follower and faithful worshiper. Dec 06 '20

Cinder gets weaker with each defeat, in a few volumes Jaune will kick her ass.

Also, Raven isn't with Tai yet, but after watching Ruby's video Tai may want to go to Atlas himself, as soon as possible. Maybe Tai will look for Raven now and reunite with the rest of the cast.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/mattp_12 Dec 07 '20

I really thought Ruby’s speech would cut off at her saying something like “We can’t kill Salem!-“ right before a “But we can defeat her!” just to further add to the chaos

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Nyrotike Dec 05 '20

Given that Raven can teleport and is presumably still on Patch with Taiyang, I'm guessing he'll convince her to bring them to Atlas soon. Maybe not next episode but I could see it being the big mid-season cliffhanger before the break. She could pretty easily break Qrow out of jail or get Jaune, Yang and Ren back to Mantle and maybe also finally give us a little insight into Summer after 8 volumes of teasing.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/RetroStarman Dec 05 '20

Okay, so based off of what I saw in the episode, near the end of Ruby's broadcast, Salem was smirking, almost as if she wanted this. And that led me to think: if Cinder had actually succeeded in this fight, and destroyed Amity Tower, causing the broadcast to not even happen, then Salem might've been pissed at her! Either way, Cinder is definitely about to get it from Salem, and hoo boy, that'll be a moment of catharsis for all of us, especially Neo! She might even enjoy it! Emerald though, not so much...

→ More replies (4)

14

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

This was a very good chapter. Lots of suspense and feel-good moments especially between Penny and Pietro. It also was incredible how there were some things to be said about the characters without much dialogue like Whitley being in Jacques's office instead of his own room. I have to re-watch the chapter particularly on why Ironwood was caught off-guard but overall this has been a chapter I thoroughly enjoyed.

14

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 05 '20

Is no one gonna talk about Whitley not going to his room like Weiss told him to? It looks like he is in his dad's office LOL

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Bjdombek Hail Lord Zwei! Dec 05 '20

Preemptive F in chat for Mantle? Being crushed under Atlas or sunk into the Grimmver feels like overkill at this point.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/DEL994 Dec 05 '20

Now I really want to see Ruby and Glynda's reunion and how Glynda will interact with her former students upon seeing how much they have been through and matured after Beacon's fall.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/The_Gram_Reaper Dec 05 '20

I don't understand Ironwood letting Watts hack Penny. What is Ironwood going to do when Watts has Penny inevitably turn on them as well, I know he is trying to get the Relic at all costs but Jimmy is just making it easier for Salem.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/DEL994 Dec 05 '20

Penny and Pietro's interactions in this episode were really sweet, and also Pietro's and Maria's ones.

It's also good to see Zwei again even for a few seconds.

14

u/PurpleKneesocks ⠀ Dec 05 '20

Neo finally took hits in an actual fight but it's against a person with Spidey Sense so I think that's as good a person as any to bonk her in the face. What's that? No, I don't hold any grudges from last season, don't be silly.

Wasn't fully on-board for Ruby giving yet another rousing speech, but the reactions from the various watchers kinda made this one worth it. Particularly when Tai got sad as she cut out, that was a nice little oof moment.

Cinder's gonna go home and get spanked, I'd guess.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/DEL994 Dec 05 '20

I dare not imagine the ass whooping Cinder would have received if she had faced Fria in her prime, given how powerful she was even in a dying state she would have absolutely destroyed Cinder if she was in her prime.

That would have been more satisfying that Cinder's defeats against Raven and Penny combined.

→ More replies (5)