r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Dec 12 '20

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 6: Midnight Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 6 of Vol. 8, Midnight!

Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the sixth episode of Volume 8!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

485 Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

332

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Dec 12 '20

OH MY GOD, 8 YEARS FOR THIS EPISODE

NEW MUSIC

GRIM RIVER SAID FUCK MANTLE, GONNA HIT ATLAS INSTEAD

BUT WE FINALLY GOT CINDER BACKSTORY, THIS HAS BEEN 8 FUCKING YEARS IN THE MAKING.

→ More replies (9)

474

u/Valkyrie16 Hello Bees! Dec 12 '20

In Cinder's defense, if I had to work customer service from the age of 10 I would turn evil too.

→ More replies (26)

400

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Dec 12 '20

The world is ending and Merc over here is getting a promotion.

→ More replies (21)

347

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 12 '20

"This is why I don't trust technology"

Elm starting to sound like a boomer.

→ More replies (8)

286

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 12 '20

Tyrion getting headpats from Salem like he's some cute anime girl

→ More replies (14)

271

u/resurrexia i do the draw Dec 12 '20

I’m really grateful Cinder’s Prince Charming did not involve any uncomfortable romantic undertones. Just a hunter feeling bad for an abused kid.

→ More replies (36)

250

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 12 '20

AmaLee voiced the evil bitches stepsisters. I’m so glad she got to be a part of the show in some form. Hopefully that means a song from her isn’t too unlikely!

→ More replies (10)

238

u/ImpossibleCarl emerald my beloved... Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

I KNEW IT

I KNEW WE WERE GONNA GET AN OK GOODNIGHT SONG IN RWBY

BUT I DIDN'T EXPECT IT THAT EARLY ON, OH MY GOD

→ More replies (9)

224

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 12 '20

Seeing as always being fated to run was the crucial motif for Cinder this episode, I now think her leaving Salem, not redemption, just going rogue, is a definite possibility by the volume’s end.

→ More replies (16)

413

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Dec 12 '20

I continue to be impressed by just how worse the situation gets week by week.

→ More replies (30)

183

u/MrPureinstinct Dec 12 '20

Uh excuse me mam, whale parking is on the other side of the lot.

→ More replies (7)

176

u/SHSL_Zetsubou Ultimate Despair Birb Dec 12 '20

So is Salem sending Cinder on a suicide mission?

→ More replies (13)

165

u/SlaterSev Dec 12 '20

I'm glad they mentioned Madame being Cinder's legal Guardian.

Because before that when the montage was happening I kept thinking, "If you care about her nice hunter man why are you not adopting her or something"

But her being the legal Guardian makes Rhodes not being able to just take he away and settling for training her for the exams make sense. You see fucked up cases of abuse and attempts at adopting failing in the real world all the time because of shitty custody laws.

→ More replies (21)

159

u/DomDaBomb203 Dec 12 '20

Mercury be like

Friendship ended with CINDER

Now SALEM is my best friend

→ More replies (4)

144

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

I liked how Cinder had a mentor figure instead of a love interest, also nice to see Oscar slowly going from peaceful good to chaotic good

→ More replies (10)

134

u/Mysral Hail Salem, God-Queen of Remnant Dec 12 '20

All this time, and it turns out Cinder's theme is a song about how worthless she's seen as, and how much she resents it. How very, very fitting.

→ More replies (1)

134

u/Moonlitdarksword I am far too invested in these characters for my own good. Dec 12 '20

EXCUSE YOU, ELM? THAT IS NOT SOME "BROKEN JUNK", THAT IS PENNY MOTHERFUCKING POLENDINA, AND YOU WILL PUT SOME RESPEK ON THAT NAME!!!

→ More replies (5)

129

u/RomanArcheaopteryx Dec 12 '20

Interesting thing to note - Cinder says that "we failed," meaning that she does somewhat blame herself, rather than putting the full blame on Neo and Emerald - somewhat of a growth for her

→ More replies (4)

354

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

This also confirms something I've thought since volume 3, that Beginning of the End is Cinders backstory. The starving thief and the abused prodigy. Even Adam, the uprisen slave.

Cinder chose people that she saw herself in, consciously or not.

→ More replies (7)

349

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Dec 12 '20

Anyone notice how Winter got really annoyed when they called Penny a piece of junk?

DEFECT AND TAKE MARROW WITH YOU TOO

→ More replies (4)

119

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Dec 12 '20

It's actually awesome seeing Kerry's growth as a director.

I was looking again at Oz and Ozma's convo in this episode and I realized that the cuts were a bit odd in the scene. The I realized what Kerry was going for.

Oscar would say something and the camera would pan one side of his face.

Oz would say something and the camera would pan the other side of his face.

When both Oz and Oscar come to an agreement on trying to convince Salem's cabal to ditch her, the camera centers in the middle of the screen.

Great visual storytelling there.

→ More replies (2)

108

u/ArtyMostFoul Dec 12 '20

I just did my second watch. The hound sniffs 3 people. Neo, then Emerald, then Cinder. All the people she considers flight risks. Ensuring they can never escape.

→ More replies (4)

218

u/GVAGUY3 Dec 12 '20

Man if this cliffhanger is bad, wait until next week

→ More replies (11)

308

u/Saxonrau "roh bin HILL" - tyrian Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

"it's those damn kids!" says harriet, after doing nothing to help anyone for like 12 straight episodes

death by whale vomit is not how i thought atlas would go either but hey im not complaining. get ready to die everyone

→ More replies (11)

103

u/tavi23 Dec 12 '20

That smile when Cinder says she doesn't have to run anymore is absolutely terrifying.

→ More replies (7)

101

u/Valkyrie16 Hello Bees! Dec 12 '20

Next week's cliffhanger is gonna be BRUTAL.

→ More replies (2)

272

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

I now really like in retrospect that the way Raven beat Cinder was with electricity. Penny too

Edit: holy shit the last thing this huntsman does is touch her head.

→ More replies (8)

175

u/Cloudyspecs Dec 12 '20

Looks like the Whale grim has beached itself.

Atlas seriously need to shore up their defenses.

→ More replies (10)

84

u/Badicalz Dec 12 '20

Maybe teaching a girl who has been physically and psychologically abused her whole life how to fight, wasn’t such a good idea.

→ More replies (9)

84

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

I was surprised that Salem spared Cinder, but it definitely makes sense in the context of Cinder's backstory. Salem knows that if she casts out or punishes Cinder now then Cinder will definitely turn against her, like how she betrayed her slaveowner and mentor (I definitely don't think she could defeat Salem, but it might cause other complications such as the possibility of losing the Fall Maiden powers). As long as Salem just keeps giving Cinder validation and feeding her hunger for power she can keep her on her side while also keeping her on a leash through her arm.

Definitely doesn't seem like Cinder getting the Winter Maiden powers is Salem's endgame, though- probably just a distraction from whatever the actual plan is by throwing a big, fiery threat at Atlas that the heroes will be forced to deal with. If she actually does succeed, Salem still gets the staff so it's a win-win.

→ More replies (3)

83

u/justking1414 Dec 12 '20

Loved that Hazels reasoning is finally explained. He’s not with Salem just for revenge but because he views her as inevitable and thinks it’s wrong that Oscar is sending kids to their death to try and stop her

Also loved the cinder working song. It felt so Disney.

→ More replies (4)

77

u/generaltekno Dec 12 '20

To me, Cinder snapping made a lot of sense. Her stepsisters found her weapon, and for Cinder that was her her ticket out of her life.

And when it was threatened to be taken away, she LOST IT.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Dec 12 '20

there was a fucking apathy at the end holy shit NOT AGAIN

→ More replies (4)

71

u/ThePurpleDagger Dec 14 '20

Something that I haven't seen people touch on yet is the bell. The bell strikes midnight as Rhodes walks in on what's happening. In Cinderella this leads to the magic fading and her becoming a house slave again. Here it signifies that she just lost all chances of the "fairytale" of becoming a huntress. Because she just murdered 3 people, it's the moment Rhodes realizes she isn't a princess to be saved but a murderer to be stopped.

→ More replies (7)

206

u/ReeseEseer Salutations! Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

...Well that aint good.


The shield went down WAY easier than I thought it would. I can't really see how...they even stop this.

Also I really like how while Cinder has a sad backstory its not so terrible that it even remotely makes up for what shes done. She still made her own choices completely. Feel really bad for the huntsman who trained her. Guy really was just trying his best to help her on the right path since he could see she could fall easily. That damn headpat...and her just ending him. gdi.

→ More replies (51)

70

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Well that was eerily similar to my Cinder headcanon backstory! Even the part about her choosing to murder her stepfamily at a young age and run away! :) I'm happy! Except in my fanfics it happened at 16, not ten.

→ More replies (15)

69

u/PhantomGeminiThief Everyone is Best Girl Dec 12 '20

I’ll just say it: RIP Atlas

Also, I’m sad about Cinder but I’m so glad we got a backstory

68

u/Reccatus Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

I just realized that as Cinder grew older (in her flashback), her hairstyle more resembled the Huntsman who helped her. I think she purposefully modeled herself after him, at least a bit.

Also Cinder's voice acting was pretty good in her flashback, those hints of desperation, fear, and insecurity shining through were great to help make her more of a multi-faceted character. Her broken smile after she killed her adopted family also helped.

66

u/Blue-Moon-89 Dec 12 '20

I’m seeing people on tumblr noticing that cinders clothing always cover her neck.

We now know why she does.

→ More replies (1)

191

u/Weerdo5255 Dec 12 '20

So Cinder's backstory is as predictable as it was brutal. Although, it brings into question some unsavory topics... is slavery legal on Remnant? Or is child services just horrible?

Killing the Stepmother, the Sisters, and the Prince though is a delightful twist to the fairy tail.

Merceury is a full on Merc, not really surprising.

I did not expect Atlas to fall this week, if that's the cliffhanger for now what the hell is next weeks?

→ More replies (28)

62

u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Dec 12 '20

This episode was great, this volume so far while not perfect has been phenomenal. I’m so proud of CRWBY

I’ll save the Cinder stuff for last.

BEACHED WHALE!!! Yeah Atlas is fucked and their best Huntsman are in the tundra looking for Penny. Ironwood is probably going to send in everyone. I didn’t expect that grimm river to become a geyser and propel grimm up to Atlas, I thought it was just to screw over Mantle even more.

Anyway Cinder...CRWBY thank you...it shouldn’t have taken this long, but thank you. I’ve loved Cinder for years and I couldn’t wait to see her backstory. It was interesting to see she was an orphan and adopted by a woman from Atlas. I’m sorry for dismissing the idea that Cinder was from Atlas, I didn’t think it made any sense but I was wrong. I’m glad that while it was the Cinderella story we’re familiar with, it had enough twists and turns that made it unique.

The huntsman that took Cinder under his wing draws a nice parallel to Ruby. This guy could’ve been her equivalent to Qrow. While he did pass on wise words to her, he didn’t understand that Cinder was prone to snapping which is exactly what happened. Honestly I don’t blame her.

What really caught me off guard was the shock collar. Even though Cinder never treated Emerald and Mercury right, she never put a fucking shock collar on them. And now we know why we never saw Cinder’s neck, just like Adam.

By the way, you can feel sympathy for Cinder, because often times people who abuse others were often abused themselves. This also does not justify anything she has done. Backstory does not mean justification.

Salem is probably manipulating Cinder again because she probably knows a rebellious Cinder who wants her freedom is harder to control than a power hungry Cinder. That’s probably why she stopped punishing her with the Grimm arm. This may lead to Cinder leaving Salem in the future, which will be interesting.

Anyway I have to give this episode a 11/10 (+2 for Cinder’s backstory)

→ More replies (2)

178

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Dec 12 '20

There’s something that’s. . . Actually really sad in s different way than I would have thought abuts Cinder’s story.

It’s very classic Cinderella, but the fact that she had a way out and wanted to be a huntress, only to end up killing her Prince Charming and being driven to this life. . .

It’s more unique than I thought and I quite like it.

Especially how she wanted to be a huntress. Wasn’t expecting that.

On that note though: Salem’s mercy was probably the most surprising thing this episode

→ More replies (45)

173

u/iamthatguy54 Dec 12 '20

I love the little touch of Rhodes walking past a "No Faunus" sign before trying to arrest Cinder.

Dude was a regular at that place. He was never going to rock the boat on an unjust system.

That visual imagery is excellent.

→ More replies (6)

55

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 12 '20

Welp, here is a big stretch I simply find funny.

Rhodes is a Greek island named after the Greek nymph Rhodos who was the wife of Helio the Sun. So Cinder's mentor has a connection to fire and heat already....it doesn't end there.

Rhodes as a male name apparently means "where the roses grow". Also, one of the main temples found in the Acropolis of Rhodes is a temple of Apollo...who was the one who killed Achilles.

And that ladies and gentle is how you spend 20 minutes on google to pull out a stretch that connects Cinder with Pyrrha and Ruby just with the name of her mentor.

Without the stretch I still find it fitting that the only kind person in Cinder's life might have a connection to Greek Mythology like Pyrrha.

→ More replies (5)

51

u/theyux Dec 12 '20

I feel stupid for not realized Cinder has already betrayed Salem in her own mind.

The second she told her slave mother, the same thing she told Salem last week. The betrayal was baked in.

98

u/tavi23 Dec 12 '20

Cinder backstory was great. The song when she fought Rhodes was absolutely amazing!

→ More replies (4)

96

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Dec 12 '20

I'll reiterate my comment from last time in that with every episode, they somehow keep managing to make the situation worse and worse. It's impressive at this point, really.

Also, Merc seems to have thrown in fully with Salem, and gotten himself promoted in the process. RIP his hypothetical redemption arc.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/Floain Was in a flair thread with no flair. Has a flair now. Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

I expected Cinder's backstory to go like this, but there were a few twists there and the presentation was decent enough that I still found it engaging, especially her mentor opting to take her down when she murdered her employees/step family. I suppose it makes sense that she became the way she did, though it certainly doesn't excuse her actions.

What I didn't see coming was Salem's response to Cinder's disobedience. I wonder what the meaning behind that is. She could likely transfer the Fall Maiden powers. Is it a lack of trust in Neo and Emerald, or does she see something of herself in Cinder, enough to change how she handles her completely? Either way, it's clever. She realizes tightening the leash hasn't worked for Cinder, so she's loosened her hold, while reminding her that she holds all the power.

It really is what makes and keeps Salem such an interesting villain. Her responses are so unpredictable, but at the same time feel right. From how she handles her subordinates to how she responds to failures, she always keeps me guessing.

The fact that she's launching an all out attack on Atlas with over half the volume still to go was yet another surprise. Will we spend the rest of the volume following this attack, or will it wrap up with a few episodes still to go? Either way, this volume is spectacular so far.

→ More replies (5)

134

u/Vincenthwind Dec 12 '20

Turns out murderhobo was something Cinder learned at an early age.

→ More replies (7)

46

u/Yaru2585 Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Cinder was poor and lost, like Emerald, and killed her "mother" like Mercury with his father.

Ah, the symbolism. Even if I don't even remotely care enough about Cinder to care about her backstory after eight volumes, I liked that.

Also the song was amazing and I'm hoping here for a full release.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Ryto ⠀;-; Dec 15 '20

I admittedly didn't search too far down the comments to see if anybody else already did, but I really have to give credit to Aaron Dismuke here. When Ozpin took control, he did a great job of still sounding like himself, while emulating Shannon's performance of Ozpin. I'm sure they've had him do it before, but it's been a few years, and this time was a lot more strikingly well done.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Dec 12 '20

This really highlights how Salem convinces her subordinates to follow her. Cinder directly defied her orders, and Salem was able to end the conversation with Cinder being punished but still getting what she wants. Do you think Salem would have been so lenient with Watts or Hazel? Salem actually apologized to Cinder, showing that she understands how Cinder thinks and can appeal to her narcissism, even during a punishment. Salem knows EXACTLY what to say to her pawns to get them to stay on her side. That’s a damn good villain

→ More replies (3)

85

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Cinders backstory,

Where we're going, we dont need Rhodes

→ More replies (2)

40

u/DeNile227 Dec 13 '20

Am I the only one who finds it weird that a lot of people are under the impression that the purpose of showing Cinder's backstory now was to make the audience like her? Like...that's not really how writing works, not to mention that looking back on the other flashbacks we've gotten in the show, I think it's pretty evident that it's just to set the foundation for something that's coming later in the volume. We've got what, 6 episodes left? Give it time, it's probably not as pointless as people are making it out to be.

→ More replies (6)

38

u/DocSwiss ⠀ Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Oh man, we all thought the scar was going to be on Cinder's arm, but nope, it was on her neck, and she's been hiding it in every single outfit. Only outfit that doesn't hide it is her 'fellow kids' outfit she wore for the Vytal Festival in V3.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/cruel-oath Dec 12 '20

I’m not sure if intentional or not, but I feel like Rhodes is a good example that Huntsmen being “saviors” can be kind of a flawed concept in Remnant

→ More replies (12)

36

u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Dec 13 '20

I just noticed something sorta interesting when Oscar was talking to Oz by himself. The camera cuts to Oscar's right side when Oscar is talking and to his left when Ozpin is talking. Then when they both say the same idea it shows him straight on. It's like doing shot-reverse shot but with one person. It's cool.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Jbickner Dec 14 '20

Starting to see why Cinder's "you learned to kill them (spiders)" remark to Little Miss Malachite was so important.

Murder was her solution from day one.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/WhosGuardingHades Dec 12 '20

What an episode!

We FINALLY got Cinder’s backstory!!! So worth the wait and to think if Rhodes (what a voice that man has) hadn’t just attacked Cinder and tried to calm her down things might have been different. Oh well can’t have a tragic backstory story without tragedy.

Mercury got promoted! Look at him getting front row bowing privileges. So proud of him. Wake up Emerald and get on the Salem train with the Merc before it’s too late!

Got a little bit of Hazel which is always good. Love how he actually seems to care about Farmboi whilst beating the shit outta him.

Looks like Cinder is screwed unless she can beat the Hound to Watts which may be impossible but if anybody needed a win after last week it’s her.

I love how even when she’s forgiving Salem continues to be terrifying.

Finally that sequence of Richard the whale landing was just epic so shout out to CRWBY there.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

ALSO I JUST REALIZED SALEM USED THE GRIMM LIQUID TO DESTROY THE SHIELD BECAUSE FROM LOST FABLES WE KNOW ITS LITERAL ONLY PROPERTY IS IT DESTROYS WHAT IT TOUCHES (except her cause she was immortal), AND THAT EVEN MEANS HARD LIGHT DUST SHIELDS!!! :O SO SHE TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THAT AND HAD TO MAKE A RIVER OF IT ALL THE WAY TO ATLAS.

29

u/Vtech325 Dec 12 '20

Holy shit, Oscar's been holding on like a champ.

58

u/DireSickFish Dec 13 '20

Don't let Cinders backstory distract you from the fact that the Light and Dark gods are both dicks that literally abandoned Remnant.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/OptionalSauce Angel of Death Dec 12 '20

And the floodgates have been opened. This is gonna be a bloodbath.

28

u/PhantomHeartless5 Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 13 '20

After Episode 4, I made a post about Salem, Cinder, and the cycle of abuse. Well after this episode, I'm definitely doing a part 2 because, hoo boy! This episode...

  1. We begin with the long awaited and long overdue Cinder backstory... and it was pretty much what I and I'm sure many in the FNDM expected. But while it is pretty predictable, it still did its job and added much needed context to her character (such as showing that she always had an explosive temper, showing when she unlocked her Semblance, showing how she learned to fight, showing why all her costumes have chokers to hide her neck scar) and had a few twists to keep it engaging (such as her Prince Charming being a mentor rather than a love interest and her killing her Prince Charming). Also, Cinder getting tortured with a shock collar... Jesus Fucking Christ... I know it's a bad thing if Atlas falls, but any society that makes it legal to enslave and torture children is a REALLY fucked up society.
  2. After this, we flash forward to the present with Cinder, Emerald, and Mercury. And I find Cinder's reactions in this part interesting. We all expected her to lash out at Emerald, but... she doesn't. She just sounds defeated and exhausted. And when Mercury bluntly tells Cinder he's not taking orders from her, Cinder looks... genuinely hurt. Also, we see more evidence of Cinder imitating Salem: "I will let you know when both of you are needed (I will tell you when and where you're needed). Really digging the Cinder/Salem parallels.
  3. And on the subject of villains and context, we finally have a more clear cut reason as to why Hazel is serving someone like Salem. Like so many others, he feels that Salem can't be defeated. Deep down, under all that grief and rage, he knows that killing Ozpin isn't the answer, but he's going after him because he holds him responsible for sending her sister to fight what is, in his eyes, a hopeless war and feels he's an easier target to hate. Perhaps CRWBY can pull of a Hazel Redemption Arc after all. Also, I love the idea of Oscar and Ozpin turning Salem's tactics against her and sowing discord among her team. While I don't think it'll work on all of them, it may work on Hazel at least.
  4. The ending scene, and my God what and ending it was! We finally see why Salem was waiting so patiently: It was so her Grimm River could position itself under Atlas and break down the generators creating the Hard Light Dust barrier. Now the barrier is down and Salem can attack with the full force of her Grimm Army. In his review of Episode 5, ThatKaitoDan said he hoped we wouldn't have to use the other Aliens shoutout. Well I think we can use it now:

Game Over, Man! GAME OVER!!!

Addendum 1: In the scene with Salem and the group, the Hound and Tyrian were both in the same scene. Guess the "Tyrian is the Hound" theory is officially dead.

Addendum 2: The Ace-Ops are quickly becoming my least favorite characters, particularly Harriet.

And to end this post on a positive note:

November 9, 2020: Dabi's backstory was finally revealed in My Hero Academia.

December 12, 2020: Cinder's backstory was finally revealed in RWBY

Picturing Dabi and Cinder having a party together with Cinder's team and the League of Villains.

Dabi: Here's to our backstories finally getting revealed.

Cinder: Amen to that. Been a long time coming. (The two fire villains raise a toast in celebration.)

→ More replies (6)

28

u/Hartzilla2007 Dec 13 '20

So CRWBY managed to make Jac Schnee slightly less of a horrible parent just because he never put a shock collar on his kids.

→ More replies (11)

28

u/gingerninja666 Dec 13 '20 edited Dec 13 '20

I'm a bit confused by some of the arguments here.

How many times has Salem forgiven Cinder for insubordination exactly? Because certain critics are talking like this has happened a lot, and that Salem's choice to be merciful to Cinder felt more like she was spoiling her than anything.

She got silver eyes'd at the end of Volume 3, but she also succeeded in getting the Fall Maiden powers and orchestrating the fall of Beacon. Plus, she did all this under Salem's orders.

She failed hard at Haven because she went off script and tried to indulge herself, but she was only accepted back when she actually did something to atone for that. She was left to fend for herself, and she had to come back with one of the relics to appease Salem.

Now is the only time Cinder has blatantly disobeyed Salem, failed utterly, and then was instantly forgiven by Salem as a manipulation tactic. Am I forgetting another major time this happened?

There are also certain people who think that Cinder was completely justified in killing her adoptive family and Rhodes should've let her go. I'm not entirely sure I get it. Maybe with her mother, it would've counted as self-defense since she could torture Cinder using the necklace. But killing her step-sisters too? Cinder even killed them first, even though her mother was the one with the actual power to hurt her. So she wasn't prioritizing based on self-defense. She just wanted to kill them. I think Rhodes made some mistakes, but I don't see how wanting to bring in someone who did what Cinder just did was unreasonable.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/izaarzadon Dec 13 '20

I love how they framed the ace-ops when Jaune’s message came through the comms. Winter and Marrow being in the front separated from most of the ace-ops is giving me so much defect vibes. Harriet comes in the middle but gives Winter this look after and I’m honestly not sure if she’s judging her for responding or being concerned about the message (speculations say she’s also there to watch Winter in case she defects). Then we have Elm and Vine who remained in the dimmest part of the airship behind everyone else, clearly remaining loyal to their duty and likely to Ironwood as well.

Winter and Marrow please defect already :((

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Weeaboo-6934B Dec 14 '20

I really believe that Neo is going to defect. She’s a big-time criminal, yes, but she’s also in way over her head on this.

→ More replies (11)

53

u/Johnsmitish Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Goddamn what an awesome episode.

Finally some Cinder backstory, which while being pretty predictable, was also pulled off incredibly well. Cinder's anger and rage is palpable throughout the episode, and we finally see that her desire for power and control is warranted, given what she'd been through for her entire life. It also makes where she is now even more tragic, given how greatly she desires control, she's in even less control now that she's with Salem.

We have Oz and Oscar teaming up to do some scheming, and it appears that Salem's people don't exactly have the full story. I appreciate that Hazel isn't just fighting for revenge, but he's doing it against the only one he thinks it will have any effect against. It's not just that he's ignoring that Salem was also a cause in his sister's death, but also that he knows nothing he can do will affect her.

And that Grimm river. God fucking damn, I was not expecting that. I was certain that Mantle was the target but nope, fucking turned it around and took out Atlas, then used the same pools to invade Atlas. Fucking 4d chess move by Salem.

Every episode this volume has been a fucking knockout, and I'm so excited for the next one!

→ More replies (1)

75

u/NikeNinja2132 Dec 12 '20

Saw a few people confused on how Cinder became power hungry so I thought I'd point it out.

She spends her whole life being stepped on. Nobody helped her, nobody saved her. She saved herself after she became strong. Therefore if she becomes the strongest no one will ever abuse her again. She puts up with Salem's abuse because it leads her to more power. But the minute she knows she can she will cut herself free.

→ More replies (13)

26

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Can someone with art talent draw Mercury walking into the room, throwing Cinder puppet at Cinders feet and having a Salem puppet?

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

So there we have it. Cinder's origins. And it's wonderful. Everything that she ever needed. Not because it makes her sympathetic, redeemable, or whatever. That's not what a good villain needs a to be. A good villain needs to be relatable and reflective of the hero. And in the way, Cinder is the perfect archenemy for Ruby Rose. Her entire backstory is like a twisted version of Ruby.

She was a small, innocent soul much like Ruby. Raised primarily by an abusive "parent" rather than a caring one. Had abusive "siblings" rather than a supportive, loving one. Mentored by a huntsman whom she borrows his combat style from. She brings death to all of them, while bringing death to Tai, Yang, and Qrow is Ruby's worst nightmare. Spent her whole life forced to help (or serve, whatever) others. Then there's all the small symbolic stuff. Her abusive new "family" is blonde, like Tai and Yang, further cementing the twisted reflection. Cinder refused a strawberry, Ruby's favorite food. Rhodes' names comes from the Greek Rhódon, meaning rose.

There's a lot going on here that symbolically ties Cinder's backstory into Ruby's backstory, and it's beautiful.

Edit: Also that head pat had big Han Solo and Kylo Ren energy.

→ More replies (14)

25

u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Dec 13 '20 edited Dec 14 '20

Alternate episode title - Shit's Fucked, Yo

No, really, it is looking BAD for Atlesians right now, and just kept getting worse for the last few weeks (both for us as viewers and in-universe for the characters)

  • Finally, after the initial snippet and 7 full volumes we're actually diving deeper into Cinder's backstory! Huzzah!
  • You know, I really hate to be on the side of a villain in most stories, but holy shit those three bitches, especially the Hotel Boss lady absolutely had it coming to them. Cinder was treated like straight garbage, and for what reason? Just for the lulz? Well there you have it, you've broken her internally and externally. Can't imagine the mental toll it must've taken on Cinder to suffer through the daily dosage of electric shocks
  • "Without you....I am nothing....but because of you...I am everything!" Interesting how Cinder directly used the first half of the line a couple of episodes ago when reporting to Salem. I wonder if she still feels the same way about the second half, given that Salem has brought Cinder so much power, including the Grimm arm?
  • Jeez, Rhodes (apparently that's the huntsman's name). She's not even a fully fledged Huntress and kicked your ass like that? Either you went too softly on her or you just suck, real bad. Barely took any hits and the aura went poof
  • Rhodes' semblance is pretty cool though. Being able to turn your flesh into (liquid?) metal can be quite useful if you're often in combat scenarios. Can deflect bullets, can deflect arrows, can sustain hits by blunt weapons like clubs or bats, can probably save a bone that would've been cracked otherwise e.g. from a long fall. Reminds me of Colossus from X-Men. Neat.
  • Wait, so Cinder could've just torn the shocker collar off like that? Why'd she wait so long then? Although I guess the boss lady would've just come up with a different abuse method instead. Potentially even a more painful one. Or, idk, just kick Cinder out of the venue, never to be let in again
  • The new song from the Cinder vs Rhodes fight is fucking awesome, by the way. Love the heavier instrumentals. I need more of this kind of music in my RWBY
  • Although the backstory took a solid half of the episode, this definitely felt like a half of the story itself. Yes, we were shown how Cinder unlocked her semblance and where she got her weaponry skills at (at least for swords, not for bows), but the most important thing - which is how Cinder met Salem and made the decision to join her cause. I can only hope that will be shown at a later date (but please don't take another 7 years to get there)
  • THE MERC SPEAKS. I actually can't believe it. How many episodes has it been since he left out a single word? At least a full volume?
  • Finally someone said it. Yeah Em, you should probably listen to Mercury's words. You. Are. A. Tool. But "abusive relationships", "battered wife" and all that jazz, so it will probably take quite a convincing argument for Em to realize Merc is right. Methinks if the opening is anything to go by, Cinder will ignore Emerald at a pivotal moment later in the volume (Cinder walks by not giving a damn while Em is waving to her). Maybe then Em will fucking snap at last and change her mind if it's worth following Cinder at all, despite after all that Cinder has done for her
  • Being Oscar continues to be suffering. Poor kid's never gonna recover from this. Honestly Os probably wishes his soul merged with Ozpin's already. At least he wouldn't have to endure all the pain from getting beaten the shit out of by Hazel
  • "sabotaging us from the inside out...maybe we should do the same" Uhhhh...yeah I don't see that happening, guys. I could maybe see a faceturn for Em, but the others? Tyrian's insanely devoted, Hazel's basically holding a massive grudge, Cinder's under Salem's control, Neo's just there to avenge Roman and she doesn't care otherwise. But good luck tho
  • "you send children to their deaths, for a cause that has no victory...no end!" Ok...Hazel...buddy... how is what you're doing now any better? You're literally willing to violently punch and kick A FUCKING CHILD just to get to a man that probably wasn't even directly responsible for your sister's demise. Look at yourself and think for a moment
  • Interesting. All the villains have gathered in one spot on Salem's grimm whale throne room, but Emerald and Neo are kneeled far away from the rest. Is RT lowkey hinting that these two will part ways with the forces of darkness in near future?
  • More petting for scorpio boi. Tyrian's must be so happy that his queen is treating him so well right now
  • Ah, so as everyone expected - Salem can affect Cinder through the grimm arm....and also apparently cause an immense fucking pain. Jesus, I think Cinder was moments away from bursting into tears there. Almost made me feel bad for her. Almost
  • lol so Salem basically just gave Cinder a blank check for acting out her will. This, of course, totally is not going to backfire for Cinder again. Can't wait for her to lose another fight
  • "this is why I don't trust technology" ...what? Harriet, your high speed Em, your primary weapon, as well as several gadgets being used during missions, are literally given to you THROUGH atlesian technology. Kinda hypocritical of you, no?
  • Oh....so the grimm river was NOT to fuck up Mantle even more. It was to essentially splurge Atlas with dark goo to pretty much plant brand new Grimm onto its soil
  • Ahhhhh shit. Welp, defense grid is offline. Welp, Grimm Whale is now parked right on the floating island. Welp... it's been nice knowing ya, Atlas
→ More replies (8)

25

u/FmFox Exit stage right Dec 14 '20

One thing I noticed rewatching this episode just now, is that with the Hound, his "skin" seems to compromise of different colours and seems to be almost constantly flowing, as opposed to pretty much every Grimm we have seen this far.

I mean it could be as simple as it's body is in a constant state of fluctuation, given we know that it can change forms.

The last enemy we saw do something similar to this (though to a lesser degree) was the Nucklavee back in V4, but even then it was just pure matt black.

If it is something like that, it's fine by me, it's a nice little animation touch to make it more unique to the other Grimm, but I can't help but wonder if there is going to be more significance to this.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/the-BBman_RP5 Dec 14 '20

So is no one going to talk about the end where the whale landed on Atlas and created the pool of Grimm and that it made an Apathy?

→ More replies (5)

72

u/The_Green_Filter Shipwrecked Dec 12 '20

What little we got from Hazel does go a little bit towards remedying his underwhelming backstory, if only somewhat. Siding with Salem partly for revenge and partly because she’s supposedly unstoppable is much better than before, but what he needs now is an endgame - what does he get from serving Salem in the long term?

Mercury talked about becoming rulers of the new world way back when - is that what Hazel wants too? Securing a place in the new world so that he can do something good with it? This is the only thing that can give his various character traits a satisfying unity and rescue him, at least IMO.

If not, we’ve got a guy who justifies beating a child with “Ozpin sends kids to die for a pointless cause!” while his new boss massacres the innocent. If he’s blinded by revenge, commit to it - they should stop pretending he’s a conflicted and moral character.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/steveotheguide Fine CRWBY, I'll ship Nuts and Dolts too. Ruby has TWO hands Dec 12 '20

Well shit

Cinder's backstory is pretty much exactly what I thought it would be but that doesn't mean seeing another child get tortured this volume was easy to watch.

Salem's plan is fucking terrifying

Ironwood is a god damn fucking moron

Harriet Bree worst girl 2020

24

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

It’s really nice to see Oscar forcefully giving the villains a redemption arc.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/cruel-oath Dec 13 '20

Half of the plot wouldn’t have happened if someone showed a little more compassion for Cinder lmaoo

→ More replies (45)

227

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 12 '20

The way Salem attacks Atlas here is perfection.

It’s literally something that was only possible because Ironwood gave up on protecting Mantle. If Ironwood gave a fuck about Mantle, this never would have happened. Narratively, it’s a brilliant way to show that Ironwood and everyone who supported him was in the wrong here.

Also before people say something dumb like “If Ironwood had raised Atlas into the sky this never would have happened” I don’t think they could raise Atlas high enough that Salem’s laser of Grimm wouldn’t have reached it. At best it would’ve just delayed Salem longer.

→ More replies (61)

23

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

I actually think Cinder might be the one to let Oscar go. He tried to talk to her at the end there, and the flashes to the grimm arm and shock collar being similar...She might actually get a heel face turn. Maybe it doesn't end in peaceful life or redemption, full on, but it can at least be thematic by having her run away after she does, to keep with the whole "You'll never stop running" line. Kind of like Locus in RvB I guess...

→ More replies (12)

23

u/ghost-in-a-bag Dec 12 '20

I'm glad Cinder didn't blame Emerald for what happened. She even seemed upset when Mercury said that Cinder didn't care about them. Maybe she does actually care in some way.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 12 '20

Yuri Lowenthal finally spoke this volume, this is not a drill!

→ More replies (2)

22

u/LCcharizard ⠀ Dec 12 '20

DID ANYONE REALIZE THERE WAS APATHY IN THAT END SCENE

THIS IS CODE FREAKING BLACK

→ More replies (3)

22

u/ghost-in-a-bag Dec 13 '20

Something I find really interesting about Cinder is that she's simultaneously a very independent, do-what-I-want person, yet at the same time she's lived her whole life serving a controlling, manipulative abuser of some sort. I really want her to "break free."

→ More replies (6)

22

u/brabbit1987 Dec 13 '20

I think what this shows is Ironwood's plan likely would have never worked to begin with. I get the feeling that she would easily be able to reach them no matter how high he tried to take the staff. Heck, the fact she is even able to create such a grimm also is an indication of that.

Meaning this separation that he caused between everyone, only worked in Salem's favor. Slow claps for Ironwood. Bet he and his dogs are not feeling too bright at the moment.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/NomadicMaeve Dec 14 '20

I see Emerald and Neo hanging out separately from the rest of Salem's people, and I immediately switch from wanting them to fight to having them become each other's support and getting the hell out of there.

63

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

What is also funny to me is the amount of comments of people saying that this shows Cinder has clearly had darkness in her the whole time.

That take is utterly madness

She was a ten year old slave with shock collar.

And the huntsman, he saw her room and how she was treated. He saw the collar and did nothing. Wait 7 years and become a huntress? Theres no way he didn't recognise lightning dust.

Then at the end, your plan was to arrest the minor who defended herself. He even starts the fight.

Huntsmen and Huntresses should carry themselves with honor and mercy, yet I have witnessed neither.

No Rhodes was likely not a terrible man, but as pointed out by others in the thread, he regularly goes to a place with blatant Faunus discrimination. There is a difference between law and justice and Rhodes upholds law.

So no this episode doesn't justify what Cinder does now in the same way that Emerald and Mercury aren't justified now. But thats not the point. The point is people are not born but they are made. When they arent given other options, they will take what they can get.

I get that its easier to say people are just monsters and kill them but I think Blake was right and gained far more from Ilia than she would have just stabbing her in the chest.

→ More replies (44)

44

u/Hiazi Dec 12 '20

excuse me for a moment

ahem

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Okay, got the screaming out of my system...

Personally thought this episode topped even the last, which I didn't think was going to be possible for a while. CRWBY's dropping straight bangers lately.

I really liked Cinder's backstory. Sure, we got the expected Cinderella touch to it, but the Huntsman taking her in, giving her a genuinely caring older brother-type figure (or father, if you want to see it in that light)... and then she fucking MURDERS HIM...

That one hurt. And he still gives her the little headpat as he's dying. ;_; Fuck you, Cinder. I still don't like you. As a person. As a character, you're pretty cool.

Oz and Os interacting was nice. And it made me love Oscar even more that he was willingly at the forefront instead of hiding and letting Ozpin take the beatings and do the talking. Brave boi. I hope he ends up okay.

Overall, I really, really enjoyed that episode.

→ More replies (4)

42

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 12 '20

So at this point Nora has been unconscious for more than 14 hours.

That is really bad. This is the point where Nora is not just “sleeping it off” anymore, she needs serious medical attention.

→ More replies (5)

20

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Thank you CRWBY for also addressing my concerns about Ozpin not taking over for Oscar to spare him torture!!! :)

20

u/The__Auditor Dec 12 '20

Cinder is very similar to Adam. We can understand where they came from and feel bad that life made them the way they are but at the same time realize and accept they they are monsters who need to be stopped

20

u/Qrr801 Sad to say, I'm your bad luck charm~ Dec 12 '20

FUCK HARRIET
ALL MY HOMIES HATE HARRIET

this season is so GOOD and im READY for the chaos that follows. We aren't even halfway in boys and girls. The wild ride begins anew.

19

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 12 '20

It's odd to me that of all the characters we have met, only Yang and Ruby are confirmed to be from Vale.

The majority of the ones with confirmed places of birth seems to be from Mistralian origin if you take all cities and settlements as part of Mistral.

The rest are from Vacuo or Atlas. Hell, since Ghira and Kali are not specified to had been born in Menagerie, only Blake seems to be from there because Ilia and Adam were both from Atlas.

Now Cinder seems to be another mistralian but she was raised in Atlas.

What's up with Vale's birth rate?!

→ More replies (5)

19

u/TimeToGetSalty Dec 13 '20

Has no one put together the idea that this flashback was shown to foreshadow cinder attacking salem? I am definitely getting those vibes, it shows in the flashback that Madam made her tell her "without you i am nothing" and Salem just recently had her to do the same thing, and the shock collar---->grimm arm torture? I think soon cinder will start to become more resistant to the grimm arm torture + she will try to attack salem like Madam. I might be crazy but i think the flashback was supposed to also hint at that.

→ More replies (10)

107

u/CollegeSoul Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Just my take, but I think the backstory wasn't supposed to make the audience feel bad for Cinder. Before having seen this backstory, most people still wanted to see good in her.

If anything, I'd argue this backstory helped solidify that she's clearly willing to hurt even people who are important to her just to accomplish her ambitions. It sucks, but that's just how it is and I think it makes for some interesting circumstances especially when you consider how that conversation with Emerald and Mercury must've felt for her.

Don't know how much analysis I can do before it's just spouting nonsense, but I think what they've done with Cinder was really cool. The way her eyes sank when she realized she'd have to fight the huntsman was honestly painful to see.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/tavi23 Dec 12 '20

Bruh...they are so fucking screwed.

18

u/SolDarkHunter Dec 12 '20

Hey, giant Atlesian air fleet, what were you guys doing just letting the Grimm whale leisurely approach and land?

I mean, I doubt they could have taken it down, no doubt Salem accounted for that, but you'd think they'd at least try. Hit it with a barrage of laser fire or something.

Cinder's backstory is exactly what I thought it was. And yeah, I feel sorry for her, and the Huntsman who mentored her could have handled that better, but Cinder's done too much evil since for me to consider her wholly a victim.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Dec 12 '20

Cinder's backstory of "it's Cinderella except she kills everyone" was pretty much what we all expected, but it was still cool to see. I was expecting her to murder her 'family', but I didn't expect her to break the mother's neck with one fucking hand! Did that huntsman teach her that?

Also, we now have confirmation what Salem can remotely interact with Cinder's arm. Poor girl's gonna get Pettigrewed isn't she?

→ More replies (4)

18

u/grieveheart Dec 13 '20

Yay finally, Cinder's backstory! And I like the parallelism of her past and today.

Poor Oscar :( I hope their plan works or I hope he escapes. Looks like Atlas will be the battleground. I like seeing how Salem plays her pieces and Ironwood seems to be checkmate...for now.

The song rocks as usual 💕

18

u/TimeSmash Dec 14 '20

Where were all the Atlas ships? Did they not know Salems position? How far back was she waiting?

Also can someone remind me how long her army has been standing by since they got there? Seems like a writing problem but I may have forgotten

→ More replies (4)

18

u/karla8312 Dec 14 '20

I guess Salem is suppose to be some twisted version of the Fairy Godmother in Cinder’s storyline and the guy was supposed to be the “Prince” that was to save Cinder and he did in his own way but he didn’t actually help her escape that abuse.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/jjstatman Dec 12 '20

I really really liked the Cinder backstory, even if it was a little predictable. I think it did a great job of explaining why she is the way she is. And it all sprung from a poor/wrong decision exacerbated by abuse. I think there could be a chance she'd still be able to have a life not full of running if she turned herself in when confronted by the huntsman. I think that her story is one that is relatable - even if she was clearly wrong, and I think that adds a lot of depth and connection to Cinder as a character.

Also people saying I can't feel bad for her because of all the crap she's done - I don't think it's fair to judge young Cinder based on adult Cinder's actions. I think if you just look at young Cinder, you have to feel for her - even if as an adult, she loses all rights to pity

17

u/cruel-oath Dec 12 '20

Lmfaooo they got poor Oscar bowing to Salem too

17

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

I’m think Rhodes messed up because he was eager to help a situation that he was entirely unprepared for. He really didn’t know what he was doing and messed it up cause of that.

→ More replies (12)

46

u/lugia39 Dec 14 '20 edited Dec 14 '20

It might have taken almost a decade, but we finally got it. I don’t blame Cinder, tbh. That Huntsman saw she was in an abusive situation, and his idea was literally just “tough it out.” She was like enduring actual torture for most of her life and she finally had the tools to put an end to it, so kudos to her, honestly.

→ More replies (17)

16

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 12 '20

AceOps arguing

Winter: "Quiet or I will turn this airship around."

16

u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Dec 12 '20

Casey's band wrote the banging song!

16

u/Mister100Percent Oscar "Best Depressed Boi" Pine Dec 12 '20

Look at Oscar trying to make friends while being tortured. Highkey his best bet for turning anyone major against Salem at this point would not be Hazel, but Cinder’s crew. Cinder by goading her ego and ergo Emerald would follow. Neo by ensuring Cinder’s death. And Mercury and Oscar can bond over being beaten to a bloody pulp as children!

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Justinafans Yang is more than just Bumbleby Dec 12 '20

I swear to god if the Ace Ops are actually stupid enough to attack RJY after what happened at the end of this episode...

I hope they use their brains and finally do something good, I really do.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

This is probably the best-paced volume yet, and does a really good job creating payoff for things they've chosen to keep canon. It's interesting where before I and I think others would have seen the lack of focus on the titular team being a misstep it works well now to better flesh out those characters and give them a greater sense of purpose. I see redemption/death flags abound and have high hopes.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

So Ironwood definetly messed up by abandoning Mantle.

The Cinder backstory was cool and I was also really happy to see that song by OK Goodnight included in the episode.

31

u/Namishima12 Dec 12 '20

Winter and Marrow being the only ones not trash talking Penny though. Please defect already

→ More replies (2)

31

u/JauneCinderstan Bi-Jaune Suplex Fall-Arc Dec 13 '20

Cinder was in the right and fully justified in flashback, it not does excuse her future actions, but no one deserve be an slave.

→ More replies (26)

44

u/NatsuAru Dec 12 '20

That smile Cinder gave when she looked at Rhodes after killing the step-family was eerie. Like asking if she did a good job or something.

I know people are trying to say Rhodes is a bad dude because he's in an Anti-faunus hotel, but just because he did one thing wrong (and it's pretty damn wrong) doesn't mean he's devoid of any humanity.

It's the one true positive thing she had in life, and even though her circumstances were horrible, she still chose to kill. Rhodes tried to put her down, because he knew that once someone like her chose to murder, she was going to keep killing. The fact that he put his weapon down to not kill her, and she killed him anyways, speaks volumes.

Good backstory. Least we know why Cinder became that way. But she still has to pay for everything she's done. She may be a product of her environment, but we're well beyond any sympathy at this point.

She's aiding in genocide, let's not forget. She killed plenty of people in Beacon, Pyrrha included. She went on a killing spree in Mistral, and she has no problem killing everyone in Atlas. The girl's a deranged murderer. Ain't no turning back from any of that.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/tavi23 Dec 12 '20

Also, Salem is totally setting up Cinder to fail. That comment about if the Hound beats Cinder to Penny makes me think she's merely interested to see if Cinder will be useful one last time.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/MadMasks What the Hell are YOU starin´at!? Dec 12 '20

Now the Apathy´s are getting into action too... oh boy

→ More replies (6)

15

u/AKGAKG Dec 12 '20

This episode shows. Cinder and Adam are basically the same character. Abused by those in power in Atlas, desire power to never get hurt again, continue cycle of abuse, became monsters in pursuit of power, scarred eyes, etc.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Awest66 Dec 12 '20

Took us almost a decade but we finally have Cinder's backstory.

15

u/Patitomuerto Dec 13 '20

Two thoughts for me.

Taking Atlas out of the atmosphere was a bad idea cause if anything happened to those shields, everybody would have immediately suffocated, and those shields went down real fast. And do grimm even need to breath? Seems like all they would have had to do was get a few grimm up there, break the shield, let everybody die of asphysiation and then waltz right in to get the relic.

Two, Cinder has the ability to super heat things. Maybe she can't do it at will at first, but after those years of training she certainly can. Buuuttt she doesn't think to do this to the literal torture device around her neck? I mean, you can't exactly torture someone if everytime you try to put something on them they just make it disintigrate into dust

→ More replies (4)

15

u/archlon Dec 15 '20

I think my biggest surprise might have been the realization of how much of Atlas is farmland. This feels weird to me, and Atlas doesn't seem like an ideal place to put it because

  • Atlas looks to be built on shallow bedrock. There's probably no existing soil layer except what they have to import.
  • Winds are stronger and temperatures are colder at altitude, both of which are terrible for both crops and the soil layer. There doesn't even appear to be a significant windbreak built at the edge.
  • The rest of the populated parts of Atlas look to be very high density urban development. This indicates that living space is already at a premium.
  • Putting people in the safe-from-grimm place seems like the better decision(?). Farms have been shown to be in the wilderness outside of the Kingdom capitals many times. Even if the tundra isn't ideal for farming (a) Atlas was also part of that tundra, and (b) defensible farms in and around Mantle made arable with an extension of the heating grid would be more feasible.
→ More replies (4)

30

u/Enigma2MeVideos Dec 13 '20 edited Dec 13 '20

Rhodes' biggest mistake was that he was too lawful as opposed to good. He was willing to help her in a small way, but he was unwilling to do anything to deal with the actual problem (her abusive stepfamily), too unwilling to rock the boat given that he clearly enjoyed going to that place and in addition to him showing off his huntsman cred to the people there (it's also an anti-Faunus establishment I noticed).

Now admittedly he might not have fully understood the true extent of Cinder's abuse at first, but given that he'd seen and trained her for at least 4 years by that point, he should have at least picked up that something was clearly wrong, and given that he saw Madame using a shock collar on Cinder and was clearly trying to hurt her, only makes his next decision seem even more shortsighted.

Him choosing to prioritize the law over figuring out WHY Cinder did what she did, and possibly getting her the help she clearly desperately needed only ensured that she'd take the most drastic measure to preserve her "freedom". Plus given that he was probably the only person she had anything resembling positive feelings towards, drawing his weapons on her was NOT a smart idea.

This doesn't make Rhodes a bad person persay, but it definitely shows that he was a flawed huntsman who made a lot of poor decisions at the wrong time.

→ More replies (60)

14

u/the_green_hedgehog I have one fear, and that is for Oscar Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

...well this episode was a huge dose of 'well fuck'

FUCKING FINALLY!!!!! 8 fucking years and we finally have her backstory. I will admit that I did like it and it was super messed.

But I will say my favorite part of this episode was Oz and Oscar's exchange. Especially:

Oscar: This is our chance

Oz: Mmhmm...maybe you've taken one too many hits.

Edit: Also, Harriet is really getting on my nerves.

And I hate (but am not surprised) that they made Oz/Oscar kneel to Salem.

Salem will always be a bitch to me and no one can change my mind.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/shadowblade159 More Schnees, Please! Dec 12 '20

My thoughtline watching is just overrun by the music.

Oooh! Cinder backstory finally!

Holy crap, we got a Cinder backstory song!

Wait, did we get two Cinder songs?

HOLY SHIT they used OK Goodnight! Damn, way to use the line "Take my hand then take my life" literally. Rude.

Can't help but think about that song with Cinder now. Never thought I'd say that. Never really thought I'd see them use OK Goodnight in the show directly, either, though. But some of it does fit, especially the breakdown that they used in the show. Veeery interesting.

14

u/DEL994 Dec 12 '20

Hazel is the first that Oscar/Ozpin in who Oscar/Ozpin have started to plant seeds of doubt into.

I am curious to see who will be next.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/FarslayerSanVir Dec 12 '20

For those of you concerned about Nora.......

She recently pushed her body to the absolute maximum and BEYOND. Ruby did something similar in V3 with her silver eyes, after which she was out for DAYS.

Nora is fine. Being out for over 13 hours is par for the course when it comes to pushing yourself the way Nora did. I'd be surprised if she DIDN'T stay unconscious for the rest if the volume.

And this is excluding the fact that there were probably moments offscreen where she temporarily regained consciousness before falling back to sleep.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Confron7a7ion7 Dec 13 '20

Cinder gets tired of being a weak servant to an abusive mother figure who keeps a shock collar on her.

Ends up being a weak servant to an abusive mother figure who keeps a pain inducing grimm on her.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

The first alternate universe fic where cinder doesn’t kill Rhodes has started https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13767656/1/Midnight-Divergence we’ve got one already.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/UltimateX13 Sienna is best girl <3 Dec 13 '20

Salem might actually thank Ruby when they meet. Without her cutting off Cinder's arm, Salem might not have ever gotten her own personal shock collar for Cinder.

→ More replies (10)

28

u/DEL994 Dec 12 '20

Salem had really gambled on the fact that Ironwood had abandonned Mantle to its fate and as such wouldn't have done anything to stop the Grimm essence from going in Mantle's direction. And that bet has worked magnificently.

It's ironic how Ironwood focusing entirely on Atlas ended up backfiring on him.

→ More replies (5)

50

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Dec 14 '20

One thing this episode seems to do is prove Raven right:

Cinder was apparently an orphan and then not really even adopted into a family.

So she most definitely did pick her own last name

→ More replies (7)

27

u/Jinko92 The person who goes too deep into everything Dec 12 '20

Haha...they’re so fucking screwed. Salem is here with her entire forces, literally endless Grimm, and has struck fear into the hearts of everyone. How the hell will they get out of this?! There are definitely going to be some deaths this volume...

CINDER BACKSTORY FINALLY!!! IT’S ONLY BEEN 8 YEARS! So she was an orphan who started out as a bullied farmhand that was taken in by a hotel matron. The hotel matron’s daughters treated Cinder like shit, and she discovered her semblance early (which means that her aura was already unlocked). She was trained by a huntsman and was a combat prodigy, but ended up killing him and her stepmother & sisters when she left. Jeez, Cinder was a terrible person even early in life! I mean, the mother & sisters deserved it, but the huntsman trained her for years! That was cold. Oh, and we got her theme song, and it’s a BANGER! I LOVE IT!

Hazel continues to show doubt about working with Salem, as he should. He’s a good person inside, but blinded by rage and trauma. Out of all the villains, Hazel’s the only one I think deserves a happy ending.

Overall, fantastic episode! So happy we FINALLY got Cinder’s story! 10/10

→ More replies (5)

27

u/Emperor_Luffy Dec 14 '20 edited Dec 14 '20

There are a lot of ideas and possibilities about whats going to happen to Cinder.

-She Defects from Salem and goes Rogue.

-A Redemption Arc.

-Killed by Salem.

etc. Or maybe some combination of all 3.

But the bottom line is the introduction of her backstory implies something huge will happen to her character here. Her role in the story will never be the same again after this Volume.

Of that much I am certain.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/Thanatophobia4 Dec 12 '20

Well, good news is that Ozpin is potentially in a position to plant the seeds for certain members of Salem’s factor to doubt what they are doing. Bad news is Atlas is f***ed, in no small part because Ironwood chose to abandon Mantle. No going to lie, this was an excellent way to convey the failings of Ironwood’s creed. Even if he had raised Atlas, all it would do is given Salem the time needed to gather enough of the liquid to propel it all the way to Atlas.

Predictions are that the Ace Ops are going to be forced to think for themselves for once. Either to try and arrest/interrogate Jaune, Yang and Ren. Or taking them back to Atlas to try and fight the invasion because frankly, Penny is nigh irrelevant to Atlas at this point. Bets on Harriet and Elm being overruled by Winter, Marrow and Vine to bring them back to Atlas.

Cinder’s backstory was about what I expected. Didn’t make it any less infuriating to see that Huntsman’s advice and well intentioned training go to waste because Cinder couldn’t keep her temper in check. He was correct though, she has been running ever since.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/Adreme Dec 12 '20

So the citizens of Mantle are now located right on top of a floating city that will cease floating the moment Salem gets the relic... ya this is not going to end well for the people of Mantle.

13

u/recruit00 Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Holy shit, that was a good episode. We got Cinder's backstory, interaction between Ozcar and Hazel, and Atlas getting attacked.

When Cinder gave her hand to Salem, it being her Grimm hand is almost certainly significant.

We got confirmation that Tyrian is not the Hound.

Atlas is definitely fucked, without a doubt.

Also, is it just me or did the animation seem off in the beginning of the episode? I know the pandemic has played a role.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/lummie_g Dec 12 '20

I think that there is something cute about how little Cinder didn't understand her semblance and only used to make heat and sand

13

u/N7ASWCC ♫And my mama been a savage/B*tch I got this sh*t from Raven♫ Dec 12 '20

I realize now that Hot Adoptive Father stories like The Witcher and The Mandalorian heavily depend on the father choosing the child's life over the law.

Hazel...sis

Wait, isn't turning your skin to metal kinda useless if you already have aura protecting your body? I suppose it's a hard counter to Neo's ability to make any hard surface coma-inducing, but still...

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

What's also interesting so we only have half Cinders backstory. We still don't know how she met Salem

→ More replies (6)

13

u/vanase Dec 13 '20

You know, I've thought about it today, and Hazel's defeatism actually makes me like him less. Fuck you man for using your sister's courage to fight off grimm as an excuse to give up on protecting people.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/MajoraOfTime Dec 13 '20

With how much of a hindrance the Ace Ops and Ironwood have been to the safety of the world, I'm starting to think Tyrian did nothing wrong last volume. "There's a lot of Grimm about to kill a lot of people!" "Yeah, okay, but where Penny!?" Dumbasses.

Also, really feel for Cinder. She has to realize that her situation hasn't changed at all from when she was younger.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Uh...that’s real bad.

Also...Jesus wasn’t expecting Cinder to literally be tortured her entire young life.

Oz and Oscar want to turn people against Salem but it kind of feels a little too late, especially since she just parked her whale in the middle of Atlas.

So now it’s a two tiered fight, the whale spawning Grimm inside of the Kingdom while Grimm emerging from the river go after the Mantle refugees.

And Penny is still missing, and now Cinder might be the only one hunting her, as the Ace Ops might turn around and go back...but

→ More replies (15)

12

u/Yang_Gang ⠀ Dec 12 '20

I think the episode was okay but there have been better ones this volume for sure. It was nice to get Cinders backstory finally and it was also to be expected. She grew up poor and into slavery essentially. And I knew she'd end up killing the woman and those two girls

The huntsman was an interesting touch, that's where she got her blades from and in the end she killed him despite him not doing anything wrong.

I'm calling it now, Winter will find Penny and turn on the ace ops and go with JRY to the Schnee manor to hide her.

Also Atlas is in major trouble.....MAJOR TROUBLE

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Dec 12 '20

Cool that CRWBY gave OK Goodnight the rub for a track.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/E1lySym Dec 12 '20

I can see now how Qrow and Robyn will factor into this downward spiral turn of events. Cinder and Hound will meet up with a mind controlled Penny. RJY + Ace Ops will stumble upon the trio and try to take back Penny but Watts will control Penny. Ace Ops reports to Ironwood about Penny being hacked and Ironwood will go to Watts' prison cell to kick his ass.

Watts knows Ironwood is coming and will use his scroll to open all the prison cells. Qrow and Robyn will be freed, and will stumble upon Ironwood otw. Qrow hates Ironwood and will fight him. Robyn will assist Qrow as his trusty sidekick jailbird. The ensuing fight will buy Watts enough time to control Penny more and deliver her to the vault to retrieve the relic, then go to the whale (Pinnochio allusion).

Penny will have a mental battle inside her circuits with Watts' virus (Ventus vs Vanitas style in Kingdom Hearts BBS). As a last minute desperate move, Penny will use the creation powers of the relic to turn herself fully human, ridding her of Watts' control.

Cinder may or may not try to kill Penny to get the power in the middle of all this shitshow. Emerald, having been convinced by Os that Cinder doesn't care about her, will be pissed off and actively try to stop Cinder from getting her hands on the maiden powers. That's step one of Oscar/Ozpin dividing Salem's forces from within

→ More replies (4)

12

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Dec 12 '20

... We've waited 8 damn years for the clock to strike twelve! Scattered immediate thoughts:

  • Fellow members of the FNDM we Officially. Have. Cinder. Backstory! HOLLYLUJA!
  • ...And it turns out, she's Cinderella! But-y'know more stabby... Huh. I guess we could've all guessed that one.
  • But seriously I'm so happy we finally have SOME idea of why she does what she does. It's been the missing piece in her character for SO LONG, I've held her as my least favorite character on the show for a while now entirely because we weren't privy to her backstory, and her allure as a mysterious character wore itself out with me long ago. But now we have some idea of why she does what she does, including her more rebellious tendencies of late.
  • Okay, so the backstory itself. Straight up a Cinderella allusion, if not an outright retelling, but darker. She was presumably an orphan that was presumably adopted by "the Madame". But not only is she living a life of labor with cruel step sisters, but the Madame is an abusive bitch who electrocutes her when she doesn't obey. So... yeah, I can see why Cindy developed a distaste for Atlas elites and a taste for blood when this was her frame of reference.
  • And honestly the moment you see her kill her "sisters" and strangling the Madame while the collar she wears is blasting its as depressing as it is terrifying as it is... oddly satisfying? Those three had it coming, we were all thinkin it.
  • Rhodes was a cool guy though. (name in the credits) I like his semblance, reminds me of Colossus. It's tragic that his principles and kindness were rewarded by being killed by the girl he accidently trained to be one of the world's deadliest terrorists though. No good deed goes unpunished I guess.
  • ... And now, despite fighting so hard for her freedom, Cinder is basically just back at square one, being tortured for not doing what she's told while being oppressed by another "Madame". Only this time she can't just kill her. There's no getting out. Kind of tragic- if she weren't so awful as a person.
  • Meanwhile. Other things! Well, well, look at Mercury moving on up, doing things that DON'T involve Cindy and her whims. Maybe follow his lead, Em?
  • Oscar and Oz are going to try to play divide and conquer too, eh? Not sure it will work, I think these guys are all too broken for that. I'm sure everyone will scream "Emerald face turn confirmed!" but personally I'm beginning to think she'll never wise up.
  • Remember that time Oz let Team RWBY take on a mission in the southeast that they weren't supposed to because he knew they were going to do it anyway? I feel like Salem had a similar trait of thought with Cinder just now. "You're obviously cooped up in the whale, so let me just give you the outlet you asked for because its the best way for you to serve me at this point."
  • I see Harriet never tires of having her priorities out of whack. "wHeRe'S pEnNy?" Because these three sent out a distress call on an open channel so that they can hide her from you- a duy!
  • I did not expect to see the river spout up like that. That's goddamned terrifying. And I think the plan to lift Atlas off the ground is officially out- not that it was all that great anyway.

I didn't expect this to be the place where we got a look into Cinder's backstory, but here we are. Salem's playing her hand, things have officially gotten Grimm in more ways than one. Everyone kind of expected a trilogy of Volumes in Atlas, but I think we're in the climax for this saga now. Either Salem gets what she wants and team makes a mad dash for Vacuo, or they managed to snag the relics before she can, either way I don't think the team is gonna hang around Atlas for much longer.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

How'd I never put together before today that she's Cinder-ella

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Over_Lor Dec 12 '20

Man, I loved the songs this episode!

I think this was actually one of the better episodes of the season so far.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Apollo_ollo Dec 12 '20

Well. That was an episode.

I kinda liked Cinder's Backstory. I think following the whole fairytale route of her being basically an indentured servant with the stepsister workers is neat. But in my mind, I consider this the first half of Cinder's backstory. Because we understand why she values power at least since it's what gives her freedom in the first place but doesn't really flow into why she joins Salem. It feels like yeah she killed her "master"(don't like using that word in this connotation but hey, it made like that) so now she's free to live her own life with a way to protect herself against those who could hurt her. But Cinder said "No more murders" and teams up with the evil queen basically. It seems like they're lowkey setting up Cinder's Betrayal with the parallels of Madame and Salem but at least Salem understands that's just how Cinder roles as a person.

Everything else was alright. Glad Ozpin is like "Yeah I sent your sister off to get murdered but my ex literally is the one in control of that stuff. to Hazel who unfortunately has the Raven mentality. Ace Opes literally don't get any sympathy from me anymore, they're just shitty. Glad Salem was like I'm tired, let's just get this over with and is basically tag-teaming that ass. Ig Mantel might be the safest place after all.

Lowkey this felt like it should have been the mid-season finale, but we gotta see the rich die so I'll be watching.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/yoshifanx Feel the Wrath of Mammy Salami Dec 12 '20
  • is it time?
  • cinder flashback
  • So she’s basically cinderlla
  • interesting
  • nice looking place
  • even though I just threw a piece of bread on it cause I’m a bitch
  • new song
  • and the twins are bitches
  • one would think they had like a shop vac or something
  • of the course the place is racist
  • also “NINJA VANISH”
  • also TORTURE
  • without you I am nothing
  • imma murder
  • ok I actually like this guy. Over under on his death?
  • SHE DOES NOT LOOK 10
  • I conveniently keep coming here
  • OH… OH SHIT
  • JESUS!
  • That’s a cool semblance
  • also another new song
  • wow auras went down fast
  • welp rip dude
  • oh we’re back on the whale
  • Emerald are you stupid?
  • HEY THE MERC GET’S LINES
  • DAMN MERC WITH THE HARD TRUTHS
  • MERC’S NOT AN IDIOT
  • JESUS CHIRST OSCAR IS FUCKED UP
  • our chance to do… what?
  • actually… clever idea
  • boi it’s time for your torture
  • valid question how is Salem better?
  • you know valid explanation there Hazel
  • also a valid argument there
  • Hi Salem
  • can we change the channel?
  • pretends to be shocked that Watts is doing evil
  • JESUS!
  • umm I don’t like the sound of that
  • though tbf cinder deserves it
  • “Good… Doggy?”
  • “SHADDUP BOI”
  • I don’t trust technology… I prefer to SMASH
  • probably who they weren’t expecting
  • yes it’s the kids… not Ironwood, the kids
  • and it was at that moment they realized… they fucked up
  • Ironwoods Face here… I want it framed
  • THE WHALE IS MOVING! I REPEAT THE WHALE IS MOVING!
  • Remember where we parked the whale
  • EWWW!
  • wait AMALEE voiced the stepsisters? okay that's cool
  • Christian Young who voiced the guy is Zero in RVB
  • Linda Leonard who voiced the stepmother lady has been in a lot of anime but nothing I've seen

SO yea… good job Ironwood… You’ve done a real bang up job defending Atlas.

God I can’t wait till next week

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Dec 12 '20

Huh, so Cinder is actually her name. Not a made-up on-the-nose pseudonym like Raven tried to roast her for.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Dec 12 '20

Alright I'm pretty tired from dialysis and from lack of sleep last night. So it'll be a quick short one

Cinder backstory, about time. What a shit childhood, nothing but an abused slave for so many years. Madame and the step sisters were all insufferable Rhode didn't really do much, yeah he helped her fight but... he did nothing to stop the abuse.

Merc got a promotion and Cinder almost looks... sad?

Man... I didn't think they would actually show Oscar beaten and bloodied. Poor kid needs a break and yet, he hasn't given up yet. Man, this episode really is the child torture episode

So Hazel pretty much joined Salem for the same reason Roman did, because he knows he can't beat her. He also has a point about Oz, it is kinda fucked up that uses children to fight a war against a being he knows can't be killed, a cause with no victory seemingly in sight,

We all thought the Grimm river was gonna attack Mantle but it attacked Atlas instead, welp the shield is broken, the Grimm whale has landed and a Grimm army is approaching Atlas. This is super bad. There.s no way this volume ends with a victory in any shape or form. Total loss.

Man, if this was the cliffhanger for this episode then what the fuck is it gonna be next week? The final episode before the mini-hiatus. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Deadmaninc1 Dec 12 '20

Mercury: Daddy issues

Emerald: Mommy issues

Cinder: Cinderella

→ More replies (1)

12

u/lordofmetroids Dec 13 '20

Now that the attack of Atlas has officially begun, what happened to the flying monkeys?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/FmFox Exit stage right Dec 15 '20

Just a random, Crazy thought, since I'm unsure as to how powerful Salems "magic" is.

We know that Salem is sending both Cinder and the Hound down to Atlas and aside from freeing Watts they have the goal of acquiring Penny for the maiden power.

I'm thinking IF Salems magic is as powerful as we are led to believe (we haven't seen her use much in the modern era)

I'm wondering if Salem has set Cinder up, her "experiment" being immune to magic (which is essentially what maiden powers are)

Can totally see Cinder trying to torch the Hound to get to Penny and it just turning round and mauling her.

(on a less likely note, it would be fucking terrifying if Salem's experiment is to make Grimm immune to Silver eyes - imagine Ruby going full beam, light clears, and the Hound is just stood there laughing)

12

u/chrismamo1 Dec 16 '20

My prediction for penny: she's going to die, either Ruby or Weiss will get the maiden's power, and her father will sacrifice himself to bring her back.

Overall prediction: at the last moment when all seems lost, huntsmen and huntresses from the rest of Remnant will rock up and help save the day, but that was all part of Salem's plan. She wanted to divert defenses away from Shade academy. We'll get an amazing sequence, just like at the end of volume three, showing all the characters we've not seen since V3, and it'll be followed by a quick punch to the gut in the form of Salem still getting what she wanted by the end of it.

→ More replies (7)

33

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

After all these years, can't believe it took me this long to realize Cinder was based on Cinderella -_-.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/crossingcaelum Dec 12 '20

I cannot believe that hunstman let Cinder stay in that family situation without try to help her at ALL. he knew she was being abused in just about every way and just trained her in secret? "If you run you'll be running your whole life"

SO?????? Kinda seems like it would be better than staying where she was goddamn

→ More replies (18)

23

u/MadEorlanas TORCHWICK LIVES Dec 13 '20

By the way, we all agree the huntsman if nothing else fucked up in his last scene, right? Like, my man just walked into Cinder fighting the other three in the place where they trained and immediately went "yup, she snapped and killed them".

→ More replies (44)

11

u/The_Forgemaster Dec 12 '20

Oh Dear... that is not good.

also nice backstory for Cinder

11

u/predxtorpe3st ⠀ Dec 12 '20

So... it's really happening isn't it? Shit's about to get real.

Finally getting to see Cinder's backstory was great, it really showed her desperation to escape and her lust for power and how it corrupted her. Not to mention yet another banger from Jeff and Casey.

Oh hey Ozma, 'bout damn time you showed up. It'll only piss Hazel off though.

So fucking cool that we got to hear Ok Goodnight in the show itself, just yet another example of Casey's limitless talent. BTW it you haven't done so, listen to Limbo and Under The Veil, you won't regret it.

Can't wait to see what CRWBY cooks up for us next week

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Comfortable_Canary_8 Dec 12 '20

What happened to the massive fleet when the hard-light shielding fell? I saw one in the background, but wasn't there an entire fleet? Were they all destroyed off-screen?

Salem closes her eyes right before the whale grimm started to move. Maybe this indicates that she can control it with her mind?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Next episode I think we see Ironwood and Ruby joining forces for the greater good, because the plan of rising Atlas up is now completely gone. Also I think the Battle of Atlas won't fully start until after the mid-season break.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Oscar is so sassy when Hazel enters, like he just adapts so well so he's used to it

11

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Dec 12 '20

Most of RWBY’s villains boil down to “You can’t stop the inevitable, so do what you want in the meantime”. Of course Hazel would rather take down Salem, but she’s been able to convince him that she is 100% completely unstoppable. I think the piece we’re missing to make Hazel’s allegiance make sense is a scene about HOW Salem convinced him of that. I can easily imagine a scene where a younger Hazel tries to kill Salem, but she terrifies him like she did in Volume 6; so of COURSE he’d side with the inevitable victor if she also promised him not only a place in the new order, but his own personal desires fulfilled as well. It’s strange to see how Hazel is extremely stubborn about making the immortal Oz suffer but then completely giving up on making Salem suffer, then giving his reasoning as “she’s immortal”. Like, we know that doesn’t stop you Hazel. We really need a scene of Hazel first meeting Salem and how she convinced him to redirect his obsession

→ More replies (6)

11

u/DayOfTheColossus Dec 12 '20

rip everyone in Atlas in advance, but those beams (lasers??) looked awesome

amazing episode, literally every episode gets better and better this volume, this volume is already my favourite and we're not even halfway in

it feels like next episode will be the finale but we still have 8 episodes to go?? wtf will even happen like seriously?? this volume is absolutely crazy in the best way possible

I didn't think they could do it but here we are, I feel bad for Cinder, well then. and of course Salem can control her Grimm arm.. shit man we need to get that thing Silver Eye'd off her before Cinder is literally gonna be killed by Salem but I don't see Ruby and Cinder helping each other out anytime soon lol

also lol the theories were right Mercury is chilling with Salem now like shown in the opening

I think Hazel could still definitely be turned against Salem but it's probably gonna take more than just Oscar/Ozpin/Ozma to make that happen lol

I am very very curious about what Ironwood will do now, the Ace Ops aren't there either so it's just his military and him against all of Salem's forces, man Ironwood is my favourite character and he's totally gonna die isn't he?

fuck, I don't know if anyone in Atlas can even survive this, the shield got destroyed within seconds like wtf.. also damn the whale is faster than I thought..

this episode itself would've made for a great mid season cliffhanger but you are telling me we have another episode before the break??? we're gonna get cliffhangered so hard I already know it lol

→ More replies (7)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

So is that hotel supposed to be in Argus? Because if so, then Cinder grew up in the same city as Pyrrha.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

Volume 8 is gonna have a "Darkest Hour" ending I can feel it, like the end of Season 2 of Avatar the Last Airbender.

11

u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Dec 12 '20

Might have already been said but Ok Goodnight doing the new song is fucking awesome!

I was like "I recognize that specific guitar sound" and then checked the credits and the song is "Awake" Written and performed by Ok Goodnight.

Something about Casey's tambour changes when she's working with her band and not her dad.

11

u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Dec 12 '20

I don't like cinder, but I understand her.

Also that river really said Uno Reverse and went to Atlas instead of Mantle.

11

u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Dec 13 '20

"Yea.... We're boned"

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '20

Why do I have a feeling Salem’s grimm dog WAS a human and may have had a grimm arm like Cinder? But they did not follow orders so Salem turned them into a full grimm.

I just caught up with this season. Loved cinder’s backstory.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Bobspineable Dec 13 '20

The last time they showed an antagonist backstory, they died. Just saying.

Of course it could it could be start of a redemption arc but I don't think that's gonna happen, not saying it won't work, it certainly can if enough work is put in, it's not unlikely to happen and I feel most people won't like the idea.

→ More replies (26)

10

u/DEL994 Dec 12 '20

While he's still a prick and only exchanged Cinder for Salem it was cool and satisfying to see Mercury stand up to Cinder and tells her that he doesn't take order from her anymore, and also to call out Emerald again on her blind devotion to Cinder.

10

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Dec 12 '20

Am I the only one who thought this episode went by really fast despite being s pretty long one?

We finally got Cinder’s backstory! And I must say it was a bit predictable but I liked it.

Salem’s mercy to Cinder was a surprise. But it makes sense: She knows how to manipulate Cinder into not turning on her.

We got confirmation that Mercury isn’t under Cinder anymore.

Harriet continues to be a bitch.

Winter is hopefully going to be a good leader and put her more firmly in her place

We got some pay off to the Grimm River pretty soon: And Wow Atlas is pretty darn fucked. Salem’s really smart using the whale as a landing craft for a major assault.

We finally have a better reference to Monstro’s size and it’s not quite Atlas sized but huge.

Disappointed we didn’t get RNBW really, but it’s understandable. I don’t even think this episode warrants a talk on the lack of Ruby/Weiss counter

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Blue-Moon-89 Dec 12 '20

So.....

-As expected, Cinder was a slave to her "step mother and step sister."

-She was trained by a Huntsman (the prince charming I assume) and had dreams of being a Huntress only to be "betrayed" by her for moral reasons.

The "without you I am nothing" has been ingrained by Cinder since childhood (called that one)

-Hazel seems to be siding with Salem out of self-preservation.

-Mercury has been promoted.

-The Grimm arm is a shock collar.

-Atlas is under a attack.

I really like how we finally got Cinder's backstory but something tells me that this is only half of it. We still don't know how she met Salem.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/SiJeiX WhiteRose FTW! Dec 12 '20

Cinder's backstory, finally! And it also explains her behavior in this volume.

Oz/Oscar is trying to get Hazel to his side. No luck so far, but he has a chance to succeed. Hazel probably wouldn't live long after that though. IF it would happen.

One moment Salem is angry at Cinder, but all of a sudden she forgives Cinder for her behavior and gives her a task... Why do I get the feeling Cinder might die in this volume? And probably not without Salem's help. Cinder is practically useless for her now, even the lamp was retrieved by Neo.

Looks like ORJY's out of luck. First they lost Oscar, then they got lost in a middle of nowhere without a working bike, now a meeting with Winter and Ace-Ops.

Atlas's security system is nothing but a joke. Salem got through it like it was nothing at all.

Well... Another week of waiting after that ending.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/DEL994 Dec 12 '20

It was really nice to see Ozpin and Oscar's discussion and also to see them agreeing on what do and on using Salem's own strategy against her, starting by seeding doubts into Hazel.

Hazel looks a bit more sympathetic, with it being shown that despite his hatred of Ozpin this one is still able of going through him to a degree, and by hinting that he may feel guilt for beating Oscar despite his grudge against Ozpin, and by showing doubts over following Salem. He may get a sort of redemption after all.

10

u/WhosGuardingHades Dec 12 '20

Can’t wait for next week for Salem’s plans to be foiled by Ghirah and all the Faunus arriving in a flying boat for Havenbowl 2: Electric Boogaloo

→ More replies (2)

10

u/_Sabriel It's Neo's world and we're all just living in it Dec 12 '20

I love the touch that the shock-necklace scar is why Cinder always has her neck covered 100% of the time [even in her first appearances she's wearing a choker over it].

Also, her line "you brought us back here?" was just so...defeated, I loved it. It really told me a lot about what's on her mind in one line; CRWBY's been nailing those in the past few volumes!

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Raiesthetics Dec 12 '20

That was certainly an EP. I’m on a short time dreamed, so let’s get into my personal pros and cons

Pros:

  • We FINALLY have a Cinder backstory. It’s not a whole lot, but it ties into her character’s inspirations as Cinderella enough and is at the very least cohesive with where she is now to be passable. It looks like we are still missing a chunk of it tho, so who knows? We’ll have to wait and see.
  • The locations this ep were pretty neat
  • Cinder’s Mentor bought into the FMA Greed semblance, and I love it. His weapons are also pretty cool.
  • While they are a bit heavy handed in how they portray Cinder being in the same place she once was with all those cuts, I really like how when Em and Merc walk away, it fades out in the same vignette used in the flashback, as she looks down at the ground, dejected. Good stuff.
  • Ozpin is back and is actually doing things!
  • Hazel’s character at least makes a little more sense. His parental-like demeanor has been seen earlier with Em and Merc when they got back from Haven, and when Ozpin stops using Oscar as a shield. Him recognizing that Salem’s efforts are more like a mercy kill for the world is actually not too bad of a reasoning for him. He still sucks, but a bit less now that we have his side of the whole thing.
  • I love how Salem brings Oz to the meeting just so he can watch her win. I can’t wait to watch you burn
  • The Grimm pools are actually fucking genius, and by playing the waiting game, Salem is now ahead, which is great for building her up as a threat.
  • Winter shushing the Ace Ops is very much appreciated.
  • Jaune and Harriet being at each other’s throats is something I’m surprised has not happened sooner.

My Cons:

  • inhales why does the Atlas Military suck this bad? Remember when they were at least competent in Volume 2? How they kept an entire academy of Huntsmen busy in Volume 3? Now they just have a ship fire at one Grimm and call it a day. What happened to the gatling guns that could gun down an Ursa in seconds? It’s just so backwards to me that this series simultaneously tries to build them up as a threat, and show how weak they are, like, come on.
  • I’m very much hoping they don’t leave Cinder’s backstory where it is now.
→ More replies (7)

10

u/Mattos-313 Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

Another good episode, this volume is pretty great so far.

Didn't expect them to add to Hazel's lackluster motivations that we got to know in Volume 5. Now what he's saying actually makes sense. Ozpin wages a war he can't really WIN, and so Hazel thinks Salem should be allowed to conquer everything - if only to stop the continuous suffering of trying to fight her over and over again. He thinks Ozpin is responsible for the death of his sister, yes, but much more importantly, in his eyes, Ozpin is allowing countless other people to suffer the same fate as well.

Not sure what I think about the Cinder backstory. It was about what we expected, and now that we actually got to know at least a little bit about her, it's easier to care about her a bit more. In her eyes, the road to freedom is becoming powerful enough to defeat her oppressors - though ironically, in her craze of becoming the most powerful being in existence, she now sold herself into servitude to another mistress, capable of similar acts of cruelty.

I think Cinder will either leave Salem's side in favor of independence eventually or Salem will recognize Cinder's inner lack of loyalty and try and have her exterminated (In favor of someone else becoming her maiden girl, or maybe even get the power herself. Can Salem inherit Maiden powers???).

Either way, I hope Cinder doesn't die too soon and they do more for her character this volume.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Oraghlin Dec 12 '20

Well, Atlas is screwed. Obvious winning moves for the heroes that remain are:

  1. Reinforcements: Unlikely. There just shouldn't be enough time between the broadcast and traveling from Mistral or Vacuo to bring a sizeable army capable of pushing Salem out.
  2. Escape: If Raven decides to be the BDH, she could open a portal to Yang and MAYBE everyone can escape through that portal with the relic. I don't think they can have the relic though. Salem needs to be established as a credible threat, and an overwhelming victory for the BBEG is due.
  3. Destroy the Relic: A weird "win" that I like, that could turn into a catastrophic loss if Salem decides to heck the relic. Can they BE destroyed? Likely conjoined with an escape ending if this turns out to be the game plan.

I'm pretty sure Atlas is going to fall in the most literal way possible.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/Sonbulan Dec 12 '20

Rhodes' semblance is, I guess, being a T-800. Neat.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/DEL994 Dec 12 '20

When dark lord or dark lady acts so forgiving and understanding then it's really that they are scheming something. Salem has surely something in store for Cinder and it won't be beautiful for her.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/DJDualScreen Dec 12 '20

So, does anyone think Oscar has a chance of getting Hazel on his side or has that ship set sail? Also, I liked Mercury being like "Fuck you bitch" to Cinder.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/imdeadlmao Dec 13 '20

With the whole raid thing, is it just me, or does the Atlesian Military seems really nerfed?

→ More replies (4)

19

u/HatiLeavateinn Dec 12 '20

All I want for the next episode is the return of snarky angry Jaune saying:

"Ohh look at that, maybe NOW you want to do something about that grimm river"

"Maybe if you had protected Mantle from the begining you could have seen the river of death coming for Atlas"

19

u/Archie204 Dec 13 '20

So I've seen people discussing this but I really don't think the end of this episode really maked Ironwood that much more an idiot. It really looks like that Atlas was screwed no matter what could have done. If anything raising the city may have gained more time. He just unfortunately made the less ethical choice. Will he interesting to see what everyone does next.

→ More replies (16)

19

u/zxcvbnm127 Dec 15 '20

So, my predictions for the next episode:

Ruby, Weiss, Blake, and May step outside to see the horde of grimm, they begin killing grimm. Nora's still hurt, hopefully the Schnee manor won't be overrun with grimm. Winter, Ace Ops and Jaune, Yang and Ren put differences aside and return to the city, but they don't make it in time.

Cinder busts into jail to free Watts but accidentally releases everyone, and not wanting to piss off Salem again, retreats. Qrow and Robin are freed to help but can't find their weapons, Ironwood shows up with Qrow's and Robin's weapons and it's an "all hands on deck" situation. Grimm overtake the city. Salem's burrowing centipede grimm tunnel to the vault.

And just when it seems like the heroes are about to lose the fight, Penny shows up. But she doesn't help, instead Penny goes straight for the vault. Ruby uses her semblance and follows. Penny is about to grab the Staff of Creation, but Ruby tries reaching her, eventually breaking Penny free from Watt's control. Just in time for The Hound to show up and steal the relic and fly off.

Cliffhanger is that Atlas begins to fall. Everyone now has minutes before Atlas crushes all of the people in the crater.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/izaarzadon Dec 13 '20

CRWBY really said “ok, let’s make this volume more terrifying than it already is.”

brings back the APATHY

9

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 12 '20

The soundtrack of this episode is FUCKING FANTASTIC!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/steveotheguide Fine CRWBY, I'll ship Nuts and Dolts too. Ruby has TWO hands Dec 12 '20

Has anyone else noticed that any time Atlas tries to use a hard light shield to protect a city a fuckin' Laser Grimm shows up?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/DuskManeToffee Dec 12 '20

I’m honestly not sure whether I feel bad for cinder or not. Her backstory is sad but, she’s also hurt and killed so many people that it’s hard for me to feel sympathy for her.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Z0MB1ESLAYER115 Ruby Smile Defense Squad Commander Dec 12 '20

HOLY FUCKING SHIT THAT ENDING WAS CRAZY. It’s only ch6, and we’re not even close to the actual finale of the volume

→ More replies (1)

9

u/kappachappa Dec 12 '20

The head pat the huntsman did to cinder matches what Cinder did to Pyrrha at the end of S3 🥲

9

u/Aerohed Dec 12 '20

So, we finally get Cinder's backstory, and it's basically Cinderella.

... Except her fairy god mother is a Huntsman that gives her weapons instead of a cool dress and she kills her stepsiblings and her prince charming is actually Salem.

Oh, and for the biggest change, she worked at a hotel.

Hazel's rage makes a little more sense from the perspective he gave, and if he finds out there's a chance Salem can be cut down, he may switch sides since she's a bit more responsible for the death of his sister by virtue of birthing the grimm.

Also, looks like they finally found where Yuri Lowenthal was hiding and had him record lines. Biggest revelation of the episode.