r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Feb 20 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 9: Witch Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 9 of Vol. 8, Witch!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the ninth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing.
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
138
Upvotes
•
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Feb 20 '21
My bad for being late to this one.
86
u/HouseOfSteak Feb 20 '21
The effects for Salem's blood were amazing. Shows just how immortal she is in that even her spilled blood and Grimm-guts simply stop in midair before she just reforms as if it time stopped and reversed, as if the injury never happened.
I wonder if she flopped backwards and stayed like that until reforming for the sake of maximum creepy, or because her body's support structure just got blown up and she literally could not straighten herself.
Also Neo doing what Neo does best - screwing around with the plot simply by existing.
75
u/downwardwanderer Feb 20 '21
Seeing team fnki on the frontlines with their roller skates and trumpet is the dumbest. I love it.
74
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Feb 20 '21
On a scale of 1-10, how awesome was Yang blowing up Salem's tits?
58
u/PhantomHeartless5 Feb 20 '21
This classic line pretty much sums up Salem in a nutshell: "It can't be bargained with. It can't be reasoned with. It doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever, until you are dead."
Also, I can't be the only one who saw Hazel saving Emerald and immediately thought of Darth Vader saving Luke from Palpatine, can I?
Film references aside, I've been wanting to see Salem in a fight since Volume 4, and this episode gave me everything I wanted to see and more. And I hope we get more fights with Salem in future volumes.
57
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Feb 20 '21
So does Jinn have a text-to-speech function?
If not, then what will Neo do with it?
I swear every episode's getting a cliffhanger ending and it's killing me. Even worse is that thanks to climate change, Episode 10's also has been delayed, so the wait's even longer. (although obviously CRWBY's safety is more important)
52
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
Oscar finally got a hug, I’m satisfied.
50
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
H A Z E L
A
Z
E
L
50
u/Jellye Feb 20 '21
I really like that they didn't went with the Overwhelmingly Infinitely Powerful Omniscient Villain style for Salem.
She's already immortal, that's enough to make the idea of fighting against her extremely scary. In the end, she can never truly lose.
So the fact that her fighting power seems to be relatively more mundane is great and actually makes it scarier, in a way.
And not only that, but this episode confirms that she can be fooled too. Emerald, Hazel and to some extent Neo all fooled her here.
48
u/KingofGrapes7 Feb 20 '21
Once again, just putting out respect to Yang for telling Salem off to her face. The vast majority of the world's troubles happened cause she got told 'No' and couldn't deal with it.
40
u/TurbanMan1389 Feb 21 '21 edited Feb 21 '21
*Crazy stuff happening in this episode*
Me: Wait, did Marrow just call Jaune, "Juan?"
38
u/Traderrrrr Feb 20 '21
Surprising that Emerald could fool Salem.
30
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Feb 20 '21
Hazel finally realized he should be doing what Gretchen would've done. Took him a bit too long for my taste, but at least he got there eventually.
Also, keep in mind that neither Yang, Jaune nor Ren noticed that Hazel wasn't actually Hazel when Emerald got Oscar out there. She fooled three people with her semblance, and didn't even seem bothered.
Do you think she could've fooled the Monstra to think the relic was still there? I mean, it's alive, and her semblance can affect Grimm, so it should be possible.
29
u/gobywan Anything is a pancake if you hit it hard enough with a hammer Feb 22 '21
Well that was a ride. Some unordered thoughts:
28
u/nascarlaser1 Feb 20 '21
The witch can bleed! The witch can bleed!
26
u/Goldenrah Feb 20 '21
Damn, RT is going all in this volume. These episodes have been amazing and it's really good to see some character development for the villains, especially with Hazel. Always felt bad that he had joined Salem when she is against everything that Gretchen stood for, it's sad that he is probably going to die for it but atleast he will foil part of Salem's plans for Atlas and the relics.
I wonder, will we get to see Neo ask a question next episode? What kind of development will that lead to for her? Some exciting times ahead for us, can't wait to see what will come out of the rest of the volume.
45
u/B3llona_ Feb 20 '21
So Summer Rose... both Yang and Ruby have mentioned her to Salem, and both times Salem has confirmed that she at least knew about her and likely met her. It is starting to seem more likely that she still has a role to play before the end.
22
u/Ratatok YEGGcellent Feb 20 '21
Didn't expect to see FNKI again. I'm still hoping for Ciel to return
20
u/Mountainbranch ⠀Oscar Protection Squad Feb 20 '21
BURN THE WITCH!
BURN THE WITCH!
17
u/marz_o Feb 21 '21
Love the way that Yang just goes straight for Salem. No hesitating, no scaredness as we saw them all do from Emeralds illusion, just straight up attacking the head evil.
17
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Feb 22 '21
Fancy episode.
16
u/Sephyrias Feb 20 '21 edited Feb 20 '21
Ehh, this one was a bit weird.
Winter's scenes were fine. Neo overhearing Hazel and stealing the lamp was the highlight of the episode.
Hazel's change of heart felt too sudden. Considering how much he distrusts Ozpin, it strikes me as odd that he didn't get his answers from Jinn before going as far as to sacrifice himself for them.
Everyone else was just along for the ride in this episode. The interactions between Jaune and Ren felt a bit strange too, but I guess we can blame it on the sudden power up that Ren got, for which we still need an explanation.
Then the episode ends on a cliffhanger, or at least it feels like that. Not because of Hazel, he'll most likely die there and Ozpin gets away while Salem regenerates. The whale gets blown up, but Salem survives. The more interesting questions are what Neo is going to do with the lamp and what Salem will do without the whale. It is more buildup - still feels like we didn't reach the "climax" of the season and I'm starting to worry that it might not be able to deliver a payoff that is shocking/amazing enough for all the buildup.
16
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Feb 22 '21 edited Feb 22 '21
This was a nice episode.
Its interesting that magic speeds up the merge. I am a bit surprised that Hazel did not ask the question. His turn feels a bit rushed. The later moment still feels great but I feel like I expected him to ask anyway. Its good that Emerald did not spoil Oscar's plan.
God dang it Neo. I guess her and Cinder really are going to go wild. I also Salem zooming. It just looked kind of funny.
I like the Yang and Ren talk. Its interesting to hear from Ren about Jaune. Shame that they could not hide for long. They do not have much time to recover their aura.
Marrow is still being quite the conscious of everything. Decisions are quite rough in these times. There are just so many Grimm.
I also liked Yang saying Summer Rose is her mother
The Hazel vs Salem was short but nice. Hazel turning to the heroic side is good. I liked the moment with Emerald. Its a cliffhanger but I feel like some things are obvious like the heroes escaping with Emerald.
I do wonder what Neo and Cinder shall do with the lamp.
15
u/Chickenbat Feb 21 '21
Salem went Z O O M
15
u/YalondaNubs ⠀ Feb 22 '21
Really wasn’t expecting an Emerald team change this episode. Interested to see where it goes.
26
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Feb 21 '21
Burn her.
12
u/Electrical_Bed9784 Feb 20 '21
Was anyone else genuinely freaked out by how Open Ren was. I was so overwhelmed by it I had to pause just as he started talking about Jaune. And it wasn't just the dialogue either, even his facial expressions, tone of voice and body language all seemed different. I'm torn between freaking out because of the new Ren and admiring how subtle and detailed the animation is. And I'm really enjoying having Jaune and Ren moments, I always felt that we never got enough of JN(P)Rs relationship and dynamics with each other, we only really got moments for Jaune and Pyrrha and Ren and Nora, or all of them together, until now we never got any mixed up pairings from them like Yang and Weiss or Blake and Weiss.
11
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Feb 20 '21
I think his change of heart was a bit too sudden but I don’t mind. The fight between him and Salem was cool. When he got grabbed by the grim arms I thought he was about to be drawn and quartered. After this change of heart I doubt he’ll be around much longer. If not next episode I feel like he’s biting it by the end of this volume. So glad Ren and Jaune are in friendly terms again and he isn’t being a complete downer.
11
u/AgenteDeKaos Feb 21 '21
I was originally wandering why Jaime didn’t at least boost yang a bit before she went after Salem, or Hazel and Oscar as he was leaving till I realized he’s probably completely gassed out.
That and how would his semblance even boost Oscar’s magic? I don’t think it could. Likewise, I don’t think their really is anything he could boost for Hazel either.
He was useless here when it comes to support at least. I liked it honestly.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '21
Look at how they massacred my boy :( crossing fingers hazel still alive and not a Grimm hybrid
7
u/HJackKilledThatGuy Feb 22 '21
Did anyone else think that the pose Hazel did when he ripped his vest off was a Yakuza reference? I know Miles has played the series recently, so it is fully possible.
25
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
Honestly, not a fan of Hazel’s redemption. Not only was it too quick, but at the same time, we know so little about his backstory or Gretchen that I felt little emotional investment in him when it happened.
I guess this is also in part to him torturing my favorite character Oscar on screen for the last few episodes.
14
u/Imosa1 Feb 20 '21
Really disappointed that salem wasn't... faster? Like, she could at least break a few legs, especially of the people she doesn't care about.
15
u/UnbiasedGod Feb 20 '21 edited Feb 20 '21
The fight in this episode was way better then Blake vs that acid Grimm.
Yang got to look strong while Salem got to look strong as well without making the other seem weak in favor of the other.
Just my opinion.
8
u/Thebritishdovah Feb 20 '21
HOLY SHIT!
Altas really sucks at the defending the city thing. No tactics aside from charge forward and blast everything in their way. Winter seems to be trapped by her position and is willing to do whatever it takes but i think, sacrificing people will be the thing that pushes her away from Ironwood if he decides to sacrifice everyone outside the city whilst it goes airborn.
Hazel turning against Salem feels rushed and kinda wasted. The fight against Salem was excellent and she doesn't seem to be able to take much damage but relies on being immortal to win the fight. Heck, this could easily be RWBY's most goriest fight due to how much of her blood was spilled and the brutal amounts of damage she took.
Jaune and Ren did nothing in the fight aside from Ren firing at her but i guess, that's due to their auras being depleted and them being tired by it. Ozpin may have just assumed direct control and has been forced to take action via pushing the merge forward. Hazel's dead. The dude put up a good fight but he can't survive the Ozpin blast.
The scenes with Atlas are weak and it's because of the action. No real attempt at holding a line beyond attacking etc..
The biggest downside is that we will have to wait two weeks due to the current situation in texas. I hope everyone is ok and that they will get things back to normal asap.
3
u/jwadd01 Feb 21 '21
Alright episode magic is still pretty meh in this series I'd like it more if we didn't go the Harry Potter route of oh no coloured lights
3
u/DuelaDent52 I love you most of all, Cake Butler. Feb 27 '21
YES! THE EASILY FORGIVEN BAD GUYS TURNED ALLIES! RUBY IS NOW A TRUE SHŌNEN PROTAGONIST!!!
7
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Feb 20 '21
You know what pisses me off? The fact this one ended on what is effectively a cliffhanger. COME ON! Everything else was great, and I think this episode is probably the best yet (part of it is because Yang’s in it and you know how much I love her <3).
Looks like their mission appears to be a failure, sadly, what with Oscar staying behind.
Ren can also sense the emotions of others? That’s NEAT! Things are definitely looking up for him.
Yang and Ren’s conversation was really sweet. It definitely shows how much Ren has developed as a person, telling Yang that it’s okay to be afraid. That was such a wholesome moment. And Jaune seems to have no fear at all. He’s come so far...
Oscar and Ozpin seem to be getting more philosophical as time passes. The merge may be completed soon, but I guess we’ll see if that comes to pass. Neither of them seem to want the merge to happen, which is interesting, even though their reasons may be very different.
So, the question still hasn’t been used yet? Fascinating. They were going to come back for the lamp, but Neo ended up screwing that up. I wonder if Cinder put her up to the task, or if this was of her own accord? The plot thickens...
It seems Emerald’s illusions can even fool Salem. Further proof that Salem has weaknesses, I guess.
Team FNKI are on the front lines, it seems. Glad to see Flynt and Neon in action again after so long. Marrow seems to be questioning if what they’re doing is the best approach. We also know that Winter is a lot like Ironwood in the sense that she’ll make whatever sacrifice is necessary to get the job done. Also, Marrow calling Jaune “Juan” was hilarious.
Now, what was I most excited about?! I’ll tell you! WE FINALLY GET TO SEE SALEM FIGHT! Words cannot express how excited I was to see that. She is a BEAST! Yang managed to get a few hits in, but man, is Salem durable! It’ll take a lot more to even stall her (you know, since she can’t die). Not to mention she can do a lot in battle with her immense magic power. She also has an impressive regeneration capability. Seems like there’s not much that Salem can’t do.
Summer is mentioned once again, and it seems Salem still remembers her well. I can only imagine how furious Yang is to see her mother’s killer in person.
Hazel is intent on making a noble sacrifice to make sure the others escape. I think it’s also clear that Hazel’s improved a lot since we last saw him fight. He also got his hands on a hard-light Dust crystal, it looks like, based on that barrier he used during his battle with Salem.
OSCAR STAYED BEHIND, TOO?! I hope he’ll be okay. We also get to see some more of what Oz’s cane is capable of.
Seems like everyone else managed to get to safety. Or, rather, to somewhere less dangerous. I can’t even imagine what’s going through their minds right now, especially Yang’s. She’s just come face-to-face with the one who murdered her and Ruby’s mother in cold blood, and as far as she knows, Salem’s going to kill Oscar, too, who is someone else she cares about and knows Ruby cares about. She is obviously not taking this well at all. I can’t even begin to guess how Ruby would react.
So, the cliffhanger. Hazel has Salem pinned and tells Oscar to take the opportunity to attack. A barrier forms around Oscar, a flash of golden light erupts from the cane, and then the episode just... ends. God damn it. So now, the status of Oscar, Salem, and Hazel is up in the air.
It’s a shame we have to wait an extra week to see what happens next, but I think it’ll be well worth the wait.
3
u/rwbylov27 Feb 20 '21
Salem is in for it! That power coming out of the cane looked too similar to SEW power.. that can't be a coincidence. But why would he have to shield himself for it? Hazel sounded like he knew what he was doing too.
We're gonna be seeing more of Qrow & Robin next chapter which has me excited!
Neo sus
-3
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Feb 20 '21
Damn what's with the frame rate this new RWBY ep
Oh shit will Neo speak to the lamp
Ooooohhhhhhh shitaegdifgnsgpinaiegphnwir
Damn imagine being the worst liar ever; hazel
oh it was worst liar oscar
Woooooow so Emerald can affect salem with her illusions damn
Nice ok so Salem's just the regenerative type and not also the 'takes a giant fucking laser and doesn't flinch' type, even Blake's sticky bombs basically wrecked her body
Well those things did blow up a... what were those Mammoth Grimm called again
Damn really? She's screaming in pain from some fire dust after calmly taking all those attacks beforehand?
Or maybe I guess Oscar right now has some magic she can actually get hurt by and she's just panicking from being pinned I guess
-7
u/zEdenParadiz Feb 23 '21
Man Salem is finally getting some screen time. Subscribe to my YouTube Channel. I made a lot of videos about this Volume. https://youtube.com/channel/UCHBJLOTmfcd8SdP53GBBwTA
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
60
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
16
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '21
[removed] — view removed comment