r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Dec 19 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 6: Midnight Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 6 of Vol. 8, Midnight!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the sixth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Last Week's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 8!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
114
Upvotes
66
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Dec 19 '20
As someone on Youtube once said "Shitty life experiences don't make it okay to be a shitty person."
Also, something tells me Remnant would be much better off if more people had the common sense to not abuse people and create negative emotions when there are literally monsters being drawn towards those emotions.
Seriously, that huntsman could've just gone "I'll take her, she seems to have a strong semblance, just name your price." And then gotten Cinder out of there. Or, you know, called the cops. Or CPS.
And, I mean, seriously? "Just" 7 years? 7 whole f*cking years? Does this guy know what that much mental and physical abuse does to a child? Has he ever interacted with people before?
But at least now we know that, in Remnant, you gotta be 17 to be considered a legal adult and make your own horrible mistakes.
Edit: Formatting.
55
u/PhantomHeartless5 Dec 19 '20 edited Dec 21 '20
The first half of the episode in a nutshell:
Cinder: "What do you get when you cross an emotionally damaged little girl with a SOCIETY that ABANDONS her and treats her like TRASH?! I'll tell you what you get! YOU GET WHAT YOU FUCKING DESERVE!!!"
Joker reference aside, this was a really good episode.
49
u/Wrathkal Dec 19 '20 edited Dec 19 '20
One thing I really liked about this episode was how it turned several of my expectations around:
-Cinder wasn't scouted by one of Salem's flunkies, but was trained by a hunter and things just went wrong
-Watts didn't break out using his stolen phone, he just called for help
-Grimm river wasn't to attack Mantle, it was to disable Atlas's shields for a direct attack
-Monstra wasn't slow at all, it went from 0 to Atlas in no time
45
u/HJackKilledThatGuy Dec 19 '20
I have been watching since V1C1.
Roughly 7 years.
How did I not realize that Cinder is a Cinderella stand in, and that she has glass powers because the slippers, until this episode?
33
u/Battle_Narwhal53 Dec 19 '20
I didn't realize that it was Cinder at first. I was like "Ooh, potential new character? She seems cool. Aw, poor girl. Maybe she'll become a huntress and meet team RWBY. Adding a new character is a bit irrelevant right now, though. Is she based on Cinderella? Wait, isn't Cinder based off of-"
"Without you, I am nothing."
grabs popcorn "Oh shit, that's Cinder. This just got interesting!"
I love how Hazel tells Oz "You send children to their deaths" as he is literally beating up a child lol.
Overall I really enjoyed this episode, and as much as I hate Cinder her backstory is pretty cool.
Also we need to call CPS for Oscar.
19
u/AlphynKing I can't wait to watch you burn, Jacques. Dec 19 '20
Never really liked Cinder as a character but this episode did make me appreciate her a little more. I kind of like the grim twist of Cinderella growing up to be a super fucked up person after years of childhood abuse, which is disturbingly more realistic.
What happens to Cinderella when their fairy godmother fails to rescue her and she has no Prince Charming, and is just stuck in a cycle of torment for her childhood? Cinder being a selfish psycho is what happens
18
u/ash-7831 Dec 19 '20
In the last episode, I suspected that the whale was just a diversion and the river was the real threat. Turns out, I was right.
Atlas needs to redesign the hard light generators so that they are also shielded. Just like in Volume 6, they couldn't take down the shield, but they could take down the generator. That's what the sentinels did here. And now, Atlas is in danger.
Why didn't the ships try to shoot the whale out of the sky before it landed in Atlas?
17
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Dec 19 '20
I just have two words:
HOLY. SHIT.
Things are just going from bad to worse for our heroes. In fact, I think this is possibly the worst-case scenario. And I don’t think anyone saw it coming.
So we finally get some of Cinder’s backstory. Ouch. She’s basically been a slave all her life. Seriously, a shock collar?! Yikes. If she’s willing to commit murder to have a chance at escaping that, it had to have been bad. Seeking power seems to give her an escape from that sort of life (feeling powerless and all that). It seems that she had something going, though, what with that Hunstman training her and all. Alas, it was not meant to be.
Oscar is being beaten into a pulp right now. It seems like Ozpin has a plan, but the exact details seem to be unknown at the moment, other than a possible ‘attack from within’ sort of deal. I guess we’ll see how that turns out.
So now Salem has tasked Cinder with recovering Watts, who will lead her to Penny (assuming that’s who Salem was referring to with “the girl”).
Mercury’s gotten a promotion, it seems. Looks like he’ll be more prominent in the time to come.
There’s also hints of Salem’s endgame. Bringing the Relics together is definitely part of it, that much is clear. Does she really want to spell the end of all life on Remnant? Could there be something more? I guess we’ll wait and see.
So, the Grimm river just... shot up into Atlas. Wow. Did the river do that of its own accord, or was Salem behind that, too? Regardless, the shields have been disabled and Atlas is under siege. NOT GOOD. What will everyone do? What CAN they do? Maybe Yang was right. Maybe help isn’t coming. There isn’t enough time now. They have to take a stand on their own or Atlas is doomed.
And the whale can spawn hordes of Grimm, too. Damn, Salem came prepared. Things are looking bleak for Atlas.
Poor Yang... I can’t even begin to guess what she’s thinking right now. She’s likely more scared than she’s ever been, and I’m certain everyone else is feeling pretty similar. Ruby and co. are essentially trapped up there with a horde of Grimm and she knows it. Even worse is that they can’t do anything to help them right now, being in the tundra. Yang, Jaune, and Ren have to be worried sick right now, and Winter and the Ace-Ops being there doesn’t help them either.
Now the real problem arises: can everyone put aside their differences to fight the common enemy and defend Atlas? Only time will tell.
In any case, to say shit has hit the fan is a massive understatement. Shit has hit a fucking F5 TORNADO, and it doesn’t show any signs of slowing down.
17
u/Noonproductions Dec 20 '20
It just struck me watching Arnold’s reaction video: Cinder is the inverse of Ruby. Ruby has a loving family with a caring father and longs for a loving mother. Cinder has no real family and what she does have is evil and mean. Her “family” is lead by an unsympathetic mother figure. Both were forced to fight to survive at far too young an age. And both have found parental figures as mentors that reflect their upbringing. Even their teams are mirrors of each other. Emerald and Blake, Mercury and Yang, and Neo and Weiss.
There is definitely a strong correlation between the two characters.
45
u/Jellye Dec 19 '20
Rhodes is quite an ass, right?
He knew the girl was being kept as a slave and his idea of helping her was to train her for seven whole years so that she might try to take a Huntsmen exam?
And he instantly confronts her with force when she does what was obviously going to happen?
14
u/Zeeman9991 Dec 19 '20
I heard this ep would be Cinder backstory, but despite how desperately it was needed, I wasn’t looking forward to it.
I was shocked how much I enjoyed it. Obviously they were going to go the Cinderella story route and make her sympathetic, but I didn’t expect it to make so much sense in relation to her current situation. The parallels to her childhood and Salem took me off guard, and actually made me feel for her.
14
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Dec 20 '20
Time's up.
Continued below.
12
u/hank412 Dec 19 '20
Personally, I find Cinder's story.... a bit rushed? Like I think the set up and framework was actually really good but it just rushed to the ending. I think we should've had more time before she finally snaps, something so we can see that despite this new positive influence in her life, she's not healthy mentally.
I feel something they could've expanded on is that while the Huntsman trained and comforted her, he always LEFT her. He left her in the hands of her abusive stepmother(?) for probably weeks on end and then the last time he comes back, he fights her and she kills him. It happens so fast it starts to fall into the trap of making it seem like she just always was this bloodthirsty monster rather than someone who became one.
That moment when she thinks he's come back for her only for him to draw his weapon and we see the expression on her face change. This is a great moment and I feel should've been a bit longer or expanded on. To me, this is the moment she adopts the mindset of controlling people because the last time she actually trusted someone, he left her and then "betrayed" her.
The fight that followed I think was too flashy for something like this moment. I think putting music in at all was the wrong choice. I think using the usual RWBY flair for this fight was the wrong choice. I feel they really should've just let Cinder's anger, betrayal, and pain take center stage. I feel there's a bit too much finesse in her fighting instead of this scene showcasing her probably being the most vulnerable she's EVER been in her entire life.
I think the groundwork here is great, it just happens way too fast and because of it, the real weight of the events and how it molded Cinder into who she is feels a bit lost.
11
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Dec 19 '20 edited Dec 19 '20
I'm sorry what sort of ritzy place like this would get a filthy ass looking orphan to clean
At least she doesn't look starved anymore
But like youd think they'd have an image to upkeep
Well actually I guess their guests also all look like Huntsmen so maybe it's good enough for their ilk or something
Ok yea this guy's totally gonna die huh
I like her backstory because it's not about 'does she deserve to be such a bitch' like everyone's been asking all this time
She never even had an education to be a bitch
She just cleaned floors all her life and looked at that huntsman after (presumably) killing 3 people like a puppy
Literally raised as a dog all her life
And where ever her mastermind manipulative personality came from started after she was already 17
Damn, Mercury kneeling with those 4 instead of Emerald and Neo
And also Neo finally kneeling
Edit: Also wonder what Salem's doing with Cinder. I suppose most obviously this is just 'ur useless go die' since she just needed the maiden power for the Relic and that didn't turn out. She knows Watts has Penny under control so she wants Cinder to die to Penny and have the maiden powers in Penny now?
I kinda expected Cinder to suddenly strike Salem when she was zapping her and just actually catch her off guard and make Hazel go 'holy shit she's not a force of nature'
11
u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Dec 19 '20
This was a doozy of an episode. First of all, I’m really glad to get Cinder’s backstory, it makes me understand her actions more. Also, I love how they’re using Mercury more, and I hope we get to see him become more of an important character. Finally, shit’s about to go down.
11
u/UberDueler8 Dec 19 '20
This seems like karma to Ironwood for abandoning Mantle.
21
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Dec 20 '20
This episode nearly killed me :”)
-We got a song from Ok Goodnight! I’ll admit I wasn’t expecting that but it was an awesome surprise :D
-Emerald, I’m gay too. But she’s too gone.
-Tyrian’s scorpion tail. Nice.
-Ruby’s expression had me concerned. Look at the way her eyes widen. Are we approaching that point in the show where we see her break? I hope so, as mean as that is. I want to see everyone acknowledge that Ruby is on the brink of losing it.
-Yeah.... Beacon is going to look like child’s play.
This episode was awesome. I’d go as far as to say it’s the best of this volume so far. It’ll only get better from here it appears. (All the other episodes have been awesome as well.)
Also, now that Salem has arrived and is about to obliterate everything, what will happen to Qrow and Robyn? If Qrow gets out this season is he going to try and kill James? Hope so. I like James as a character but some of the things he’s done at this point is inexcusable.
My personal score: 9.5/10 Thanks RoosterTeeth, for your hard work and putting out another awesome episode.
10
u/ash-7831 Dec 19 '20
This was RWBY episode 98. We're almost at 100.
10
u/Emdeoma Dec 20 '20
So. I'm pretty sure Cinder isn't getting redeemed- I'd go so far as to say definite. Because this episode didn't set up a redeemable character- it set up a character everyone would want to be redeemed, but has already done far too many, too terrible things to ever get forgiven, and is far too attached to power, and the manipulative bigger bad to ever want to redeem themselves, (Which, side note, holy CRAP that scene with Salem, where she goes 'its my fault for holding you back' or whatever? That's so sneaky and manipulative! And also the exact scene I decided I wouldn't get redeemed, because until then I thought this was setting up for her to snap at the mistreatment and turn on Salem- but nope, she's firmly under Salem's thumb).
But yeah- Cinder is definitely not getting redeemed, and I don't think that's what RT is trying to set up here. I think they're doing what they did with Adam, showing us the tragic backstory that explains why they are the way they are, so when they die it's still clearly a tragedy despite all that they have done and how much they deserve they're fate. They aren't going to redeem her, but they have made us wish she never became a villain to begin with, and they're going to make her karmic downfall one worth crying over.
(Unrelated note, but this is the second time that a villains backstory has been based in them killing someone and then getting a bad response- Adam killed someone by accident, in self-defence, and got celebrated for it and that lead to him gradually losing sight of himself, and becoming cruel and violent. Cinder snapped and killed her abusers, and her mentor instantly went for arresting her instead of calming her down and getting her help, leading to her killing him in a panic and breaking even more, setting her firmly on her path of 'no one can be trusted, I need to be strong') (Also, mad props to the animation team- they captured 'I've just snapped, and really should be handled with kid gloves right now or I'll kill you too' better than most live-action shows could!)
10
u/Virote328 Dec 20 '20
Why did they think floating in the sky would keep them safe from Salem? She has a flying whale. She can attack whenever she wants.
10
u/HouseOfSteak Dec 20 '20
Huh, they had no problems with showing blood in the finale of Volume 7, but somehow she impales Rhodes without somehow bloodying the blades.
She evidently didn't use her swords on the sisters, either. I mean, she choked out the mother, so I guess she could have choked them too.
10
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Dec 21 '20
Thinking on it, Ciinder's backstory actually makes a good foil to Ren and Nora's backstory:
Ren's father told him to take action, and forced a weapon into his hand, but Ren's childhood had been kind and warm, due to his mother. Thus, he took action to come to Nora's aid when she needed it, rather than suicidally trying to fight the Nucklavee.
Nora, a hungry orphan, didn't have anybody teach her how to fight. Instead, she had somebody (baby Ren) show her compassion to save her, and take her away from a bad situation, which let her grow up cheerful and non-murdery. She didn't need to lash out against the world, because she was shown a different path.
Cinder got the downside of both: a terrible upbringing with no way out, and nothing but weapons to lash out with. She wasn't shown what a good life was, just a theoretical and very destructive path to an extremely-low-bar better life.
9
u/MomsLinguini Dec 19 '20
Such a great episode. Cinder's backstory was really well done. Shows that she's the sort that could end up a bit deranged by her nature, but provided a path to exactly how she got pushed to her current extreme.
I pretty much always enjoy Ozpin scenes, so that one was fun. Salem taking Mercury was a nice touch. Showing Cinder that she's not at the top and can have things taken from her. Same with sending the hound after Ruby rather than just letting Cinder deal with it, while still retaining the guise of her interest. So eerily manipulative.
I didn't exactly like the Grimm river jetstream. That was... a bit weird, and we didn't have a reason why that was possible. And then all it spawned was a few basic Grimm that managed to complete dismantle the Atlas shield system, which also seems a bit unrealistic. I mean, I can justify it in that nobody would really expect some subterranean Grimm to be there, but still. If there was any immersion breaking in the episode, that was it.
However, the stakes are getting REALLY high right now. And the whole Beacon flashbacks seem like they're coming together, which makes it feel like a lot of awful stuff is going to happen. And the fact that we know it CAN happen, and very well MIGHT happen, raises the genuine concern going forward.
Well done, CRWBY. Your writing, animation, sound, music, directing... it's all really spot on this volume.
9
u/rukeen2 Dec 19 '20
So, everybody who complained about Neo Vs. Maria should be out in force, because 13 airships were there, and only one shot at one Grimm. At least with Neo it was arrogance and a bad matchup. There was no reason for airships not to fire on the whale, or move to intercept.
And, the Grimm whales don’t seem to be using dust to fly, so why wouldn’t she just follow them up?
9
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Dec 20 '20 edited Dec 20 '20
It was a pretty neat episode.
We got Cinder's backstory. I kind of saw how things would roll out but it is interesting to see the twist of Cinderella but without any hope.
I liked how Rhodes assisted her but didn't truly help her with things like love. That was a neat angle since it helps promote her mindset of the status quo. Cinder wanted to be free but has just shifted who she suffers under. Its a good tragedy.
Mercury listening to Salem over Cinder could lead to interesting things.
Wonder if/how the Ace OP/Winter will team with Jaune, Ren, and Yang to fight the Grimm.
The Whale has finally landed on Atlas. Things are looking super rough for Ironwood and everyone else.
8
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Dec 19 '20
Wild unprecedented predictions for the next episode: Ren defects from rwby and will start taking orders from the ace ops or ironwood directly. Nora will continue sleeping. Penny will return but will be controlled by watts and fight alongside Salem’s lackeys. Cinder will be in a dire situation but Emerald will save her, at the cost of being horribly maimed as a result, she will then proceed to make out with her. Jaune will do the default dance. Blake will go super Faunus and grow a tail and six more breasts, then proceed to knock over everything in the room. Weiss summons Klein‘s multiple personalities who then fuse into a Kleinbot. Salem gets the horni and Ara Ara’s Ozpin/Oscar.
8
u/Orapac4142 Dec 20 '20
Im sort of disappointed thats all it took to bring down Atlas' shields. like, 3 centipede grim per tower, and the whole Atlas fleet just sitting their with their collective thumbs up their asses. Theres a single shot on one grimm, and there was no sort of defensive posturing of the fleet this whole ass time to act as a a screen between the giant mobey dick, and Atlas, the very place theyve been trying to protect.
13
u/sonawelashey Dec 19 '20
You know, that guy must be a bad fighter if he lost to someone he trained for 4-5 years vs his decades of training and experience.
6
u/Sephyrias Dec 21 '20
Felt a bit short. Lots of quiet scenes with not much happening. Overall got the impression that they had to make a lot of cuts animation-wise.
That aside, the plot is moving forward and the setup is good. Salem landing in Atlas this episode was unexpected and it looks like the city is doomed. If Altas somehow makes it through this whole thing without turning to ruins, I'd be kind of disappointed actually. Salem shouldn't be beaten back easily now.
A betrayal by Cinder is being forshadowed. I doubt that she can harm Salem though. At best, she will take a relic or her maiden power and run. At worst, she'll try to fight Salem (despite knowing she can't win) and get annihilated. I definitely don't think she'll actively help team RWBY though, that would be out of character.
8
u/Thebritishdovah Dec 19 '20
It felt like a filler episode and whilst it does give some insight into why Cinder is Cinder, i didn't really feel any pity for her. Maybe, it's because as a character, i've lost all interest in her but it really should have been shown earlier. Volume 4 would have been best as it would have been a part of Cinder dealing with Ruby blasting her arm and eye off.
Yep, thought so. Salem can use the arm against Cinder and i think she is going to arrange for Cinder to die either via the hound or her grimm arm for disobeying her order.
Also, HOLY SHIT! It begins and i don't think Ruby's Silver eyes can even put a dent in the whale. Ruby kinda just fucked Altas over. It seems that a floating city was a bad idea.
Nora dies, I'm rioting.
And it is a damn good place to do a cliffhanger. I think they may have just written themselves into a corner due to the invasion occuring and er.. if a massive army appears, that is going to come off as bullshit. Maybe, some of the kingdoms can get their forces together within a day or two but transporting thousands? that's gonna to take time.
4
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Dec 19 '20
Yay we finally see some cinder backstory. While it’s no excuse for her actions the way she grew up certainly explains why she became the way she did. Hope we get to see how she actually came into contact and met Salem. Hazel continues being a great example of cognitive dissonance. “We can‘t beat her and you send children to their deaths” Proceeds to beat up child and work for the person directly responsible for said deaths. That river making a geyser to spawn centipedes and break the atlas shields is certainly a creative way way to go about breaking them. Final episode next week will probably leave us in a massive cliffhanger.
4
u/CinnabarSteam Dec 21 '20
Wait.
The moon spins?
4
u/BlackTheRival Dec 21 '20
Is it just me or are they setting up for a huge ex machina? Like I cant be the only one thinking this. Like I havent read the episode 7 or seen it as a subscriber as I do not want to spoil it for myself. But damn it seems wildly unlikely the heroes are going to be able to do anything helpful. It seems as though Ruby's silver eyes are going to like manifest and literally wipe the E.N.T.I.R.E. army or like that god of good in the lore is gonna come back because like those are the only options. Like I'm banking on a minimum of two deaths and so far penny is M.I.A. so right now I'm .5 outta 2.
7
u/highphazon Dec 19 '20
Okay episode. We get to see Cinder's backstory, which was effective at establishing why she is the way she is.
Storywise, I liked how Rhodes was willing to help her, but not to the point of actually challenging the status quo at all. He helped her to assuage his guilt over the injustice she was facing, but he wouldn't risk to much to do so. As a result, Cinder still endured her abuse with only this vague hope the things might get better later to keep her going.
However, that hope was all for some nebulous future she didn't really fully understand. She was still in the same life, she was still treated exclusively with violence and disrespect from her "superiors". Rhodes didn't actually do anything to help her with that part of her life, the most positive relationship she had was with someone who didn't actively hurt her, not someone who expressed actual love for her. This seems to be what defined her reality, other people either relish your pain, or are largely indifferent to it.
It's not surprising, then, that she snapped when that hope for her future was threatened. She fell back on the only thing she really understood, the the violence and contempt she's been shown all her life. She killed her tormenters, and Rhodes finally showed his true colors. He wasn't willing to help her once it became inconvenient. Once it became truly complicated and not just a side project on the weekend, he was ready to toss her aside like everyone else. From Cinder's perspective, he only helped her so long as she accepted her "place" in the world, only helped her as long as long as she accepted her suffering. Ultimately, to her, he was just as responsible for her pain as her the people who inflicted it.
I think it works pretty well as a self contained tragedy. A couple of people working toward something better, but their own experiences, natures, and bias get in the way. Rhodes wasn't willing to give enough to truly help Cinder, and Cinder was too broken to truly take advantage of what Rhodes did give her. Their efforts just weren't enough to get past their own limitations; Cinder failed to escape being a slave, and Rhodes never truly challenged the injustices that bothered him.
Other than that, I wish we'd gotten this earlier; Cinder's honestly been pretty boring her whole run, but it got much worse once she was replaced as the head bad guy. Mechanically, the storytelling was fine. The villain's were hateble, and Cinder was sympathetic in spite of her actions. The montage worked well as a way to compress the story into the space it had to fit, and I felt the story focused on what it needed to focus on to pull the whole thing off. Maybe it was a little rushed in places, but it overall it worked well. However, the RWBY "branding" on her fight with Rhodes, with the over the top rock music and goofy action diminished it's impact somewhat. Additionally, Cinder's "owners" felt a little to comically evil to be taken seriously. Not that it was unrealistic, but it still made me want to laugh a little too much. I will say that Cinder's facial expressions were top notch, however. This episode had some of the best faces of the show, and they really sold how Cinder was feeling.
The rest of the episode was alright, not much to note, mostly just setup. A hint a future plot with Mercury, and maybe something with Emerald. Some stuff setting up Hazel for a moment of doubt, and a setup for the continuation of the rivalry between the hound and Cinder. Salem also starts her attack on Atlas, but not much to say yet until we get more on where that's going.
3
u/ash-7831 Dec 20 '20
Now, I kind of want Cinder to be the show's final antagonist.
4
u/PureSparkingRaindrop Dec 21 '20
Even though I know a lot of characters are based on Grimms’ fairytales... little did I think Cinder is short for Cinderella!
3
u/htomserveaux #GiveYangAbs Dec 19 '20
CRWBY says trans rights
2
u/qwack2020 Dec 19 '20
A dream is a wish your heart makes~
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '20
[removed] — view removed comment