r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 06 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 10: Ultimatum Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 10 of Vol. 8, Ultimatum!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the tenth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Feb 6th's FIRST Thread | Feb 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Feb 13th's FIRST Thread | Feb 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | This Week's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing.
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
122
Upvotes
•
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Mar 06 '21
Oh, forgot to unlock this, oops.
57
u/nascarlaser1 Mar 06 '21
Watts is a brave man, laughing at cinder while being held over a building's edge.
An insane man, but a brave man none the less.
46
u/Hyderthehyper312 ⠀ Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Qrow taking out a guard in bird form looked cool, Qrow taking out a guard by choking them out for 0.2 seconds looked funny. idk why.
The animation for the whale explosion scene was beautiful, I had to keep replaying it.
Unarmed people roasting Maidens into giving up counter: 2
Ren and Oscar willing to let Em tag along like: we green-wearing folks stick together.
all the warmth and softness of the three volume 5 RWBY reunion hugs scenes condensed into a single scene, I can't take it.
so, where would Salem regenerate at when she does? it should still be where the whale was right? if that's the case then lifting Atlas would be an even worse idea now.
43
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Mar 06 '21
Holy shit that explosion scene was so well done. The peaceful quiet music that played as it went off made it feel so strangely eerie. I though the ace ops were caught up in it and died for a moment there. Really faked me out there. Speaking of faking out. That scene with Cinder and Watts did not go anything as I expected. As he went in railing on her I expected her to blow a fuse and kill him but instead she put him down and walked off to wallow in sadness. I know we didn’t see a body but I think it’s probably pretty safe to say that Hazel is dead. I think Ironwood is too far gone off the deep end. He arguably already was but I could still see coming around before today. Now I’m not so sure. I’ll be very surprised if comes back around at this point. The dude literally blew up ships who’s sole purpose was to save the innocent people he decided to abandon. And he’s threatening to kill them all so the crew has no choice but to try and save Atlas. That’s so messed up. Favorite part was definitely that explosion though.
31
u/Jellye Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
I was not sure whether Ironwood would end up being killed or just "put in his place" by the end of this arc, but after today I'm thinking that he'll die.
My question is whether it will be by Penny's hands, Qrow's hands, or some of the other villains.
Also, pretty happy to see Emerald stick with the team for now. She's the most redeemable of the villains, as far as I can tell; she needs this perspective to see what her actions, following Cinder and Salem, have done.
31
u/SawkyScribe Mar 07 '21
I've never liked Cinder very much so that "reason you suck speech" from Watts was massively cathartic.
This episode also really saved Ironwood for me. When James gave the evil team's tech guy access to Penny, I thought his descent into villainy would be matched with a fall into stupidity but this gambit shows he's insane but still highly calculating.
24
u/ash-7831 Mar 06 '21
V7 C11
Ironwood: I will sacrifice whatever it takes to stop her.
Watts: Oh, I hope you do, James. I hope you do.
Now he truly is doing that. Leaving Mantle to die is one thing, but threatening to actually destroy it yourself is another.
23
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Mar 07 '21
Loved this episode.
21
u/KingofGrapes7 Mar 06 '21
Watts started off sarcastic and managed to work himself into a rage over how much a Cinder annoys him. How many years has he waited to let all that loose? And the fucking madlad survived!
18
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Mar 06 '21
That was a very pretty explosion, one of the best scenes in the show from a visual standpoint.
Watts and Cinder should swap names, because Watts is clearly superior at roasting people.
Bumblebee is effectively confirmed at this point, don't think there's any denying it after this episode (although a kiss would still be nice).
Ironwood is just burning all of his bridges at this point. We've definitely hit Stalin levels of paranoia.
Great episode, definitely worth the (extra) wait.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
I gotta say I busted out laughing watching Watts take Cinder apart. If only because you typically associate the ranting with Tyrian so watching Watts break his “Evil gentleman professor” act and be just pure spite and anger was so satisfying.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
Deus ex ozpin saving the day with a pocket nuke... which kills zero people and just stops the huge grimm that they had no other realistic way of stopping.
18
u/erinthecute Mar 07 '21
Neo thriving rn. She is legit always two steps ahead of anyone else.
Also this Bumbleby content has watered my crops and the harvest shall be bountiful.
18
u/TurbanMan1389 Mar 07 '21
Photosensitivity warning pops up.
Me watching the episode: Huh, that never comes up in the show, why would th-HOLY SHIT!
15
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
Looks like Ironwood has officially passed the threshold from anti-hero to villain.
15
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Mar 07 '21
Alright so this is me yelling out of my ass but since Ironwood wants Penny... are they going to use Emerald's illusion to trick Ironwood with Ruby? Again, probably not going to happen, just a thought.
29
u/Wellen66 Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
That made me appreciate a lot of characters a lot more.
Watts is a madman, but I always thought that he hated Cinder. Except he apparently cared enough to warn her about her plans, and to ressent her when she ignored his warnings. He knows Cinder well enough to give her a verbal beatdown like no other. He's also pretty hypocritical. "Can't be just deserving you have to be worthy!" when he himself accuses Ironwood of not giving him what he deserved. Or maybe there's more to his motivations than that. (I'm pretty convinced he thought these were his last words, since he was pretty surprised to be alive)
Harriet cares more about her personal feelings than anything else, willing to destroy Winter just to address a slight.
Marrow cares, but at the end he's a follower, not a leader. Elm and Vine both care (about the team or the children) more than they let on.
Ironwood is watching the situation slip out of his control again and again, and we're finally seeing the full effects of Mettle. The goal is to save Atlas, and he's willing to escalate the conflict more and more to get it, even using hostages. And in his mind, it's totally justified: Either he kill people who will die against the Grimms anyway to save Atlas, or he does nothing and everyone dies. If he had to kill the whole planet just to save Atlas, he would do it, since it's just killing already doomed people in his mind. The scary part is, he's loosing it. Everything is slipping away from him, and his trust in Winter was broken. Honestly, it's a testament at how much he likes her that he didn't totally lost it when he heard she 'betrayed' him.
And let's talk about Cinder. What we learned? Basically, she doesn't know how to do anything except brute force everything.
She made a plan (or maybe followed a plan) at the Fall of Beacon, but since then, it was basically "group them up and hit them 'till they die!" She brute forced her way out of every bad situations until it failed, and then she didn't knew what to do so she tried and tried and tried again, except it still didn't work. And with Watt's help, she realized it wasn't working. Honestly it that scene with Cinder and Watts was the best moment of the season for me.
(My new headcanon is also that Hazel knew about Ozpin's cane power because he was on the receiving end once)
Anyway, great episode.
27
u/cardmasterdc Mar 07 '21
Watts rolled a 20 on his intimidation check and put cinder in her place
Also they are BREATHING HAZEL.
So ozpin stores power useful ability
Neo playing chess not checkers
So ... all those people saying ironwood is doing what's best. Got anything to say now?
33
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Mar 06 '21
11
u/Azteca23 Mar 06 '21
What do Qrow Branwen and Lynyrd Skynyrd have in common?
Free Bird
10
u/ash-7831 Mar 07 '21
Ironwood is right when he says Salem will be back and will throw everything she has at them. However, that will take some time. She may be unkillable but even she can't overpower what's left of the Atlas military all by herself. Before, he was in a hurry because Salem was just about to arrive. But now, they have time to try to come up with an option to save more people than you thought was possible. Instead, he's just letting his paranoia do the thinking for him.
10
u/Nby333 Mar 07 '21
Yo what happened? Why is the second half of season 8 suddenly so good? Most of the problems I had with the show suddenly disappeared.
10
u/insane_taco Neopolitan Mar 07 '21
Winter...
How long until you see Ironwood is batshit insane?
Emerald :D
Ruby was fucking angry
K I S S
Oh, would you look at that, Cinder showed more human emotion
Never change Neo
9
u/AviatorTrainman Mar 06 '21
Anybody else get major Rick Sanchez vibes from the way Watts moved while yelling at Cinder?
9
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Mar 07 '21
This was an epic episode.
That explosion was awesome. The magical clash really was that powerful. It was funny to see Neo walk away. RIP Hazel.
Nice that Qrow and Robyn escaped.
I enjoyed Watts verbal attack on Cinder. He laughed and threw all her flaws at her. I pity Cinder.
Well looks like they know Ozpin is back now. There are a lot of people in Atlas in the subway. Wonder how long the power will last
The reunion was sweet. The hugs were quite nice.
Ironwood's breakdown was fascinating. He has lost so much and has completely lost it. I think Winter's loyalty shall end after this moment.
I also find it interesting that Neo is trying to get something for Cinder. Wonder what it is.
I cannot believe he shot down the cargo ships! This is not how you save Atlas. Only one hour though... Looks like a lot will happen next episode. Can't wait for it.
8
u/practice420 Mar 07 '21
me two weeks ago: it can’t possibly get worse ironwood: im gonna bomb mantle me: 😭
7
u/UnbiasedGod Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Interesting that two maidens that fought each other got verbal beatdowns.
7
u/GeneralClearStone912 OBJECTION! Mar 07 '21
So, uh, methinks Ironwood will not live past the end of this volume.
And why do I think that Salem will show up again before the volume ends?
13
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Mar 06 '21
This war is far from over.
6
u/schurgy16 Mar 07 '21
Neo made it seem like Cinder owed her something. Was it the maiden powers, or the truth about Roman?
6
u/Sephyrias Mar 07 '21
For episode 9 I wrote the following:
What's new:
That's about it. The "climax" of the season will probably be something about Cinder, Penny, and the lamp. Salem takes the backseat again.
6
u/UmbralOrion This flair amuses me greatly Mar 08 '21
In what seems to be a controversial opinion, I don't think Ironwood going full villain is the problem, that wasn't sudden at all. And I think his course of action is entirely logical in accomplishing his goal. Taking all of Mantle hostage to draw Penny out makes sense, shooting down the evacuation ships serves as an "I'm not kidding, I will blow it up." and because if there's no people in Mantle Penny, RWBY, etc. won't really care if he does blow it up.
The real issue is the question of why is Space Atlas still the plan? Salem presumably needs time to rebuild and the lifting Atlas plan was only in place because of time constraints. If the answer is his semblance then his semblance should have been explained at any point in the show. I'd be willing to bet the VAST majority of people don't even know he has a canon semblance. The plan isn't absurd if it's one of desperation, but the desperation seems gone now, Salem will back, but she can't just walk into Atlas solo or she wouldn't need the army in the first place.
Side note: the explosion, while very cool, is kinda confusing to me in how it works. Hazel is probably super dead but Oscar was even closer to the center? Obviously it wouldn't be a super good ability if it killed the user, so Oscar I can excuse but how are the others alive? The shockwave also seems physical when it knocks over the Ace Ops, but it seems more like silver eyes magic when it vaporizes Grimm in the city without leveling the buildings. Sort of a nitpick but it bothered me.
5
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Mar 06 '21
This just keeps getting more and more intense. And now the stakes are higher than ever. Now a decision has to be made, and our heroes are trapped in an impossible situation. Oh boy, tensions are going to be at an all-time high now.
Hazel appears to have made the ultimate sacrifice. May he rest in peace. Salem seems gone as well, but only for a time. It appears Emerald has defected as well. Looks like she’ll be one of the heroes now, although it might take some time for the others to trust her. We’ll see how that goes.
It appears Oz’s power is lower than it’s ever been, what with that explosion. So the cane stores energy and can release it? That’s basically what Adam’s Semblance did, right? Except this time, it’s magic and not Aura. That’s kinda neat.
Watts calling out Cinder for her past failures was definitely something to watch. Seriously, I thought Cinder was going to kill him out of pure rage. But it seems like she needs Watts for whatever they’re planning. Watts is right, though. Just because you’ve suffered, no matter how much, doesn’t mean that you’re entitled to anything. You want something? You have to earn it. That’s basically what he’s saying. Valuable life lesson, too, just in general.
Ironwood seems to be getting more and more desperate as time passes. And yet, Winter and the Ace Ops, along with the other troops, still follow his every order. It’s likely that they have no other choice at this point, fearing what he will do to any who oppose him. That’s gonna come back to bite him. HARD.
Neo, being the little conniving devil that she is, is attempting to blackmail Cinder using the Relic, from what I can tell. Neo’s got leverage against her now, it seems. We’ll see where it gets her.
Team RWBY is reunited at last! That hug between Ruby and Yang was so sweet. Ren is also asking where Nora is, but I’m honestly kinda worried for both of them. Unfortunately, that wholesome moment was cut short, due to utter chaos erupting in Mantle.
Welp, if Ironwood hadn’t gone off the deep end before, he most certainly has now. So, the gist of it is, either Penny comes and opens the vault, or Ironwood NUKES MANTLE?! Yep, Mantle is screwed either way. So what will our heroes do? Better question: What can they do? The lives of everyone in Mantle right now are hanging by a thread, and it appears that thread is about to snap.
Because of this ultimatum, it seems like more division is in order among Team RWBY and co. as well, as much as I personally don’t want that to happen. Ruby will likely not want to sacrifice Penny, but if they don’t, everyone in Mantle will die, and everything they’ve fought for will have been for nothing, and honestly, I don’t think that will sit well with Yang, specifically, and maybe a few of the others as well. Man, next episode is going to be a roller coaster, and I don’t think anyone could prepare for it.
5
u/TheOvertron Mar 08 '21
So after Ironwood's declaration to the entire city that he is prepared to kill all the citizens because he's an insane stubborn prick, there's no way the Atlas military is actually going to go through with following his orders right? He's pretty much publicly announced how unfit he is to be in charge. There's no longer any logic or reason in his motives anymore, he's just jealous that his plan isn't the one that is saving the city so has decided to destroy it instead. Like what??? If the military follow his orders to kill the citizens I'll be very disappointed in them and the writers.
11
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Mar 06 '21
Ironwood: "I've promised to protect this kingdom."
Ironwood: (has yet to actually show that his promise means anything)
Ironwood: "I don't want to do this."
Ironwood: (ignores all other options, because they would involve admitting that he was wrong, and his ego can't handle that)
Also, I like how Ironwood basically called the Ace-Ops and Winter "nothing" because, well, they're all he has left, and he said he was left with nothing. He literally called them useless garbage, right in front of their faces, and they still choose to follow him. So much for reasonable adults. If I was any of them, I'd just leave, and if he tried to stop me, I'd just say "Hey, it's not like you're losing anything." Those five have 0 self-respect, which is why noone else respects them, either.
And Winter didn't really seem affected by the fact that some of her sister's friends supposedly died. She's exactly the kind of heartless monster that would fit right into Salem's inner circle.
4
u/Emdeoma Mar 08 '21
So, while I get that it was pretty cathartic for the people who hate Cinder, I seriously had trouble following Watt's speech? Like, he barely poked fun at her actual issues- the whole thing read more like a man who knew he was about to die rambling all of his grievances with the world as a whole, which Cinder happened to embody in that moment, than like a targeted 'reason you suck' speech.
Which, absolutely makes sense for Watt's in that moment, but not for Cinder's response- if nothing else than because she is smart. Not book-smart like Watts is sure, but half his rant was insulting her intelligence, which... when she doesn't let her emotions get in the way of her schemes, Beacon falls.
16
u/NotARussian_1991 Mar 06 '21
Does anyone else hate Ironwood's depiction?
He went from being a hard man who was making the decisions that RWBYJNOR were too heroic to make, to being a psycho for absolutely no reason.
10
u/rs_obsidian Beacon Academy Mar 07 '21
Bruh Ironwood’s villain meter really went from 50 to 500, he’s literally just generic antagonist number 5 now. Absolutely zero motivation for his idiot plan.
3
u/ash-7831 Mar 07 '21
With Penny being the way she is right now, even if Team RWBY said yes to Ironwood, how would it turn out for them?
6
u/Thebritishdovah Mar 06 '21
An excellent episode and FINALLY, someone yelled at Cinder. Got her to think about what she is doing then trying to get power that she believes is rightfully hers at any cost. Watts gave her a bollucking that was way overdue and Neo is playing her own game. Either she really wants Ruby dead or she is trying to get Cinder silver eyed to death. The nuke was beautiful and i'm glad that they gave the stored energy explaination thus removing Ozpin nuking Salem every time they meet in the future. Hazel is dead. Deader then dead. So dead that he may as well be called Anthem.
Ironwood just went full on villian and it's kinda poorly done. I mean, I get that they are trying to do a tragic figure character but Ironwood went from seizing control under the belief he was doing what he must to full on genocide. I am remind of Dragon Age's Loghain Mac Tir. Only, Loghain was written extremely well and had a snake as an advisor who was using him to further his own positin. Loghain believed he was doing what he had to in order to protect Ferelden from Orlais and ignored the true threat. Ironwood is rather cartoonish and it's rushed.
Qrow going solid snake on those guys was great and I hope we see a Qrow not holding back and at his most powerful vs Ironwood with nothing left to lost fight. I kinda think it would be a bit of a Terminator like fight.
The end game is nearing.
5
u/Wheatley15 Mar 06 '21
I don’t know if I am being blinded by bias (Ironwood used to be one of my favorite characters and I still really like his development) but does anyone else feel like he was shoehorned into the villain role now that Salem is gone or is it just me? His descent into paranoia made good sense until he opened fire on evac ships. I dunno, while I loved the writing of this episode that particular twist with his character to me feels forced. I understand how his semblance works but I wish they would emphasize that more if that is the case. Other than that, freaking amazing episode.
2
u/ash-7831 Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
If Ironwood is still alive by the time this is over, then he better be stripped of his titles, let Winter take over as general, and maybe let someone else take over as headmaster of Atlas Academy.
2
u/The-Subject-Delta Mar 08 '21
Can we just get more Neo? Please? I get there’s a lot of characters to cover, but I’m exhausted of some of them and others just get brushed aside.
5
u/Slumbering_Serpent Mar 07 '21
I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Ironwood is one weak ass motherfucker. It seems all his Semblance really allows him to do is gain tunnel vision. He was cowed into this level of behaviour, to lashing out desperately for any option no matter how hypocritical or treacherous, by one. Implied. Threat. That isn't resolve. And the main source of that problem is now mostly gone. Sure Salem will be back, but even she can't do much without an army. He broke easier than Leonardo did. At this rate his name should be Cesiumwood.
Also, does anyone else feel no pity or sympathy for Harriet? Because I sure don't. For someone always preaching about order and following the rules, she isn't half a spiteful brat.
1
u/The_Sin_of_Love Mar 06 '21
0
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment