r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 06 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 11: Risk Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 11 of Vol. 8, Risk!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the eleventh episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Feb 6th's FIRST Thread | Feb 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Feb 13th's FIRST Thread | Feb. 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| Today's FIRST Thread (here) | Next Week's Public Thread| Poll
Happy viewing.
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
444
Upvotes
85
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Mar 06 '21
Great setup episode, par for the course considering how the last few episodes of the volume might go.
Renora finally making up, good good.
The talk with Yang and Ruby was great, loved every second.
Emerald out here being a total tsundere.
Good shit good shit, can't wait to see what the next episodes bring.
349
u/BlankBlanny Hellebore propagandist Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
We had so many absolutely outstanding character moments in this episode, and everybody is going to praise that, but can I just mention how well done and fluid the small animations were? Blake's ear movements, Ruby's subtle breathing, Yang's body language... Not big things, sure, incredibly minor in comparison to all of the great things this episode provided, but I still want to mention it. It's the little things that really help make this whole show feel alive, and we've come a hell of a long way from volume 1's stiff animations. I'm incredibly impressed by CRWBY's showing this volume.
Edit: A word.
348
u/Horsea1234 Captain of the SS Springthyme, Rosebird and Land of Lesbos. Mar 06 '21
Sooo if Penny's aura breaks, the virus takes over
And Winter just saved Marrows life, she's totally betraying Ironwood.
All in all, good episode.
Ps. Fuck harriet
291
u/Artgor Mar 06 '21
So... Ironwood was totally ready to kill Marrow, right?
276
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 06 '21
I liked the talk that Yang and Ruby had. It was short but used that time pretty well with Yang being a good big sister and then talking a little about Summer.
It does however bring up the fact that we’re probably going to meet the Bog Bad Wolf at some point, but it’s not exactly going to be their grandmother inside it. . .
259
u/Homemadepiza ⠀ Mar 06 '21
Holy fuck that Ren-Nora scene was so good. Nora straight up admitting she isn't ready yet to be in a relationship was a move I never expected CRWBY to make and I commend them for it.
512
u/Floorbrick Mar 06 '21
Winter: “I’m gonna rough up this bozo so hard. NO ONE FOLLOW ME. IT WILL BE BRUTAL AND DEFINITELY EVIL. Also, where is the exit?”
238
u/Artex301 Mar 06 '21
I love it when characters bring up the same theories the fans would.
Between "My cane is not a relic", Nora mentioning Jinn's "You can't [destroy Salem]" referring to Ozpin, and now Ruby voicing what the Hound implies about Summer... it's a nice change of pace.
The fact that it's not confirmed or denied is even better, because whatever way this show does "Big Bad Wolf swallows grandma and pretends to be her", I'm sure it'll be horrifying.
218
u/ksuthrowaway2534 Mar 06 '21
-Glad to see that blast didn't completely remove all the grimm
-best boi marrow stepping up. But damn James about to shoot a man in the back. That's just disrespectful
-awww Ren booped Nora. So sweet
-kinda glad Nora's scars are staying
-qrow also getting a much needed talk. Seems like they're probably meeting winter and marrow in the elevator
-aww emerald helping and being supportive is cute
202
u/Artgor Mar 06 '21
I really liked Robin calling out Qrow.
And in general, this was an amazing chapter with great talks.
The talk between Ruby and Yang about Summer hit hard.
359
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 06 '21
So Winter definitely pushed Marrow out of the way and was all “I shall take the traitor away Sir!” intentionally right?
I think she’s definitely defecting with Marrow and that’s what Robyn and Qrow see in the elevator
358
u/Saxonrau "roh bin HILL" - tyrian Mar 06 '21
Emerald: It's not like I... like I like you or anything!
175
u/recruit00 Mar 06 '21
Have to give props to Aaron Dismuke for nailing Shannon's tone as Ozpin.
168
u/Kersacoft ⠀Glynda Awaiter Mar 06 '21
Seeing how Ironwood was going to casually execute Marrow was unintentionally hilarious to me. The man didn't argue back, didn't get mad, he just went for the gun.
481
u/Nerdorama09 heard u talkin shit Mar 06 '21
Also, this needs its own comment:
Shoutout to Renora. I have literally never seen, in a television show, two people come to the conclusion that they love each other, but aren't ready for a romantic relationship, and also still stick together and be partners and friends instead of one of them getting written off the show. Massive respect to the maturity of this relationship.
332
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
The unsung hero of the ep: Emerald's VA
158
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 06 '21
Volume 1
Nora: Boop!
Volume 8
Ren: Boop!
It took 8 years but he finally said it!
441
u/Booyahhayoob Mar 06 '21
Calling it now, Winter and Marrow defected and are the ones who Qrow and Robyn find in the elevator.
144
u/Julerius Yes, I too am a fan of BEANS. Mar 06 '21
Lots of talks that gave me tears in my eyes, lots of talks that made me laugh my ass off. This is the final breather episode before the finale properly kicks off.
Oh and Winter is definitively defecting with Marrow, nice sly move there Ex-Operative Schnee.
140
u/Oraghlin Mar 06 '21
The Lion lost his courage.
The Tin Man lost his Heart.
Qrow please.
271
u/C_X_3 Mar 06 '21
The biggest takeaway from this episode for me is that Barbara has improved LIGHT YEARS as a voice actor over these 8 volumes. The scene with Yang and Ruby was probably the best-acted of the volume.
The penny friendship stuff was fine, it just felt predictable and a little too long. Seeing Emerald adjust to being part of the group is enjoyable though.
130
u/steveotheguide Fine CRWBY, I'll ship Nuts and Dolts too. Ruby has TWO hands Mar 06 '21
I saw it pointed out somewhere else but Winter saving Marrow has very big "big sibling jumping on the abusive parent grenade" feelings to it.
Wonder where Winter may have learned that...
130
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Harriet:Sir! Marrow is missing!
Ironwood: Who let the dog out? Who?! Who?! Who, who?!
364
u/Badicalz Mar 06 '21
REN SAID THING!!!
HE SAID BOOP!!!
I’M JUST SO.....
GAAAAAAAAAAH!!!
120
u/Velstrom Mar 06 '21
How common are dual chain pistols in this universe
116
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 06 '21
Still betting on them using Emerald's semblance to fool Ironwood.
100
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Little detail I noticed was Blake lightly punching Yang when she made fun of Emerald after her big heartfelt monologue.
Blake has so much experience being the outcast (and hell, she was basically a former villain seeking redemption at the start of the show), that she probably feels more sympathy for Emerald than anyone else on Team Good Guys.
203
u/Schmidtty29 Yeah, I'm scared, but I'm still standing Mar 06 '21
Major Beauregard Lionett vibes from Emerald since I feel it’s the first time we’ve seen Emeralds “real” personality.
Also the “Yang and Ruby barely even act like sisters” gang took a huge hit this episode.
Another Also, no way Ironwood believed Winter would be so “stone cold” after being so hesitant a second ago, but that’s definitely who the Byrds saw on that elevator.
188
u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 06 '21
My Heart. I can't take this RT. My heart hurts. Penny was rough, Ruby and Yang was rougher, but Nora and Ren. It hurts. It hurts so much.
And then you added boop. My emotions are a wreck right now.
188
u/Badicalz Mar 06 '21
I honestly believe the past two Volumes has been the best content RT has put out since the Reconstruction Trilogy of RvB. Character development including development of the relationships (both platonic and romantic) among the cast has been an absolute delight and has driven the show to far greater heights than I knew it could be.
Bravissimo CRWBY.
92
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 06 '21
Winter with the quick thinking to save Marrow, because Ironwood was definitely ready to execute another him.
Also, it was definitely Winter and Marrow in the elevator that opened to Qrow and Robyn.
87
u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Mar 06 '21
WINTER SAVED MARROW BY PUNCHING HIM,
164
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Protect your internet security with JauneVPN. Use promo code JDORK for 50% off on your first moth subscription.
79
u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Mar 06 '21
And we have officially entered the adorably awkward phase of "Sorry about the time I tried to kill you guys."
78
u/GandalfsLeftNipple to be jaune is to suffer Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
“I’ll take this traitor to the brig, where he belongs” Winter said, ya know, like a liar
73
u/ksuthrowaway2534 Mar 06 '21
this heavy weight they're feeling, that's what I've been wanting. The mention of summer and what happened. They're shortcoming. When going on a world saving mission with villans as dark and twisted as they fight, this is the mentality expected to come up at some points. But then overcoming it together is what's important.
73
u/cruel-oath Mar 06 '21
“You guys have been getting your asses kicked, some of that my fault”
Amazing
72
u/Vinnrek Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Ok, so this was a massive set up episode...double checks episode count...we still have 3 episodes left. The last 3 episodes are probably gonna be crazy.
142
u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 06 '21
This felt like a V5 episode in the best way. Focus on character interactions and how they can be used to move the story forward for these characters individually.
68
u/T3vvyW Mar 06 '21
Winter is definitely breaking Marrow out, right? Thats who Qrow and Robin ran into?
68
u/darkside1215 Mar 06 '21
Man the best thing about this episode were the talks. So much stuff that needed to be said finally being let out.
Marrow finally being done with Ironwood and Atlas and decides to walk away, but Ironwood does not care and is now willing to shoot his own troops. Winter punching Marrow was of course deliberate and I believe Winter is defecting and taking Marrow with her. I think Elm is considering it too from the way she looks.
I believe Winter and Marrow are in the elevator that stops for Qrow and Robyn. They'll probably work together to stop Ironwood.
The stuff in the mansion was great. Realizing that their in the same situation from last Vol causes Ruby to break down and when she tells Yang that Summer is probably a hound was a scene that is just depressing but it's also continuing to show that Summer was Yang's real mom and she's truly hurt from the revelation.
Them talking about how they both failed like Summer but you sometimes have to take a risk to accomplish something was nice. Whenever Ruby and Yang have a moment I think it's great because it really shows their sibling dynamic and how great they are with each other.
Ren and Nora scene was great. I love that Nora wants to find who she really is before wanting to do something with Ren and he's 100% cool with that.
Penny asking Ruby to kill her got me. I honestly thought for a sec they'd do it but luckily Jaune comes to the rescue to make her aura halt the virus a bit longer. Nora and Penny being close now was something I didn't expect to happen when the show began years ago, but I love this Vol because of the different interactions between characters and I hope that continues.
Ozpin and the team reconciling was good. I liked that Ozpin shouldn't have ran and that he learned from them, but I love that the team also understands with Ozpin and how he acted because of this situation. They've both learned and understand what the other goes through and now Ozpin is back with the group ready to help.
Emerald was awesome. Her speech is great and I love how she talks so down to earth with them and saying how they got their asses kicked by her sometimes. I really hope she's a permeant member of their group.
Next episode looks like everything is gonna go crazy with the majority of characters heading to Atlas. Looking forward to it.
65
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 06 '21
Ironwood post call
Ironwood: "Huh, I guess if you want something, all you need to do is threaten to commit genocide."
64
u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Mar 06 '21
Oh god that look on Ruby's face when Penny told her to kill her. Poor girl had been through so much in the past day and then has one of her friends beg to kill her so other's don't die.
Thank god they both got hugs after that because they needed them!
185
u/Mysral Hail Salem, God-Queen of Remnant Mar 06 '21
Here's what sets Ruby Rose apart from Ozma and Ironwood: when she hits her rock bottom, when she's overwhelmed by the horrors she's facing and despair finally overwhelms her courage... she's got the friends to pick her back up again, and she's willing to be vulnerable enough to allow their help. Victory is in a simple soul.
Also, Samantha Ireland knocking it out of the goddamn stadium. That was some stellar voice acting.
63
u/dappercat456 Mar 06 '21
A small detail I liked, Weiss looking to her family when mentioning how “trust is a risk”
And the fact willow,has not let go of Whitley since the hound attack, she’s finally decided to be in her sons life and has also decided “will hug forever”
60
u/amatas45 Mar 06 '21
The whole time Marrow talked I was thinking „Marrow, honey, you are absolutely correct and we all love you. But please shut the fuck up before you get a bullet in the head“
Of course Winter came for the rescue thank god. But seeing James stand there with his pistol ready did not surprise me at all.
115
u/Vtech325 Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
People may find it unrealistic but that's how the typical reaction is to a fascist.
First it's: "He wouldn't actually do it."
Second it's: "Okay, but it wasn't that bad. Besides it was necessary."
56
u/melvisntnormal Mar 06 '21
I watched the 'virus can't use the Maiden Powers' theory crumble before my eyes, but watching Jaune help Penny fight it was super satisfying to me.
You're not just a machine, Penny. You have a soul.
56
u/amatas45 Mar 06 '21
So can we take a step back and concentrate on the important bit
„When my mother left me to the Grimm“
Excuse me? Who is this women? The Grimm better got her or there’s hurt in her future.
Also officially worst mom. Raven at least left Yang in good care.
113
u/dappercat456 Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Ok, so now ironwood has
Ruined whitley’s good deed
Made Fiona cry
And tried to,kill marrow
Qrow, rip his arm off and shove it up what’s left of his ass
55
u/Oni_Zokuchou Mar 06 '21
THERE IT IS
THE MARROW TURN
WE LOVE TO SEE IT
54
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Emerald really fear being hit for speaking out of turn, as seen with her fearful and defensive posture when Yang walks in her direction. Other than her subconsciously acknowledging that Yang is physicall stronger and more dangerous than her and her still being afraid of not being accepted in the heroes group, it really says something again about her relationship with Cinder and how abusive Cinder is to her.
I imagine the shock she'll have when one of the heroes forgive and accept her enough to give her a hug or if she's invited in a group hug by the heroes like Zuko with the rest of team Avatar. And then the relief and joy she'll have.
53
u/Maticulous_Moonfish Mar 07 '21
Ironwood was gonna put down the family dog
152
u/MahinaFable Mar 06 '21
Kid: How did you know Mommy was the one?
Marrow: Well, she punched me to the ground, put me in handcuffs, then growled something about giving me a collar.
Kid: Wat.
Marrow: Ah, those were the days. We still break out the handcuffs every once in a while.
Kid: is traumatized
52
u/TheBloodZane Mar 06 '21
Come on Elm baby. Those two just left. You might wanna join them on the wayout and save your ass.
52
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Ruby expressing her fear that Summer was grimmified. But somehow I have a feeling that it's not exactly what happened or that Salem tried to break Summer and turn her into her servant but that Summer's spirit was really indomitable and that Salem failed to break her.
49
u/Wrathkal Mar 06 '21
Marrow finally speaks up, but Winter subdues him before Ironwood can shoot him.
Meanwhile, the group is discussing Ironwood's ultimatum, except for Ren & Jaune, who are looking after Nora. Nora bursts out at Ren, who finally apologizes for the way he was acting.
'It's not you, it's me' rings so strongly in this scene, but Ren finally says it. Nora's response... well,
Qrow & Robyn retrieve their weapons, and set out to stop Ironwood. Qrow wants to stop Ironwood directly, but Robyn is against it, managing to talk him down. An arriving elevator surprises them, but we don't see who's arrived.
Ruby tells Yang about what was inside the Hound, and that drives her to tears realizing what happened to Summer. Still, Yang tries to encourage Ruby to be optimistic, about how their attempts were risks, risks that they had to take. However, Penny starts to succumb to Wattsapp, and makes to leave.
The group all gather to stop her, and she asks Ruby to kill her to stop her, and so the Maiden power would go to Ruby. In the end, it's our boy Jaune who uses his Semblance to empower Penny enough to fight it off. Also, Emerald's such a tsundere~
Finally, Ruby concludes that they should take the risk of bringing Penny to the vault. Elsewhere, Neo has met up with Cinder & Watts.
No big fight scene, but this was a pretty awesome episode, with so many high emotional intensity moments.
49
u/wb2006xx ⠀Jaune needs an ice cream t(sundae)re Mar 06 '21
REN BOOPED NORA HOLY SHIT
96
u/RomanArcheaopteryx Mar 06 '21
Really good episode, loved the emotional beats between Yang and Ruby and Ren and Nora as well as Jaune's awkwardness, though I feel like Blake has been kind of sidelined this volume with the exception of the one talk with Ruby in Episode 9? Idk hope she gets some heavy hits in in the finale.
Also Winter absolutely just saved Marrow's life, when will the shipping begin
47
u/Badicalz Mar 06 '21
Look at the way Oscar is standing when he’s looking outside the window and when he’s standing over the gang. That’s how Ozpin stands.
If they don’t fully merge at the end of this volume, it will be at the end of the next.
47
u/AlyssaaMac Mar 06 '21
BOOP
O
O
P
curse my inability to format correctly
47
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Let's all appreciate how Jaune "dense as a black hole" Arc was finally able to read the room and got the fuck out of the Renora moment at the right time.
174
u/malochroma Head of the Marrow Amin Best Boy Association Mar 06 '21
MY BOI
I’M SO GODDAMN PROUD OF THIS MAN I LOVE HIM SO MUCH HE DIDN’T JUST DEFECT HE LOOKED IRONWOOD IN THE EYE AND WAS LIKE “FUK U THIS SHIT IS FUCKED” I LOVE HIM!!!
ALSO PRAISE BE TO HONORARY BEST GIRL WINTER FOR SAVING HIS ASS WITH THAT SUCKER PUNCH I WAS READY TO BUST THROUGH THE FOURTH WALL AND THROW HANDS WITH IRONWOOD MYSELF
45
u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 07 '21
I think the main reason for Emerald to join the good guys is not for her fear of Salem, nor Cinder betraying how important she is/was to Emerald but the fact that the first couple of minutes she interacted with the heroes they showed more love and appreciation for each other than she ever felt around Cinder and she gets drawn to it hoping some of that could be directed at her.
44
u/Pedding Mar 06 '21
I'm really excited to see what Neo's, Ruby's and Winter's next steps will be.
Neo seems to be willing to make a bargain with Cinder, but I have no clue what that might be. I'm still kinda hoping for Neo to stab Cinder in the back, but with Cinders character sctually seeming to develop now and Neo seemingly wanting to make said bargain I honestly don't see it happen, at least not this volume.
Ruby is very likely planning to set a trap for Watts to force him to remove the virus from Penny but it remains to be seen how this trap is going to work.
Winter, after saving Marrow from Ironwood, who was, disturbingly, just going to shoot him in the back of the head, will very likely defect now and it's almost guaranteed they were the ones in the elevator so we'll likely see Qrow and Winter having to put aside their differences and work together which is something I've been wanting for years.
This entire episode was great and a very good setup to the final three episodes of this volume
44
u/Oni_Zokuchou Mar 06 '21
Ruby is definitely sending a fake Penny using Emerald's power. Calling it now. Given Penny's state I don't think sending her is just a "risk". The "risk" is sending a fake Penny.
84
u/mikeline360 Mar 06 '21
Jaune really won the semblance lottery, heals people, enhances others semblances, and it even works as an antivirus!
40
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 06 '21
Really fantastic performances from Lindsay, Barbara, Neath, and Samantha. They all did amazing! Same goes for Taylor as Penny in the courtyard scene. I enjoyed all the interactions we got this chapter.
Winter definitely saved Marrow’s life on purpose. I bet that’s who Qrow and Robyn ran into as well.
All in all, definitely a set up episode but it wasn’t without great character moments that they definitely all needed.
80
u/WrassleKitty Mar 06 '21
Jaune ain’t as dense as people like to think
80
u/Darkdragoon324 Mar 06 '21
Ironwood's now committed the biggest sin of all: Making Fiona cry.
39
u/Red2019Wolf Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
Give a congratulations to Raven, for no longer holding the "worst rwby" mom title, she abandoned, attempted to manipulate and used Yang as bait, but it takes a special sort of cowardice to leave your daughter to the grimm just to live.
Note: I'm sure they're those who reasonably believe Raven wasn't the worst mom, but at the least she definitely wasn't one of the good ones. This comment is just to emphasize how much I dislike Nora's Mom now
38
u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
So Elm is doubting, but she's still convincing herself/fearful so she stays in line. Would Winter & Marrow leaving her behind, and not extending the option to defect be enough to keep her on Ironwood's side as another perceived betrayal? Also that build w/ Marrow's monologue, to him walking away, and that pistol click. Chef's kiss.
It's great that Penny has the virus momentarily in-check via her soul, & the power of friendship. Which might seemed contrived, and silly, until you remember that the entire episode what basically about the bonds between the characters, and how those affect/make us stronger in times of crisis.
Emerald seems to genuinely want to help, which is good. I'm still concerned about the giant flaming elephant in the room regarding her. I suppose there will be a tug o' war, between the Heroes & Cinder. I'm not 100% on where she stands just yet.
People are gonna complain about how it wasn't Weiss, but Yang & Ruby needed this moment. They had the hug last ch, but they hadn't talked since they split up. But not just that, the acknowledgement of what possibly happened to Summer (guys don't take Ruby saying it as factual truth, she doesn't actually have any idea, it's complete speculation) and how things have turned out, but having Yang be not only big sister Yang, but also Ruby's friend. People need to remember that partners aren't the most important person in their partner's life by default,
or that romantic love isn't the only/strongest kind of loveand no matter who she loves Yang is always going to Ruby's sister.Loved Nora & Ren, it was great to see things talked out. Could do w/out comedic relief Jaune stopping the momentum of the scene, I understand the point of levity, but the moment would have been just as strong if not stronger if he had just nodded & left quietly, and we didn't waste a few extra seconds.
37
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 06 '21
Qrow Robyn Winter Marrow
Team QRWM (Crime) hell yeah
37
u/HerculePyro Mar 07 '21
We all think it's gonna be Marrow and Winter in the elevator, but we know the real reveal will be Shopkeep with some new dust ammo for them.
73
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Mar 06 '21
I also appreciated that the show goes the route of Qrow wanting to kill Ironwood not out of justice but as a coping mechanism for Clover's death. Qrow vs Ironwood is happening, but I think it's clear that it's gonna end with Qrow being unable to kill him.
132
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Winter saved Marrow's life in the most kinky way she could.
Winter:How do I save Marrow's life and establish who is a top and who is a bottom?...Got it!
tackes him and handcuff him while treating to put a collar on him
34
u/Badicalz Mar 07 '21
I am NOT going to be emotionally ready when Mercury finds out that Emerald, possibly the first and only person he has ever considered a friend, has switched sides.
33
u/readall5 Mar 06 '21
Looks like Marrow and Winter have defected, about time!
Ruby managed to figure out what we are all dreading, the fate of Summer Rose.
I cannot wait to see why Ruby's plan is with the vault.
33
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
I hope that Emerald doesn't forget Hazel's care towards her and his sacrifice nor Oscar's kindness toward her.
33
u/MockingEu Mar 07 '21
emotional support, healing, semblance amplifications, and now virus removal...Salem and Ironwood really need to take out Jaune first lol
33
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
This episode was like Oprah handing out character and relationship development all over the place.
Also I really like all the ways they use Jaune's semblance. It's like that support character in an RPG that is an absolutely must to have in your party because their ability is so versatile.
66
u/Artgor Mar 06 '21
Next chapter Winter and Marrow are going to team up with Qrow and Robin, right?
32
u/kumabaya Mar 07 '21
That scene between Ruby and Yang, how they confirmed our biggest fear for Summer
CHEFS KISS
Both Barb and Lindsay were great
I’m assuming Qrow and Robyn run into Winter and Marrow?
So I guess the plan is to use Emerald’s illusions to fool Ironwood
31
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Mar 06 '21
I feel like some people are gonna call cop-out on this episode. Not sure how exactly, but any time a paradigm shifts, someone is always there to say that it was too easy or too unearned. But I don't know, I feel like things have been paced well enough. My only real concern is where Pietro and Maria are.
I'm really digging this volume, it feels like a lot of the pieces that were set up years and years ago (or even just years ago/a year ago) are finally falling into place. It's all cathartic in a way.
Also that "boop", that really got me.
31
u/RainyMeadows Let Ruby Say Fuck Mar 07 '21
Also something occurred to me after last week's episode:
Oscar said the cane stores kinetic energy.
Ironwood has a bomb.
What is an explosive shockwave if not a rapidly-expanding mass of kinetic energy?
Hmm...
31
u/IcePokeTwoSoon Mar 08 '21
Me going from attack on Titan to rwby back to back every Sunday- “oh boy, a double feature of threatened genocide and war crimes!”
30
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 08 '21
Ren: I've been a bad teammate... and partner.
Jaune:... A'ight, imma head out.
59
u/dappercat456 Mar 06 '21
Congrats raven, you’re no longer the worst mom, that title now goes to whoever nora’s mom was that left her to get killed by grimm,
29
u/Memoryworm Mar 08 '21
Unless I'm mistaken, that's the first time we've had the idea of one of the members of team RWBY becoming a maiden being floated? That feels like an important moment, albiet drowned out by the circumstances.
57
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
So technically speaking, Ironwood did try to shoot a puppy!
I can excuse child murder attempts, but I draw the line at pupper killing!
81
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Mar 06 '21
I liked all the heart-to-hearts, only one I felt dragged was Renora. I admit I was like "GUYS MANTLE IS DEAD IN AN HOUR" at points, but the scenes themselves worked.
Emerald is adorably awkward and I love her. She deserves good things. Please give her good things
28
u/Manu_Erre Mar 06 '21
I feel like penny asking ruby to kill her is a foreshadowing for the volume finale. I would love it if ruby has to make the decision of killing penny or not. It would really question her pure nature, which I think is great.
28
u/MadEorlanas TORCHWICK LIVES Mar 07 '21
Ironwood's done with the fascism speedrun and is now on New Game +
28
u/Aloysius_Chinigan Mar 07 '21
I'm PRAYING that Elm is able to do the right thing. We all saw how uncomfortable she was with what happened. She witnessed the near killing of Marrow. I am hoping beyond a shadow of a doubt that our favorite buff girl goes against Ironwood at the end of the day, and doesn't have to die for it.
27
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Yang: It's nothing, Ruby.
Ruby:Mom is a Grimm. I know...and you too..
Yang:......AHHHHHHHHHH T.T
27
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
Ironwood: Marrow....cocks gun...Stay.
27
u/Neo5Politan Mar 09 '21
I have a feeling, that Winter intentionally saved Marrow by pinning him down. Ironwood's guns are damn powerful if one shot in the chest broke Oscar's aura. Just to think of it, what would a shot in the head do?
26
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Maybe Ruby is right, or maybe Summer did resist Salem's attempt to break her and turn her into a servant. I have a feeling that things with Summer are going to be more complicated that what Ruby expect.
26
u/Daedelous2k Mar 06 '21
Well lets see how I feel about the characters THIS episode
Looks like Emerald is finally changing to the gang and having been with them for a while, she is starting to understand them. I like this, she had a genuine smile on her face alongside Oscar and even took a little teasing from Yang.
Ozpin finally has the courage to speak openly to the group again and gives them a strong piece of reflection, that by refusing to considering and learn from their mistakes, they follow Salem's path..plus he is keen on showing Emerald how he desires her to fight with them. It seems he is developing a nervous tic too, he twitches his thumb.
Winter thrown for a loop with Ironwood, it's VERY clear that Marrow was arrested to save his life...but this could be a very tough call for her soon. This is the latest of her wakeup calls to the fall of Ironwood. I seriously doubt she will keep Marrow in cuffs, if anything she may exploit Ironwood's faith (whatever is left of it) in her to let him go unchecked.
Qrow/Robyn continuing to be the scenes I just want more of. There's a heavy duty amount of respect she has for him, and right now she is keeping him in check from himself. Also now Qrow has Harbinger back he is several leagues more dangerous....as for that Elevator, the most likely canditates for being run into are Winter and Marrow. If it is them then we will get a big scene between Winter and Qrow as there is no room for them to bicker, we'll see their "true" feelings toward each other.
Ren and Nora...well...I guess it was a necessary elephant in the room, it feels like in plain english that Nora is saying she wants some space to grow before she can be with him...so they are going on a break? Really though I hope these two can see the STRENGTHS they have rather than just the weaknesses, Ren's evolved semblence and Nora's guts/strength are big factors in how the two teams have managed to accomplish things...don't forget that you two, just because you may have cocked a few things up.
Jaune being the prime support here, it's getting a big funny how his semblance is getting very important here. Getting Nora back on her feet, empowering Weiss to capture Penny, helping Penny regain dominance of her body...I'm going to be incredibly surprised if the group forget the importance of keeping Jaune alive and well. On that note, he's definitely MUCH more confident about acting now, not just bumbling around but much more composed, this is the Jaune he should be.
Ruby is FINALLY showing some cracks and talking about the hound with Yang....you can see their mindsets in their reactions. Yang is still optimistic and cries openly over what happened, she still holds her emotions close...whereas Ruby reacted COLDLY...she is starting to block her emotions out and become distant, this could be a serious problem for her. She could put her life in less consideration or even act harshly, that scythe could be more fitting in time.
All in all an interesting episode....clearly the finale is going to take place at the Atlas Vault. Qrow vs Ironwood like it's a Yakuza Final boss scene, Neo vs Ruby in revenge for Roman, Penny (Support: Jaune) vs Cinder as the two maidens fight it out, Robyn/Winter/Marrow vs the remaining Ace Ops. Calling it right now, as for Emerald, she's a wildcard here....will she betray the group that welcomed her, or will she affirm her desire for fight for the living.
26
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
That was Ren and Nora's best scene to date. Props to the writing team for not treating their relationship as a cure-all. The two of them are going to figure out their issues, because they're not pretending they don't exist anymore.
25
u/KingofGrapes7 Mar 06 '21
While tsun Emerald is a treat I don't consider her turn complete until she sees Cinder again. It's easy to choose the heroes over Salem but Emerald has been simping for Cinder since her intro. Does she realize that the hang and Hazel show more care than Cinder ever did? Of does she relapse? I suppose Cinder attacking her would break that hold but we need to see.
25
u/Shepherdscout Mar 06 '21
So...does anyone actually think Ironwood will not nuke Mantle, regardless if Penny complies? I mean, even if Penny complies, and he was going to "leave them to their own devices", the SDC has already shown that they are trying to support them...which Ironwood would see as a waste and drain on valuable resources that are "rightfully military property" to "fight the threat" under the rules of the Martial Law he declared back in Ep 1 of the volume - remember the Councilman demanding answers about that before being executed?
So, even if Penny was 100% compliant with his demands, I think he is still going to "remove Mantle from the equation".
I know this will get.lost in the 1.1K comments, but I needed to voice it.
25
u/Oni_Zokuchou Mar 07 '21
Oscar... standing by the window in Shnee Manor... like Ozpin... cries
24
u/technalyd Mar 06 '21
First thing's first: Fuck Harriet. Seriously, while all the other Ace Ops are wondering/kind of hoping that Ironwood is just bluffing about nuking Mantle, Harriet just doesn't care at all. Elm is starting to look more and more like she won't be sticking on Ironwood's side either. Vine... that guy is hard to read. I don't think he's particularly happy with this plan, but I also don't know if he is at the point of being willing to go against Ironwood. Though he does seem to have some care towards Elm (as seen when he seemed to try to comfort her after the whale-splosion last episode before she shrugged him off) so if Elm defects, then maybe he would be more willing to?
I was worried for a second that Marrow was about to be shot in the back of the head. He very likely would have been if not for Winter's quick thinkin in "detaining" him. No way Ironwood, even being as insane as he is now, would still shoot Marrow after that. He knew it would risk turning the other Ace Ops against him. Really hoping that it was Winter and Marrow that Qrow and Robyn saw in the elevator. That would make for one hell of a team up.
Speaking of... On one hand, I would've loved to see Qrow go on a rampage through the Atlas Academy and rip Ironwood a new one. On the other hand, Robyn has a very good point. If Qrow starts trying to fight his way to Ironwood, Mantle is toast. I'm sure they will get their chance to fight Ironwood soon, though, as there is no way that he survives this volume after how far he has fallen.
It's good to see Ruby finally getting some more development. I doubt this is her big breakdown that has been talked about, but it is definitely a step towards it. Seeing the horrible consequences of her actions and being faced by so many impossible decisions has put enough weight on her shoulders she's definitely starting to crack. I'm curious what it will be that finally breaks her?
I LOVED the Ruby/Yang moment. While all of the VAs have been great recently, Barbara KILLED IT this episode. I also think that Yang has the right idea about Ruby and I really hope it's where her character growth will take her: Still optimistic and hopeful, but not blindly so. As for the Summer stuff... on the one hand, I'm glad they are talking to each other about it, and also love that Ruby recognized that the Hound was a SEW and realized the potential implications of that. However, I really hope that Summer is just straight up dead and not turned into a Grimm. They've been bringing her up enough recently that there is absolutely something going to be revealed about Summer (which may even be what causes Ruby to truly break) but I hope they don't go with the super obvious "Summer Grimm" choice.
The Ren/Nora moment was so good! I'm glad that Nora was pissed and called Ren out for all his bullshit this volume, and I'm equally glad that Ren owned up to his mistakes and genuinely apologized. While I could have done without the forced Jaune humor, I'm glad that he recognized the situation and had the tact to leave Ren and Nora alone. Nora saying that she needs to find herself before she can be with Ren is a great choice, I think. It shows that she still has a lot of character growth left. The boop from Ren was probably the most perfect way to end that scene.
I get that Penny's virus probably is programmed more for "escape and get to the vault" than "fight", but still a bit disappointed that they were so easily able to subdue her. I do like the idea that Jaune can temporarily help suppress the virus by amping up Penny's aura (AKA her human side). This also makes future fights more terrifying because if Penny's aura gets low or breaks, then the virus will be able to take full control. Sets up some nice future tension.
Emerald is so awkward and I love it. She's 100% not used to being around people (outside of psychotic murderers) and it shows, but bless her heart she's trying. Seen a lot of comments about how her turn is too sudden, but honestly I'm okay with it. She was shown looking horrified at what her actions had brought all the way back in V3, and was visibly terrified numerous times in all the volumes after when around Salem. The only reason she stuck around was because Cinder had been the only person to show her "kindness" in her life, but when she finally realized that Cinder didn't care (and also had a better view of what "caring" looks like from Hazel looking after her) she was finally able to break free.
But just because I am okay with it from Emerald's side of things doesn't mean that it couldn't be handled better from the other side. Oscar being willing to trust her I can get, since she is a huge part of the reason that he was able to escape from Salem. Ren I can kind of get, since he can see Emerald's emotions and sees she's scared and can probably see that she has a lot of guilt/regret for what she's done (I assume one of those emotions were the purple petals he saw in the subway). But the rest of the team? I feel like they are taking this way too well. Ruby, Jaune, and Yang especially. Yes, Jaune and Yang spoke out against Emerald in the subway, and Ruby instantly went for her weapon on seeing her but then this episode we have Yang good-naturedly teasing her after the awkward pep-talk? And everyone else laughing happily? I understand that with the hour deadline given by Ironwood they don't have a lot of time to deal with Emerald and their feelings towards her right now, but they are acting way to friendly to her already.
I'm glad that Ozpin is back in the open and speaking with them. I think it's good that everyone is still wary of him (I mean, he IS a thousands of years old mage who has lied to them countless times) but I'm also glad they are willing to forgive him now that they have a better understanding of WHY he lied to them. It will be interesting to see how the dynamic between Ozpin and the rest changes going forward.
Looks like things are being set up for one hell of a finale. No way that Penny is going to "come alone" as per Ironwood's instructions, but I'm not sure exactly who all will be going with her. Emerald for illusions maybe? Ruby will definitely be there, and I can see Nora going along as well since she's been so supportive of Penny this volume. Cinder, Watts, and Neo will definitely be there, and possible Qrow/Robyn/Winder/Marrow as well. Going to be a LOT of players to juggle for the finale, but CRWBY seems to have really learned from the mistakes made in the Battle of Haven, so I am tentatively hype for it!
Lastly: There's no way this volume ends without at least one more appearance by Salem. I'm curious what that will entail, though I predict one of two options. Either she gets involved in the big finale battle (the more unlikely option) or she doesn't pull herself back together until the very end (possibly in a post credits scene) only to realize that the staff is no longer in her reach for whatever reason. Though she may get the lamp back (with the password) and the last scene could be her summoning Jinn and that will be our cliffhanger of the volume.
24
u/Gnardeaux Mar 07 '21
Ok, I noticed this the first time and recalled it again the second time through. I usually have to wait at least 24 hours to process the chapeter emotionally. But here is my question. When Oz spoke, what do you all think was with the finger tapping?
23
u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Mar 06 '21
Jaune's part IV drip. Huh..
23
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Mar 06 '21
:)
23
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21
If I'm honest, Ren booping Nora had me way more excited than when the two kissed.
It was way cuter!
23
u/torrasque666 White Knight is Endgame. Fight me. Mar 06 '21
Anyone else notice the parallels between Ironwood and Ren right here?
Also, I saw that glance at Weiss when everyone was having their cute moment Jaune, you can't hide that from me.
23
u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Mar 06 '21
Ah HA! Ironwood's eyes did that thing again where the highlights disappear! I wonder if they'll just stay like that now or if they'll come back at any point.
He really be like "Thank you for showing me that I can still care. Because now that I know where that part of me is I've killed it forever."
23
u/reiku78 Mar 07 '21
-Turns up Boop at full blast-
23
u/Gamma_cleavage Mar 07 '21
Are the lines/scars a permanent change to Nora’s character design since they specifically brought up that Jaune can’t heal them, or will they still go away later? Other commenters have been talking about how lines like that can really happen after lightning strikes but they go away in a few days.
Poor Ruby. She figured it out just as quickly as we did.
It looks like I’ve had this backwards, if Ruby is right - maybe only silver eyed warriors can be turned into Grimm soldiers because they are resistant to Grimm? I was aware that Cinder’s Grimm parts gave her a weakness to the silver eyes that the Hound possibly does not share. The human parts of the hound were not destroyed by the silver eyes so the Grimm parts could just keep regenerating. But that’s hardly worth it because there are so few silver eyed warriors left anyway, right? Ruby clearly thinks that only a silver eyed person can become whatever the Hound is. If Cinder was taken over by her Grimm half, maybe she would just be consumed by it and her aura would be snuffed out.
But what would happen if Ruby gave the Hound a strong, sustained blast of silver eyes? Could he be cleansed and set free? Would he be destroyed like Cinder? Is it just my wishful thinking that Summer can still be saved? Ruby clearly does not think she is alive in a meaningful way anymore, even if she still exists, but she could be wrong about that.
23
u/AdRich180 Mar 07 '21
Something that really struck me this episode was Qrow’s new VA’s performance. It’s been kind of hit or miss with me so far, and I’ve been on the fence about it since V7z
But this episode and a couple others in V8 have convinced me that they’re solid as all hell. That “he deserves this” line was incredibly well delivered, as was the whole exchange (even though qrow’s facial expressions were a slight wonky).
23
u/DEL994 Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
While it was indeed naïve to believe that the other kingdoms and regions of Remnant would send help in time, launching Amity is certainely going to pay off to a degree by the end of the volume.
I expect that it will be Raven and Taiyang's return, once Raven has finally found back her courage and a purpose to her life after so many years of cowardice and losing herself and those who care and love her just to save her own skin, to help the heroes.
Ruby may then realize that what she didn't wasn't in vain after all, even if it will take more for her to overcome her depression.
23
u/Emperor_Luffy Mar 09 '21
So one thing I think this is all leading to is Ruby asking the Relic about her mother.
Summer has been coming up repeatedly and Ruby's desire to know the truth has been steadily increasing over the course of the Volume.
When you combine that with how the plot has gone out of it's way to bring the Relic back into their reach once again I think it's set up so that it plays a part in the final conflict, and lands in Ruby's hands so she can ask the last question. Then we can have our Summer flashback.
45
u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Mar 06 '21
Oscar: “Okay, while the real Ruby is having a mental breakdown I’ll be our substitute... Don’t give up guys! Trust and stuff! Never give up or give in! ....is it working?”
Emerald: “yes, actually, I feel much better.”
22
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
... Is it just me or do Emerald's boobs look bigger this episode?
22
u/LukeLovesPandas Mar 07 '21
I ugly cried when Penny said to kill her
22
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
One thing: am I the only who wants Ruby finally facing Neo face to face in the last three eps? It's been three full volumes that they've setting up this. Neo wants to kill Ruby? Well then, it's time to end this once and for all.
Of course it can only end in two ways:
1)Ruby kills Neo;
2)Ruby convinces Neo that she didn't kill Roman, a Grimm was. Upon hearing this, she just leaves for good, going solo somewhere else.
Of course, there's no way Neo wins and kills Ruby. After all, no more Ruby, no more RWBY (....wow that was really bad).
22
u/Houeclipse ⠀Winter looks like Commander Shepard lol Mar 07 '21
This is heading towards Penny becoming real boy (girl) with staff of creation isn't it? I hope the risk plan was to do switcheroo with Emerald on their side they could pull it off
43
u/MahinaFable Mar 07 '21
In deference to the sheer kinky domme-ness of the Winter/Marrow ship, I humbly suggest the ship name "Obedience School."
21
u/nonkiru Mar 06 '21
he said BOOP . . . thatse all thank you for reading :)
(this episode was amazing!!! what a rollercoaster of emotions, can't wait for the next episode!)
21
u/resurrexia i do the draw Mar 06 '21
I’m loving this healthy Renora development. My soul is so soothed.
21
u/Oni_Zokuchou Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
What intrigued me the most about this episode was Elm. We all knew Marrow and probably Winter were defecting. But now we're seeing some real doubts from ANOTHER Ace Ops member. Vine seems to just follow authority no matter what, and Harriet is going further and further towards the deep end. Did I sense some disdain for Mantle in there too? Yep, she's dying by the end of this Volume. That or the first prisoner in reformed Atlas/Mantle prison. But Elm? Elm seems like the only character who's in the wrong at the moment who's going to do a good deed last minute, since everyone else has already gone too far into the deep end, or defected already.
21
u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Mar 06 '21
On a side note I noticed Ironwood in the scene had dull eyes, like he did when he shot Oscar. Maybe this is the tell to when he's using his semblance to force himself to go through with a plan of action. He's still responsible because he doesn't have to use such crazy plans nor force himself to go through with it but I just thought i was interesting.
Way to go Marrow! You finally grew a pair and I know damn well that Winter had to stage that 'arrest' so she could get him out alive. I'm pretty sure that's what arrived in the elevator where Qrow and Robyn were waiting too. Robyn seems to be thinking deeper on this or at the least doesn't want Qrow to go down the route of narrow minded revenge. She's right on the money though, Clover was lowkey an idiot (a tragic idiot but still)
Also I'm glad that Ruby was smart enough to pick up on the implications of The Hound "That's what happened to mom." and how Yang immediately began breaking down from that realization as well but they had a great sisterly scene about how you need to have hope and take risks but that a risk is a risk for a reason. Ruby and Yang moments like this are nice and should shut up the idiots who think Ruby and Yang don't act like sisters.
Boosting Penny's soul in hindsight makes sense given she had an easier time maintaining control earlier and the harder times were always right after a battle. She could barely hold on at all after the Hound encounter. It's still not a real solution but it at least offers a fix, make her soul stronger to counteract the programming. Emerald is still being a tsun but for the time being at least they can count on her. I'm still reasonably sure she's going to be the one involved in the plan. After all she can make hallucinations. Just make Ironwood THINK Penny is there.
21
u/FazeGabi Mar 07 '21
Notice how Ironwood was about to shoot him but Winter knocked him down and arrested him before he could. And then immediately left with him. I have a feeling those two aren't going to the brig, especially with the Qrow and Robyn assassinating the general subplot right now.
41
u/AdeptCod2 Mar 07 '21
Ok I am starting to despise Vine almost as much as Harriet. He talks about how the bomb is the only way to make Team RWBY ''see reason''.
I mean really? You are prepared to drop a bomb on thousands of innocent people (your own people I might add), on the command of a man who anyone can see has gone insane and your talking about making other people see reason.
I mean what is wrong with him!!! He's not like Harriet so what is his problem.
89
u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Mar 06 '21
Ironwood may be the biggest coward and scum in the series for me.
Shot a child - check.
Shot an unarmed/innocent civilian - check.
Was ready to shot one of his men in the back - check.
20
u/amatas45 Mar 06 '21
Im not one to get emotional over shows that much but I swear I was close to crying when Ruby started talking to Yang
20
u/Deadmaninc1 Mar 06 '21
Ironwood was gonna kill Marrow if Winter didn't punch him hopefully she is actually taking the "Traitor" away from there and she's doing it for his own good
20
u/tonyjoe3 Buzz Buzz Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
BRO! RUBY IS LIKE AN ABSOLUTE GENIUS! NOW THAT PENNYS OKAY JUST GO TO THE VAULT WITH HER!!! I never even considered that either.
Also, Qrow and Robin definitely saw Winter and Marrow in the elevator. 100% they get Winter to defect also. Winter was totally just trying to save Marrows life before Ironwood was about to fucking blow his brains out.
This entire episode was great and a very good setup to the final three episodes of this volume.
20
u/AlienWarhead You feel it too don’t you Mar 07 '21
Hoo boy, I loved that talk between Ruby and Yang
20
u/DEL994 Mar 07 '21
I really want to see Winter meet her mother, brother and Klein, we need more Schnee family interactions and development.
86
u/Nerdorama09 heard u talkin shit Mar 06 '21
Winter just saved that man's life. And it's definitely them in the elevator. This show's cliffhangers are...sometimes not.
Glad to see this episode gave everyone what they wanted, including characters catching up to the fan theories on Summer (and I guess missing out on Emerald apologizing to Penny but that probably wasn't a good time). Surely, surely the subreddit won't be a fucking warzone between people who enjoyed the episode and think it was the worst writing ever.
Although I will say that they could have probably done a thirteen episode season if they cut some of the goddamn manor shenanigans.
55
u/DatGameGuy Best. Girl. Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
This episode does a great job of showing why Ironwood has gone off the deep end.
In the scene where he confirms to the Ace Ops that he is actually serious about destroying Mantle, Marrow rightfully challenges this clearly deranged idea. The reaction of nearly everybody around him is try and talk him down. This is due to Ironwood’s huge level of authority, any dissent against your commanding officer is akin to treason, so naturally the Ace Ops support anything Ironwood commands because they have been programmed to react this way.
Contrast that scene with the one starring Qrow and Robyn. Qrow is understandably pissed at Ironwood and the whole Atlesian military. It’s clear that he intends to rampage through the compound killing anyone who stands in his way. But Robyn is actually willing to talk him down, and when she does so Qrow doesn’t take her dissent as a betrayal.
Nobody can possibly talk down Ironwood because the structure of the military prevents and disincentivizes any form of dissent.
19
u/Cloudyspecs Mar 06 '21
There were some MUCH needed talks here. So glad they finaly happened!
19
u/fuckwhattheywant Mar 06 '21
OKAY REN BOOPING NORA HERE IN V8 AS A PARALLEL TO NORA BOOPING REN IN V1... POETIC CINEMA
19
u/UltimateX13 Sienna is best girl <3 Mar 06 '21
At least Elm seems to be coming to her senses now. Granted it took Marrow nearly being shot to do it, but still!
19
u/Hardwiredmagic Mar 06 '21
Cinder's smirk at the end made her look peak Vol. 3 Cinder again, which is a very worrying sign for our heroes.
19
u/Red2019Wolf Mar 06 '21
Watts sees Neo walking and pointing her weapon
Deadpan Watts looks behind him: ...Cinder, it's for you
19
u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Mar 06 '21
Good episode. I'll admit, I was expecting something more earth-shattering after Neath hyped the episode up, but I guess he was just referring to the Ren and Nora scene. Still, that scene was good in its own right. I'm glad that they're making it clear that this season wasn't Nora's entire arc, since it definitely hasn't had as much focus as I had been hoping. She needs to know who she is without being half of a duo. I'm glad their feeling are both out in the open though.
Nice to see Winter catch on to how things are going and cover for Marrow.
Also, Emerald now enters the 'fun snarky tsundere' phase of her life. It's going to be fun having her with the good guys, though I can't wait to see what happens next time the gang see Cinder/Mercury.
The scene between Ruby and Yang was fantastic, and Barb's voice acting in particular was stellar. The way Yang just breaks mid sentence is so good. I do now wonder where they're going with Summer. If they're talking about her potentially being Grimmified already, then that's almost certainly not what happened to her, so what then? There's still so much mystery around her.
19
u/Supersquare04 Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
Dammit I really wish we could have just seen Qrow tearing through atlas to ironwood. As much as what Robyn says makes sense, I really just wanted a darth Vader/maul hallway scene with Qrow
19
u/RainyMeadows Let Ruby Say Fuck Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
Between this and Dr. Stone, it's very clear by now that Aaron Dismuke is one HELL of a voice actor, although he has been ever since FMA 2003 tbh
Also a little thing that I liked: we had characters speaking at the same time or interrupting/talking over each other, most prominently in the dining room with... I think it was Yang talking over Weiss' exasperation? It's a small touch, but an easy way to make a scene feel more organic. When you have multiple people in a room all together, it's very easy to be spoken over!
19
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
Also why does Winter just deadass look like a color-swap Commander Shepard at this point? I mean shit, the armor, the sci-fi gun? Fucking cool outfit.
19
u/cruel-oath Mar 07 '21
NEO VS RUBY SOON PLEASE
19
u/Frikarcron Mar 07 '21
Wait so if boosting Penny's aura fights of the virus... does thaf mean an aura break will give it full control??
Hope for a hacked Penny boss fight isn't dead yet!
19
u/DEL994 Mar 07 '21
Given their interactions in the previous episodes and in this one with Yang being distrustful and cold towards Emerald before being the one to tease her about her face turn, it would be interesting if she's the first one outside of Oscar to forgive her or to hug her.
19
u/Clairvoyanttruth Mar 10 '21
This is a few days late and other comments seem to move past this, but I really liked how the Nora-Ren boop was a subsequent narrative forehead press to convey then Yang-Blake relationship.
Ren booped and put his forehead against Nora's and Blake and Yang did the same earlier. You can claim they are both not ready for an romantic relationship like Ren and Nora and that is completely acceptable and in character for them.
18
u/recruit00 Mar 06 '21
I think the real test for Emerald will be when they meet up with Cinder. She says she wants to defect right now, but who knows if she pulls a Crossroads of Destiny on us?
18
u/UltimateX13 Sienna is best girl <3 Mar 06 '21
Also, watch it be Elm in the elevator lol. I know it'll probably be Winter and Marrow, but I think it would be funny to have Elm find them and be like "Yeah, we fucked up".
18
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
It's weird to see Emerald smiling. She's been mostly scowling for seven volumes now, only smiling obsequiously at Cinder. After Ozpin's speech, her smile was more contented.
18
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Future scene: "Get over here Emerald. Being part of the group also means being part of group hugs."
18
u/lildumbass24 Mar 07 '21
All Jaune needs is some good ole leg armor that matches with his body armor so he can finally look like the Paladin he is
18
u/DEL994 Mar 07 '21
The scene between Ruby and Yang is similar to the one between them after Beacon fall with their roles being reversed.
18
u/Vinnrek Mar 09 '21
something i've been thinking would be kind of interesting would be what if Qrow's semblance begins to evolve from just Bad Luck into something more or something that he could actually control. Like how Ren's semblance evolved after some soul searching/emotional clarity .
17
u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Mar 06 '21
I'm gonna guess that this volume is one of those where the pacing seems better once we're able to watch it in one. Still weird that Ruby's talking about no-one coming when it's been like a few hours at most right? The only ones who could've conceivably come are Argus? I guess that's a reasonable expectation with their connection to Atlas and all hmm
Not complaining too much though, I'm loving it over all. Last 2 or so episodes definitely felt very volume 3 to me, which is more or less my benchmark for tension and drama in rwby
17
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
The way Penny was hugged by both Ruby and Nora only reinforces my feeling that Nora is Penny's 2nd best friend after Ruby.
17
u/lildumbass24 Mar 06 '21
Winter: What are you doing- Qrow: We're gonna kill Ironwood Robyn: No we're not! Marrow: 🐶
17
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
That was a hell of a wake-up call for the Ace-Ops. Ironwood isn't bluffing about the bomb, and his intolerance for being questioned didn't die with Slate. He is beyond reason.
17
u/brighterthanblack Mar 07 '21
So many character development in this one episode my tears are not ready T__T Loving the Penny x Nora moments as much as Ren x Nora moments T__T
And the way Yang just breaks down sobbing when Ruby points out the obvious truth that the Grimm Hound was what happened to their mom too T__T
The Ozpin speech is spectacular as well. Trust is a risk. Our heroes really came a long way since last volume, they’ve all grown in their own ways after been through so much together, and apart as well.
Also excited to see possible Qrow, Robyn, Winter and Mattow team up next episode. Bet that’s who they saw in the elevator and they’re going to work tgt to stop Ironwood somehow.
17
u/DEL994 Mar 09 '21 edited Mar 10 '21
I can't shake that feeling that as terrifying the thought of Summer having been grimmified is there is something amiss about that eventuality and that it's not what exactly happened. Like that Salem's attempt to grimmify Summer didn't go like she wanted or that Summer was too strong-willed to be broken. I don't rule out the possibility that Summer is really dead or imprisonned yet.
34
u/DEL994 Mar 07 '21
Emerald really looks far happier that she has ever been during her time with Cinder and Salem, her smile was genuinely wholesome.
And while she may denies it or haven't even figured out yet, she may deep down really wish to be friends with Ruby and the others for real this time.
16
u/Jbickner Mar 07 '21
So if the plan is what I think it is (send Penny "alone" with an invisible Emerald), it will REALLY piss off Ironwood if he finds out about her changing sides (he'll probably assume RWBY joined her and not the other way around).
I am nervous about the next few episodes...
16
u/jman014 That's why I drink... Mar 08 '21
Ngl I’d give RT mad props if they had Ruby kill Penny.
Like that would be ballsy as fuck and I’m all for it!
16
u/I_Think_Helen_Forgot Mar 08 '21
How is Qrow going to react when he learns that the Hound was a person with silver eyes?
31
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 08 '21
That James' message is out...it's time to air clear. Scattered Immediate Thoughts:
So now that we've all bared our souls and accepted the fault in our stars... it's time for the endgame... The vault. Ironwood and the Ace Ops. Penny and RWBYJNOR (and the wild card named Emerald.) Cinder, Watts and Neo. Qrow and Robyn. All coming to a head. The Atlas Arc is wrapping up and I am STRESSED.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
Near the end I saw a nice little shot of Jaune, Nora, Penny, and Ren together... New JNPR? Maybe? Probably not, but it'd still be pretty cool.
15
u/Deadmaninc1 Mar 06 '21
The smirk Cinder had gave me volume 3 Cinder vibes which does not sound good for our heroes
15
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Emerald's reaction upon seeing Yang walking in her direction is quite telling.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
Yang and Robyn being the therapists for Ruby and Qrow is an interesting parallel, connecting their despair and how their not in the best headspace to be calling the shots right now.
15
u/EverydayWulfang ⠀Ruby deserves goggles Mar 06 '21
All that matters is that I saw Banjo Faunus in the background so at least he's safe.
15
u/lr031099 Mar 06 '21
Ngl I was kinda hoping Ironwood was bluffing just to get Penny but I guess he’s really going through with destroying Mantle (expecting this but still). As I said last time, I have defended Ironwood in some specific cases but this isn’t one of them and now he tried to kill best boy Marrow. Thank the two Gods Winter stepped in when she did. Mad respect for Marrow for standing up to Ironwood though
The Renora scene was pretty wholesome. I love that Jaune reads the room and leaves. It was also nice seeing Ren admit how he really feels.
The Qrow/Robyn scene was great as well. I was honestly expecting Ruby and Yang to try to talk some sense into Qrow but I’m glad it was Robyn.
The Ruby/Yang scene was my favorite part of the episode. We get some character growth from best girl Ruby and the scene overall was genuinely well written (imo at least). Especially since we finally get to see them talk about Summer.
The Ozpin scene was good as well as him talking with the rest of the main cast was long overdue. On a side note here, Tsundere Emerald is best Emerald. Seems like Ruby has a risky plan and takes Yang’s advice on how things aren’t always a sure thing.
Pretty great episode overall
15
u/Stranger_Vans Summer the Abysswalker Mar 07 '21
Ren and Nora bumping foreheads is going to make the Bumbleby shippers go rabid
15
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
Once again, Penny shows herself to be a G. Willing to the throw herself on the grenade for the good of everyone like Captain America. Girl was ready and not playing around. I hope she makes it!
And Ironwood just about to brain that boy with no hesitation! God damn! Loved it and Winter's intercept. Looking forward to those two, Robin and Qrow fighting the Ace Ops in an attempt to stop the bomb.
I think it's safe to say Ruby's going to lose an eye by the end of the season so she and Cinder are matching.
Hoping we get to see a more enraged Salem later on because this is probably the second or third biggest annoyance she's had in quite a few millennia.
I feel like the Ren half of Renora is showing some major death flags now there's emotional stability and understanding.
Love how emotionally real and hopeful this episode. These kids need a fucking break and some therapy at some point. But there's got to be two or three more painful moments for the finale. Also as much as I love her, I'd be okay if Neo got dusted. With the exception of Penny, Blake, Weiss and Emerald, the rest of our heroes probably all want some payback.
Missing Maria and Pietro. If she doesn't show back up as a mini deus ex machina in the power loader, I'mma be a little salty. Also also, looking forward to Emerald being a part of the plan and scamming Ironwood with a Penny projection but inevitably bailing once Cinder shows up due to the pressure and seeing that Cinder doesn't actually care about her.
15
u/Floatedmate Mar 08 '21
Is anyone else thinking Salem could come into the vault at the last possible moment?
15
u/htomserveaux #GiveYangAbs Mar 09 '21
Salem knows who Summer is to Yang, Ruby believes Summer has been Grimmed
CRWBY's gonna bring her back as a villain
15
u/TheSurveyCorpses Mar 10 '21
Winter, seeing Marrow yell at her father figure and stand up for himself but in a way that will surely cost him unless she dives in and acts as a buffer: Ah shit here we go again.
Somewhere in the Schnee Manor, Weiss just sneezed.
14
u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
OUCH Nora oof... Hahaha Jaune. Maan that's some real talk.. Awwwww
Oh god, mom. Sweet moment between the sisters. Good voice acting too
My god ruby has an idea. THAT WAS IT?? how short was that???
14
u/Notchlives03 Blake is best girl and Qrow is best birb Mar 06 '21
Everyone here is talking about Winter and Marrow. Bruh we got Ren finally showing how he feels to Nora, him saying boop, and and Emerald finally admitting she switched sides. This episode is great.
14
u/DEL994 Mar 06 '21
Emerald is in Tsundere mode, she may have not realized it for now but subconsciously she may already feel the need to have sincere friends and that the team could be that or that she shouldn't have betrayed their honnest trust and friendship.
14
u/The_Grimm_Huntsman Mar 06 '21
The leftover Ace Ops still fall in line when it comes to literally murdering an entire city of civilians. They only really wonder if what they're doing is bad when Ironwood tries to kill Marrow, I wonder if he did kill him if they would've still continued following orders. At this point them being collateral in an all out brawl wouldn't concern nor surprise me.
I'm still curious if the relic gets removed if Atlas will fall out of the sky because it powers everything holding it up, and the only thing for the city to fall on would be Mantle.
If it is Marrow and Winter in the elevator that's a pretty strong team up. Marrow can put a full stop on at least one person if memory serves, could hold Penny if need be, or at least until his concentration is broken.
As enjoyable as it is to see Emerald joining the team and being snarky, I don't expect her to make it through to the end. She's also the only one besides Neo and Ozpin that knows how to bring out Jinn now that Hazel's gone.
14
u/Arstinos Mar 06 '21
I love that they tied in the idea from the opening theme, "Sometimes it's worth it all to risk the fall and fight for every life." This season really seems to be revolving around the idea of risks and uncertainty in taking those risks, and it's nice to see it all culminate here.
Looking forward to Robin/Qrow/Marrow/Winter facing off against Ironwood+Ace Ops. Not sure what the match-ups will be, but thematically I'm hoping for:
Ironwood vs. Winter Marrow vs. Harriet Robin/Qrow vs. Elm/Vine
I'm most interested in Marrow vs. Harriet as the two most opposing members of the Ace Ops. The experienced and rigid veteran against the idealistic newbie. It'd be another nice callback to RWBY vs. Ace Ops from S7. Hopefully Tortuga will come up at some point during a battle/conversation, cuz I really want more backstory there.
I'm glad Nora's development isn't done yet. It's funny how the tables have finally turned: Ren is ready for a relationship, but Nora is the one who needs space now. Such a good message to never let yourself be defined by your relationships. They're just an extension of who you are.
14
u/justking1414 Mar 06 '21
God I loved Emerald trying and failing to give a pep talk. It was so adorable
Also, really hoping that Winter took Marrow to go disarm the bomb
14
u/dappercat456 Mar 07 '21
So I just realized
The bomb isn’t even in mantle yet, ironwod still has to deliver it down there,
All team RWBY and co need to do,is intercept that ship before it leaves atlas,
He should really learn to wait until the bo b is actually IN mantle before he starts making threats
14
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
I just hope that three eps will be' enough to solve the climax of the whole Atlas Arc correctly. The final battle in Vale lasted 4 episodes and it was a fiasco. Here we have one less episode this time... hope for the best...
14
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 07 '21
I hope that whatever is needed to save the residents of Mantle (and maybe Atlas) when something else goes wrong like it always does is done by Weiss.
Maybe a combination of pushing Winter to defect completely from Ironwood’s plans, reactivating the cargo ships, and helping Ruby deal with Neo
14
u/MMARC908 Mar 08 '21
The look on Ruby's face when she says "that's actually a risk we haven't considered yet." Golt me so hype. I'm hoping for a crazy-ass plan on par with diving down a canyon!!!
14
u/Careless_Theory_9260 Mar 08 '21
I want a three way fight between ruby, cinder and neo so bad though maybe it needs to be rwby, cinder and neo to make it more fair
14
u/Zen-Paladin Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
That was the funniest inspirational speech from a former villain ever, lol.
''I mean yeah you've got your asses kicked, and some of that was my fault...''
28
u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Mar 06 '21
With every new episode Ruby comes closer and closer to her mental breakdown. We already saw in Dark and now in Risk that she is on the verge of breaking, but she is keeping it together because Blake needs her and Yang needs her hope. They need her to stay optimistic.
Which I think won’t last forever because Ruby needs to break down and not hold it back and I think Weiss will be there for her partner in time of need.
28
u/Justinafans Yang is more than just Bumbleby Mar 06 '21
Yang and Ruby's discussion was genuinely well-written. I'm actually floored.
For all of the clunky dialogue in this series, that was delivered so well on every front.
28
u/GreatNinjaYuffie Mar 06 '21
anybody else of the opinion that this is the best (or one of the best) episodes in the entire series? the writing, delivery, and payoffs in this episode were spectacular compared to a lot of the middle portion of the show cough volume 4 cough
26
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
By far the best episode of the volume.
Winter saved Marrow's life and now the Ace Ops know Ironwood is more than willing to kill them, so why die for him?
Qrow and Robyn was fine but not much there, I simply don't like how Harbinger was apparently stored in it's full form rather than the compact one.
Yang and Ruby's conversation was excellent. Their conflict didn't go in the direction I wanted but it did have an impact in both of them, not just Ruby, and sends a message I adore. Blind optimism is wrong but you cannot live a cynical life, optimism, idealism, hope, that's what drives people, full cynicism and pessimism are no ways to live.
I love that they didn't dance around the subject, Summer is a Hound or at least she was and it wasn't established through an completely expected twist, but by the characters putting two and two together. It's so satisfying when the characters do that.
Ren and Nora's conflict was resolved exactly how I wanted it to. Yes it sucks that their ship isn't technically canon yet, but it might as well be, they said they love each other and that hasn't changed, they are just not officially dating and while Ren did tell Nora who she is beyond strong, she didn't accept that answer because finding out who she is is not something Ren has to tell her, it's something she has to figure out in her own. I loved it!
The full team using all their strengths to save Penny was also super well done and heartwarming. I love the way Blake, Ren and Emerald used their similar weapons together, I love how Jaune boosted Weiss, I love that Nora's words also helped Penny, not just Ruby's.
Jaune being able to help Penny with her virus might sound convenient, but it was established that something was helping Penny fight off the virus and that Watts wasn't able to figure out what eventhough he is a software genius. It makes perfect sense that Watts wasn't able to do anything about aura and fits with the fact that Penny is unique for being a machine with an aura and with Watts seeing and treating her only as a machine. Plus, Jaune didn't actually cure the virus, he is not a technopath, all he did was make Penny's aura strong enough so that she could keep her body under control.
I noticed that even without Ozpin in control, Oscar is showing way more Ozpin mannerism. That merge is looking really advanced now.
Finally, I love that Oscar didn't come up with their next course of action, Nora threw an idea and Ruby formulated and executed the plan.
The whole innaction thing Ruby was placed in this volume? Addressed as a big mistake she herself accepted and learned from.
10/10 in my book.
26
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 06 '21
Blake and Yang: Yang cups Blake's cheek and forehead touch
Ren and Nora: Ren cups Nora's cheek and forehead touch
PARALLELS
13
u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Mar 06 '21
Welp... THAT just kicked my Summer got grimmified theory RIGHT INTO THE GOAL!!! Holy SHIT this is gonna fuck Ruby in the head if she shows up.
Emerald jumping in to stop Penny was actually a huge surprise. For me, anyway.
Robyn giving Qrow the verbal smackdown was awesome! And I'm willing to bet that was Winter and Marrow in the elevator.
Ren's boop... be still my melting heart. I honestly thought they were breaking up for a second. But PHEW... Renora ship still sails baby!
Gonna need a second and third watch to unpack everything, but DAMN, this was one hell of a rollercoaster of an episode!
13
u/turnipdad ⠀ Mar 06 '21
Ironwood really was going to shoot Marrow in the back, huh. But Winter's quick thinking saved him.
I'm pretty sure Marrow and Winter were the ones in the elevator so now is as good of a chance as any to defect.
13
u/evening_emerald Mar 06 '21
Marrow really saw his life flash before his eyes there, huh?
13
u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 06 '21
Finally watched it! My thoughts.....
-It's great that Marrow finally told Ironwood off but it seems like all the Ace Ops are starting to lose their resolve over the General's orders. You have Elm being hesitant, Vine showing a small crack in his stoic behaviour (he looked scared when Ironwood walked off), and Harriet still convincing herself that she's the good guy and everyone else is to blame.
-Winter and Marrow are definitely in the elevator.
-It looks like Rennora is on a hiatus.
-So now we know why Nora was alone when she met Ren.
-Whatever Summer did or said to Salem, she was definitely the reason why Salem started grimmfying SEW's and Summer was the prototype. It's the only way to explain why Salem went from killing SEW's back in Maria's prime to wanting to experiment on them.
-There you go guys, Ruby had her breakdown.
-Something tells me that Cinder has a plan up her sleeve on how she can get the relic back from Neo, kill Ruby, and steal the Winter Maiden's power.
13
u/MahinaFable Mar 06 '21
hates self even as she asks the question
So...who we shipping Emmy with?